When Dick Cheney’s daughter –not a native New Yorker- decided she wanted to hold a protest in NYC, she was allowed to have a HUGE covered sound stage, a JumboTron, they shut down Foley Square for her and I don’t remember anyone caging the ralliers with movable orange soft fencing or macing them.
Dick Cheney’s daughter was allowed to shut down one of the busiest traffic aggregators in lower Manhattan. She was allowed to erect her outdoor theater stage right in front of the main door to the federal courthouse–where she was protesting against holding the KSM trial in federal court. She was given her full measure of symbolism and First Amendment expression
Well, of course she was. She’s Dick Cheney’s daughter.
Contrast that with the Occupy Wall Street protests. There, the NYPD is denying the protestors the right to use blue tarps to cover themselves when it’s pouring rain. Movable orange fencing is being used to corral people. And unarmed and non violent protestors are being maced, punched and dragged.
The NYPD is not allowing the protest to actually happen anywhere near Wall Street itself, denying the protestors their symbolic expression. I understand that yesterday they were herded all the way up to Greenwich Village. Here’s the video [cont'd]
There has been an almost complete corporate media blackout of a protest that has been going on 24/7 for over a week. Our own Kevin Gosztola has been doing an amazing job of covering Occupy Wall Street protests and creating a platform to view the work of the LiveStream videographers. Without this amazing work and a lot of folks Tweeting, many would never know this was even happening.
But then again, Occupy Wall Street is not some astro turf faux “movement” with fancy outdoor theaters built and paid for by millionaires who want to make sure that Curtis Sliwa and Andy McCarthy don’t get rained on.
Nope, Occupy Wall Street is a shoe string, leaderless mass uprising, so of course corporate owned media has to make sure its message does not get out over airwaves it leases from us, the public.
Congratulations to the NY Daily News for having the guts to run a story.
And congratulations and best wishes to all the sister “occupy [insert name of place with excellent folks]” protests that are springing up all over the country. I found out about you all from Twitter, because, ya know, corporate media doesn’t think that’s news.
Mayor Mike should be ashamed of the disparate treatment being shown to different protest groups based on the content of their speech. Ray Kelly works for you, not the other way around, though sometimes it’s hard tell.
Ray Kelly opposed holding the KSM trial in NYC and Ray Kelly put out a red carpet for child of Cheney and her astro turfers to rally for his cause. Contrast that with the actions seen over the weekend.
One of the things that struck me is that most of the really heinous acts appear to have been done by police supervisory personnel, whom you can pick out wearing white shirts. The rank and file cops, in blue shirts, often seem uncomfortable performing their assignments. They appear to be trying to behave more professionally. I realize that’s just the impression I get from watching the Live Stream, but it makes me wonder.
Are regular beat cops not “with the program”? Are they not enjoying their orders from Kelly? Why are supervisors doing hands on policing thuggery?
Ray Kelly has disgraced this City and his own police force. Mayor Bloomberg, however. bears the ultimate responsibility, because Ray Kelly works for him.



82 Comments

recommended and tweeted
Excellent piece. great contrast. thank you Cynthia.
Thanks, Cynthia!
Too bad there is an MSM blackout. Ray Kelly and Mayor Bloomberg should be trying to answer some very uncomfortable questions right now, but alas, the only people who would ask such questions don’t get invitations to press conferences.
Yet another example of official repression here in the “Land of the Free”. You are free under the First Amendment to speak as you wish, and to peaceably assemble-unless, of course, one speaks using unapproved language addressing the incorrect topics. As far as assembling goes, it is incumbent upon you to ensure you are supporting the line of the PTB, not some sort of “Populist” tripe.
Your Constitutional rights are extremely flexible and if you actually heard, be sure you speak in the language which counts nowadays, that of cold hard cash. Have no coin of the realm? Well, in all likelihood, no one really cares what you have to say…
Oh nooooo, we can’t have none of that.
