
France – Flicker Creative Commons
CraneStation’s latest diary got me thinking. We here so much about the excesses of the elite and the wealth distribution in this country but how many of us have taken a really good look at our own life styles. Seems to me that as one commenter said quite some time ago on a BBC news article, “The best way to get back a rich folks is not to play their game.”
This may piss more and a few people off but really how man of us actually envy their life style ? Their excesses and ability to gorge themselves when ever they want.
I know this is trite and cliche’ but we really do consume much more that is necessary. Not just food – though that is a big part of it – but houses and cars and entertainment and toys and on and on.
Has anyone actually though that the reason CraneStaion and Masoninblue and exist on dumptster diving is because of the wasteful life styles the rest of us indulge in ?
Here are a few things to consider.
The French stay thin and live an average of 3 years longer than we do.
Eating is a leisurely experience. In the United States, we often wolf down meals in record time or eat while driving or sitting at our desks. But the French appear to have all the time in the world to sit around and dine.
“We sit down and eat for pleasure, using all of our senses,” Mireille Guiliano, author of the best-selling book French Women Don’t Get Fat, has said.
In America, low-carb diets have many of us saying no to white foods like bread and pasta, but in France, everyone seems to be toting a fresh baguette to bring home.
“You need to eat a large volume of bread or pasta for the calories to add up, and most of the time, French meals are quite light and portions are small,” says Benchetrit.
They consume a hell of a lot less than we do and take time to do it. Not only that but meals are a special occasion. You will rarely see Frenchman eating alone.
Is it our culture, our heritage, our gastronomy, our climate…? It is a combination of all these things. The famous “A table !”, which means that everyone should come, sit and eat together represents all those things in one : social habits, values, education and of course delicious food.
The also bike and walk a lot. The streets are narrow and not conducive to cars. They use public transportation a lot as well. This is not only true for France but most of Europe. And I do not want to leave the Asian community out here, but look at the diets and life styles of Japan and even Korea.
And the “stuff” that we own and replace even when it’s still perfectly functioning simply to get the latest and greatest. Do we really need these big TVs and room size entertainment centers ? I won’t even go into the the automobile area here as we all know how outrageous that has become.
And gardening. Europe loves gardens. Even roof top gardens. Vegetable gardens, flower gardens and quite often both.
The French are pastmasters at getting the most out of their potagers. Virtually every yard has a spotless vegetable garden. Often, it occupies most of a small yard. And it is planted so tightly you can hardly imagine how the gardener manages to walk between those closely packed rows. What’s more, there never seems to be a trace of a footstep between those immaculate lines of vegetables, which always appear freshly cultivated. It’s as if the gardener hovers in the air to do his or her work!
And entertainment. We here are most likely to squat in front of our video screens and let out minds be awash with whatever drivel it offers. But Paris and Berlin and Amsterdam offer streets lined with small clubs and cafe’s with local groups and acts and socializing galore. It’s where groups like The Beatles and The Rolling Stones got their start. As wells as singers and comedians etc.
These being examples of how one can have a different approach to life. To do ones living differently. To simplify, simplify, simplify.
I am not suggesting at all that anyone just drop what they are doing and live like this or some other way. Far from it. Change takes time and work. Little by little. Take what works and discard the rest.
But it’s not enough to just go through the motions. To take some superficial approach. Like all those articles I have read or programs I have seen of people “giving up the urban/suburban” life to move to the country and then bring their attitudes and desires and behaviors with them. Trading their fancy lifes in the cities for a fancy life in the country. Like episodes of This Old House and Hometime and others.
It takes an attitude change. A deep rejection of the seductiveness of the elite. Like the charlatan you turn your back on and walk away from but without a self righteous attitude about it. Embracing a different life style with out feeling superior to others in the process. And this is the difficult part since it is a letting go of ego. And this is where I have had a difficult time with those who have attempted this and the the movement of the past. Far to many have tried to appear to have change but retained the better than though attitudes they had in the first place.
These people will ultimately fail.
But to succeed would be a cultural revolution.



23 Comments

One of the biggest pluses from this is we would become a heck of lot more healthy.
So turn off the TV.
Eat less.
Plant a garden.
Get a smaller house.
Walk.
Find a cafe’ somewhere and just hang out.
See I think we have been taking the wrong approach to an extent. Instead of wanting the elites to let go of what they have, we should learn how better to live with out them entirely.
After all they need us for their stuff.
We need to stop consuming and start living. That’s what Crane and I are doing.
Uhm, we write a little bit too.
Recommended, btw.
Own your failure.
Love this diary. Recommended. Of course, the French don’t need to worry about health care, and they have much, much more vacation time than we do, so that allows for a little less tension, but I totally agree with your premise. Simplify and downsize and don’t let “things” that you have, or think that you want to have, rule your life.
