Cross- posted from Huffington Post.
In 2008, young people in America — including many who voted in their first presidential election — rallied behind a youthful senator from Illinois campaigning on the promise of change and hope. Now the incumbent in the White House, Barack Obama faces a difficult challenge in recapturing the youth vote for his reelection. Early this month, The New York Times reported that enthusiasm for Obama among voters aged 18-24 has fallen sharply since the last election cycle. And many of the young people interviewed in the article spoke of feeling alienated from politics.
So what is behind young peoples’ disaffection? And what must President Obama do if he is serious about winning back the country’s youth?
Young People Face a Broken American Dream
Young people are not acting irrationally when they report growing cynical. They are responding to the reality of an American Dream that lies in fragments at their feet.
Traditionally, the promise of prosperity in this country has rested on three foundations: good jobs, decent housing, and attainable college education. In recent decades, each of these three legs of the stool of economic stability has been kicked out from underneath the middle class.
With regard to jobs, young people have been told they could do anything — that they were America’s best hope for a competitive edge over other developed nations. But for those entering the workforce today, the good jobs just aren’t there. A quick survey of Bureau of Labor Statistics data reveals that only one of the ten fastest-growing occupations carries a median income of over $50,000 per year. Five of the ten make less than $30,000.
Second, young people were told that if they studied diligently and prepared themselves for careers, their hard work would allow them to one day earn enough buy a home. Yet home ownership is getting more and more inaccessible, with affordable housing now as distant a reality as well-paying jobs.
Finally, there’s college. University education was supposed to provide the basis for achieving the other two keys to middle class life. However, today’s graduates leave college shackled by ruinous debt, with sky-high tuition meaning that students must take tens of thousands of dollars in student loans. Even in a good case scenario, these loans take decades to pay off.
The New York Times‘ story about growing alienation of young people from politics included interviews with several 18- to 24-year-olds who said the impossibility of finding decent work and the burden of student debt were driving factors in their despair. Their alienation is not baseless pessimism. Rather, it reflects a breakdown in our political and economic system.
The Consequences of Abandoning Our Youth
Failure to invest in America’s youth has serious consequences: a loss of international competitiveness, a rise in disenfranchisement, and an expanding polarization in our politics.
While the United States languishes, other nations are actually investing in their young people. That America is a world leader in student debt leaves members of our next generation with a disadvantage over their foreign counterparts that promises to become a long-term liability. Moreover, countries like Sweden and Germany have government-sponsored workforce investment and apprenticeship programs that help their young people transition into full-time work with some confidence of future security.
The Obama campaign’s 2008 promise of hope inspired many, but it also raised the danger of creating false hope amongst our youth. We need a next generation that is engaged in renewing our politics and making current beltway deadlock obsolete. But young people who feel ever more disenfranchised are ever less likely to take on that challenge. False hope fosters a lingering sense of anger, cynicism, and distance from civic life.
Those who do bother to get involved in politics may be tempted to enter at the fringes. Loss of hope is giving rise to something even more insidious than embarrassment on the international stage; it quietly pushes more young people to the extreme edges of social and political discourse. Those who feel they have been sold a false bill of goods find solace in the messages of conservatives and libertarians, who offer no policies to address the true interests of young people, but who effectively channel popular disaffection into a worldview that pits working people against one another.
Winning Back the Next Generation of Voters
More polarization is the last thing we need. Obama can re-inspire young people, but he will have to show some concrete results, not just rhetoric, in order to do it this time.
First, instead of kicking the can down the road on student loans, the president must take action to ameliorate the pain of existing debts and save young people from crippling financial burdens. After months of stalemate, Congress finally reached a deal on June 29 to extend the low 3.4% percent interest rate on federally subsidized Stafford student loans for one more year. But that means that without further action from Congress and the president, those loans will jump to 6.8 percent next year, hitting young graduates in the pocketbook just as they are exiting school. Obama is using his commitment to student loan reform as a campaign issue: he mentioned the loan rates in his weekly address just days before the vote. But Obama could go further by supporting Rep. Hansen Clarke’s (D-MI) Student Loan Forgiveness Act, a bill that would forgive federal student loans after borrowers have made payments of 10 percent of their incomes for ten years. Those who work in public service would get their loans forgiven after five years. It’s not a panacea, but having the president use his bully pulpit in support of the measure would help to show young people he is serious about making college affordable.
