“…everybody knows what the commission’s targets are… Medicaid, Medicare, and Social Security.”
Rev. Al Sharpton and the NAACP’s Ben Jealous, along with most of the old black political class want us to think the most important thing happening is their ongoing clown fight with Glenn Beck and Sarah Palin. The newer crowd of tech-savvy, social-network-aware types around Color of Change think the most key and crucial thing to do is to make airports, bus and train stations Turn Off Fox News. They’re both wrong. The real action is someplace else.
Back in April, President Obama created the National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility & Reform. Its purpose is to recommend, this December 1, just after the elections, measures that will save the government money, “to improve the fiscal situation in the medium term and to achieve fiscal sustainability over the long run.” The president has pledged in advance that he will push whatever his commission recommends through Congress in the lame duck session.
And everybody knows what the commission’s targets are. They won’t recommend ending the wars in Yemen, Pakistan, Iraq, Somalia, and Afghanistan. They won’t suggest closing a few hundred of the thousand military bases the U.S. maintains in foreign lands, or scaling back the hundreds of billions Uncle Sam spends on militarizing Africa, or propping up its client regimes in Israel, Egypt or Colombia and elsewhere. The commission won’t try to get back any of the trillions the Fed has given away to Wall Street, or stop it from handing out more. The commission is not about to close the banking loopholes that let wealthy corporations and individuals move trillions offshore to evade taxation, or shut off the many forms of corporate welfare. The commission’s targets are Medicaid, Medicare, and Social Security.
Not so very long ago, before 1965 passage of Medicare, the cost of health care for senior citizens was so high that hundreds of thousands of elders in the U.S. were eating cat food. Black seniors, as always, were the worst affected. Given its stated objective, of rolling back Medicaid, Medicare and Social Security, it’s easy to see why President Obama’s debt commission has earned its label as the President’s Cat Food Commission. It’s much harder to see why black America’s political leadership chooses to ignore the Cat Food Commission created by Democrats in power, and instead picks meaningless fights with Republicans out of power.
There are some gigantic lies loose in the land, lies endlessly repeated and embellished by corporate media; lies with names like “national security,” “free markets,” and “fiscal responsibility.” As flies beget maggots these lies and their larvae have thoroughly infested our national discourse. Among them are the notions of a “national debt” and the idea that a country’s finances ought to be run like a family’s. Back in the days of George Washington and John Adams, when currency was backed by gold and silver, there actually could have been a U.S. national debt, if creditors could collect it and debtors would pay it.
But nowadays the U.S. Federal Reserve creates money, not out of gold, or risk, or labor, but out of thin air. The tens of trillions the Fed spent in 2009, to buy up a fifth of the nation’s mortgage-backed securities were created simply by crediting the accounts of the previous owners of those securities. In other words, 21st century money is a spreadsheet operated by the Fed. In the ongoing Wall Street Bailout, the government first creates money in the private accounts of favored banksters via spreadsheet, and calls it a low-interest or no-interest “loan.” The government then borrows the money back from the favored banksters at loan shark interest rates to spend on wars or whatever. This has become a large portion of the fictitious “national debt.” An entity that can do that lives in a different fiscal universe with fundamentally different rules than those governing your family’s budget.
“Now a Democratic President Obama has joined the right’s crusade against Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security”
If the powers that be wanted to, they could use their magic spreadsheets to close the modest gap which may appear in Social Security revenues two or three decades from now, or they could raise benefits immediately. They could restore full funding to schools, libraries and local governments for a fraction of what the Afghan war costs every week. For a fraction of what the top two banksters got, they could forgive all the nation’s student loan debt. But the lies about the government “having to live within its means” and the fantasies that the Fed’s magic spreadsheets can somehow “run out of money” because of greedy seniors and the medical care received by poor people are far more useful than the truth could ever be.
Democrat Erskine Bowles and Republican Alan Simpson, the Cat Food Commission’s co-chairs, make no secret of their bipartisan aims to cut Medicaid, Medicare and Social Security. Democrat Bowles has called Social Security “a cancer” eating away at the nation’s fiscal health. Republican Simpson recently and notoriously remarked that Medicare and Social Security had turned the nation into a milk cow with “310 million tits.” Simpson in particular has a long history of labeling social security beneficiaries as “greedy geezers,” as undeserving “little people,” and the like. No serious person doubts that their “fiscal reforms” will be carefully calculated to fatally undermine Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security, and set the stage for their ultimate privatization.
