As a single mother whose life’s work has largely focused on solving the climate crisis, I’m often in a quandary: how much do I share of the work I do on this issue — which overwhelms those rare adults who immerse themselves in the details with grief — with my 11-year-old son?
When I posed this question in an interview with NASA’s top climate scientist, Dr. James Hansen, who often speaks of his grandchildren as his motivator for speaking out on climate change, he advised me that it is more important to let a child be a child. Let them experience the wonder and beauty of nature, not fear it, he said.
And so I was a bit perplexed as to what to tell my son as I prepared to get arrested for the first time in my life. It turned out that I would be joining over 1,000 people from around the U.S. and Canada in non-violently protesting a pipeline that President Obama was poised to approve. This was not just any pipeline; it was, as Dr. Hansen called it, a pipeline that, if opened, would light the “carbon bomb,” a move that would signal “game over” for the climate.
In the aftermath of Hurricane Irene, my son and I were watching the movie Avatar on DVD (for the nth time), and as it ended, I thought, “This might be a good opportunity to explain my plans for this week.”
“You know, this movie is very close to what is happening in Canada right now. And it’s one reason I will be getting arrested this week.”
As my son took in my explanation for my planned act of civil disobedience, he quickly concluded that he, too, wanted to be arrested. But, after some hours of contemplation, I had to reluctantly tell him no.
Why “reluctantly”? Because I felt that I was denying my son the right to act, politically, on an issue that would very likely have a much larger impact on his life than on mine. He, far more than the adults who were weighing in, should have a vote on this issue. Yet he and all the children have little say in the world they will inherit, one that may be changed utterly, in ways we can’t even comprehend.
As I stood before the White House gates a few days later, listening to the police issue their warnings of our impending arrests to our group of over 100 demonstrators, I thought of what I would say as they carted me away — what cry I wanted the president to hear.
And I recalled the day President Obama stood before the American people, in those days and months when BP’s deepwater well billowed millions of barrels of oil from that horrifying wound in the Gulf of Mexico floor. I remembered him remarking that, yes, he was very concerned about the spill because, while he shaved one morning, his 11-year-old daughter Malia had asked him, “Did you plug the hole yet, Daddy?”
Children have a way of speaking to our hearts. And so, I mused, even if President Obama didn’t hear the songs and the chants of the more than 1,000 people who were arrested over the course of two weeks, even if the prayers of religious leaders and Native American elders went unanswered, even if he didn’t read the editorial opposing the Keystone XL pipeline in The New York Times, even if he ignored the advice of his very own EPA, perhaps, in this instance, Sasha or Malia might see us outside the White House gates and ask him, “Did you stop the pipeline yet, Daddy?”
As the police cuffed my hands behind me and led me off to a white school bus, I shouted: “For Sasha and Malia!”
I don’t think the president or his daughters heard me, I thought, as I watched my fellow protesters be cuffed, searched and photographed through the bus’ caged windows. But perhaps, if we keep this up, they will.




31 Comments

This is such a tragic situation. Thank you for doing what you do, recc’d.
Thanks for this awesome post, Daphne, and welcome to FDL.
One more thing: Your kids are so fortunate to have you as a parent. They must be so proud of you.
Although I read FDL religiously, I don’t normally comment. Your post is one that I couldn’t recommend without comment. Sasha, Malia and your son are lucky to have you, Daphne, as is everyone that inhabits this place we call home.
i said he was a shitty father to those girls,he is a shitty father to the nation…he needs to retire NOW
and reccd
They’re rich. They’ll be fine. They know this at least intuitively, if not consciously.
First of all thank you for going over and above as a citizen protesting the keystone pipeline.
But in regard to the President’s children, I think that, like most rich people, they feel safe and insulated with their money from the rest of us. It’s a game of risk with them and the potential for loss does not come at the same cost as it does for the majority of us.
For example, if the oil leaks and spoils the aquifer, they will still be able to afford the food and water available from Wall Street owned privatized retail sources at higher prices. Same thing with school vouchers and the dismantling of public education. What do people like the Obamas give a damn about that? They can afford to send their two daughters to one of the priciest private schools in DC at a cost of annual tuition of $84,000 for both the girls.