Second, Obama could introduce stronger workforce investment measures, such as expanding vocational certificate programs as a pathway toward improved job skills and higher educational attainment. A June 5 study from Georgetown University’s Center on Education and the Workforce entitled “Certificates: Gateway to Gainful Employment and College Degrees,” found that certificates, which take less time and money to earn than do college degrees, could serve as an important path forward for a segment of young people preparing to enter the workforce. The study’s authors, Anthony P. Carnevale, Stephen J. Rose and Andrew R. Hanson, recommend investing in certificate programs in order to boost young and displaced workers’ prospects during this period of high unemployment. Indeed, employers say jobs requiring online research (and other skills in which one can earn a certificate) are sitting vacant. Yet Obama’s education budget proposal for 2013 focused almost exclusively on college completion, requesting little or no new funding for non-degree certificate programs.
(Dr. Jill Biden, wife of Vice President Joe Biden, has been crisscrossing the country on a campaign tour to showcase community colleges as career-starters. If Biden were to add a few certificate programs to the tour as part of her workforce development boosterism, it could encourage Obama to transform his verbal support for vocational education into actual dollars for these programs in his 2014 budget proposal.)
Finally, Obama needs to work to restore the right for people to bargain collectively with their employers over the conditions of their employment. It was not preordained that the manufacturing jobs that gave rise to America’s middle class would pay living wages and provide decent benefits. Those things were won through collective action. Instead of making empty promises to bring back factories that have moved overseas, the White House should focus on making sure that the jobs that do exist in this country are good ones.
That means reinventing collective bargaining for the next generation, cracking down on corporations that violate rights to free association, and creating new means for workers who are independent contractors or have non-traditional work arrangements to join in employees’ organizations. A variety of innovative proposals — from extending the Civil Rights Act to protect the right to unionize, to instating “just cause” laws at the state level — have been proposed as steps toward achieving these goals. But the Obama administration has yet to make employees’ right to organize a priority.
That is a problem. For without good jobs, affordable housing, and a solution to the student debt crisis, young people will have every reason to cry foul about the choices of political leadership being presented to them — and to demand something better than what the president currently has on offer.



24 Comments

So the answer in Obama’s fourth year is to start governing like he promised he would from the very beginning? I am 59 years old. Pardon me for being cynical even if I am not being screwed as much as the younger generation.
Amy, I really have to wonder.
Do you honestly consider that Barack Obama will DO what is necessary,not only about the things you mention, relative to young people, but in terms of what MOST people need, and have made very clear that they need?
Obama’s “problem” is simply that he has NOT been the President of the many, but the servant of a very select few.
Beyond that, Obama has continued the worst of the destructive Bush programs: The wars go on and have become secret,”Gitmo” continues to exist, and those caught in that limbo are even further from the lwegal and humane protections which ALL human beings deserve. the Rule of Law is made mock of by Obama’s “assertion” that he has the power to kill anyone, anytime, and anywhere that HE so chooses, without due process of law, through the use of armed drones that are killing civilians. As well, the criminal fraud of the massively bailed-out, “too-big-to-fail” banks goes on … unchecked and unpunished, TARP which was proclaimed to have been created to help homeowners was, instead, used to “foam the runway” for those banks and their top-most executives.
Instead of meaningful health care reform, a secret “deal was made with Big Pharma and the insurance “industry” resulting not in access to health care but easily manipulated health INSURANCE, and the ECONOMIC stimulus was a pathetic, ill-considered, “too-little-to-succeed” … sop.
The list goes on …
So, in addition to the things you mention, all members of the “youth vote” (frankly, a dismissive term, in my mind … being more concerned, if we are fully honest, with Barack Obama’s re-election “chances” than the plight of the younger generations) face a crumbling political economy AND a deliberately collapsed civil society, and the thoughtful ones, within this cohort, fully understand the implications of these other things, for their lives and future.
Other than blowing kabuki smoke at these young human beings, what do you imagine, specifically, that Barack Obama might, or would, honestly be willing to risk, politically and personally, in order to help them in their growing desperation?
Why, his administration cannot even perceive which way the wind is blowing when it comes to the growing support across all age groups, but especially among the young, FOR the legalization of marijuana and ending the first “endless” and phoney war … the war on drugs.
