We Got This (Occupy Sandy) from Alex Mallis on Vimeo.
Mayor Mike has a lot of egg on his face, so does Ray Kelly. Despite being derided, kettled, pepper sprayed, and generally treated like subhumans by the NYC government, Occupy Wall Street continues to rise above the pettiness that characterizes the behavior and assumptions of “various serious people.”
Continuing to think outside the box, OWS has two new initiatives: Occupy Sandy and Rolling Debt Jubilee.
I live on the North Shore of Long Island, walking distance from the beach, in an area full of very old tall trees and very old overhead wires. Oh, and spotty cellphone coverage. I have been virtually incommunicado for the past couple weeks. No electricity, no internet, no landline phones, no TV, no voice over cellphone and very limited texting over cellphone.
What little information I had access to, came from the car radio, and it told a tale of stranded victims on Staten Island and the Long Island South Shore and Brooklyn, left unaided by the City. No police doing door-to-door searches for the trapped and stranded elderly or infirm, no social service agencies coming to their homes to make sure they had a meal, nadda.
So, OWS called upon its stupendous logistical skills and filled the void left by Ray Kelly and Michael Bloomberg. Bloomberg holds daily press conferences, but for people with no access to mass communication, he was a tree falling in the forest with no one to hear. Did it really take him 2 weeks to figure out that squad cars have speaker systems on them and could be deployed like sound trucks?
BTW, Con Ed, LIPA and PSE&G: Would it have killed you to hire some sound trucks to make announcements, since people without power or internet cannot use your hopeless websites?
I digress. OWS did what they do best, rallied compassionate people, started cooking meals and gave them away, just like at Liberty Plaza (it’s hard to get me to call it Zuccotti Park). They organized blankets and flashlights and charging stations (including the Green Peace solar truck and those cool Gilligan’s Island bicycle generators), just as they did at Liberty Plaza. They knocked on doors to ask the stranded residents what they needed. They sent out tweets for “needs of the occupiers” and supporters from all over the world sent supplies, just like at Liberty Plaza. They even improved on that with an Occupy Sandy “wedding registry” on Amazon that helps doors to ship supplies quickly and easily. Genius!
So complete is their logistical competence that they are now holding training for the National Guard troops who have been sent in to help and…wait for it…for the Mayor’s Office representatives. Considering how poorly they have been treated by this administration, they could have refused to aid the government efforts and played tit-for-tat, but their goal is to help by any means.
The press has always had trouble covering OWS because it doesn’t play into their preconceived notions and because there is no self promoting “face” of OWS. So, the story of this movement has been consistently misreported and under reported. OWS transcended the typical media narrative and has left the press behind, left the government behind, and focused on just getting the job done on the ground.
They transformed the political dialogue in a presidential election year and without a single Super PAC ad, probably contributed more to the defeat of Mitt Romney than any deep-pocketed donor. Now they have are demonstrating the power of horizontal organizing to fill the void left by the City government, FEMA and the utterly underwhelming Red Cross. Another aside, a celebrity-studded telethon to raise money for the Red Cross did not result in the Red Cross being effective. I don’t know what they are doing with that money, but it is not being spent on Long Island, I can tell you that. Next telethon should direct donors to make purchases on the Sandy wedding registry.
Rolling Debt Jubilee
In another episode of thinking outside the box, OWS has discovered that an industry exists to buy distressed debt at pennies on the dollar. The companies that buy this debt then try to collect it and when successful, make their money on the spread. OWS has set up a fund to create capital to buy the debt, but intends to forgive it rather than collect it. There is going to be a telethon on Novemeber 15th at 8 PM.
Some have hollered that it creates a taxable event. However, if OWS is even more clever, they will contact the debtors, and stipulate to “settle” a pre-litigation case over the debt and the debtor will waive counterclaims and defenses in exchange for cancelling the debt. Since value is given, no taxable windfall. Since the most deeply discounted distressed debt has already passed through the hands of prior debt collection agencies, who no doubt have engaged in sketchy debt collection practices, it will not be a farce to say the debtors have counter-claims and defenses. This idea came from Masaccio.
OWS did a test run of this concept and was able to buy $14,000 of debt for only $500. This model should be used by the federal government to force the modification of mortgages, instead of bailing out the big banks, TARP money should have (and still could be) used to buy up the mortgages directly, reset the principle balance to reflect the current market value of the homes, and then reset the payments to fit the homeowners’ current incomes. Does that mean some homeowners, even with principle reduction, will end up with VERY long debt repayment terms? Yes, but it also means they can now sell those houses and get out from under if they choose, or they can pay for a long time and slowly rebuild equity.