Since social solidarity, the idea that we’re all in this together, is the core rationale for Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security, the Commission will surely craft measures that will undermine this solidarity. They will likely employ the time-tested tactic of “two-tiering” benefits for the elderly, freezing in place the levels current seniors receive, while raising the retirement age and lowering the benefit levels for future senior citizens. If successful, this will create a permanent wedge between those receiving higher and lower benefit levels, a wedge that the right wing is poised to exploit.
Billionaire Pete Peterson is only one, the most prominent of the U.S. right’s financiers of foundations, think tanks, academic and consulting careers, bloggers, web sites, radio and TV programming, conferences, talk show personalities and articles promulgating the lie that social security is about to go broke, or will bankrupt the nation. Pledging to plow his entire ten or eleven figure net worth into the foundations that advance this political agenda, he has, over the last decade or two, pretty much kept his word. And it’s working. The “liberal” corporate media never tire of telling us that social security and the national debt are making paupers of all us. A substantial portion of people under 40 now believe that social security won’t be there for them, cause it’ll go broke long before they get old. The right wing has, over the past several decades, carefully laid the infrastructure for this effort to undermine and destroy Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security and the social solidarity that underlies them.
Now a Democratic President Obama has joined the right’s crusade against Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security. A Democratic President Obama uses his bully pulpit to trumpet about a crushing “national debt” and social security as if they were gospel truth. A Democratic President Obama has created and empowered the Cat Food Commission which will eviscerate these programs of human uplift in the name of “fiscal responsibility.”
The real tragedy isn’t that the First Black President is doing this. The tragedy is that black leadership used to be the core of the left in this country. But in the era of Obama, the whole of black political leadership has willfully averted its eyes to the train coming down the track. When Republicans stuck it to them, they could at least squeal. But betrayed by Democrats, by our First Black President, they are silent, and powerless and irrelevant. They pick meaningless fights with Sarah Palin and Glenn Beck, who for all their racist vitriol, are temporarily OUT of power, not IN. They craft social networking tools to help us turn off Fox News, while MSNBC, CNN and CBS spout the same falsehoods, from “national security” to “free markets” to “entitlement reform.” That’s why they are what they are, diversionary fighting clowns, the epitome of a Black Misleadership Class.
Bruce Dixon is managing editor at Black Agenda Report, and based in Marietta GA. He’s a member of the GA Green Party’s state committee, and can be reached at bruce.dixon(at)blackagendareport.com.



46 Comments







Thanks much for your post, Bruce.
The Catfood Commission must be canned.
Sage points, and I have pointed out long ago that NAACP is way out of touch in many ways. Heck I’m a former NAACP Legal Chair and I’ll tell you that. I’ll also tell you that former NAACP CEO Bruce Gordon was Verizon home Veep during the NSA wiretaps, I’m 99.44% sure he knew what was going on there. He unceremoniously took a powder not long after this came out, fascinating….
But then you say:
Don’t be so certain that Palin is out of power, she is buddy buddy with NH Senate hopeful Kelly Ayotte, and Ayotte may well slip into power despite a horrible record on Civil RIghts and Open Government as I’ve noted on my blog, in video and on these pages. Palin and others have seen to it that a sh*t ton of money has flowed in to help Kelly Ayotte, you need to follow this.
http://kellyayottesenate.blogspot.com/2010/08/kelly-ayotte-caught-on-kingcast-video.html
http://kellyayottesenate.blogspot.com/2010/09/hotline-on-callnational-journal-and.html
http://seminal.firedoglake.com/diary/68747
Peace.
Most interesting post, Bruce. I have enormous respect for the older black leaders but they are older. Are there young ones who are getting ready to step up and take the reins and move ahead?
It’s not a matter of older vs. younger. That’s a fake conflict imposed on us by the media. Heck, James Rucker of Color of Change is probably about 40, and I’ll be 60.
