When I was in high school, opposed to the Vietnam “war” and impressionable, I read Emma Goldman and discovered Peacemakers. I believed in anarchism and embraced civil disobedience.
I modified my thinking over time, but I remain politically active and call myself progressive. Among the more difficult of my struggles personally has been the line I’ve walked between art and politics, not because they don’t go together but because I never fully committed my life to art. But that’s another story.
Politically, I have become increasingly disillusioned, and I embrace OWS, in my case (un)Occupy, as one of the few movements in my lifetime in the US that addresses the broad and disparate crises of our failing economy (and capitalism), the horrors of climate change and perhaps most important, exercises a methodology of equality and inclusion. It has inspired young people who are smart, tech-savy and committed to change and the future.
I was arrested with (un)Occupy in Albuquerque in October 2011, defending our space. In August 2012, I was arrested in Los Alamos at the annual anti-nuclear event that commemorates the bombing of Hiroshima. I did this in part to honor my father, who died in 2009 and was the most visible anti-nuclear activist in Los Alamos for decades. It was easy to be arrested.
What is not so easy is the aftermath. There were 6 of us arrested that day, and we are in solidarity about our reasons for being there and our unity going forward. We are in a different court than those who have been arrested since 1999 in Los Alamos. Our trial will be held in municipal court, the judge is the former police chief. We were taken into custody by a private security force and turned over to the local authorities. All of the witnesses against us are police, who may have relationships with the judge.
The Los Alamos National Laboratory was run by the University of California until 2005 or so. At that time, a public/private partnership was demanded (in part due to hyped up post-9/11 security incidents), and UC partnered with Bechtel to win the contract. From my perspective, the arrangement has been a disaster. The workers at the Lab despise Bechtel, the yearly cost of running the lab (to taxpayers) has gone from under $30 million to $100 million, and the fabric of the community has been damaged by the short-term contracts and job insecurity that seem to be the SOP of the corporatocracy.
The cost of maintaining the nuclear arsenal continues to climb, and of course the weapons themselves are unusable no matter what, unless we want a truly ruined planet. Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD) was the brilliant strategy that got us to this point, and we continue to operate from that basic framework today. To that end we destroyed communities and homelands in the Pacific with testing, we poisoned communities, lands, water and air from Nevada to New Mexico and beyond. The LANL 6 stand against all of this.
The work of the Laboratory could be useful if we harnessed all the brainpower for climate change, for example. It is not hard to fight for a better future, and I have no regret for going to Los Alamos that day. I am proud to stand with others who believe the same. We are fortunate to have lawyers who have supported resisters throughout their careers. They have been volunteering their expertise and have given us their time unstintingly.
On January 9 we will be on trial in Los Alamos. The charges for each of us carry possible fines of up to $1500 and maximum jail time of 179 days. (We are denied a jury if the possible sentence is less than 180 days/6 months.)
I have some kind of a platform here, and I wonder how to make the best use of it. We are dreamers here, I think. My father used to say, “Do good.” How do I best do good next week? What say you, esteemed community of FDL?



52 Comments

I’m proud to virtually know one of the LANL 6 at least a little bit, bgrothus.
Dreaming some ‘doing good’ and useful will take time to consider, but first: is there any way your attorneys can see to tweak the sentencing guidelines enough to secure you a jury trial? Are you all co-defendents with a single trial? Would media attention help or hurt your cause?
And of course I’m wondering about anti-nuclear solidarity with the local Pueblos, First American activists, Idle No More groups, and of course (un)Occupiers. Would those alliances be more likely to piss off the judge, or would this judge be swayed by calls for leniency or dismissals of the charges from the community?
Rec’d for now, and my heart goes out to you for your dedication to the planet and to your dear father who set you such a stellar example. Whoosh.
Well, there is little doubt about the outcome, IMO, but sentencing, who knows? We can appeal to another court where we may get a better hearing. We tried to remove the judge, but he got to decide, and he said, “No.”
I hope media attention will help. Of course we are working together with our community on this. We are on trial together.
