In 2007, BBC reported that a $1.2 Billion dollar US State Department contract for training Iraqi police had been so shoddily managed that auditors simply couldn’t tell how the money was spent. "Auditors have stopped trying to audit the programme because all the documents are in disarray and the government is trying to retrieve some of the money," BBC stated. The program was run by a private US contractor, DynCorp. Dyncorp insisted that the difficulties did not represent "intentional fraud" on their part. That was 2007.
Yesterday, a new report from the same auditor–the Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction (Sigir)– was reported by BBC, again regarding this State Department contract to Dynacorp for Iraqi police training, but this time for $2.5 Billion. The contract is the largest ever let and managed in State Department history. From BBC:
But Sigir’s Stuart Bowen says in his report that weak oversight made the contract vulnerable to waste and fraud.
According to Mr Bowen’s report, for years the state department had only one person in Iraq monitoring invoices during the early stages of the DynCorp contract, despite the complexity of the paperwork.
This meant many invoices were not questioned and as a result there is "no confidence in the accuracy of payments of more than $1bn to DynCorp", the report says.
As has been widely reported, Obama’s recently announced and very narrowly focused budgetary freeze will not impact huge and mismanaged contracts such as this one at the State Department, but instead restricts spending on discretionary funding here at home.
So, while wasteful, poorly managed and potentially fraudulent spending can continue to be lavished unchecked on private corporate contractors and the police forces of Iraq and Afghanistan (even when they commit repeated auditing "irregularities"), our own communities are scrambling for funding for basic funding for such things as law enforcement:
ALBANY — With New York City’s fiscal health in the balance, Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg traveled to Albany on Monday to ask the Legislature’s help in stopping some of Gov. David A. Paterson’s proposed budget cuts, saying they were unfair, could cripple the city and would force him to layoff thousands of police officers and firefighters.
and schools:
METRO: Richmond County school board Vice President Alex Howard said a four-day school week should be considered for the rest of the school year. He said the change would offset funding cuts and extra furlough days. One day’s savings in transportation would be about $4,300, he said.
These two exerpted news stories are just two of thousands of similar news items all across America, from communities and states both large and small. All of them echo the same sad and increasingly desparate refrain from The Big Apple to Augusta Georgia–local and state communities struggling to fund even the most basic of services for the same American citizens who are unwillingly paying through the nose for a flood of mismanaged boondoggles overseas.
This is one of the classic hallmarks of American empire–the resources flow ever-outward in a fraudulent river of waste, while the taxpayers are told to tighten their belts here at home.
Remember that old urban legend about the bank robber Willie Sutton? When asked why he robbed banks, he is reputed to have said "Because that’s where the money is!" Obama might do well to take a page from Sutton’s Law. If you want to get serious about managing the national budget-go where the money is.
But don’t take my word for it, President Obama. Ask your own auditors and inspectors general. They’ll show you where the big money is. Here’s a hint for you. It won’t be in domestic discretionary spending.



10 Comments







Great job of connecting seemingly unrelated threads. Recommended.
One more information bit to throw in. Guess who was responsible for training Iraqi security forces (police and military) for most of our time there? None other than General Petraeus. He touted his success on it in September, 2004 in a WaPoo Op-Ed designed to whip up votes for Bush and then erased history as he committed to training them all over again in conjunction with the surge in 2007 and 2008. With the violence levels going back up in Iraq, it looks like his only success in the training was redistributing tax dollars to DynCorp executives.
Thanks Jim. Perhaps the WH needs to get Lanny Davis out there to put some positive spin on this.
Glad you were able to get to this post–it has not yet shown up in the blog list at seminal.
Yeah, I just DM’d you on Twitter about that. It looks like the “Latest Diaries” list is not refreshing. The comment count on my diary is wrong also.
Wow, Casual Observer!
So, now we may have children at home in this district one day per week, whether parents are working or not. Will anyone really be able to arrange for child care for one day per week? As for our children catching up to other children in other countries… well, I guess that was just more campaign rhetoric. Can’t let any of those munitions companies lose any profits or have to lay off any highly placed executives, after all.
I don’t think they care so much about the law enforcement issues, since the military is already waiting in the background to step up, if needed.
Go where the money is? These days, it should be Go Where the Fraud Is! …because that’s probably where you’ll find the real mother-lode of money. Or so it seems…
Huge deficits in state and local governments wherever you go, and Obama is going to start cutting back. That is definately going to ripple through the domestic system in all sorts of ways, as these governments decide how and where to cut.
I agree with you that it’s likely the biggest fraud is going to be where the roar of money is loudest. And that will be in the Defense sector.
But it would take an incredible leader to fight that battle right now–to attempt defense cuts–and we ain’t got a leader like that.
That pretty much sums it up for me.
Another thought…
It really is too bad that Michelle Obama is not president, rather than her husband. You can almost always count on a Capricorn to do the right thing. A Leo? Not so much.
Casual Observer,
Great post! This is a perfect representation of everything wrong with our country.
No one complained while they just handed out our tax dollars in Iraq.
No one complained while we were told that the Military and State Department, and all the Agencies in Iraq weren’t even trying to control the corruption in Iraq.
We were told how the Contractors riped us off, and even indangered and killed our servicemen, and no one complained.
Ofcourse why would they when they have sat back, and let our Government rip us off, spend us and our children into debt, and about distroy our Country. They didn’t even complain much when they took our money and gave it to the people who caused the problem saying they needed to, to save us.
We are a people who just go with the flow, and then wonder why we keep getting shafted.
Do people really wonder? I think most of us know it’s our own failure to act and hold abusers accountable that allows it to continue. We just don’t want to pay the price in time, effort, commitment.