This story is not about David, though it certainly could have been. Until the last five years of his life, he had no health insurance. He couldn’t afford it.
No, what follows is the HuffPost summary of a longer, must-read article that appeared Sunday in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinal (link here: http://www.jsonline.com/news/wisconsin/64677772.html)
Bill Caudle, 39, enlisted in the Army so that he could get health insurance (to) help pay for his wife’s ovarian cancer treatment, reports Mark Johnson of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. Bill was laid off from his job at a plastics company in March, where he had worked for 20 years, and searched for a new job for a few months before signing up so that his wife and high school sweetheart, Michelle, would be guaranteed chemotherapy. On their own, the Caudles’ insurance cost them $1,370 each month, which they could not afford on Michelle’s part-time salary at a fast food restaurant.
The four-year commitment means Bill will miss all of his youngest daughter’s four years of high school. Chelsea, the daughter, cried when her mother told her. Bill left for processing and basic training October 6. The next day, once he was officially processed, his Army health coverage started.
What’s wrong with this picture? I will tell you
This is the egregious example du jour of a U.S. health care system rotting at its core.
People, this is not a political issue, though it would be easy to make it one. No, this is a human rights issue, rooted in a socio-economic catastrophe.
This is the frickin’ United States of America—arguably the wealthiest and most powerful nation in the world. The powers that be have made absolute hash of our economy, having embraced a tops-down, law twisting, it’s-all-about-me-and-my-like-minded-greedicons way of thinking and doing things.
The net result is that the middle class is being crushed and the low-income class (which now includes much of what used to be the middle class) is being systematically decimated.
So people like Bill Caudle lose their jobs as companies forfeit the lives of human beings (yes, I really do mean that) in favor of maintaining temples where the holy bottom line is worshipped. I know, I know. Capitalism. Whatever.
So families like the Caudles are ground up in a system not necessarily of their making nor liking. They lose their modest incomes. They lose their benefits, because who the hell can afford the nose-bleed inducing premiums of Cobra and beyond? I’ve been there. I know.
So Bill Caudle saw risking his life in Iraq as the only solution to attempt to keep his wife alive and maybe, just maybe, make her cancer manageable.
Want to talk death panels, folks? Guess what. We’re living ‘em. We just don’t use that language to describe what we’re doing to our own people—people of every age, married, single, healthy, catastrophically diseased, irrespective of race and gender, every single day.
Now it gets political. Because if you believe this is wrong (and it is), then you need to make noise. Lots of it. You need to contact your Congress critters (House and Senate), and also some beyond your own corner of the country. You need to tell them that anything less than a “robust public option,” as they are fond of saying, is a travesty.
We are, in effect, sentencing our citizens to death by our failure to protect them. Ask Michelle Caudle. She knows. The death-panel-that-isn’t-acknowledged-as-such attempted to triage her. To condemn her to certain death in the absence of hopeful medical solutions. To tick off her name on a list of, “Gee, that’s too bad” victims because no one gives a hoot about her personally. “Eh, there are stories like that all over the place. If we allow ourselves to get personally invested in them, next thing you know, we’ll start caring. Compassion and the bottom line are not compatible, you see.”
Michelle Caudle is just one story among way, way, way too many. This is not a job for ghost-busters. It’s a job for you and for me. Will you call? And write? And make noise? Do. Now. Please.
(Cross-posted at www.clotheslineblog.com)



29 Comments




I saw this over at First Draft. It is so very sad, and maddening, and just plain wrong.
I’ve lost hope. They’re gonna dicker around, and they’ll pass something, but it will be something bad with mandates that make insurance companies richer and all of us who can’t afford the mandates criminals, and there won’t be coverage and this type of thing will still happen.
Teddy had it right, and it was so simple – Medicare for all. That was the path to take.
Good piece, barbara.
If you think this is not a pretty story, tho, hold on to your hat — it gets worse.
The left is (still) ignoring what’s really going on in the country and the culture.
The reichwing extremists have gone mainstream and they have the political and media apparatus in place — the GOP and its media mouthorgans: Fuxnewz, Rash Limpballz, Matt the Drudge, etc. ad nauseum — to finalize their 70-plus-year-old plan to dismantle all of FDR’s (and Progressives’) programs and policies, overthrow the democratically elected government (violently if necessary) and replace it with a fascist authoritarian theocracy based on biblical capitalism . . . or, in other words, drag America back beyond Plymouth Rock to the Old Testament era.