Obama Top Fundraiser on Wall Street
By Kristin Jensen and Christine Harper
Bloomberg News
Wednesday, April 18, 2007
Bloomberg
Obama Returns to New York to Raise Money, Dine With Bankers
June 23, 2011, 11:28 PM EDT
By Hans Nichols
gonna scream
I AM SO DISGUSTED BY WHAT HAPPENED TO THOSE YOUNG WOMAEN PROTESTERS ,I COULD PUKE!
little Napoleon Bloomberg who serves Wall Street with his hack media is a disgrace…..how would he like it if his precious Georgiana got maced?Too bad she doesn’t have the stones to come out against her dear daddy on this!!! rant over!
recommended
Think this Friday and Saturday will be the big days this week if you’re thinking about attending but can’t stay indefinitely and want to come at the best time.
I imagine the schedule for this week, as nothing is posted on http://www.occupywallst.org aside from GA meetings, is the same as last week with morning and closing bell marches. If anyone knows otherwise, please correct me.
It’s pretty ugly. Come to New York, get your breasts squeezed by New York’s finest (Kevin Gosztola, photo and video footage links, Sept. 25, 2011)
Great post Cynthia. Absolutely fantastic.
Also, there are some cops who should be placed on Administrative leave. I bet if MiniCheney had been maced, somebody would be paying for it already.
Boxturtle (Why bother with press conferences? Have ‘em questioned by their own handlers)
reccd
I’m kinda shocked that the Government isn’t busy connecting the protestors to AQ. Via anonymous senior administration officals, off the record since it involves data from classified government intelligence programs.
Boxturtle (Attn NYC: If you implement the above idea, I want 10% of whatever Wall St. pays you)
“Are regular beat cops not ‘with the program’? Are they not enjoying their orders from Kelly? Why are supervisors doing hands on policing thuggery?”
You got that exactly right. If you look at the footage, most of the regular cops seem pretty uncomfortable with what is going on.
This is typically true of real anti-popular suppression tactics like strike-breaking, etc. It’s hard to get most regular cops to really go along with it. If the city wants to ratchet up the aggression, the next step is to find those cops who “have a taste for it” ie like beating people up and don’t care too much if they’ve done anything wrong, and forming them into a special unit.
we have no ‘real”rights. never had. the guardian is reporting the mace attack as ‘alleged” LOL. meanwhile they are banging the nato/libya drum etc
A fine example of the New and Improved American Nazis.
The blue shirts over the brown shirts is a fashion improvement in my opinion.
Give them time…
This groping business raises some red flags because sexual abuse is a common intimidation tactic. The extremely slippery slope ends at gang rape as a form of genocide. See Bosnia and central Africa, for example.
Ms. Georgianna Bloomberg and her teh Expensive thoroughbred….contrast the treatment of class warriors
http://www.nypost.com/pagesixmag/issues/20081123/images/Features/bloomy/2.jpg
PIGS, DOGS and SHEEP
The dogs are performing their function. When the sheep are making the pigs uncomfortable with all their bleeting, the dogs are called in to coral the sheep and protect the pigs from all that discomfort.
“Animal Farm” is real and we are living it
We, perhaps, need to stock NYC with wood for guillotines and designate a Bastille.
Where are the Hells Angels when you need them?
I feel much better now. Blue is my favorite color. /s Freat job, Cynthia, thank you.
That’s “Great job, Cynthia.”
Don’t forget the tumbrels.
With 2 to 4 MILLION Unemployed in the greater NY megalopolis; why are they alone when A MILLION could start from EACH END of Wall Street to Overwhelm this NYPD/Bernankster MADNE$$!?
I think the goons planned a head bashing party after dark on Saturday and were foiled by the candles and portable lights. It’s no fun bashing heads in the light were you can be IDed.
And this is the reason so many police departments are lobbying to make it illegal to videotape police “doing their job” in a public place.
Good piece, recommended, but I have to say, the comparison that comes fastest to my mind isn’t the teabagladies, it’s the Arab Spring v. the US Fall.
Rounding up women in pens and macing them while they stand, unresisting – goshdarnit, why can’t we export more of that freedom, faster?
1. Everyone’s skeptical. Even though it’s completely open, to the point of moving painfully slow on some matters, the general public assumes it’s a closed group as protests are often that way. Ie, those who there are the group, they didn’t get me involved personally, so therefore they don’t want me. They’re trying to remedy that by working with other groups that have an established presence in the city. But, it’s an open group so all it takes is showing up and you’re a part of it, the public just doesn’t know that.