I have no illusions about the court, and we expect solidarity from around. Won’t make any difference to the judge, I don’t think. Glad to have evidence of IdleNoMore in the area, hope to have some support there.
Shoot, bgrothus; the 9th is just a week away! Ya might have given us a li’l bit more lead time, eh? ;o) In the meantime, would a petition help, or again, hurt?
And maybe someone could advise you on the tags your diary should have in order to spread it around in the cache. (I’m crap at tags.)
Sorry, I did not want to have too much lead time, figured a week is enough to think about this.
I forgot tags. I will add some. Thanks.
{{{ bgrothus }}} I didn’t find what the charges against you are.? I thought it was trespassing…?
Can we all contribute to pay your fine? I wish I could come up with a way to “do good”.
Will follow any lead you think is worthy.
Thank you for being so brave and true. I bow down
Ach, I wasn’t criticizing, just teasing a bit, especially as I’m a slow thinker. ;o)
Is it okay if I bring a few links to explain a bit more history of the action at the Lab, and a couple of support links? It would necessitate outing your name, etc., so please know I’ll understand if you’d rather I don’t.
I’m out, Wendy, not a concern.
Also, don’t think about the fines. We won’t be paying any. That’s the rub.
I hope the mods front page this, my friend, so more minds can dream the good with you.
If any of these are not to your liking, you can go into the Edit function; at the top in a grey bar (iirc) there is an icon like a speech balloon; click on it, and you get choices about moving a comment to the trash.
Your father is lionized in one of these at least. ;o) Some history:
http://www.occupynewmexico.org/anti-nuclear-activists-blockade-lanl-gates/
http://www.sfreporter.com/santafe/blog-3679-nuke-free-now.html
Support links
http://www.grass-roots-press.com/2012/12/21/trial-of-the-los-alamos-6-and-nuke-free-now-in-2013/
http://losalamos6.tumblr.com/
…and there are further links at the bottom.
Martin Luther King Jr. proceded you to jail for justice …Some good company.
Remember you are going to a court of law not a court of justice…in or out of Jail work for Justice.
There are no exit ramps just entrance ramps on the highway to Nuclear, it’s our death warrant.
Thanks for writing this up as a diary, bg. I’m not good at strategy much, but since nuclear is such a huge issue after the continuing Fukushima horror, has there been any collaboration with peeps working on Fukushima?
Man, I really, really hope you don’t wind up in jail, but if you do, is there access to social media or web logging through an intermediary? It would be way too many days for a hunger strike or some such, I suppose?
Recommended!
Recommended! Keep up the good fight!
I trust that the (un)Occupy folks have trial support and jail support activities in mind to publicize this case. It is interesting that you are being taken to municipal court; the NATO 5 are in county court. Must be a way to ensure a kangaroo trial.
Just in case you are placed out of reach of a way to blog, have someone there be able to blog your stuff on FDL. Stand proud in your family tradition.
I read in your assertion that there will be no fines, an assertion of your First Amendment rights to freedom of speech and freedom of assembly to petition your government for redress of grievances. I trust you have good legal representation. Within the context of their advice, I think you raise these issues: (1) whatever your issues statement is for the Los Alamos protest; (2) the disappearance of meaningful freedom of speech in address government actions; (3) the disappearance of truly public space for assembly; (4) the increasing privatization of our law enforcement and court systems in ways that imperil the first, fourth, and fifth amendments. Just my opinions here. And have this as an elevator speech that you say whenever you encounter a camera, microphone, or reporter. Short enoough for them to copy and print in full. Or soundbite in full. (Should they be honest journalists). Frame it as best you can so that the the most conservative pro-nuclear person in New Mexico will have to fight the impulse to nod in agreement. (High bar, there, eh.)
I fear we are only beginning to see trial and jail reports on FDL this year, as much as I hope we aren’t. There is that much crap going on at all levels of government.
I have full confidence that you will “Do good.”
Also, jail support provides an opportunity to report on jail and prison conditions to the world.
This song from the civil rights movement did go through my head: “Paul and Silas bound in jail; got no money for to go their bail; keep your eyes on the prize; Hold on. Hold on. Hold o-o-on. Keep your eyes on the prize. Hold on.” Part of your statement could be about the prize.