Frank Schaeffer wrote a book about it and so did Jeff Sharlett. Frank’s dad, Francis Schaeffer, was the architect of the plan, way back in 1935 and Jeff infiltrated the notorious C Street “church”/dorm where creeps like Mark Sanford, John Ensign, Tom Coburn and assorted fascist ilk bunked (tax free, too!) until recently when they apparently abandoned their posh digs there and disappeared to Dick Cheney’s underground bunker, wherever he’s hiding out these days.
It’s some pretty amazingly disgusting stuff that they’re up to — and it’s almost completely, totally secret, too (go figure). They preach that a small, “chosen by god(!)” group of Republicans (surprise surprise) is destined to rule over the rest of us poor slobs, and THEY will decide who will recieve whatever charity THEY deign to bestow on us, controlling every aspect of society, culture, and the economy from top to bottom.
I believe their “model” country is China, with its dictatorial political apparatus and policies of filling up its prison/factories with opponents and dissidents (Dick Cheney’s favorite wet dream, betcha betcha). And with all those for-profit private prisons to fill up, it’s the perfect solution to their “problems” — throw anyone who disagrees with you in jail, then work/starve them to death.
A co-opted fourth estate helps a lot, too. As long as the media remains on its lazy asses and follows Fuxnewz’s lead, the reichwing can continue to drive the agenda. And as long as the education system is under-funded and neglected, the population will become more and more under-educated and misinformed (re: Texas textbook policies) which results in a more easily manipulated and controlled (and desperate) slave-wage labor force.
See? It’s so simple. And obscene.
You’re right on about Medicare for all. That was David’s salvation. Now an argument could be made (and apparently is being made) that resources should not be “squandered” on those with (fill in the blank: metastatic cancer, renal disease, congestive heart disease, progressive neuro diseases, etc., etc., etc.)
So why David’s “salvation?” Because, while he never believed he could defeat his cancer, he lived in hope that he could beat it back, and the oncologists were supportive of that for a while. He wanted to live.
It sounds to me that, while Michelle Caudle’s cancer is quite advanced, she lives in hope and, like David, is highly motivated to beat back her disease, even in the face of some discouraging results and the unbelievable damage toxic chemicals do to a cancer patients body. Who would ever submit to that unless they want to live. This is a major pro-choice issue.
David’s safety net was Medicare. Michelle had nothing, once nose-bleed insurance premiums exhausted the family’s resources. And so it is that The System turns its back on the Michelle’s of our world, essentially saying, “Pay to play or die.” Harsh? Yup. True? Yup.
Wow. That’s a lot of info. Hard (for me) to figure out how the FOXes got positioned to run the henhouse. And harder still to understand why people hear and digest the garbage they’re fed there.
Does anyone know the demographics of FOX’s viewers? Besides the severe right-tilt? I’d be interested to know the education piece if it’s available. I agree with you that ignorance and/or a steady diet of warmed-over bile tilts the balance in favor of the conservative agenda. It was ever thus. Public schools are the devil’s workshop, did you know that? So goes the neocon talking point.
Okay, I’m totally off-topic here. Breathe, barbara.
Who could have foreseen that the truth about actual death panels would have been hijacked by the Republicans? No death panels for granny, but death panels for children, mothers and every other person the insurance companies wanted to dump by the roadside because they were unprofitable.
Capitalism and health care, a match made in hell.
George Lakoff says we must change the meme, e.g., death panels. But really, that’s what’s going on here, isn’t it? Republican values to thin the herd. I suppose Republicans get triaged, too. Why don’t they care? Or aren’t they allowed to speak of it?
“Perennial cable news leader, Fox News Channel finished the third quarter 2009 up among total viewers and news’ target demographic of 25-54 year olds. FNC averaged 2.25 million total viewers in primetime (Monday through Sunday), for an uptick of 2% year-to-year, with 583,000 in the demo for a gain of 5%, according to Nielsen Media Research.
FNC was the third-ranked basic cable network among total viewers behind ESPN and USA. CNN came in at number 20 while MSNBC was 25th.
Led by The O’Reilly Factor (which averaged 3.3 million viewers), the network also had all ten of the top ten cable news programs among total viewers. ”
http://www.broadcastingcable.com/article/355911-Cable_Ratings_Fox_News_Stays_Ahead_of_Competition_Sees_Uptick_in_Viewers_Demo.php
Great piece, thank you. I hadn’t seen this story until now.
Hmmm. Clearly the kinda/sorta liberal media dominates the pack, given CNN in 20th place and MSNBC at 25. /s
And will FOX et al be telling the story of Michelle and Bill Caudle? I’m guessing . . . mmmmm . . . no.