The Triumph of Doing Over Talking
Over and over the MSM has whined that OWS doesn’t have a platform, it doesn’t have stated goals, it doesn’t have a message. Well, first of all, that tripe just demonstrates how lazy the MSM is. OWS has devoted many pixels to creating websites and online commercials explaining the programs and goals. The MSM is just too damn lazy to Google. OWS has devoted many pieces of cardboard and many yards of banners full of signs carried up major roadways full of slogans and demands. MSM couldn’t be bothered to show up and watch.
Nonetheless, OWS spends less time on messaging than any arm of government or any traditional interest group or charity. OWS doesn’t spend their donations hiring the “right” consultants who spoon feed puff pieces to reporters over meals at fancy restaurants. They don’t do ad buys for commercials with patriotic sounding music.
I’ve seen a ton of Red Cross commercials since my TV came back on, but not one Red Cross truck. OWS doesn’t play the game. Unlike the Red Cross, they don’t spend their time talking about what they would like to do or could do or did once before, they just go do it. It doesn’t matter if the “it” is changing the political dialogue to talk about the 1% vs. the 99%, or feeding a hungry person, or buying up student loan or medical debt. They spend much less effort talking about doing it and more effort getting it done.



60 Comments

Tweeted. Recommended. Thanks Cynthia.
That’s exactly what i meant to say BooRadley. Recommended, Tweeted, Shared on Facebook, bookmarked and emailed to everyone i talk to. Thank you very much Cynthia Kouril. I hope you and your neighbors recover well and soon.
Superb post Cynthia, and so good to hear you are okay.
Front paged, recommended & tweeted.
Thank you so much, Cynthia. This is the sort of truth that brings tears to my eyes. If I was anywhere near the Sandy coast, I would be there. I too will repost and hope this gets the coverage it should have.
In solidarity!
If NYC gets the $30 billion from the Feds that they say the city is owed, how much will be siphoned off by Ray Kelly’s CIA-on-the-Hudson, fueling further repression?
This post is so wonderful and so inspirational, I’m just kind of left speechless.
Thanks, Cynthia. What do you think the best article is to purchase at the Amazon site? What do people need the most?
I was a big fan of the Red Cross, until I volunteered for the Los Angeles Chapter. When I volunteered, I noticed that the LA chapter had spun off into many smaller divisions (Santa Monica, San Gabriel, etc.). I remember my first class with 20+ members. After two years, I had been to three classes and volunteered for numerous assignments to no avail. I was called only once. At the yearly classes, my 20+ group (the same people in every class) all complained about the same thing. The Red Cross was all talk but no action. We had all been promised a participatory role, but when the time came, there was no phone call.
As a result, I suspect that the smaller divisions had spun off because the larger chapter was not meeting the needs of their community.
Based on my experience, I would join the Occupy Sandy Group and forget about the Red Cross.
Occupy Sandy provided Doctors Without Borders lists of patients who were in need of medical care. The Occupy volunteers has gone door to door compiling those lists days before the aid agency arrived.
http://www.doctorswithoutborders.org/news/article.cfm?id=6410&cat=field-news
There has been nothing but praise for Occupy Sandy and the work they have done in Brooklyn, Queens and Staten Island.
Same experience, Red Cross is only adept at collecting money not logistics or responsiveness. OWS would be the example of humans helping humans unconditionally. The haves have been saying you are on your own and they got their power back so all is well in “I got mine” Amerika. We can see where the “low Class” people live very clearly now.
The OWS folks are our neighbors. The Red Cross is a business and is hooked into the power structure that is eating us all alive.
This has been humbling for me to read and the video is quite a story.
I will be directing my friends to give aid for Sandy recovery to Occupy.
Thank you.
Cynthia, glad you are ok.
We have our power back and intertoobs as well. Other than cutting up all the free firwood strewn around my neighborhood, i’m pretty much back to normal today.
BTW, we are overrun with line crews from Ontario. They are all huge, like NFL huge, gorgeous, blond, polite and friendly. Is all of Ontario like this?
There was a tweet I saw the other day that when Occupy Sandy folks started chanting “a better world is possible” NYPD and FEMA folks joined in.