Thanks for pressing the issue. Hoping for the best outcome. Solidarity.
FB’d the grassroots press link to my personal network.
Thank you, ThD. One of our lawyers is part of the group that is representing NATO Chicago. They go back to COINTELPRO and Hampton, so I am humbled for this support. As for kangaroo court, no doubt about that.
As for the matter of fines, what I said is that we will not be paying any fines, to be clear.
Thanks for the ups on your network. Much appreciated.
Also, thanks for the support here. I doubt we will be able to do any communication via the net from jail, but we will try to cover that base as best we can. Of course we are in good company, and much humbled by that too. As I said, I have been a supporter of CD for most of my life, just not in this position before.
(((((bgrothus)))))
You and the others are heroes. Jane was arrested for protesting the Tar Sands. Tarheel was arrested for protesting NATO.
Thank you for blogging about it. Please keep that up.
Like the idea of shifting Los Alamos’ priorities to climate change.
Recommended (FDL)
Tweeted
Recommended (FB)
Not a hero, or at least I don’t think of it that way. However, it may be that we get publicity for the cause, and that would be good.
If they want to keep it quiet, they dismiss it. If they want to discourage future action, they go wild. Maybe somewhere in between. No way to guess at this time.
Thank you for putting this post on FDL, bgrothus.
I hope that many members of this community might read it and look at the links which wendy made available, @ 8.
Thank you, Barbara, for your courage, your humor, and your steadfast and long history of standing for what matters. Much respect to your father, as well.
Recommended to the thoughtful attention and considered conscience of everyone.
DW
Rec’d!
As for the fate of the facility… true justice would be to have Los Alamos tasked with conducting practical R&D on procedures and engineering prototype gear for dealing with severe fission plant disasters and meltdowns ala Fukushima.
The same practical R&D that is decades overdue strictly because of corporate greed.
Here’s an idea, but I can’t in good conscience really ask you to do it, and in fact, struggled for some time before posting. But I immediately thought “What if that were me, what would I do that might do some long term good??” And I came up with something that I THINK I would do, but, you know, thinking you would do it and actually doing it, are sometimes two different things. At the end of the day I may just be a coward full of hot air.
You, however, are not, which is why I hesitated so before sharing this. Please know this bgrothus, as this is truth. I am literally HONORED to have shared fonts and ideas with you, and am in such a state of deep gratitude for what you have already done that I could never, ever thank you enough. What you’ve already shown is more than most, and asking anymore is…. unfair I think.
So I will share what came into my mind when I did the “What would I do” thought experiement, but know this, I don’t actually wish you do it, in fact I wish that you don’t. I mean this sincerely. I am sharing so as to perhaps give you some more ideas of a direction you can go that wouldn’t be quite the risk of this. And further, know this, WHATEVER you do, or don’t do, I remain HONORED to have “known” you, and you are actually a hero to me. Thank you.
But my thought experiment of what I would do went like this:
I would at all times of the proceedings be polite, attentive, and follow all instructions to the letter. Then I would simply ask that my lawyer see if I could have a couple of minutes to address the court before sentencing.
And then I would look that likely corrupt motherfucker right in the eye, and NEVER take my eyes away, letting him know I know who’s “right” in this case and tell him this:
“Your honor, first of all I want to say I’m sorry that you and all of these other folks have had to spend some of your valuable time on something that I did, as that was not my intention, and I am sincerely sorry.
Secondly, I want to say your honor that I don’t hate my country. I love my country.. with a passion. It’s this passion that leads me to do the kinds of things I do that have led me here today, as I attempt to stand up for what’s right and just in this world today that is so corrupt and unjust.
Our founding fathers gave me the right to peacably assemple to redress all of my grievances, and your honor, I have a long list of grievances that I believe to be valid, and just. And this is what I attempt to do when I do the kinds of things that led me here today.
And because the founding fathers gave me this right, and because I am so sure that my cause is right and just, it is my opinion that I should not be punished for such actions.