I hope, forlornly, no doubt, that your posts will not just be celebrity “drive-bys”; that you shall actually be willing to engage in a further discussion with those who take the time and consideration to comment on these posts of yours. Should you choose not to do so, then you may be very certain that you shall, soon, not receive very many responses … that your posts, however deserving of attention they might possibly be, will be judged, reasonably, to be nothing more that the verbal equivalent of the Hollywood “wave”.
If you truly care about the younger generations, then, please, get into the streets with them, meet them, come to know them, care about them as individuals, and do not pontificate to them from on high, and, if you are wise, never tell them what they must do. You may suggest, you may “lead” by example. Now, I am sorry if that might seem harsh to you, however, there is no other path, in our present and future world, to meaningful credibility … as Barbara Ehrenreich will certainly tell you … if you should ask.
DW
Well said DW. If Obama was really all that concerned with America, why would he have pushed for a “Grand Bargain” in the Kabuki theater around the expansion of the debt ceiling last year?
Sad as it is, Amy, for Obama, the cows kicked their way out of the barn, stamped down the fence, crossed the creek and were last seen grazing on tar sand and frack water. As Bob Dylan once sang, “When the foot of pride comes down, there ain’t no going back.” That’s the way that many of us feel now, young and old. The man is a dismal failure from my perspective, and evidently from that of a whole lot of others. How else could Mitt Romney have a snow ball’s chance in hell of getting elected? Your article shows just how out of touch you are.
Racheting up Bush’s war on marijuana isn’t exactly a good way to win friends and influence people under the age of 30.
Young people put the man in office, and he turned his back on them.
And they know it.
What a terrible waste of an historic outpouring of enthusiasm. What damage to the expectations of an entire planet.
Win them back? Dream on.
A lot of good points are made in the article and the comments but put as simply as possible: Obama has very little record of meaningful accomplishment. People my age, may out of fear, be in Obama’s court but I doubt that the country’s youth will be motivated by fear.
I have yet to hear anything substantial out of the Obama camp beyond “We Suck Less”.
Despite what bo was thinking after his 2008 victory, not all young people are stupid enough to fall for the bullshit twice.
Look at all the work the asshole is putting into campaigning for re-election. What a waste that he didn’t even put 10% of the same effort into the populist agenda of 2008. What a waste of time this guy is!
He did indeed. Obama’s recent escalation of the drug war is doing him no favors. It isn’t winning him any votes. Neither is the high unemployment (for both young people and everyone), and the student loan bubble. And let’s not forget last year’s debt disaster, when Obama was willing to trap the US into an austerity deal for a decade which would have hurt the economy even more.
Obama is under the mistaken impression that everyone who voted for him in 2008 is enamored of him, and will come back in 2012 because he’s so awesome (at least in his mind).
I’m 60 years old; and Barack Obama is, without doubt, the worst disappointment I ever voted for in any election for any office.
While anyone earns points for keeping faith in and believing that this American Democracy we Americans are told to keep faith in and believe works for us it is here in mid 2012 painfully plain to see such faith and belief is sorely misplaced and repeatedly now abused by the Ds and Rs who both clearly are elected by $$ and answer to $$.
The American militarists aka Pentagon/CIA/NatSecAgencies won the WH in 1964,1968,1972,1980,1988,1992,1996,2000,2004,2008 and it is not difficult to surmise will win the WH again in 2012,2016 and 2020 given the present political trendlines in USA,WashingtonDC and Wall Street.
The American corporatists who gave us Consumerism to deflect Communism post WW2 have gamed the boardplay in the United States to where they now routinely face no real world tax load(s),are able to marshall tremendous financial and market powers. The profits get taken private while the costs get socialized,ignored or given the kick the can down the road response.
Both the American militarists and corporatists have when combined the ultimate $$ “throwpower” to do what they have been doing since 1945 and ramped up everso much more during the 1960′s and again in the 1980′s and again post 2000. Barack Obama is their creature and it is plain to see Obama knows who he needs to please.
>>> The so called “American healthcare reform of 2009″ was little more than a public auction where the bidders were all insiders to begin with and knew when,where and at what point the auction ended.AHIP,PhARMA and allied interests won with Obama’s selling out early and often to give us the IED device we now are being mocked with called ACA.
>>> The 2007-2008 Real Estate,Mortgage and Funny Money Debacle went to the Wall Streeters as a win. Not part of the American One Percent Aristocracy? You know where you are here in 2012.