Yeah, Ray Kelly, actual first responder cops want to live in that better world, too. But you stay warm and dry at One PP.
Cynthia, we totally are! Well, not all blond, but …
So glad our excellent Hydro crews are giving hand with your Sandy stuff.
Compare and contrast: A friend-of-a friend is the supervisor of an elite emergency wire-down crew here for Toronto Hydro. She and her team were put on stand-by to goto NOLA when Katerina was approaching. They waited two weeks for the call to come. It never came.
Incredibly, OWS is moving from merely providing food and blankets to actually helping people repair their homes.
Short term I would say the best things are anythig that generates heat or light.
But I have noticed a bunch of tweets looking for construction tools and cleaning supplies (and face masks to protect from dust and mold)
So, all the Home Depot kind of things on the registry seem to be the next phase.I think I would go with battery or self powered tools since many of the places where they will be used won’t have power.
Also any kind of electric generator that does not use gasoline, plus the fuel to run it.
I love the sign they had up at the church “mutual aid, not charity”.
If we looked at everythign like that, we would not have the Great Recession.
((Hugz)) and so glad you are safe, was worried and worried when your liveblog stopped. Rec’d, of course, and a huge fist-bump for Occupy Sandy. Love the Rolling Dept Jubilee, too.
This is the way ‘government’ should work. No politics, simply grass-roots identify problem and solve it. Just think, if enough of this went on, ‘serious’ government would be not only irrelevant (which it already is) but unnecessary.
I have family that lives right across the street from One PP, and believe me they were neither warm nor lit for many days.
We are in a bad patch right now but this is proof people power will overcome greed and avarice.
Thanks for a great summary and video.
If you’ve been without power for a while, you may have missed some great photos about the interaction of Occupy Sandy with the PTB, so here’s one of OWS providing food for people from FEMA
Glad you’re OK. Looking at the (basically useless) LIPA map, it appears that much of LI is finally getting power back.
Oh, in those big appartment buildings? Yeah, those stayed dark for while. One PP has it’s own generators.
According to twitter, people from Occupy Boston have collected and sent supplies (including 3 generators), and now the local Red Cross is referring people who want to make in kind donations to them.
Occupy Boston@Occupy_Boston
#OccupySandyBOS update: the Red Cross is now referring people doing donation drives to us. We need help: drivers with vehicles, especially.
Fantastic post Cynthia ! So inspiring !
If there is hope for the planet it comes from the Occupy movement and those working compassionately outside the corrupt system of government we now operate under .
Bravo !
I have an electric stove, so when power went out we lost heat, hot water and even the ability to make a hot cup of tea. A couple days later the local variety store had one of these in stock
http://www.amazon.com/Portable-Butane-Stove-Camping-Burner/dp/B000RA8V1S
I got it for $24 and 10 cans of butane at $2 piece. It is all cheaper on Amazon. This thing changed my life. I set it up on the ceramic cooktop of my stove and used it as if I had a gas burner.
One cannister makes enough heat to cook three meals, make enough hot water for sponge bathing and dish washing AND a generous amount of ad hoc hot tea and instant cocoa.
You don’t mind the cold and the dark so much with a steaming mug of yummy in your hands.
So, it’s not on the Occupy Sandy wedding registry, but I would reocommend sending a burner ALONG WITH SOME CANS OF FUEL in a single donation.
Don’t just send the burner or fuel by themselves, I think it will be too hard to reunite them.
For the folks who can’t get their houses certified yet to have power turned back on, this burner will make the difference between being able to stay in the home and function.
You know what I would love to see? One or more of the big oil companies send a tanker (with appropriate small nozels) down to OWS sites to help them fuel up their delivery vehicle and generators.
targetting fuel like that would get the aide where it is needed most.
Great, great post. Inspirational.
But don’t hold your breathe waiting for
MayorKing Mike to ever, ever admit he’s wrong. Not gonna happen; been here 12 years and never seen it…Oops, copied that comment from a previous post when all I had seen was twitter info. Here’s the coverage of Occupy Boston’s Sandy efforts.
http://blog.thephoenix.com/BLOGS/phlog/archive/2012/11/11/new-england-storm-front-from-boston-to-new-york-occupy-sandy-endures.aspx
http://bostonherald.com/news/regional/view.bg?articleid=1061173878
I stillhave not gotten over the fact that the primary activity of Mayor Mike was holding televised press conference instead of deployng patrol cars to use their loudspeakers in neighborhoods.