2. Everyone’s a critic. “They should have done this instead of this. Why aren’t they doing this? Forget it, no way I’m getting involved!”
3. The police are everywhere. If you live in the city, having your face on NYPD/FBI/DHS video and photos as someone who is suspect is discomforting. When you’re from the portion of the population with higher incarceration rates and more tension with the police, I can understand why they are reluctant to join.
4. Poor communication and scheduling of events. Me being a critic here, but if people have to work or go to school or look for work or barely have enough money to be out there, they need to know on This day, around This time, there will be protests Here against This. If you look at the http://www.occupywallst.org/ website, they just have General Assembly meetings and a couple of non-protest events listed for today. Critical Mass announced last night they will be coming out on Friday, why isn’t that on the website? People like I just described cannot show up on a whim and just hope something is happening.
One thing to think about later this week is that the Jewish holdiays kick in, which really shuts down a lot of foottraffic in Manhattan.
The streets get a bit empty.
However, protestors should not do anything that might screw up the Wed night commute home, since folks need to get home before sunset. Messing up that commute will definately bring down the wrath of NYPD and cost the protestors a lot of support from regular new yorkers.
So, some tact and culeral sensitivity on Wed afternoon will satnd you guys in good stead.
No, it’s the white shirts. Watch to footage, it’s mostly supervisors.
I am going to assume that is a metaphorical suggestion, b/c we don’t advocate violence here. Just FYI.Don’t mean to harsh your mellow.
Meanwhile, Daddy’s still very, very busy making money.
Doesn’t it bother anyone else besides me that Dick Cheney pals around with Canadian child molesters? Yet that’s what he’ll be doing at 5:30 tonight. A must-read.
Occupy Wall Street has not only be compared with Arab Spring, it specifically seeks to emulate it.
I did the comaprision with Baby Cheney’s rally to show the disparate treatment based on the contnt of speech and the indetity of the speaker
Both big no-no’s in 1st ammendment law.
I’m hoping to see some of those arrested bring suit–> Guys, this week would be a good time, it quiet in the courthouses during the Jewish holidays and a good time to get a TRO restraining the NYPD/Bloomberg admin from curtailing your Constitutional Rights.
You got a good bar group helping you, let them shine!
The obvious difference between the Foley Square event and this one in Wall Street is access to one’s job. The Foley Square event did not interfere with anyone getting to their job as everyone has the right to do. The Wall Street protest should of course be allowed as long as the rights of others are not infringed upon.
During the week, when people needed to get to work AND were available to witness what went on, the police did not attack protestors.
On the weekend, when the financial district is practically a ghost town [some delis don't even open on the weekends] the police go all riot.
Foley Square OTOH is a magor traffic pass through connection the Brooklyn Bridge with Broaway and the major east west conections of Chamers Street and Worth Street. Even though it was on a weekend, I assure you that the Cheney rally was a HUGE disruption to traffic.
There is also a major multi line subway station that empties smack dab in the middle of Foely square, so subway users from amny lines were also inconvenienced.
Most retail businesses around Foley ARE open on the weekend, so all those workers were incoveninced, and unlike the financial district a lot of people actually LIVE near Foley.
Inconvenienced is not the same thing as being prevented from getting to work. The many thousands of Wall Street workers have every right to get to their jobs. For the police to move the protesters away from the doors was acceptable.
On Foley Square, you are talking about traffic, which was not my point at all. How many of the Wall Street protesters had to go to the hospital based on the police going “all riot”?
And btw, your mention of Ray Kelly not wanting terror trials in NYC? I live in NYC and don’t know anyone who wanted to have their lives so disrupted by accomodating terror trials in NYC. We’ve been through enough.
I can knit
The perp in the pepper spray incident has allegedly been identified as:
Deputy Inspector Anthony V Bologna
(518) 989-9051
5 Sawyer Ave
Staten Island, NY 10314-2940
Rather than seeing the exodus (no pun intended) of Jews from Wall Street on Wednesday afternoon, I wish a rabbi or cantor would come forward and hold Rosh Hashonah services at the occupation site! Don’t you think the numbers of protesters would swell during the Days of Awe? Imagine fasting there through Kol Nidre and Yom Kippur! And, what could be more appropriate than celebrating Sukkot there 5 days later?!