It’s a matter of black leadership having hitched their careers uncritically to the president, and thus being utterly unable to directly criticize him or his policies in public. They can say they’re against war, but they won’t do anything to make their Democratic war president the least bit uncomfortable. They can say they’re against cuts in Medicaid, Medicare, and Social Security, but they feel obligated to swallow their tongues when their own president appoints and empowers the cat food commission. Black leadership, as Glen Ford pointed out two years ago, has made itself irrelevant.
The best of them claim to be “holding the president accountable”, but the old phrase has no meaning. Absent an explicit threat to withdraw support from the president or his party when they betray the agenda millions thought they were advancing when they elected Dems and the prez in 2006 and 2008, there is little or no incentive for them to serve the Democratic party’s base voters.
Sorry. I didn’t actually mean older as in years but experience. Didn’t express myself well. I do, however, think that age matters because some of the leaders are not going to be around for many more years. Thank you again for such an excellent diary.
Dear Bruce,
I usually listen to you and Glen Ford on Mark Thompson’s show weekly on Sirius Left 146 from 5-8 p.m. . Last night, I missed you on the show but understand that you confronted the pro-Obama host on Sirius Left 146. I believe Mr. Thompson often is patronizing towards you and Mr. Ford with his lead-in, reminding both of you that “some listeners think you are negative and even undermining the president with your comments.” A friend of mine told me that you confronted Mr. Thompson because he was salivating all over Pres Obama.
I also like to hear Glen Ford on that show as well as listening/reading his material at http://www.blackagendareport.com
I also like what Margaret Kimberley has to say and write too, especially about American foreign policy and how those foreign policies impact domestic policy, in addition, to her analysis on lobby groups.
Paul Street who often contributes to Black Agenda Report has recently wrote a new book on Obama coming from a left-wing analysis which is very valuable to this political discourse.
Walden Bello has an article at Foreign Policy in Focus which I suggest everyone read which correlates to everything said by Bruce Dixon.
Thanks.
Now that’s the problem, we still have chitlen leadership from 60′s youth movement, they were trusted as youth to lead, but the only time youth under 40 is listened to is in a rap video
Please name one black lkeader under 40.
Black leaders and Dems are out of touch with youth, that’s why Obam i s a oneterm pres, and dems lose the house and senate
LEAD or GO HOME
Like Black youth will stay home, no one represents Black needs, not even black politicians.
We do need younger voices to speak to young people – black and white. Some of the people in DC are so old they are not even aware of today’s technology and how it relates to everything. I’m old (76) and I promise you that those congress critters who are in their 80s have no business being there.
Thanks for this, Bruce. It’s sad to see Alan Simpson, a rich white conservative from Wyoming’s most powerful political family not named “Cheney”, being given far, far better treatment (and far more free passes for bad behavior) than was given Shirley Sherrod, Van Jones, the Rev. Wright, and Prof. Gates.
The answer is C. Racial disparities in the criminal justice system.
http://www.amazon.com/New-Jim-Crow-Incarceration-Colorblindness/dp/1595581030
Incredibly interesting and powerful post. Thank you.
(Hey MSM: Prove you can read.)
I’m a fire-breathing liberal who has loathed Alan Simpson since he was on the Judiciary Committee grilling Anita Hill. But please offer some proof that “hundreds of thousands of senior citizens forced to eat cat food” actually happened and is not an urban legend. The fact is, cat food is simply not that much cheaper (if at all) than tuna canned for human consumption. I have trouble believing that old folks who couldn’t afford people food were buying equally-expensive cat food.
I’ve seen it. The elderly’s cupboards with a few tins of cat and dog food, and no pet.
It’s probably safer to eat than eggs. There would be a shitstorm if the cat & dog food was salmonella contaminated.
Brian, well said. Good diary.
that has never ended. its a bit misleading to suggest the “Catfood commisions” recommendations will lead to retired people eating cat food, because they already do, because of cost. Im not suprised that was asked tho.If you search the internet with that question you will find unbelieveable ignorance, and appalling callousness from the young and dumb. social security benefits are chintzy. i doubt you could live on them. if they make them even cheaper retired people will begin to starve to death in unacceptable numbers, like they did before social security.