Who had TV to watch the press conferences with?
As long as we are in fantasy mode I would like to have a rule that whenever the power goes out due to a disaster it is also shut off in the wealthiest neighborhoods and non essential Government buildings like the Governors/Mayors office and home.
Let’s see if the msm finally wakes and really gives OS its due. I don’t think that the problem in the past has been msm laziness; I think that tptb had deemed OWS as the “wrong side of the tracks” and the msm were not going to go against tptb. After all, OWS was not happy with the status quo and many people felt the same way. Giving them good press could have stirred up more rebelliousness.
Unfortunately, it’s assumed that everyone has a smart phone and can access websites during a power outage. I continue to run into this situation everywhere.
This makes my day. Thank you and glad you’re OK!
I came to the realization long ago that the rc was nothing more than a pr group. susan g. komen for the cure took the rc play book, but apparently did not have enough friends in high places. Many soldiers from WWII told me that the rc was not very useful, some said that when the rc came to give them comfort, the rc would charge them for coffee and a doughnut. When I see celebs such as Lady GaGa give a million $$$ to the rc, I think that money goes directly into their publicity machine and is unlikely to get to the street that needs it. You can guess that I don’t give a nickel to the rc.
I’m thinking that this situation is a godsend. An opportunity to both help those in need and embarrass the entire political system in front of the American electorate.
Why American Red Cross does not work: They are based on a corporate model – so they are very good at holding meetings, doing taskforces, etc. Getting food into people’s mouths, getting them heat, getting things immediately better? Not so much. OWS’s great skill ( and what is probably attracting the National Guard and veterans who are down there taking training and direction from them) is this: boots on the ground, scrounging, asking for stuff, getting stuff into people’s hands, ad hoc (who knew to ask for medical personnel who speak Russian, Ukranian, etc. etc.? OWS…), change on a dime, don’t worry about the rules (they’ve got 7 year old kids making PB and J sandwiches and handing them out to volunteers – make everyone useful and productive. What can a little kid do? Make a PB and J – this is a technology they understand: slices of break, a butter knife, a spoon and jars of jelly and PB), just ‘get ‘er done’. All that money to American Red Cross? Totally wasted.
There has been a bunch of loose talk about the income tax aspects of debt forgiveness. Documentation for the settlement idea is easy to prepare, though attention has to be paid to the law state by state.
There are other ways to deal with the problem as well. I hope this issue doesn’t worry people at all.
There is a good article in the New York Times.
Hear! Hear!
Press conferences from Mayor Mike? No one could have anticipated . . .
I think you’ll get those very old overhead wires buried and that spotty cell phone coverage fixed long before Mayor Mike apologizes to OWS.
(Oh, and your question about who was watching those press conferences? They weren’t aimed at the people of metro NY, but at the lazy MSM that you wrote about at the end of your post, so that they can say “See, things are happening!”)
Thanks for the link. I never read the nyt except through links. I haven’t seen many links with a positive view on the various Occupy groups.
It seems our bureaucracies are based on favors and politics (same difference in a way) and not functionality or effectiveness. Reminds me of how the U.S. back in the day used to make fun of the Soviet Union’s ineffectiveness to provide for the people.
What has happened to the Red Cross? I can remember when they were at disasters within a few hours and doing great work. This needs to be a News Story because people are giving their money to an organization which is not fulfilling its
stated commitment.
Forgot to say thanks to Cynthia for the info and am so glad that you are ok.
Thank you for this post, Cynthia Kouril!
Thank you all for the kind wishes
so good to see your fonts again cynthia. thank you for this post — tweeted and recommended
Expanding on what I said in post #8, the Red Cross has great and lofty goals but fails on application. When I was going to meetings, the staff indicated that they had three major goals:
1. Getting a lot of money to support disaster relief.
2. Training 0.5% of the population of an area to be “shock troops” to go out into disaster areas and set up relief efforts. Training was in basic services such as logistics, first aid, training lots of people fast, etc. The idea was to have a network of capable people to send into either disaster areas or to serve in local disasters.
When I asked about training classes, none were organized. They were set up on an ad hoc basis. We the “greenhorns” were excited to be a part. As only one class was set up in the three years of my association, I lost interest.
