
Stash That International Cash, Baby! (Photo: blatant world, flickr)
Go to any gathering, and you’ll find nearly every person carrying an iPhone or an iPad, despite the Apple Computer’s dismal record on labor practices. Apple executives must be laughing all the way to the bank — their Swiss bank, that is.
In its fourth quarter earnings report released last week, Apple Computer revealed that 2/3 of its on-hand cash – some $54 billion — is squirreled away outside the boundaries of the United States, presumably to avoid paying its fair share of taxes. In the meantime, reports Students and Scholars Against Corporate Misbehavior (SACOM), a Hong Kong-based group, Apple’s major manufacturing contractors routinely subject employees to forced overtime, wage theft and no breaks — and even unprotected exposure to toxins.
Apple, together with rival tech firm Google, has been lobbying for a “tax holiday” that would allow them to bring some of those billions into the U.S. at a lower tax rate, promising that to do so would create jobs. But, as we reported, a similar measure tried in 2004 created few jobs, and instead rewarded companies that had kept their money overseas. Where Apple has created jobs is in China, where the workers who make its slick products are made to work in deplorable conditions.
A new SACOM report, “The iSlave Behind the iPhone: Foxconn Workers in Central China,” examines conditions at the Apple Computer contractor’s plant since the suicides of nine workers last year made big news. One thing that has changed: workers were given a raise — to all of $1.18 an hour. But workers are often shorted overtime pay, SACOM reports, and Foxconn even illegally withheld, during the Chinese New Year, payment for overtime already worked in order to prevent workers from taking the traditional holiday to visit their families.
Most workers in these factories are migrants; the corporations deliberately build facilities in lower-populated areas where wages are lower. Not that labor costs account for much of the cost of an Apple product. According to Sophia Cheng, writing at the SACOM Web site:
Take the iPad, for example, which is the sole item produced at Foxconn’s 100,000-worker factory in Chengdu. Industry analyst iSuppli estimates that Apple spends only $9 on labor for every $499 iPad.
In SACOM’s latest report — whose release was timed to coincide with the opening of the first Apple Store in opulent Hong Kong — workers complain of deplorable dormitory conditions, where access to electricity and water is routinely cut, and of the exploitative fees they are made to pay to Foxconn for their room and board.
Workers say they are also made to stand for 10 hours at a time without taking breaks, and subjected to abusive behavior by supervisors, including being made to sign confessional letters when accused of making a mistake or infraction. In China, labor unions are run by the state, so when workers act on their own to strike, as they did at United Win, another Apple contractor, in 2010, they risk legal sanction.
Download the full report, “The iSlave Behind the iPhone: Foxconn Workers in Central China,” here in a PDF file.
This is a crosspost from AFL-CIO Now.



51 Comments

Some video to go with your piece, from Debbie Chan of SACOM, done for ACTIVATE at Al Jazeera, last month.
http://www.aljazeera.com/PROGRAMMES/ACTIVATE/DebbyChan.html
“Take the iPad, for example, which is the sole item produced at Foxconn’s 100,000-worker factory in Chengdu. Industry analyst iSuppli estimates that Apple spends only $9 on labor for every $499 iPad.”
And probably $20 in parts. That’s how Apple acummulated 54 billion in cash.
Most workers in these factories are migrants; the corporations deliberately build facilities in lower-populated areas where wages are lower.
These migrants are I bet not Han Chinese many Americans don’t know China has many different ethnic, language, religious, racial groups. Apple and many countries oppression of these workers I am sure is making China more unstable.
Apple could make its stuff in America and make a profit. Ipod workers in America would make enough to actually buy apple’s product. Chinese workers cannot afford to buy ipods.
Also the benefit of those wages stays in China and helps their economy it does not help us.
What does it say about working conditions when FoxCon employees commit suicide rather than work there any longer.
Suicide? Really? I mean how bad are things there?
Answer that question, and you might get some real answers about how bad things are there.
I mean for F sakes, suicide!!!
Think of Steve Jobs as America’s Werner Von Braun. Both were pretty smart, sucessful guys. Just try not to think about them both using slave labor . . .
Watch the Debbie Chan film. She goes to Chengdu with the intent of filming about the suicides but doesn’t end up doing that. Chengdu probably has a lot of ethnic workers, but it isn’t big on migrants, it’s the capital of Sichuan, not someplace in Guandong.