Thanks for this, bb.
Thanks, Jason. Spread the word, please. There are a kezillion stories out there, but this one seems to capture the diabolical health care system in a snapshot. Rock. Hard place. Indifference, writ large.
This is frightening. These fascists keep shouting “we’re the greatest country in the world” while gutting it. Why don’t they like democracy?
These authoritarians want to replace the Constitution with the Bible. But which “bible”? The one they’re going to revise and edit beyond all recognition? Or with the one where God says to welcome strangers? To assist those in need? Love your enemy as yourself?
Idea, idea!! The Bible redacted. Would save the radical right so much time and money. Maybe even off-shore the project. Just draw big, dark lines through the offensive parts. Otherwise, the New Testament will read like a three-page epilogue.
You’re welcome. I laughed out loud at your The Bible redacted comment. Sad, but true. It is not an all volunteer army when people have to join to feed their families and get medical coverage. At Knoxville’s diary link the calls where at 72,722 a minute ago.
Nice barbara;
Thank you.
You have called it like it is.
You have called out those who caused it.
Their credo is
“Greed is Good” and “the Divine Right of Money shall not be challenged”.
DW
Thanks.
This is a very touchy subject in my little corner of the world since I know a few folks who are employed by major insurance companies. I’ve nearly severed my tongue more than once, chomping down to keep from screaming, “Greed! Profit uber alles! Especially over the well-being of clients! Bonuses for cutting back on claims paid! How big was your CEO’s salary cut to improve the bottom line? Huh? Huh? Huh?” That would be crass, I suppose. And, like everyone else, my friends need their jobs. (sigh)
Obama cannot be unaware of the horrific senseless stories like this one that emerge on a daily basis.
He cannot be unaware that they are but a few drops in a vast ocean of stories spanning many years.
He cannot be unaware that 147,000 preventable deaths happen each year because the people who died couldn’t afford health insurance or their insurance company denied/terminated coverage.
Obama knew this when he told members of Congress and a national television audience that the insurance companies aren’t evil, they’re just trying to make a profit, and he knew it when he falsely accused us of being the bad guys because we’re stubborn “ideologues” for insisting on real change instead of cosmetic touch-ups to cover windfall profits rewarding insurance companies for killing us.
Obama can save what’s left of the decimated public option by demanding it be included in the final Senate bill, but he isn’t even willing to do that.
He can’t be bothered to say a few words that might save hundreds of thousands of lives and I utterly despise him for that.
Hi Mason, Have you got a cite for the 147K fatalities annually? I’d like to use it myself, but would would like to see the source.
Took your advice — breathed, and inhaled.
You’re right about my militant venting. It’s just I know how crazy these people really are — and how dangerous.
I saw some guy on Chris Matthews’s show earlier, an “Oath Keeper,” some reichwing paramilitary group who recruits ex-cops and soldiers to take an oath NOT to follow orders from the feds if a state decides to invoke its sovereignty. They want to fight the Civil War all over again but they’re calling it a Revolution b/c that’s sounds a lot more ‘Merican and flag-wavy patriotic.
Chris sucked, btw. He never pressed the guy to answer any of his questions — he’s too in love with the sound of his own voice. He spends 5 minutes with a guest and monopolizes 4 1/2 of it phrasing a question, and the rest of it interrupting the guest’s answer.
History note: Hitler came to power in 1932 with only 29% of the vote. Never underestimate your enemy.
Oh, and the slogan he won with: “Rebirth or Bolshevism!”
Sound familiar?
There is this study from Harvard which found 47,000 excess deaths annually due to lack of insurance. I suspect 147,000 is a transcription error.
THERE ARE A MILLION STORIES IN THE BIG COUNTRY. What You don’t seem to realize is that those people who vote in the Senate, don’t vote by stories like this, but what they think. What they think is that’s not me. Just like Kyle didn’t want to pay for women healthcare because he didn’t need it.
The people in these stories aren’t them, and they don’t want to pay for them, or give them anything.
You see even the so-called Democrats that are against what would help people like this, call themselves Conservatives. So we can finally see that conservative doesn’t mean what it implies, but means I don’t care unless it’s me.
We see it, but don’t get it. The conservatives say they are for smaller Government, but it grew twenty percent while they were in power. They say they want low taxes, but taxes went up because their cheap policies forced the states to collect more taxes to pay for what they mandated and no longer paid. They say they are the party who is conservative towards Governemnt spending, but every phaze of it went sky high while they were in power. They say they are religious, moral, and for whats right for us, yet everything they did while in power was against most of us, and for the powerful. Now they are wanting to kill the Healthcare bill, saying it’s abd for us. They want it to be almost impossible to file bankruptcy. Both the things that would have helped the people in that story.