Because of this opinion sir, I view any jail time as another example of how unjust our system is, and consider such an order invalid. Therefore, if I must face addition injustice, then I must again protest such an injustice. As such, I will refuse to eat for any time I find myself in jail, both as a further protest of our grievances here, as well as in support of my fellow woman up north who does the same thing in the name of idle of No more.
I do this not out of anger or disrespect to you sir, as I will honor whatever ruling you give today. I do it because in my heart I believe it to be just one more injustice that I must speak out against.
Thank you for this time to speak and once again I am sorry that you even had to be here today.”
Recommended! Courage, Barbara (which I know you have in abundance)!!
Thank you for walking the talk. Hope you stay inspired. Also I hope you have the best of luck and are able to avoid the 179 days in jail.
Some new feature documentary is coming out about the nukes hanging over the heads of every one on the planet. All of us are just one opportunistic terrorist cell away from a suitcase bomb going off, or the Russians mistaking one of missile launches that is carrying weather satellites to fly over Norway as INCOMING.
I think you should listen to Burt Rutan on Climate Change – WUWT-TV November 14th 2012 – YouTube
Burt Rutan is a smart guy that I trust more than Al Gore. Don’t get me wrong, we’ve done a terrible job of taking care of home planet. However, I’m not sure we can trust all the grant funded hype, terror talk and control mechanisms, like carbon taxes and Agenda 21.
Take some time to hear what he is saying and keep in mind what this man has done in the course his lifetime, through his own initiative.
Good luck with the court case.
Recommend & FB’d
Courage girl courage.. You will endure and will fight another day for what is right for every living being on this blue pebble of the cosmos we call home!!
I emailed your post to hotflashcarol, veteran of Occupy Oakland, and asked her for ideas. She said their #1 tactic was to pack the courtroom with well-behaved (lol) supporters.
It seems I didn’t post this arrest link from the Los Alamos Daily Post earlier, but as far as positive coverage, I think they did well.
While digging it our again, I found this singularly creepy new item from AP and FoxPhilly:
Oopsie; did Bechtel blow it?
Can you freaking believe this amount of money? Thanks for the update, wendydavis.
I will try to find out more about the shooting incident. Nice that the place is a “campus.”
How Bechtel gets away with this is incredible. Fire the SOC people (Save Our Country is the name of the security outfit), but pay this incompetent manager another $41M and give ‘em a whole nother year to get this thing up and running? Come on.
They are criminals, that is all I can say.
The way they get away with it the same way as all the looters and villains and planet-trashers do: owning Congress and the White House. They write the policy, including tax policy, the NDAA, the military promotes you for fucking up but having a good PR firm, same with nations who are our ‘partners in peace’. Commit genocide in Congo? Give some money, get a good Madison Avenue firm…bingo. Commit massive bank fraud? Get Lanny Davis to cut you a nice Deferred Prosecution, and tell the public it was the right thing to do cuz…cuz…the system must not tremble. Feh! Sorry; this administration is so corrupt and working so hard against the American people (well, not to mention brown and black people around the world) some days I feel like I could blow a goddam gasket.
Guess I need to go out and look at the Milky Way tonight, eh? Get some perspective? ;o)
Anyhoo, I hope the judge knows what sentencing you all to jail will bring down on his head, and he lets our people go.
Bechtel ran a scam on Massachusetts that bankrupted the state with its ridiculous cost overruns, and killed with its shoddy workmanship. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Dig
bgrothus,
I’m glad you took this step to write. I know you were not enthusiastic about doing it, but I hope you rerun the info from lln. It would be so very important for people who want to do something more. Supporting C.O. in another fashion so-to-speak.
Thanks for your commitment and courage. Holding you in our hearts and minds for sure.
Bechtel is the one that should be in jail. And for the above Atrocity, instead of going to jail, Bechtel was awarded yet more Government contracts.
I could use a lesson in organizing information, wendydavis. Thanks for posting the incident links above.
I know there is probably an official term for it, but when you f#*K things up so bad, you make yourself indispensable because nobody else could fix or wants to fix your mistakes.