The working conditions are bad enough that Debbie Chan doesn’t end up doing a film on suicides, after all, because they’re carrying out dead workers when she gets to the plant in Chengdu.
What does it say about the Main Stream Media that they all call Steve Jobs a Business Genius for driving his workers to suicide?
Steve Jobs reminds me of Newt pro outsourcing, anti American Public education and on a personal level Newt divorced his wife when she had cancer and the church took up a collection for Newt’s Family.
“it took two years before Jobs would acknowledge that Lisa was his child, going so far as to swear in a court document that he was “sterile and infertile, and as a result thereof, did not have the physical capacity to procreate a child.” While Jobs reaped the rewards of owning a burgeoning technology company, his baby and her artist mother subsisted on welfare.”
http://www.minyanville.com/special-features/articles/lisa-brennan-jobs-business-icons-rich/8/31/2010/id/29768
I am seeing a scary pattern here the Book “King of the Hill” looked at the Alpha Male in politics but maybe we need a Alpha Male in business book.
ouch.
Thanks for the info.
Interesting, albeit disturbing, read. But no real surprises.
Good post. Thanks.
Jobs returned to Atari and was assigned to create a circuit board for the game Breakout. According to Atari co-founder Nolan Bushnell, Atari offered $100 for each chip that was eliminated in the machine. Jobs had little interest in or knowledge of circuit board design and made a deal with Wozniak to split the fee evenly between them if Wozniak could minimize the number of chips. Much to the amazement of Atari, Wozniak reduced the number of chips by 50, a design so tight that it was impossible to reproduce on an assembly line. According to Wozniak, Jobs told Wozniak that Atari gave them only $700 (instead of the offered $5,000) and that Wozniak’s share was thus $350.[30] Wozniak didn’t learn about the bonus until about ten years later, but said that had Jobs told him about it and said he needed the money, Wozniak would have given it to him.[31]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Jobs
“Bill Gates betrayed his ailing business partner and tried to deprive him of his share of the Microsoft fortune, according to a scathing memoir from Paul Allen, the company’s billionaire co-founder.
Allen portrays the Microsoft mogul as a sarcastic bully who tried to force his founding partner out of the firm and to cut his share in the company as he was recovering from cancer”
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2011/mar/30/microsoft-paul-allen-bill-gates
The Alpha Male finds a creative partner who does much of the creative tech stuff
fights to manage the company demanding perfection, guided by a magical thinking vision of the future and a seduce or destroy leadership style.
I still need more research to confirm and not every idea matches exactly for everyone Newt is the template for understanding Bill and Steve for example but
Newt never seemed to have any business partners to screw over only ex wives.
Still its a working theory thats interesting and needs more research.
Wow. All the nice things “everybody” said about Steve Jobs and it turns out he’s just another corporate “bandit” and “slave master”.
Who’a thunk?
If the iPad sells for $499 and it costs $29 in China, that leaves $470 for revenue attributable to American workers (sales, marketing, engineering, accounting and the like). Am I missing something?
Thank you, Adele, for this most excellent and important diary.
It describes Steve Job’s true legacy (among other things).
Highly recommended to the thoughtful consideration of all who spend time and expend mental effort at FDL.
DW
Apparently “nice guys DO finish last.”
” ‘Tis easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for rich man to enter heaven.”
I guess we all know Steve’s new address.
I apologize for that. That was uncalled for.
Is the Alpha Male in business a parasite off his more creative partner who shares with his more creative partner a vision of the future and offers in his turn to work on the details of management of a company while his partner does the creative stuff?
In America do the Psychopaths have an edge in internal management and fighting off the competition are there any start ups that don’t have Psychos or people with some psycho traits working for them?
“In its fourth quarter earnings report released last week, Apple Computer revealed that 2/3 of its on-hand cash – some $54 billion — is squirreled away outside the boundaries of the United States, presumably to avoid paying its fair share of taxes.”
Aren’t they paying taxes in the countries where these offshore products are being sold? For example, is it wrong for Apple to pay taxes in the U.K. for money that is earned through U.K. sales? I’m not sure they are trying to avoid “paying its fair share” Whatever the hell that means anyway.
Excuse me for asking, but what are the unions doing for Americans now? Seems to me they spend a lot of time kissing up to the PTB.
Don’t apologize
One can only hope if there is an after life that Steve is working in his own factory.
Seconded!
Yes, you are missing something.
Most of that $470 contributed to that $54 billion.
Proud to say I own no Apple product and never have.