We don’t need or want to have anything to do with the rich. We decide with whom we want to associate. How rich or poor they are is not a factor we consider. So far, we have not met a rich person whom we would like to spend time with and get to know.
People, if you don’t do anything else, at least kill your TVs. That’s a great place to begin reclaiming your lives.
Amen..Here Here…and Right On.
I think that covers all the bases.
If I lived in a compound that cost me fifty thousand dollars a month to maintain, I would still stand in the kitchen in a tee-shirt eating chips over the sink. Plus, I would not want to worry that, while paying the 50,000/month if I got a flat tire on my Mercedes I would lose everything. That’s just too much bother. I do not envy it.
Life is slower but a lot more enriching without all the stress over stuff and money.
Thank you so much for the mention, and with this and Englehardt’s article today, and with others weighing in, who are in various stages of rethinking the need for wealth, maybe we can be okay being poor at least some of the time.
Now, if we could just get some health care and essentials to those in need we’d be even better. We are grateful to be able to dumpster dive. Not everyone can.
Did I read you right when you said that you, CraneStation, and Masoninblue exist on dumpster diving? While I share some of your sentiments, I just can’t imagine doing this yucky activity. But, that’s just me.
Technology has now evolved to the point where one needn’t have a lot of paper and cardboard to possess a library of books or music. If I was living on my own, I could easily live in a Tiny House set on a 1/10 lot. One can grow a lot of food on a 1/10 acre lot.
Everything that we wear, all utensils, appliances, flatware, furniture, housewares and linens and most of our food comes from dumpsters. Absolutely true.
Dumpster fruits:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/70377872@N04/6904331147/in/photostream/lightbox/
Meats:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/70377872@N04/6985290385/in/photostream/lightbox/
We also ‘shop’ for gifts. A doll:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/70377872@N04/6732370629/in/photostream/lightbox/
Quilt:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/70377872@N04/6839301492/in/photostream/lightbox/
Angel:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/70377872@N04/6985422437/in/photostream/lightbox/
I don’t miss the mall!
Amazing what people throw away.
Oh, I love the tiny house! We you the one who showed me shipping container houses?
Shrink-wrapped meats, chicken, pork, fruit and vegetables thrown into a grocery store dumpster on or before their ‘sell by’ date are not “yucky.”
With rare exceptions, they look the same as the stuff you pay for, if you go inside the store and buy it.
We’d rather not pay for our food, since we can get it for free, and we’re eating better than we ever did when we had careers and lots of money.
Dear Masoninblue & CraneStation: I hope you didn’t think my comment was insulting. I just can’t relate to dumpster diving. Well, maybe for appliances, furniture, flatware, etc. etc., but I draw the line at food even if it’s shrink wrapped. Again, that’s just me.
I am rather frugal myself and go to thrift stores when I can.
I wish you both happiness and peace, although you both sound like you’ve found it.
Karen
Holy crap ! Is that all stuff you guys got ?? That doll must be worth a tidy bit as well as the quilt. Nice quilts are expensive. I know my ex-therapist did quilts and told me after a query, “You can’t afford it.”
And those pears look yummy.
Here’s the thing. I just got back from a walk with my photo stuff in a nice park/running trail area out in Shaker Heights. The pricy part of Cleveland with big stately houses on pretty big lots.
It would be very easy to judge the people in these houses, they may not be part of the so called 1% but they are up there income wise.
But think about it for a minute. They are quite literally trapped there in their big houses and new cars and fancy furniture and techno-toys etc. having to work with ever decreasing income and increasing outgo to pay for it all.
It would be very difficult for most of them to change this in a country where if you have no money you are nothing. A nobody. An un-person.
It’s a trap. Once you get in – it’s very, very difficult to get out. I have known myself only a very few people who have done so voluntarily. And one was not so voluntary as she was told that to get “clean” she had to give up here fancy NYC dress business and go to work in a laundromat.
This is however where I think too many on the left get it wrong. They still want the trap but they also want the key.
It don’t work that way.
Yes. It’s all from dumpsters. Even the chair, drape and basket that the fruits are in.
Dang me. What people will toss out these days. OY
No worries, I avoided the food for a long time myself, and I still shop in the thrift stores. They are my favorite stores!
Enough is enough. Really. It is.
If you really think about it, the best tasting foods were invented by poor people, whether they were Chinese, Mexican, or Itallian.
My mother grew up poor. Her Southern cooking is hard to duplicate, even by Southerners. She cooked with a lot of fat and flavor, but we only had meat a few nights of the week. Some meals were just greens and corn bread, or potato soup. Those meals were simple, but were like heavan.