Maybe Bloomberg would show up. ;)
anybody comment on the NYT “blogger’s” entry yet? http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/25/nyregion/protesters-are-gunning-for-wall-street-with-faulty-aim.html
It was all about the arrests and how hippy-ish and discombobulated it was. Nothing about the actual protest message, which I think is pretty clear to anyone who writes for a living. It was all “gosh, why are they trying to say?”
And a quote from a trader who doesn’t know the definition of monopoly. utter crap.
Commenters came out of the woodwork to do the reporter’s work for her and guess what? NYT stopped accepting comments. LOL! That’s your freedom of the press!
what is your point? the author here wasn’t saying to not protest. You have a valid POV. So do these protesters and they are getting quite a different reception.
that would be amazing!
(any rabbis out there reading this?)
and yes, a perfect site for sukkot.
the point is that other people have rights, not just the protesters
what exactly is the actual protest message?
right… again, no one said your “other people” didn’t have rights. Were your anti terrorist trial protesters gathered up in the orange nets? denied media coverage? Where are the rights for these protesters?
Asking that question doesn’t mean your preferred protesters don’t have rights.
So the protesters should have been moved from the doors, good then we agree. Not sure why you’re calling any protesters “your”.
I have no idea what you mean by “denied media coverage”. Denied by whom?
“Yet, the one thing that this varied group of people has in common is that they are tired of government corruption and the privileging of corporations and the wealthiest 1 percent of Americans by the American government. ”
I direct you here: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/tracey-e-vitchers/occupyingnot-riotingwall-_b_980003.html
this is for “DavidH”
Again, what is the message, that they are tired? That’s it?
I’m done with you.
Hey I gave you a chance and you come up with “they’re tired”?
figures from Staten Island…just sayin
none so blind as those(YOU)who cannot see…none so deaf(you) who cannot hear…go away troll
David H…no friends…no groups …no profile…justa troll..y
Hey, it’s what they’re tired of. A government run by the corporations, for the corporation, of the corporations.
You have the opportunity here, too, to say you agree that ALL americans have the right to free speech without threat of arrest like your buddy Baby Cheney. But no, you can’t bring yourself to that concept even if you disagree with it.
Go ahead. I’m “giving” you a “chance”.
they’re out in droves today. wow. Guess this protest is having some “measure” of success in that regard! :)
So there you hate the American Constitutional guarantee of a speedy trial or apparently any trail where the truth might slip or are you afraid of showing the world the Man we waterboarded 184 and turned him into a blathering idiot ?
You’re in the city go ask the protesters.
The whole point of an action is shut things down. The whole point is for those who make a living at Wall Street to not be able to do it. Otherwise it’s not an action but a symbol. As we’ve found out, symbols can be selectively ignored if they don’t promote the plutocrats agenda.
We need more than symbols.
I’ve been hesitant to add to the live blog I am running because I do not know the source and it is fairly significant if true but…
There is an unconfirmed report going around that 100 NYPD didn’t show up to work today. I don’t know why. It could be about something related to pension plans or the police union. It could be job-related, like they are worried about something going on internally. But Occupy Wall Street people are suggesting it is related to what happened Saturday.
Kevin,
I was just going to paste the Occupy Wall Street tweet: oh heck I will anyway:
OccupyWallSt Occupy Wall Street
100 officers refused to show up for duty today. The big question is, were they all officers of the 1st precinct? #OccupyWallStreet
1 hour ago Favorite Retweet Reply
OK, I called NYPD PBA and spoke to their press guy. I asked about the 100 officer no shows and he said I was the very first person to ask about it and he therefore seriously doubted it had occured.
If anybody gets more/better info, let Kevin know please? Occupy Wall Street is Kevin’s story and he should get all the leads we can source up for him.
Excellent observation.
As long as there is so little coverage by the U.S. MSM , this needs to be hugely promoted by not only Al Jazeera English, but throughout the rest of the world. La Independencia, etal.
Since the U.S. has no shame (yet) it would be lovely to really let them shame themselves to the whole world. All the European papers and across the Mideast and Africa need to be sent blogs, tweets, photos and videos. The rest of the world needs to see that the U.S. has no moral leg to stand on at all. That all its yammering on about Democracy and Feedom and Rights, is just a bad Joke.