Ok we do need a conversation about more moral products got any suggestions? And arguments why they are more moral? People if they want to switch out of apple need alternatives. You or the techies here could do a diary.
Let’s all remember it’s not just Apple that is doing this kind of stuff. It’s almost every manufacturing company in this country that has shipped jobs to China, in order to increase the wealth of the 1%. Apple has just become the poster child.
There have been news reports in the past year that companies are now moving to Bangladesh, because the Chinese workers are getting to “uppity”.
This is information we need thanks and this topic needs a front page post. It also needs a tech geek to write it and that not me. Cars and green Power I can write about this is not my area of expertise.
Heh,
You don’t want me doing a diary on computer, phone, or social media alternatives.
I’m a Luddite from way back.
Yes we do
Apple has more cash than the US Gov.
http://articles.cnn.com/2011-07-29/tech/apple.cash.government_1_ceo-jobs-apple-cash-balance?_s=PM:TECH
I’ve never owned Apple products either. Too proprietary and way overpriced in my opinion.
That’s certainly true, but Apple is particular vulnerable here because they enjoy profit levels above the norm for the industry. Apple could be a highly profitable corporation and pay and treat its workers better. The same is true for other multinationals, but Apple is an especially egregious case. When you combine this fact with the company’s popularity among American consumers (including people on the left) then Apple may be a good target for political activists.
Live blog of the Oakland general strike.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/nov/02/occuply-oakland-general-strike-live
Whoaaaaaaa, hold on there.
This is one of those ‘urban myth’ stories that get worse in the repetition. Here is some perspective from folks that do study the situation:
…”In other words, Foxconn’s suicide epidemic is actually lower than China’s national average of suicides.”
from “Media gets its facts wrong – working at Foxconn significantly cuts suicide risk”
http://www.zdnet.com/blog/foremski/media-gets-its-facts-wrong-working-at-foxconn-significantly-cuts-suicide-risk/1356
or http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2007-09/11/content_6095710.htm
One of the items of interest that has come out in the ongoing dispute Apple and Samsung is having is that the chips for the iPhone are made in Samsun’gs Austin Texas factory and shipped to FoxConn to assemble. Many of these chips are also usd in iPads. I would like to see Apple move more jobs back here to the US, but there is more going on here than just this attack on the company suggests.
Do not forget those $499 Dell and HP computers are entirely, entirely done overseas, by the same FoxConn company.
Oakland is where it’s at !!!!
I second that. I’d read it. But, then again. I’m easily entertained. :-)
I have more cash than the U.S government every payday.
My bestest buddy works at the Fed in Dallas. He told me he went down to the vault on Monday, end of trhe month, and all he found was $169.32 in cash, a Nixon/Agnew campaigh button, a $40.00 IOU from John Dean and case of Mr. Pibb.
Who woulda thought the “Birthplace of the SECOND American revolution” would be Oakland???????
They’ll be reading about that in the history books in a hundred years.
There suicide rates are better than China in general???
And that’s your pitch?
The lesser of two evils is still evil.
And as for Dell and HP, they’re in bed with the same evil. No difference.
I would appreciate the links to the info about Dell and HP so I can use them. Thank you.
Before Steve Jobs would meet with Obama, he insisted the President call him personally. When they met, he gave him a diatribe about killing of teachers’ unions. When he met Linus Torvalds, founder of the open-source Linux operating system, he did not care to talk about programming or innovation in same, but talked obsessively about Apple’s market share. Reportedly, he went to his grave b*tching about Android.
When we have exhausted FoxConn, we can move on to all the kids getting cancer as they pick apart Apple’s obsolete products on rubbish heaps in the Third World.
There is nothing cool about Apple products. If you want to know whether Jobs & Co. wanted the ipad to be a product for consuming or for actual production, look no further than his comments about styluses.
How much for the case of Mr Pibb?
What I wrote is not a pitch. Try reading the two articles and then comment.
It is amazing that you are posting comments to an internet website yet asking for help in locating easy to find information. Amazing. Here is one link for you.
HP is the leading foreign manufacturer of PCs in China.(1)
http://www.hp.com/hpinfo/newsroom/press/2008/081009a.html
Apple is investing well over $4 billion in capital projects in 2012 in California and North Carolina. You may not like the company, but that big horde of overseas cash came from the products they sold in Europe and Asia to people that wanted them. The US tax laws are set up to make sure that cash stays overseas. Yelling at Apple will not change that.
p.s the quote goes: when you chose the lesser of evils, what you get is evil.