>>> Barack Obama has amplified the War On Drugs,War On Terror,War On Social Security,War On Public Commoms,War On A Green Earth. Deny this if you must to salve your partisan urges but this is fact and truth.
>>> Barack Obama is in the bag for TelAviv as is SoS Hillary Clinton who both routinely kowtow to TelAviv. This being so is at the root of much post WW2 ME poltical strife and military conflict. At this point here in 2012 who is protecting the ME from Israel? Not WashingtonDC which performs the role of a captured and occupied capital city for TelAviv. If Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton had to pick between the American people and TelAviv it is doubtful which they would pick — this is a very troubled state of affairs. Look to Iraq Debacle,look to Libya Sack and Pillage,look to what/who/why is tormenting Syria now and always keep in mind Iran has done nothing “wrong” other than cast WashingtonDC out of Iran or serve as misdirection for TelAviv’s brutal ME occupations and warmongering.
>>> Barack Obama and the Lost Youth Vote? Good inquiries abound about it but it is requisite to understand Barack Obama is doing what he is doing post 2008 because that is what Obama intended to do.
There is no set of reasons that will provide any other logical explanation. POTUS Obama is not being thwarted by the Rs or by anyone. POTUS Obama wins everytime even when Obama goes to great lenghts to stage political theatre narratives that Obama is a “thwarted POTUS”. Barack Obama betrayed many of us who elected him to the WH in late 2008 and it is plain to see this was intended as a sop to defuse what Bush and Cheney had piled up during their eight years as Co-POTUS. Barack Obama has not touched Bush or Cheney in any moral,political or legal way since Jan.20,2009. Fact and truth.
Stay with your optimistic hopes Amy if you must — you are surely not alone here at FDL or if you can take the BS levels allowed and enforced at such sites such as Salon,Dkos and Move On.
Recommended.
Like in x-word puzzles: Two-letter word, negative.
Ni? Na? Nu? Ne? No?
I suspect this is it, that he exists in a hermetic fantasy bubble where the only people he interacts with are either fellow politicians who share his cynical acceptance of the corrupted political process, the rich who can buy access or carefully vetted sycophants who dare not criticize him or even allow the thoughts that would give them the courage to germinate.
Reverse engineer his record of governance and it becomes obvious he is a man almost completely divorced from the common reality of Americans, who travels in circles where the terrible cost of his administration’s many failures is never felt. He is just another sociopath in a rarefied world inhabited by sociopaths, a world of ‘savvy businessmen’, of billionaire “pragmatists” and bought politicians who throw up their hands and say the system cannot be fundamentally changed- the same system that makes them obscenely wealthy and rains misery, poverty and hopelessness down upon the forgotten shadowy spectral masses below.
If Obama is the best we can “hope” for, we are lost, the country is doomed to its fate: a world where the rich dine at $20,000 a plate dinners to support politicians who will make them even richer while millions go hungry, bankers and mega-corporations rape and pillage with no checks or accountability, where the Bill of Rights is nothing but an impediment to control. A world without hope; a world with no will to change.
If you ever placed your hope in Obama, you placed your hope in the American political system. It’s a sucker’s game.
Tis a shame I can fan this comment. Better than I could have said.
If O is elected again, he will “fix” SS, and fix it really good. Romney can’t do it. And that’s why the 1% have already chosen him to win.
If Romney does any worse (I mean WTF? seriously?, how the heck is the magic underwear not beating O? … just equal?, … with the economy, endless war, … etc. insert O’s “accomplishments” here) than he’s the worst candidate ever. Because he’s supposed to be.
O must be “elected” again, or else they can’t get their SS privatization, aka “the fix”. And that’s O’s advantage over Romney. And the reason the 1% still want O.
Yes, he will win. If you think otherwise, … we can agree to disagree.
Yes, he will gut SS, I mean “fix” it.
And yes the applause cue will be met by Dems clapping and praising loudly. I can hear it.
I often try to not comment on these political sites anymore and have reduced my “follow along” of political sites to the point where FDL is the last one I do so at anymore. Likely a few ( many?) at FDL would be happy to see me go away and stay away here at FDL too…
I doubt if Barack Obama is going to lose the WH in November 2012. This 2012 WH election appears to be intended to not bring that about. Mitt Romney? Seriously?… it is a very real testimony to how pathetic this D Party DINO Barack Obama has performed as UniParty POTUS that the UniParty had to drag Mitt Romney thru the R Party Primary Circuses so to make it easier for Barack Obama to stumble and bumble back into the Oval Office post November 2012.