IIRC during the 50s and early 60s there were stories in print and on TV of seniors resorting to eating cat and dog food, not hundreds of thousands, however. In those days cat and dog food brands were limited, nothing like the variety we see now, and was very inexpensive. Most cat foods in those days were fish of various sorts, Puss ‘N Boots being the most notorious, bones and all could be seen when the can was opened. Friskies, etc, were mostly tuna and was cheaper than tuna for two-leggeds.
If Cat Food is beyond your means the cookbook will also have many recipes with more “economical ingredients.” You might want to try The Grass and Dandelion Soup.
Can’t they do both or are they stupid?
You will fit in very well at FireDogLake got any polls you trust about the Obama’s falling African American support?
Thanks so much to FDL for posting what Bruce Dixon of Black Agenda Report has to say on this very important issue.
Perhaps, the left needs to gather it’s own March on Washington to stand up for:
1. Worker’s Rights
2. Teachers (and Against the Privatization of Public Education)
3. Saving Medicare
4. Saving Social Security
5. Disability Rights
It is such a travesty that so many elderly people in America will be voting for Republicans this fall because of the incompetence and impotence of the Democratic Party to really stand up for the things listed above.
The elderly will be voting in large numbers for Republicans under the “no higher taxes” nonsense when much of those taxes helps pay for these older people’s medications and Social Security payments by the month.
I cannot believe how ignorant Americans really are and of course those sick media people who seemingly never tire of giving idiots like Glenn Beck and Sarah Palin more and more air time.
When people are forced out of their homes, perhaps, they can take up residence in the homes of Mr. Simpson and Mr. Bowles.
Medicaid, Medicare, and Social Security are paid for by specific taxes, with 42% of federal receipts covering 39% of expenditures. No problem there.
The money for wars, military bases, propping up US client regimes and corporate welfare procurement programs for un-necessary military hardware come out of the general fund.
So in the interest of purposeful accounting and accountability, as with entitlements, there ought to be a “security tax” to pay expenditures for “keeping us safe.” Isolating and highlighting these receipts and expenditures, separated from the general fund, would allow proper scrutiny and examination of the waste, fraud and abuse for the American people and promote the scaling back of un-necessary expenditures.
yes don that was behind the old teachers unions bumper sticker joke , “the next time the navy wants another nuclear sub they should have a bake sale”
remember that? each part of the budget should have its own specific revenue source. then we could really know what our spending priorities are, and who dosent want to pay.
Nice thought, and that would give all of us a focus to be able to be, “conscientious objectors,” and to withhold that part of our taxes now funding the displacement and killing of innocent women and children and non-habeas assassination orders against US citizens.
Thanks for posting this. Its a sensitive subject but it needs to be written on. ATM there IS not left in the US. There was almost no left during the bush presidency, the unions having been evicerated over the preceding decades but there was a quasi left in the peace movement, and of course there was the black causcus and black civil rights leadership, such an important part of the left. But its even worse under Obama. Even those last two leftist institutions have been co opted in the name of the honor of “the first black president” no matter WHAT he actually does in power.
thank you and Welcome to Firedoglake Bruce Dixon !
have only been regularly reading BAR for the last year – heartily recommend firedogs bookmark it – their Mr Ford has a thing or two to say that will certainly resonate here
Thanks for posting this, Bruce. Great post.
David Dayen has another fresh cross-post available: Another Rig Blows Up in the Gulf of Mexico
Do you think Simpson still collects his pension? For a guy that wants to trim that deficit I would think he would give up the pension which I think is 90% of current salary and recommend all his other former politicians to give up there’s. Fat chance of that happening.
Can Obama’s Catfood Commission!
The only change we got from Obama was better rhetoric.
If the Catfood Commission is exposed for what it is and is disbanded I could lose thousands on my new cookbook. “Frogs in the Pot or How I Learned to Adapt” with hundreds of delicious and nutritious pet food recipes for the emerging serfs. The Fancy Feast in bechamel sauce is finger licking good.
Love Black Agenda Report!!! They have Oilbummer’s number!
This was satire, right? Because you can’t be serious, or are you?
You want the Fed to inflate away the issue? Just print money to make it go away?
Wow, this article was either really funny, or really dumb.
Excellent Post. I love the spreadsheet loan scenario you laid out so well. Everything you say is true.
jpm, where was your outrage when Dubya was driving up the deficit? I didn’t see you here, then. Why all the sudden do we have a deficit spending problem?