I have an association with Apple and their products going back to 1987, as a system integrator, Apple trained dealer systems engineer, software developer, etc. And although Macintosh is my choice for a computer (well, four actually) I was able to watch Apple’s not always so above board behavior over the years. Apple treated its dealers badly, especially the education specialists and that extended to developers and customers.
When Steve Jobs came back to Apple, he killed off the Newton handheld PDA, which by that time had finally matured through several versions to be a usable and advanced PDA (think Palm). Supposedly he killed it off because it was John Scully’s pet project, but in doing so, he put a lot of developers in the hole, as some had second mortgaged their houses to develop for this new Newton (I was going down that path also and had a couple of programmers and a financial backer ready to roll).
There was a NY Times write up about an artist doing a monologue piece about Apple and the abuses of it’s foreign labor force, and I wrote to the guy (his name escapes me at the moment) doing it, and I basically said to him, “if Steve Jobs wanted to do something really insanely great, he should convince the Apple board to repatriate Apple’s foreign cash hoard at the standard 35% tax rate, thereby showing some appreciation to the country that facilitated his becoming so successful. This was two days before Jobs died; maybe he had an intuition that someone was looking for that.
Am I missing something”
yes
Under IRS Code Section 482 Apple declares the value added overseas before it is shipped to a US port – and My guess is they would say $530 of value was added so the US portion of revenue was a loss of 30 per Ipad – and then they get a refund on their taxes.
Average Chinese suicide rate reflects famine and forced movement for new roads. dams, towns.
It does not say average worker in a plant has a higher suicide rate than FoxConn.
I love the way stats are mis-used.
Unions exist for the purpose of collective bargaining on behalf of their members. They still do that but on a much smaller scale than when they had political support from the Democratic Party. They are not designed to “do” stuff for “Americans” although many members are marching with #Occupy. You may be speaking of Union leadership, many of whom (like leaders in business, finance and government) are corrupt and need to be replaced.
Again, you must learn the accounting games – “in country only taxation” runs with the company self reporting what its in country income and expense – Inland Revenue does not chase very hard the cost basis – the value added – claimed to be from outside Brittan.
That is why the corporations 50 years ago went on a campaign to get every country to use in country taxation only – the US is the only country to use world wide income less credits for tax paid outside of the US- but then the US – as in England – does not challenge Section 482 and the companies claimed “deferred tax status”, for all that value added out of country – the only tax being paid when the profits are “brought back into the US” – a concept that ignores the Banks doing “back to back loans” so that the capital is already available for US expansion without being brought back into the US.
You can be sure they are not paying their fair share – defined as what corporations pay on profits per the law before accounting moves that profit – in theory only – offshore and thus untaxed.
“Proud to say I own no Apple product and never have.”
Same here. Vanity products that owe their existence to slave labor, misery and a world-class asshole’s ego.
I doubt the late Mr. Jobs was any worse than any other rapacious neo-liberal capitalist. It’s just that now he’s gone some of us are emboldened to point out he was not a cross between Elvis, Jesus and Batman. Jobs understood people who have a fetish for technology. His products were hawt. Overpricing them made them even sexier.
I would sell my Apple stock if I had any. I think the ride is over.
You people are ignorant, lacking in perspective, and have no idea about computers/technology or how to use them. Practically everything you use and consume has the problems you cite here, from the governments, the laws, the financial system, the businesspeople, the factories, the work, the workers, and on down the line, and I don’t see any of you refusing to do without each and every thing you feel qualified to blow hard about in your criticisms. The comments here sound as petty and empty-headed as anything at balloonjuice. By all means, let’s change the system, and this carping energy could be put to much better use.
you mean trade unions. industrial unions like the wobblies would be a different matter.
The 32GB version equipped with the code division multiple access (CDMA) air standard carries a BOM of $323.25. The compares with $320 for the first-generation 32GB 3G iPad, based on pricing from April 2010.
http://www.isuppli.com/Teardowns/News/Pages/iPad-2-Carries-Bill-of-Materials-of-$326-60-IHS-iSuppli-Teardown-Analysis-Shows.aspx
This estimate from iSuppli does not include various other costs such as the salaries of the engineers that developed and tested the devices.
As if the choice is being a hermit or a thief.
Apple makes 50% profit on each iphone. It wouldn’t kill their shareholders to follow the law and pay people the overtime they earned.