Not that they dont already know this from their own experiences, but to see what is being done to its own citizens will give the World heart to keep on.
Other people also have the right to learn what these protesters are trying to tell them because the Mainstream Media is decietful and supressses important information from the public and, YES, even lies to them. Demonstrations is a straughforward way of disseminating information to people who should have a right to know what their own government is doing behind their backs.
There are those in government who would be imprisoned if the public were to know what they really do. They are terrified of a public trial of people who were really involved and do know what was going on. The truth is we have plenty of people in government who are traitors.
The part about government officials lying to the people, senate, president about the money, they are stealing and the laws they are breaking or the part about how they cannot let the accused from the middle east speak out in an open, public trial because they will be implicated as traitors, the part about how thy are trafficking in drugs, slavery and prostitution worldwide or the part about how they have been replacing the constitution with an murderous, illegal, fascist police state with war crimes thrown in just for thir amusement??
Read the comments and you can see the things they want to tell their fellow citizens. I wrote it, but the list minder said it was repetititve… so reasons ARE in these comments for anyone who cares to READ.
Yes… for some odd reason the hoi polloi seem to resent the wage slavery imposed on Americans by a government that no longer works because it is being overun by soulless grifters who STEAL from them to the point that they have no chance of pursuing life, liberty, happiness or even the right to speak freely. Go figure!
I suspect that if Al Jazeera Engliish covers actual events over HERE with their usual honesty and diligence, our gorvrnment is likely to make them sorry for it…. Don’t you remember when they were the ONLY impartially honest voice reporting on the middle east after we attacked Iraq? Our special ops went in, ripped their offices apart and put them out of business for awhile. I don’t recall. at th moment if that was done before or after we bombed the civilian, non-military target hotel where the entire international press corps was living.
Then you don’t know many New Yorkers except maybe very rich people.
Most New Yorkers were FURIOUS and outraged because this is the exact and only place he should have been tried. We have had plenty of terrorist trials here and gotten convictions too. No disruptions or problems either. When American justice works, it works incredibly well and effectively and quickly too.
That was OUR trial!!!! WE already paid the price for it after all!!
In case no one has mentioned it here, Common Dreams has a video of an NYPD white shirt walking up to a number of protesters penned in and casually shooting either peopper spray or Mace right in their faces and just as casually walk away. He was positively identified as Anthony Bologna. There are links to the mayor’s office, NYPD and Ray Kelly to comment. As the protesters, all women, fell down screaming in pain, the cops penning them in just stood there watching instead of dropping the fucking fence and going in to administer first aid. IMO, this is almost as bad as what Bologna did.
So people not having to go to the hospital means police behavior was acceptable? How about shooting Mace into the faces of people penned up and helpless? Go to Common Dreams to find out about that one. How about pulling a woman by the hair, slamming people onto the pavement?
You have got to be kidding. There is practically a media blackout on this. They have been denied coverage by MSM media outlets. This only came to a partial end the other day when the Daily News had a front page story – of course with a photo of a woman cuffed and held face down on the ground with lots of cleavage showing. The police riot is what opened the door.
Dosido
Here is a great article on that by Allison Kilkenny, who calls this “rubbernecking” reporting and clearly calls out the agenda of the reporter in highlighting the lunaticish fringe always haunting public protests to give the appearance that it’s all just a freak show, and at the same time completely missing the real story of how this protest is organized.
http://www.commondreams.org/view/2011/09/26-5
This Financial District is Responsible For Most of the Poverty and Suffering on This Planet
- from a sign carried at the protest
Again you’ve got to be kidding – or else you can’t read. Did he say “they were tired” and that’s it? He said they’re tired of government corruption and the privileging of corporations and the wealthiest 1 percent of Americans by the American government. Guess that’s over your head. Or you haven’t noticed those things happening. Go back to your hole.
There are many people here without any friends, groups, or anything in the profile, are we all trolls then?
But seriously it probably is a puppet more likely then a troll.
Another scary angle I was wondering about: employer/landlord background checks.
Do arrests show up on background checks?
This is perhaps something that previous generations of protesters did not have to contend with.