In the British Parliament it is not allowed to call someone a “liar.” It is for this reason that Members of that august body have come up with such grand circumlocutions as “My esteemed Colleague is being parsimonious with the truth!” Now just so we get our language right when dealing with nitty-gritty problems of truth telling in foreign cultures let me start with Merriam-Webster’s on Parsimonious:
Definition of PARSIMONIOUS
1: exhibiting or marked by parsimony; especially: frugal to the point of stinginess
2: sparing, restrained
Now in the last few days the Nuclear Safety Commission has outed itself on how much it has been lying, err, rather been parsimonious with the truth. The Asahi Shimbun has an article today headlined Meltdowns also likely occurred at No. 2, No. 3 reactors of Fukushima plant in which we see:
“We have to assume that meltdowns have taken place,” Hosono said at a news conference May 16.
Haruki Madarame, chairman of the Nuclear Safety Commission, said in a separate news conference the same day that the meltdowns should not come as a surprise.
“When highly contaminated water was found at the No. 2 reactor building in late March, we recognized that a meltdown had taken place. So I informed the government,” he said. “As for No. 1 and No. 3 reactors, we recognized that, given the processes that led to the accidents there, the same thing had occurred.”
Note that the Chairman, Mr Madarame says that the announcements today should not be a surprise. This shouldn’t be a surprise to us now precisely why? Today the NSC finally publicly admits that meltdowns, pressure vessel and containment breaches have very probably occurred in 3 reactors. Just let me whisper that to you: THREE REACTORS HAVE MELTED AND BURNED THROUGH THE STEEL SURROUNDING THEM. However, Madarame wasn’t surprised, how could he be, he has facts which he has been parsimonious in dealing out. The NSC knew this was the case back in March, and told the government. But it didn’t publicly say so then.
TEPCO has blithely run to a rosy program of denial of the state of the reactors. The same report continues:
TEPCO’s measures to contain the crisis have been based on the assumption of lighter damage to the reactor cores.TEPCO had said it believed that only a portion of the nuclear fuel rods had melted. Now, it appears that all parts of the fuel rods have melted.
TEPCO recently said a meltdown likely occurred at the No. 1 reactor. But a TEPCO official on May 16 declined to comment on the possibility of meltdowns at the No. 2 and No. 3 reactors.
“We have yet to be able to grasp the entire situation at the plant,” the official said.
On March 27th I blogged about this scenario here. Now we know the truth.
There are several things that I predict follow from this.
- The exclusion zone will get bigger, more villages will be evacuated, never to return. I predict the exclusion zone will surpass Chernobyl in area.
- The ground water will be poisoned for months or years, no agriculture and drinking water from this area will be usable, for the foreseeable future
- The seas will continually be poisoned for months or years. This was not a factor in Chernobyl. Fishing along the East Coast of Japan will be profoundly affected for years.
- Cancer rates will rise in Japan. Cancer therapy stocks will rise.
- TEPCO will go bankrupt. They will shortly grasp the situation that they are effectively nationalized. Short their stock if you can.
- The Government and people of Japan, and neighboring countries on the Pacific Ocean, will bear the costs of the unintended consequences of the nuclear risk taking that TEPCO and Japan pursued.
Thanks, Safety Commission, that’s really looking out for the safety of citizens.
cross-posted www.petraitis.us/blog



9 Comments

Just read this on VOA:
I predict his last statement will be disproved, and sooner rather than later.
Uh a lie of omission is still a lie.
He says the amount of radioactive cesium released into the atmosphere is much smaller than that released in the nuclear accident in Chernobyl.
Given their record on the truth everything they say is suspect. However notice cesium is mentioned not plutonium, uranium etc there are lots of radioactive elements in radioactive waste.
Also not he mentions air not water contamination. This was not a broad denial like a Psychopath or Republican would use.
Any bets these lies might be vetted by lawyers trying to deny as much as possible but still keep their clients out of prison? I am not saying they are not lying just not saying broad based easy to disprove lies.
The shape of what they don’t mention gives us an idea of what are hiding.
Example can the problem be fixed if so when?
This person,Yoichi Shimatsu who is Editor-at-large with the 4th Meida is a Hong Kong–based environmental writer. He is the former editor of the Japan Times Weekly. has an interesting perspective:
“Confused and often conflicting reports out of Fukushima 1 nuclear plant cannot be solely the result of tsunami-caused breakdowns, bungling or miscommunication. Inexplicable delays and half-baked explanations from Tokyo Electric Power Company (TEPCO) and the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) seem to be driven by some unspoken factor.
The smoke and mirrors at Fukushima 1 seem to obscure a steady purpose, an iron will and a grim task unknown to outsiders. The most logical explanation: The nuclear industry and government agencies are scrambling to prevent the discovery of atomic-bomb research facilities hidden inside Japan’s civilian nuclear power plants.”
http://en.m4.cn/archives/7235.html
Federation of American Scientists:
” Japan’s nuclear power program based on reprocessed plutonium has aroused widespread suspicion that Japan is secretly planning to develop nuclear weapons.” Japan would not have material or technological difficulties in making nuclear weapons. Japan has the raw materials, technology, and capital for developing nuclear weapons. Japan could possibly produce functional nuclear weapons in as little as a year’s time. On the strength of its nuclear industry, and its stockpile of weapons-useable plutonium, Japan in some respects considers itself, and is treated by others as, as a virtual nuclear weapons state.”
david@1: I could believe that they’re not seeing water or food contamination across Japan. There was no fire like at Chernobyl, so most of the crap would stay near the plant.
things@2: Yeah, parsing “Into the atmosphere”. No mention of the Ocean or ground. It does make me think of tort lawyers. They’ve been avoiding mentioning U or Pu tests, because those would tell us that the fuel rods are fubar. Now that they’ve admitted the meltdowns, we may see more stats on those.
Mafr@5: Unlikely. Japan needs no reaserch program, they’ve been just a few weeks from going nuclear since the late 1970′s at the latest. They’ve chosen not proceed, but they have everything they’d need to build a bomb right now.
Boxturtle (I HATE this comment structure. *Beats dead horse*)
will anyone be held accountable?
responsible?
or is this “God’s” fault?
can’t wait till it happens here. hope I’m living next to it. it’s just radiation. what could possibly go wrong?
Looks like the Japan government is going to be held “accountable” in that they will be paying for it.
Looks like nobody will be held responsable. Really, the root cause was a poor choice for the location of the backup generators so I’m not sure who you’d blame.
Boxturtle (God’s Fault or God’s message?)