Barbara, here is a video of my Occupy Oakland friend Nichola Torbett, who was one of the Vandenberg 15, which included Daniel Ellsberg and other activists. They were arrested for protesting the launch of a Minuteman III Intercontinental Ballistic Missile from Vandenberg Air Force Base to the Kwajalein Atoll in the Marshall Islands. In this video filmed the night before their court appearance, they already knew that the charges were going to be dropped. But Nichola talks about having been willing to go to jail and unwilling to pay the fine. I also remember her posting a really interesting statement on Facebook – it was what she was planning to tell the judge before she knew that the charges would be dropped. I asked her to send me that because I think it will be inspirational.
The jail support information that Tarheel Dem posted is exactly what I was thinking about, so glad he shared that here. I wish all of you courage and strength, and I thank you for putting your freedom on the line for the rest of us.
Oh, Barbara, I didn’t realize time for trial was so close.
As an aside, I do remember when UC was accused of mismanagement and were kicked out of Los Alamos. Privatization…that always goes so well, doesn’t it? And it’s always pushed as cheaper and more efficient, and it’s always more expensive and less efficient.
But back to you and your trial. I presume you are charged with a simple misdemeanor trespass, given the fine amount and the just-less than six month sentence maximums.
Tarheed Dem and others who’ve commented on the type of court; remember that where a case is tried depends on a given state’s organization and system of courts. Trespassing is usually a misdemeanor. It may well be that Illinois’ county court jurisdiction is equivalent to New Mexico’s municipal court – the lowest level (with the exception of justice of the peace courts,if a state has them). Remember that each state is different, and each state sets the jurisdictional limits for each level of court.
Weren’t the Nato protesters charged with more than trespass? Forgive me, but I can’t remember exactly.
Anyway. In Texas, I would predict a first offense misdemeanor trespass sentence of probation, or deferred adjudication — that’s where if you “stay out of trouble” for a given period, at the end of that period the charges are dismissed and you have no conviction. Conviction is what’s deferred.
It also means that if you do get arrested again, or say, fail a drug test at any time during the deferred period, you are automatically convicted and you have given up your right to appeal as part of the deferral agreement.
That’s the most likely sentence for a respectable middle-aged Anglo middle class lady, under ordinary circumstances.
But, under these circumstances, a political defendant (or group of defendants) despised by the court/judge for their views and actions, and a former police chief as the judge, I would not be surprised to see some actual jail time handed down.
That’s all theoretical though,from someone with no experience in the actual state and city with the actual law.
What are your lawyers saying? Or have they advised you not to discuss their predictions and advice in public?
when you say the fines will not be paid (note, she didn’t say “there will be no fines” but that any fines won’t be paid), I assume you mean you will deliberately refuse to pay any fine the court assesses.
I assume you’ve considered that carefullly, and that your lawyers have warned you of the consequences.
The consequences very likely being serving the jail time. Only if you are trying to pay an assessed fine but simply are too low-income to pay will the fine be forgiven without jail time.
Many of my clients charged with petty crimes preferred to do the time because they were just too poor to pay a fine.
If you were my client,I would probably say “pay the fine,” and we’ll raise the money. My basic view of civil disobedience principles is that you accept whatever the legal punishment is when you deliberately violate an unfair law. In most cases, that has historically meant serving time.
I’m laying this out mostly for non-lawyer readers because I’m sure that Barbara has been through all this with her lawyers and fellow protesters.
On the other hand, if you are not going to pay because you plan to appeal, that’s another thing.
But unless there are legal issues (as in so many Occupy arrests, for example, where cops seem to have dragged people carefully staying within permitted areas into non-permitted areas for the purpose of arresting them), it seems to me to violate the principle of CD to appeal. IF that is, the arrests were legitimate under the letter of the law.
I see this comment is getting long, so I’ll forgo analyzing further complications raised by these last points.
You haven’t really said what your theory of this protest is, Barbara, so I’m not sure what you’re looking for.
(I’ll support you, though, even if we disagree on tactics, believe me. Just thinking this through with my lawyer’s wig on right now.)
Wow. I apologize; if we had edit here I would break that comment up;didn’t realize I had gotten that prolix.