3. Cataloging local resources for disaster relief. One thought is that they would use schools and gyms. The schools would be used for their kitchens, toilets and showers. The gyms would be the temporary homeless shelters. The cataloging effort was to find the schools, record their capacity to serve HOT meals and to get buy in by the school district. Another thought was to find stores that sold generators.
On a personal note, last November I visited my 84 year old parents in MA last year during the storm/power outage in November. My parents were without power for almost two weeks. The little things like having light in a room at night and serving them a hot meals made a HUGE difference in their morale. Also, just having someone to talk to is a BIG deal.
There are still plenty of the “Gas One” brand of butane stoves in stock on Amazon, and plenty of standard butane canisters, but it looks like the only vendor that ships both the stove and the cannisters is “Denali Wholesale Supply, LLC.” So it takes a few extra minutes and a few more clicks, but it’s worth the concentration to make sure the stove and fuel go out at the same time.
Now, I just need to find the best “wedding registry” on Amazon. There appear to be at least half a dozen of them. This one was the first one that popped up on the top of the list.
That first wedding registry is to ship supplies to “The Church of St. Luke and St. Matthew 520 Clinton Ave Brooklyn, New York 11238.” It appears to be over-subscribed, so to speak, since every item has been delivered, some items way over-delivered.
This second registry is for Jersey City, it needs … everything, including Cynthia’s favorite butane cannisters (didn’t see the stove, yet). The shipping address for that registry is listed as “Jersey City Sandy Recovery distribution center at Barrow Mansion, 83 Wayne St, Jersey City, NJ, 07302.”
HUH ? In Florida at least, all they do is secure the schools for shelters as for meals and everything else. You are F**ing on you own.
As for training, the local Hospitals and Fire Rescue did a much better job. CPR, First aid etc.
Red Cross ?? HA…Don’t make me laugh.
Amazon prefers this shipping address for St. Luke & St. Matthew in Brooklyn (note the two “Brooklyns”):
The Church of St. Luke and St. Matthew, 520 CLINTON AVE BROOKLYN, BROOKLYN, NY, 11238-2211 United States
Exactly.
I caught on when 1) I heard what Liddy Dole made as President, and 2) Katrina happened.
Corptocracy has infected everything.
This is what America should be all about. Thanks to Occupy Sandy for showing the way.
The Bloomberg Plutocrats need to apologize and move over. Time for a real change.
Yup, and getting the little kids involved in an important task makes the kids feel (genuinely) valued.
In a slightly different vein, did you know that the Japanese had jet engined planes in the fading months of World War II? They did, and on the whole were a lot better made than the German Messerschmitt jets. The reason: The Nazis used slave labor in their jet plants, whereas the Japanese used highly motivated and patriotic kids who were happy to contribute something so vital to the defense of their country.
Hey, Cynthia, so glad to see you back here. Am so glad you’re all right.
My experience with Red Cross is a bit mixed. When the refugees from Katrina came to our Convention Center, Red Cross organized it fantastically well, taped areas on the floor for each person with a numbering system so people could be tracked. Computers so people could find each other who were brought to different areas of the country. Hot food – 3 meals a day. Washing machines. Showers. Areas for donations of clothing and bedding and suitcases.
I worked there all day every day for the duration as a volunteer. They were terrific.
Afterwards, when I wanted to continue my training, that never did seem to work out and I lost interest.
I’m thrilled that Occupy has stepped up to the plate and is doing such a great job.
When was that video made?
Oh and an area for the refugees to see medical people. Wheelchairs, diabetes meds, etc.
Cynthia, You’re absolutely right about pressuring the Oil Folks to send supplies.
The Oil Folks should send supplies. And not the shit we have to skim off the beaches. Real fuel.
Thank you for an excellent description of these two initiatives. Occupy remains unheard in part because Occupiers have failed to engage the 99 percent in a meaningful dialogue about the change the Occupy movement identified as needed for our country. With the elections over, we need to seize the moment to take care of some of the national issues, too. Occupy has done an extraordinary job ground level. But each time, the effort is one voice trying to speak over the din of economic issues, campaigns, war, unemployment, and other issues. It’s about time we came together like a chorus to get the Occupy message heard by the consenting governed, the politicians, the media, and the corporations and banks.
OWS tweeted that they have raised about $100K so far which they beleive will allow them to purchase about $2Million in distressed debt.
Not bad for the first day.