Folks, I smell a Rat…! But, first, let’s quickly dispense with some of the nonsense swirling about Syria…
The Assad government is not “falling.”
…Yes, the demise of the Syrian government exists mainly in the “minds” of a couple of vendu think-tank analysts in Washington, the corporate media bandwagon, and the enfants terribles Wilsonians now riding high in the Obama Administration. The attempt is being made to simply BS Assad out of power. Obama is now functioning fully as the reincarnated Lincoln and sees himsef as “clothed in a great power.” Well, pilgrim, he has placed the US in the position of an alliance with an AQ affiliate (al-nusra). The Syrians that he recognised as government are demanding that he stop condemning their AQ ally and are coming to Washington to tell him and the Wilsonians that he must de-list al-nusra as a terrorist group.
Group Think and the desire to be loved by colleagues and the powerful account for a lot of the intellectual irresponsibility on display but it is also the fact that many of those “running their mouths” over Syria are simply ignorant, callow creatures created by ten years of war and the super-abundance of government money that allowed the hiring of the pitifully under experienced.
The only real question in my mind is whether or not Syria actually wasted a few SSMs last week. Let’s see some evidence, some wreckage, statements by Clapper about heat signatures at launch, something.
The civil war appears to be a stalemate. Having painted himself into a corner BHO will eventually have to opt for intervention of some kind. pl
Now, it would seem that even ex-FDLer, Spencer Ackerman has been sucked into the proverbial Media vortex…
Islamic Extremists Rescue NBC Reporter Held in Syria
…Securing Engel’s freedom is a particularly unexpected turn for Ahrar al-Sham, which the Associated Press describes as “Islamic fundamentalist brigade home to many foreign jihadis.” A recently revamped rebel command structure excluded the group, along with the al-Qaida-aligned Jabhat al-Nusra, seemingly to secure Western backing. Such groups are given to criticizing the U.S. — not for intervening in Syria, but for not intervening enough in Syria, and being prissy about the company it keeps.
Ahrar al-Sham might give Westerners pause. But Danger Room pal Matt Fanning, a Fort Worth-based IT consultant who closely tracks Syrian rebel groups, says the jihadist organization is one of the most effective and the most media-savvy of the rebel coalition. Their weapons of choice include roadside bombs and car bombs, tactics that “clearly came from Iraq,” Fanning says.
Ahrar al-Sham is also one of the most prolific Syrian jihadi groups on YouTube. Ahrar al-Sham takes video cameras along on raids — to capture giant explosions for upload — and doesn’t mind displaying maps of its operations against Assad’s forces. “Sham also releases probably three to five videos a day where Nusra is good for about one to three a week,” Fanning says.
But Ahrar al-Sham’s ideology is no less extreme. It’s issued religious edicts against the ruling Alawite minority and has been criticized for rounding up Shias as hostages. “I agree with al-Qaida on certain things and disagree on others,” one Ahrar al-Sham fighter, a veteran of al-Qaida in Iraq, told The New York Times in July. His nuanced view of suicide bombing: OK against government troops, not OK against civilians…
Basically, Spencer, fails to see the forest through the trees…!
Now, b at MOA, asked some very penetrating questions of Richard’s abduction…
Another Indication That Richard Engel’s Kidnapping Story Stinks
… There is now new evidence that this was indeed a fake event and that, whatever Richard Engel may believe, he and the people with him (which included one ever unnamed “British engineer” who is more likely some special operations guy) were not in the hands of Shabiha but in the hand of well known experienced video fakers.
Early this year we have looked at the roles of citizen journalists from Syria. One was Khaled Abu Salah who faked and uploaded many videos of Syrian government atrocities, one day playing nearly dead while playing very well and enraged just few days later. The other fake journalist was one “Danny” who presented his fake videos with Anderson Cooper on CNN. {…}
Now here is a video, uploaded yesterday, in which the fake citizen journalist Khaled Abu Salah interviews the just freed Richard Engel the evening before Engel returns from Syria to Turkey.
How come that this known serial producer of fake videos is involved in a murky kidnapping case that looks like a propaganda set up for “western” media consumption?
Further:
-Who smuggled Richard Engel into Syria? Was it Avaaz?
-Did “Danny” and Khaled Abu Salah knew that he was coming?
-Did they prepare the kidnapping and the liberation of Richard Engel?Some of the answers may be found if Richard Engel explains how he came to meet Khaled Abu Salah for this interview. Engel should urgently answer that question.