(“preview is our friend”)
I guess the last thing that didn’t make it into that long post is that, since the trials of Vietnam protesters in the ’60′s, judges usually refuse to allow “speeches” by defendants. Beginning an explanation if the court denies permission for it is likely to get a defendant handcuffed and hustled out of the courtroom by deputies/bailiffs/court security people.
That would probably get coverage on the news, if they aren’t covering it anyway. But I’d seriously think about whether it’s worth it.Only you can decide that.
Thank you,tejanarusa ! Your comment was spot on, not long, especially considering the amount of info needed to walk a lay person thru it. It’s good to know.
Here’s hoping it doesn’t come to actual incarceration, that’s for criminals – and you’re not.
Kind of you to say. Pretty horrifically long by comment standards, though. I really try not to do that.
Hope I didn’t bring the thread to a crashing halt.
tweeted and recommended, bg. so glad you wrote this up
Thank you everyone for your thoughts, links and advise. I truly appreciate it and am so sincerely grateful for your interest in this situation.
Please know that even if I have not responded to your comments personally that I am reading carefully and taking all into my heart and mind.
This is why I posted, because I value the community here and know that you will give your best in response.
Namaste. Never. Give. Up. Do Good.
Na
Yes.
Nothing really to offer in the way of advise. I just want to let you know my heart is with you bg. It’s my birthday that day, but I know I’m going to be thinking about you more than I’ll be focused on myself.
I hope all goes well for you bgrothus and that karma comes back to bite the butt of that judge if he does engage in kangaroo court antics. I would definitely take my background information (both personal history AND the history of mismanagement by Bechtel)to a newspaper and “invite” them to come to your hearing.
At the very least it might get the community discussing the merits of Bechtel and its management and the cost it has had on your community.
My dear Barbara. First, thank you. I am sure you considered that jail was a possible outcome when you got arrested, but actually looking at time in the slammer right up close, well, no matter what you had planned, it gives one pause. I have not put myself in that position because of others who depend on me right now, but that may change, and who knows? perhaps someday not doing so will be unbearable or impossible. For now, I don’t put myself on that path.
I honour and admire you for doing this necessary work, though.
It may come to jail time. Proud and honourable tradition, you would be in excellent company. Have you seen Mandy Hiscocks blog, “Bored but not broken”, which she posted (by proxy) from Vanier Prison for Women. She was released on Nov 21, the blog stops there, but it is good reading. She found many ways to grow and to do good there, and I certainly will never be the same after reading her posts.
WRT the Speech, I have to agree w/Tejanarusa. Chances of them permitting you to address the court are slim to nil. But as Noam Chomsky remarked, speaking truth to power is a waste of time; power knows the truth. It’s the ordinary people who need to hear the truth.
I wonder, what would your father advise? My mother has been dead these twenty years and more, but I still sometimes talk to her, and if I listen hard enough, it seems she answers.
Good fortune, and keep us posted, if you can and want to.
((( bg ))) Rock on, woman. You are courageous and steadfast. Will be keeping you in my thoughts.
I’ve been re-reading Mandy’s blog, and I think this post may be of use and interest to anyone who might find themselves doing what David Swanson called in a post earlier this week ‘hard time for peace’.
Mandy’s post, In case you or a friend are planning to join me.
Again, my sincere thanks to all of you for sharing resources. It is inspiring and strengthening to listen to and read about the real courage some have and to be in solidarity with others on these paths!
You, like your Dad, are inspirational too, M’dear…! *g*
What Tarheel is saying is true – be sure and have an elaborate version of your personal Manifesto, to keep your self going. But also have the version that is in nice little media-friendly sound bytes. Often the difference between becoming a media darling or media ignored is whether or not there is that sound byte.
Twitter censorship spotter @section_2b says that this Tweet:
is not on a search of Twitter for hashtag #USpoli (see https://twitter.com/Section_2b/status/286676587498311680 ).
I checked and don’t see the Tweet in Twitter’s list when I run a search on #USpoli either.
Meanwhile, @DavidcnSwanson kindly mirrors this diary at http://warisacrime.org/content/countdown-jail.