As we approach the self-immolation known as “The Sequester,” I find myself thinking about a woman in West Africa, asking people, “Would you like to buy a pen?”
She was a middle-aged woman, wearing a bright-colored dress. Judging by wear and tear, it may have been the only dress she owned.
She was standing on the steps in front of a small department store, which was selling pens by the dozen. She repeated softly, in French, to passers-by, “Voulez-vous acheter une plume?” And she held up a pen.
I didn’t need a pen, but I did need to know what she was up to. I asked her how much her pen cost. She quoted a fair price. I gave her that much, plus some more. She gave me a pen that I didn’t need. And she had enough money to eat something that day. Or so she said, en francais.
Back to “The Sequester,” the 12% budget cut for the military (leaving aside soldier pay and benefits), and the 9% budget cut for other federal programs (leaving aside Medicare and Social Security). Opponents of The Sequester are focusing on the military cuts. Their theory seems to be that the American public has been signing blank checks made out to “DoD” for so long that there is no way that we’ll stop now. Or maybe they think that we will subliminally translate the words “defense cuts” into “some crazy Arab is going to blow me up” without anyone actually having to say that, much less make the case for it.
I have a nodding acquaintance with polling, so I understand that foreign aid might be the least popular federal program right now, second only to black helicopters. But our immunization program alone saves three million lives each year. Our emergency food assistance program fed more than 66 million starving people last year. Possibly including the lady who sold me that pen.
And the total cost of all that food was equal to one-sixteenth of a new aircraft carrier. In fact, for the cost of one aircraft carrier, we could feed every hungry person in the entire world.
So let’s see. A nine percent cut in the foreign aid budget means that six million more people go hungry. And American taxpayers save 44 cents a month. Not even enough to buy one hamburger.
Further translating this into Americanese, give some thought as to what The Sequester will do to the food stamp program, or the Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program. A lot of Americans will be going to bed cold and hungry.
I know that I will never see that lady with the pen again. Even though I remember her, she probably doesn’t remember me – if she is still alive. She is not going to vote for me, and she is not going to contribute to my next campaign. Nor will her relatives, nor will her friends. I’m not sure why I cared whether or not she was hungry, but I did, and I do. It’s just part of being human, I guess.
So here is one argument against The Sequester that you’re not hearing elsewhere – it will cause a lot of pain. A lot of hunger, a lot of disease, a lot of death. I understand that this argument is hopelessly unfashionable, and completely contrary to the zeitgeist of fear and hatred that dominates our political discourse. But there it is, nevertheless. I sure see it. Maybe you do, too.
Courage,
Rep. Alan Grayson



16 Comments

Thank you, Congressman.
I have heard that Ryan White funds are endangered in the sequester, but no one seems to be able to have any current information. Can you define what human services (domestic) are being cut? Everybody says that Medicare and Social Security are exempt from the sequester; doesn’t that mean other areas will be especially hard hit?
And what effort is being expended to avoid the sequester at this point? Didn’t everyone go home for one of Congress’s ten-day holidays, when the rest of us who pay Congress’s salaries get a day off — if we’re lucky — for Presidents’ Day?
There you go again with that pesky logic and fact thing. If the argument was based purely on such, there would be no problem. But it isn’t and there is a big problem. And that is the TGOPers function in a warped, ideologically driven and faith-based universe. Anything that contradicts their ideology or ‘faith’ is hell-spawn and fought tooth-and-nail.
You can not reason or negotiate with the irrational. There is no acceptable course with them other than abject capitulation to their demands.
Matthew 25:40
Oh, never mind…
Thank you for putting a human face on this mess. The creepy repubs don’t do that, and it’s just as well, since the only human faces that interest them are Mitt Romney and his hyper-rich friends and clients.
I thank God that you’re back in Congress again, Rep. Grayson.
The only greater blessing would be if you represented my Cong. district. :)
We’ve just had a big rock buzz our Home Planet and a smaller rock bombed Russia.
I wonder how much of a deal it would be to switch our defense industries to doing work in space exploration and research. There are now businesses doing just that.
There could be little or no loss of jobs in those industries, and our previous exploits to the moon and other places did return a wealth of benefits for us all.
One of my pet things that would work, you do understand? ;)
Thanks Congressman. Glad to see you back in the House.
Feed the woman. Feed our people and give them heat in the winter.
Stop the subsidies to Big Oil, Big Ag and nuclear. Bring home everyone from Iraq and Afghanistan. Stop giving our city police military weapons. All that should create some spare change for taking care of people.
Congressman…..I am thrilled you are back in D.C. It gives me great comfort to consider you my congressman because I agonize every time I am reminded that Eric Paulson represents me. I have been contributing to your reelection efforts when contacted by various groups that support you and will continue to do so.
It’s great to see that Noblesse oblique and speaking French are back in vogue now that the French Foreign Leigon are spreading Socialism through North Africa.
Perhaps we should look beyond the poor starving ragimuffins alluded to here and look at the how USAID and corporations are using neoliberal policies to take land in Africa for the export market. Much of this aid is skimmed by the corrupt actors in power who are propped up by the US.
Even when the food aid gets through it can destroy reigonal small scale farmers because insted of buying local surplus they dump US surplus on their markets.
I don’t know what these new cuts to SNAP and heating oil will be but Obama and the Dems have already helped cut both programs and many in the North East are depending on Hugo Chavez and the kindness of Venezuelans to heat their homes this winter.
So, what’s your proposal?
One thing anyone can do is look South Of The Border and see that some countries are resisting our brand of Capitalism with some modest success.
Another is to quit fawning over these shallow drive-by monologues.
Can we just have the part of the sequester that cuts the military?
What izzat? A member of the French aristocracy with Scoliosis? It’s, “Noblesse oblige “. If you’re coming to an intellectual gunfight, don’t show up with a Swiss Army knife. There’s LOTSA’ smart people on here that will chew you up.
The sequester was Obama’s way of deferring the hard issues until after the election. I assume he had a plan beyond his self interest?
The poor in the frigid Northeast have been depending on Joe Kennedy and “Hugo Chavez and the good people of Venezuela for years.”
I was disillusioned by the time that Obama by the time he finished stocking his administration with Republicans and neoliberals (aka, pretty much also Republicans).
Just when I thought that Obama could not possibly be more disappointing, he sent his first budget to Congress, cutting fuel subsidies for poor people.
You who live in warmer parts of the U.S., make no mistake: the cuts proposed by Obama indisputably amounted to a death sentence some poor people in the colder regions of this country.
Dickens’ debtors’ prisons were compassionate in compariso.
Austan Goolsbee, a former DLC staffer who was then part of the Obama administration, went on the Daily Show to try to sell something or other. Stewart asked about the cuts to fuel subsidies. Goolsbee immediately went into a glib song and dance about how oil prices had decreased. Stewart responded, “Yes, but home heating fuel prices have increased dramatically.”
Goolsbee, caught on television in a deliberate deception, could only shout, “Wow. I can’t believe how well prepared you are.” He had nothing further to say on the subject.
So, not only were Obama and his people willing to hand poor people a death sentence, they tried to get away with lying about it too.
When Goolsbee’s time with the administration was getting short, he went on the Daily Show to sell something else that the administration was pushing. In Stewart’s place, I may have told the fucker that, given his attempted deceit the last time, I could not in good conscience give him air time. (Imagine if all our media did that!)
And I am supposed to vote for Obama and other neoliberals? Do I really want to be an accomplice to the real death panels that DLCers like Obama and Goolsbee serve on?
Grayson brought the Frog Speak in to the diary so i can only say, bite me and start chewing.