If you want real change, stop begging for mercy from the masters and run for office yourself as an Independent. Nothing will change until we replace the monsters in Congress with Americans who do care.
Outstanding post, Daphne. Rec’d.
The debacle with Obama is similar to domestic abuse. Obama is a serial and habitual abuser. There is no reasoning with an abuser, and begging for mercy will not stop the abuse. The only solution is removal from office.
Obama is a rightwinger to the max.
Your son, sorry. Your son must be so proud of you.
Righteous speak.
As others have said, he doesn’t care. And his children will be raised in luxury and pretense THAT WE CAN NOT EVEN IMAGINE!
He’s set for life now.
I think one of their fears, albeit small, is that their children will one day have the perspective of us peasants. And if they do, they will see the evil inherent in their parents.
But that is a small concern. Being educated and raised in their environment does not breed/cultivate our kind. It makes entitled and spoiled adults who don’t care a whit for others, … BECAUSE they were TAUGHT not to.
He’s got his. He got paid. And his family will be fine. In fact they are set for life. Set in ways we can NOT imagine. Serve the corporate masters well and you will be rewarded.
What kind of a parent would purposefully ruin the enivronment that his children and grandchildren will be living in? I do not know. Money will not be able to reverse the damage, I do not think.
yup
see George W.Booooooooooosh
ive been saying it since BP…whata dickhead he is
IMHO, “dickhead” is way too gentle a term.
Remember, Mr. Medea did throw his own children in the carcinogenic BP spill in the Gulf of Mexico, and forced them to eat contaminated seafood.
Oh really. Sasha & Malia are worried about how their dad will be able to afford (adjusting Chelsea’s $5 million wedding for inflation) their $20, $30, $40 million weddings. After all, Clinton had only one; O has 2.
cant change planets to breathe…gas masks at weddings teh chic
Oh please. This whole daddy thing is obnoxious and pathethic. If you want to do something constructive, run for office or just go home and take care of your own family.
guess you dont like kids or other living organisms…quaint
There’s always that. Perhaps that would be a better way to appeal to Sasha & Malia. Find a high end wedding attire designer who is environmentally aware (would such a human actually exist) and convince him/her to draw up such gas masks… And present them to O at a WH reception, along with his/her card and offer to design all the wedding party attire free of charge.
But I daydream.
now that idea i liketh verrrrry much,maybe one of the Nippon persuasion
Thank you for your actions and sacrifices and for sharing your clear and moving thinking on this.
Puleeze. Chelsea’s wedding did not cost 5 mil-that number is celeb-”journalism” bs. The well-connected don’t actually have to pay for all that stuff anyway-the venue was provided gratis so they only had to cover her dress, flowers, and the organic vegan food and drink at the reception.
This article is the sort of pretentious nonsense that gives liberalism a bad name. Sasha and Malia have nothing to do this, and motherhood has nothing to do with it.
Maybe you didn’t bring tears to Obama’s eyes but you nailed me.
Begging your pardon, but – -
Given the recently-elected Harper govt in Canada -
(This time with a full majority)
Given the overwhelming Conservative majority in Alberta –
How is stopping the pipeline ging to stop oil sands production?
Canada has made clear that it will be increasing production.
The pipeline is simply an issue of where it will go.
The U.S. or China.
And if it goes to China, there will be even greater CO2 emissions.
Not to mention greater CO2 emissions to ship Mideast oil to the U.S.
A “carbon bomb” really?? Get real people; energy is what keeps things moving; and the world is for the forseeable future is going to generate energy with combustibles. The recent failures of government backed “green energy” projects should convince you of that. Do you really want to hamstring energy production and weaken the economy further? Finally, all the class hatred on this site is disgusting. Do y’all really hate the rich including Obama that much?
“energy is what keeps things moving;”
Fool! If we continue with the pillage, conservatively, 25% of all the life on the planet will stop “moving” permanently.