When are we going to wake up to the fact that these people are not just the opposing party, but the enemies of the people of the United States.
Help for those million stories, will be small if any, even in the proposed bills going through the Congress now. Remove the conservatives of both parties, and we have a chance of changing things. Leave them there and have a constant fight not just for healthcare but for whats right for our Country.
If you’ve ever noticed my comments (or, lately, lack thereof), you will know how hard I am trying not to hate Obama. I think I won’t, but I concede it’s getting harder and harder to do my little Peter Pan “if you believe in fairies, clap your hands” thing. Have you told him? I know that sounds supremely naive, but have you told him?
If such a thing is possible, I have a personal retrospective stake in this, because it’s a certainty my David would have been triaged sans Medicare. Too old to be of value, actuarially speaking.
I have long believed that those who are cloistered in their ivory towers and white houses should be required — required!! — to spend a portion of each year with the people they represent (insurance clients, citizens of this country, members of congregations, classrooms, etc.) because once their world is fly-by and photo ops, there is no way in billy hell they can get what’s happening to us.
Please don’t give up. Push him. Push him hard.
The other thing to know about me, FWIW, is that I don’t watch television. My old console served as an end table for a decade or so. Once in a while, I watch the Vikings or, if I’m really in a self-flagellation state, the Twins.
So, I have only seen YouTube clips of Matthews. But this…
…totally squares with what I’ve seen. And yeah, it’s mighty darn frustrating. None of this is journalism. None of it. And that includes Olbermann and Maddow. They’re entertaining, but way too eager to demonstrate their arguable grasp of things, hammering whomever is in their sights at the moment. It grows tedious. And what does it accomplish for the left? Pretty much nada. Really. Didn’t we see earlier that CNN ranks 20th and MSNBC 25th in viewership of cable “news”? Urgh.
Merriam Webster says this about what it is to conserve:
But then they define conservative thusly:
May I respectfully suggest that “keeping in a sound state” often requires informed decision-making and potential course-correction?
People, “keeping in a sound state” is about preserving mummies. It’s about moribund, stagnating policies that, particularly in the case of health care, do not serve the people well. Hell, do not serve the people at all. Well, serves some people. The executives and the lobbyists and the legislators who are in thrall to both.
formidable, I’m not being a good model here for kumbayah. Sorry.
To keep a sound state, could mean a robust economy free from crooks and based on solid finacial policies, and doing what is best for people and country.
Question what have the conservatives ever done to keep a sound state?
Sorry for the mistake. Realworld’s post at #20 is correct. Thanks to both of you for bringing it to my attention and correcting it.
“Hi Mason, Have you got a cite for the 147K fatalities annually? I’d like to use it myself, but would would like to see the source.”
“There is this study from Harvard which found 47,000 excess deaths annually due to lack of insurance. I suspect 147,000 is a transcription error.”
Hate to admit it, but it wasn’t a typing error. I just sent my memory a message warning it to not make that mistake again.
No need to apologize — I was never much one for the kumbaya-thing either.
BTW, I don’t know what you base your definition of “jouranalism” on, but I’ve read a lot of the articles on timearchives.com from the 1940s, 50s, and 60s during the civil rights era and most of them are so outrageously slanted towards the Jim Crow/segregationists it’s absolutely horrifying, so I’m not sure that your dismissal of KO and RM is totally justified (as being pawns in the same game as the Neoconservative knuckle-draggers) — that seems to be playing the false equivalency game to me.
I once read a definition of what journalism is (or should be) on the Guardian/UK’s site — it said it was the reflection of reality, not the writer’s opinion of it. At least KO and RM are trying, which is more than can be said of Fuxnewz.
My 26-y.o. son doesn’t have insurance either — we’ve got our fingers crossed.
R Crumb just released an illustrated version.
What I was speaking to re KO and RM is the tone and the melodrama, which mostly applies to KO (far as I know from what I’ve seen). I totally get that news has been slanted since the Tower of Pisa was constructed. I am very old-fashioned, I guess, with respect to civility. And it seems to me civility makes the radical right absolutely nuts. They can’t deal with it. When we climb into their nasty nook with them, they simply up the ante faster and faster. Bill Moyers is a journalist. With a point of view. But immensely . . . civil.