Barack Obama could have/would have been the re-incarnated FDR D Party PowerHouse POTUS if Barack Obama had been anything like his D Party handlers and campaign hacks were selling during 2007-2008. Was not. Is not.
I do think Barack Obama is the Stealth Weapon pointed at doing the undermining,gutting,defunding and politically killing and burying FDR’s New Deal Triumph,Social Security. The UniParty tried doing it with the R’s in the WH but it will be done more easily and with smudged/wiped clean fingerprints as well with a D/DINO POTUS like Barack Obama who is a real Ronald Reagan Admiring Democrat in the WH.
Being wealthy in the USA is a very good thing if you are. Fiat currency run by quasi private bank that games the funny money angles all around to benefit the One Percenters. It is a win-win for them. For the rest of us? Check out the fallen/still falling values of real estate,homes and real $$ values of pension/retirement schemes. You know if you are a victim of any or all of these funny money smoke and mirror acts. If all Americans had been given a fair cut of the $5-$7 trillion $$ the Wall Streeters,TBTG bankers and LasVegas styled derivative players were awarded since 2008 this American economy would be working quite well. But the $$ trillions went to the top of the shit pile and they ain’t going nowhere else. Ever see Barack Obama arresting anyone on Wall Street or any TBTF Banker types since Obama became POTUS on Jan.20,2009? No? …connecting the dots does not get much easier. The Haves Won. The Haves Own Obama. TeeterTotter.Rock and Roll. The Winners win…the losers? well they lose naturally. Socialized Capitalism…ain’t it swell?
As for Iran? Going to get it. Likely get it bad too. Lots of beautiful cultural history,architecture and a centuries old social fabric will get trashed worst than what befell Iraq.
As for American Empire? More and more I think the American Empire decided to link up with the British Empire about or vice versa ( same results ) about one hundred years ago. Around the time when IMM was building and launching the Olympic Class Ocean Liners ( see who really “owned” the White Star Line — it was part of a American/British corporatists entity call International Mercantile Marine. See Titanic — one of these Olympic Class liners — and April 1912. In 1913 the Americans came up with the Federal Reserve System. WW1 broke out in 1914. The British Empire fell into a the Trench Wars and by 1917 the American Empire took sides with the British Empire to take on the German Empire. Like the British Empire was the Good Empire ( see 18th and 19th century British Empire histories ) which the American Empire had business doing business with. But the American Empire did it again during WW2 and after 1945 the British Empire was chunked off into sunset after sunset while the American Empire dressed up in a virulent American imperialism and militarism we see in full bloom here in this early 21st century.
Thanks for your nice comment tambershall. If only our comments were able to do much more than just be that — a comment. I am old enough to still remember the day JFK was killed — was only in third grade when the school principal came into our classroom to announce that JFK had been killed. First time I ever heard the word assassinated.We went home early that November day. The United States went somewhere to. I am prone to think Barack Obama is a CIA linked and frontman POTUS. For obvious reasons. Political theatre being what political theatre is we are required to practice large amounts of suspended disbelief here in this post 9/11/01 21st century. I do know my parents had it better than I ever had or will. There is a markline at 1975 or so that charts the downward slide so many of us are now seeing and knowing firsthand. As tho the USA was a poor 3rd world nation. It is not. Which is the very well told Big Lie these days.
Take care tambershall. We all have to care enough to care about fact and truth and what is and what is not a Lie. What we cannot stop we should at least try to know about. Or know why the better choices were not made and who will win and lose with this being so. In the end being evil because it was easier is a poor/failing reason to give to try avoiding the perils of the HellWorlds.Perils richly deserved by those who would not see the evil they did and did more still of.
On some or many days I think there has to be another planet. I am just not telling too many humans about it if I ever get there…:-)
Better idea. Have All the young people vote Third Party.
I hope not.
Short answer? No.
I’m a young people. I hang out with young people. I can tell you that we all despise the man now.
He may be able to fool some of the people all of the time.
No. But it doesn’t matter. It’s getting to chose between two rapists.
Vote third party, join or start a coop, plant a garden and prepare for war.
x2 eCAHNomics and KrisAinTX.
MAH
Fool me once, shame on, shame on you. Ya fool me can’t git fooled agin.