The Grey Lady’s Robert Mackay pointed out much of the Agitprop being generated… As Last Member of NBC Team Escapes Syria, More Details on Hostage Drama Emerge… Yesterday, he did a great job in exposing the real disparities in reports from Syria… Accounts of a Siege in Syria Differ on Rebel YouTube Channels and British Television…! Fancy that, eh…?
Btw, I’ve highlighted much of these shenangians in play, before… The Syrian Morass…
*gah*



19 Comments

We will never know, because apparently journalists’ lives are so important to their employers that they suppress the news to “save” them. They are completely uninterested in discussing any suppression of other “news” when lives might be saved, unless they are Media Elite Employees.
And then they get all bent outta shape at the UK Mail and Gawker for reporting the news.
The truth matters not, only the spin. Wag the dog indeed.
Thank you for this, it certainly explains a lot.
You man know that Engel’s father a high mucky-muck at Goldman Sachs (retired), and Goldman S. is Obama’s biggest funder.
How much does it cost to spray paint faux govt words on a wall.
What is Engle’s IQ anyhow.
Would it be in Asad’s interest to capture western journalist. Doesn’t pass the giggle test.
Gotta link to that. Not that I doubt you.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Engel#Early_years
Thanks.
In 2008, Goldman Sachs was second-highest contributor to B.O.: https://www.opensecrets.org/pres08/contrib.php?cid=N00009638
Thanks CTuttle, there was something that smelled funny about this to me from the time I first heard of it.
Barry’s preferred narrative of an MSDNC reporter being saved from the evil Assad by “our buddies AQ” just seemed like someone was mailing in the script for Kathryn Bigelow’s next Leni Reifenstahl impersonation.
A-yep.
Though I would say that Engel’s story checks out for the simple reason that at least one of his rebel escorts was killed on the spot by the kidnappers:
Now granted, it could possibly be that the people holding Engel were willing to kill several of their own — both at the beginning and end of the multi-day kidnapping — in order to make the pretense that they were pro-Assad forces look better. But Occam’s Razor suggests otherwise.
And it was maybe 1/380th of the total of $388 million.
Here’s the list of top contributors, for context:
There were also bullets being sprayed — unless you think that the deaths of both some of the captors and some of Engel’s rebel escorts were somehow faked.
Thank you for this CTuttle. Their body language just seemed off to me and they all seemed to gaze down slightly to their right at (guessing) cue cards.
Nice try. But in order to apply Occam’s razor, you actually have to look at all the evidence, which means actually confronting the evidence that MOA and CTuttle are confronting. All you did was ignore the evidence that is under discussion, cherry pick some other piece of evidence, then invoke Occam’s razor.
Yeah, CTuttle, there certainly is an odor.
I find Engel’s story having a little too much derring-do, passing notes etc., to be done by competent kidnappers. To my mind, that rules out the Syrian government or Shabiha. And Spencer’s analysis of Ahrar al-Sham also seems a little strange, the implication that Ahrar al-Sham wanted to encourage the US to lift its objection to their inclusion in the coalition of political opposition.
But this I find very strange:
Because the oppposition has said from the beginning and continues to say through other reports that the one thing they do not want is foreign intervention–meaning foreign troops on Syrian soil. Arms, money, diplomatic support, yes; military help, no.
I think the judgement of a current stalemate is probably (unfortunately for Syrian civiilians) correct for the current state in a changing situation. Two weeks ago I would have (and likely in some comment did) see the regime falling by spring.
The capture of Engel was somebody’s publicity stunt IMO. The list of suspect groups probably runs to a half dozen, including the NBC marketing department. And the three did treat it just too much like a summer camp adventure.
That is a very good point. But why was there little mention of the people who died by Engel and his crew? Did they not know who was ferrying them around? We they seen just as rebels and not as persons?
What injuries caused them to fashion bandages from bedsheets?
Maybe he meant blindfolds, but why would they fashion their own blindfolds?
Richard doesn’t know what he means.
Mom always said if you tell a lie you will have to tell a dozen more to conceal the first one.
PW, first off, that is what Engel Says happened, and, next you do realize how easy it is to stage it, right…?
Engel’s account does not pass the smell test. If I am firing on a vehicle with an AK-47, then:
1. Any bullets that missed the engine block would shred the vehicle and create shrapnel. Engel looks unhurt and none of the bullets hit him.
2. I would not stop firing until I had covered the passenger areas in bullets (for my own protection). Remember Jessica Lynch? Her vehicle was sprayed with bullets and she was wounded in the fight.
Engel is either very very lucky or he is being duped.