I guess your a big fan of the never-ending Global War on Terror and military contractor profiteers.
Very powerful and informative. Will any political leader have the courage to come out against the Cat Food Commission? The imbeciles on the right with their far-fetched theories about the President are easy targets. But attacking President Obama from the left can be a lonely place to be. Unfortunately, so far President Obama’s charisma has worked not to win over Republican opposition but against liberals by silencing those on the left.
Thanks for this post… too bad no one else is saying the same thing.
Another piece of excellent political writing found at firedoglake.
It lays out plain what’s about to happen, that the next Congress will ensure that our treasure is pissed away, that Medicaid, Medicare, and Social Security will be less helpful than ever before, and that there’s not a damn thing anyone can do about it.
Here and there we get excellent writing, while everywhere else Palin, Beck, and Gingrich get their words and imagery seared into the public consciousness.
The poet W.H. Auden said the poets couldn’t stop Hitler; E. L. Doctorow said maybe those poets weren’t good enough.
Thank you Bruce for excellent post here. We must fight back.
Thank you for this, sir.
Materful, as always Bruce. When I still had a radio show I had the privilege of having Blackagendareport.com’s Glen Ford on three times. He is the most powerful and insightful person I have ever interviewed and read. He called out the economic meltdown way ahead of time. Bruce Dixon is right up there along side Glen as clear thinking truth tellers. They also come up with connections that are quite profound. I don’t miss their writing or their too short segments on Mark Thompson’s Sirius Left radio show “Make It Plain”. They are on every Wednesday. But often Mark undercuts them by having some other guest on who attacks Bruce and Glen. It’s especially annoying when it’s some young giggly woman who dismisses these great thinkers.
Yesterday got pretty intense on Mark’s show. Mark is caught in real cognitive dissonance in trying to defend something like this Cat Food Commission. He told Bruce the discussion of Social Security was too complicated (actually he used another word that I can’t remember) to discuss on his show. That was his excuse for not alerting his public to the danger of this commission. Bruce then nailed him on that. Mark is twisting himself into a pretzel lately trying to defend Obama. It was painful to listen to hear him love Obama’s war speech Tuesday night.
Please go over and support blackagendareport.com. And buy Paul Street’s book on Obama.
I meant “Masterful” not Materful. Phone rang when I was just about to edit. Annoying when work interrupts my dedication to “Canning the Cat Food Commission”.
Bruce is right about regular people being suckered by this. There is a letter to the editor each week in our local weekly warning us of the terrible debt the nation is in and how Social Security can no longer pay its way. Insidious. But with clear articles like this, each of us can get our letters to the editor in too. But a usual 300 word letter to editor on this issue is really really hard.
Another one of your great posts, Mr. Dixon (I’m a regular reader of BAR). I think what you’re saying is that black leadership–along with many so-called “progressive” voters–is still thinking in terms of Democrat v. Republican, FOX News v. MSNBC, and so forth. Of course, both major parties are totally corrupt at this point, regardless of political designation, race or gender.
“…the Cat Food Commission created by Democrats in power and instead picks meaningless fights with Republicans out of power …”
The president won’t help you in those ‘fights with republicans’ but he won’t call you a f33kin re&&&d either.
Bruce, another great article. As you know I found BAR way back, and you have been a voice of truth about Obama, since whenever. Your respectful fan, VG.
I have been singing the praises of BAR and Bruce Dixon for some time now,here at FDL and at Emptywheel.
What a wonderful surprise to see Bruce posting here!
PLEASE post more threads here,more often.
Great read, Bruce.
MSM is doing a bang-up job diverting outr attention from those doing us the most harm. I’m sorry to hear the old guard is falling into the trap. We could all use their help right now.
There was a big rally in Detroit on the same day as the Beck craziness in Washington. Rev. Jesse Jackson and the UAW had 10,000 people to commemorate Martin Luther King’s “I have a Dream ” speech which was given in Detroit prior to Washington. The March on Washington was about jobs. We need a jobs march.
And we do need some new leadership. I think it will come from Latinas and Latinos. They got 500,000 to rally in Washington but the MSM refused to report. We economic justice people have to hitch our wagon to theirs and we can start to make a difference.