Most of the elite have contempt for the portion of the American population that does not have at least 6-figure incomes, however the Washington Post stands out in its willingness to express this contempt so openly. Back in the fall of 2008, when the government was crafting bailouts worth tens of millions of dollars to the likes of Robert Rubin, Lloyd Blankfein, and other well-connected Wall Street types, the Post was frothing at the idea that the government might help protect the jobs of autoworkers earning $27 an hour.
This contempt was fully visible again today when the Post ran an editorial complaining that UAW members who were employees of Delphi, GM’s former auto parts division, would get their full pensions. By contrast, the editorial complained that Delphi’s management personnel had their pension plan taken over by the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation (PBGC) and as a result would get just "pennies on the dollar."
We all know how infuriating it must be to the Post that ordinary working people might get pensions that can sustain a middle class living standard, but they are entitled to their class hatred. However the "pennies on the dollar" claim is more than a bit of a stretch. The PBGC guarantees a benefit of up to $4,500 a month for a worker retiring at age 65. That may be "pennies on the dollar" in Washington Post land, but it’s more than most of the rest of us can expect to live on in retirement.
It’s true that workers who retire at younger ages will likely take substantial hits on their pension, but this is more likely to be an issue for UAW members who do manual labor on the factory floor than the management personnel who hold desk jobs. The latter are certainly better positioned to work into their 60s than the former.



46 Comments




Thanks for kicking WaPo’s butt, Dean.
I wish WaPo would go walkabout and actually meet the people and the communities about whom they write in such a cavalier fashion. I’ve lived in a community where Delphi had a sizable presence; the folks who worked there on the line didn’t have it cushy and are dropping like flies in their retirement years after the toll decades of working at physically demanding labor in environments with no air conditioning, while exposed to industrial chemicals. Imagine what the castings plant for tie rods must have been in the summer — furnace rooms when the outdoor temp was 90+ degrees.
Was the WaPoo like this in Katharine Graham’s day? I didn’t read it back then.
Repulsive…I had a friend who yammered during the election that nothing was happening/hurting the middle class. I have not asked if she still believes this to be true….She may have missed the unemployment numbers.
They fired all their writers.
Who gets their news from the Pravda capitalist press anymore? NY Times and WAPO are dying. I never see anyone under thirty reading a newspaper.
Someone at TPM pointed out yesterday that every lobbyist who visits a pol in D.C. has an income over $250,000. ‘nuf said. WaPoo is inside that bubble. No one else exists. Like magical thinking in a toddler, who when dropping a spoon over the edge of the high chair believes the spoon has ceased to exist because it can’t be seen.
Well the Wapravda is recruiting writers who will work for free! Really! They recently put out an announcement “inviting” volunteer bloggers to compete to be selected to blog the Nationals games.
Amazing how fast the ruling class reduced us all to serfs.
That would be funny if it weren’t so sad. Not only that, I’ll bet they get lots of applicants, for the ‘prestige’ of blogging for free for the WaPoo.
We see lots of them over at HuffPo and some drop by here. I try to ignore them
Great comment. You know, Capitol Hill USED to be the affordable neighborhood in DC. The artists, writers, non-profit types, and families with regular jobs. No More. The ruling class took over the neighborhood at the start of the housing boom during Bushco. My partner, a geek scientist (full rumpled look: wild hair, wrinkled clothes, torn coat sleeves, scuffed shoes, carries a paper bag instead of a brief case), was shoveling the walk after a major snow storm. The new neighbor lobbyist wife (from Texas) steps onto her porch in spike heels and fur coat, yells to my partner, “Yoo Hoo, come here!” Then, “are you working for food? I’ll give you a sandwich is you shovel my walk.”
They know what’s going on; they don’t care.
All these people are addicts who don’t care how their actions harm others. They must be called out and treated as such…money or not.
There needs to be a consciousness raising and a “Power and Money” addiction sub group like Alanon so we can recognize and confront the people who have this devastating illness.
And I’m only 25% joking….and only that because it will never happen.
That’s disgusting. these people have no idea what it means to even cleanup after themselves..it’s all “MONEY!”
can’t find it, but there was a writer who covered life on a car assembly line; It didn’t sound very good. not good at all.
A sandwich for shoveling a sidewalk. Now that’s real pay. /s
I’ve been watching cnbc more often these days because I’m trying to track the possibility of a double-dip, and the MOTU’s take on it. It is truly an alternate universe. Just one example: they cheer every weak economic statistic because it means the FRB won’t be tightening and may do more ‘quantitative’ easing (aka FRB buying longer term treasuries to bring long-term rates down more). At the same time, they whine about how hyperinflation is right around the corner because of the profligate FRB. So their ‘thinking’ isn’t even internally consistent. Doesn’t bother them a bit. Truly bizarro world, which permeates an amazing swath of U.S. society, not just Teabaggers.
And behind closed doors, they are cheering every increase in unemployment. Because it means more “profit” for the companies they own.
It’s not behind closed doors; it’s right out in the open. Profits are high because of ‘cost cutting,’ aka increasing unemployment, and interest rates are low, so how could that be bad for stock prices.
Another piece of illogic of their thinking (there are so many, how to choose which ones to mention): they don’t seem to have noticed that even with high profits and low interest rates, stock prices have gone nowhere for a decade.
Indeed.
And of course, since President Obama actually intervened on the side of the guys working in those hot and unbearable work environments, he’s considered to be evil:
Because working at a desk job is sooooo much harder than doing something where you could die on the job.
Oh dear, Victor David Hanson is up on book-tv and I think my replacement ipod (don’t ask) is synched up and charged, so I must remove myself to more emotionally and physically healthy pursuits.
It is hilarious how people deceive themselves. Not unlike tea baggers on social security demanding they get to keep Bush tax cuts for the rich.
Every time voters go to the polling both, they vote against their own best interest because they have been decieved by the politicians, the special interests, and the press.
I was born working class (in 1944) and have been blue collar all my life. But I was in my 50′s before I developed any sort of class consciousness. Nobody, not even the leaders of the various unions I was a member of, spoke of class struggle. But now I know that class consciousness has always been alive and well in the ruling class. I used to think that the rich simply did not care about the workers. But I have learned that they actively hold us in contempt. If you have not seen “The Revolution Will Not Be Televised” click on the link below. It’s long so you might save it for later.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=5832390545689805144#
Well, as Bob Somerby points out, the ‘progressive’ pundits haven’t been too swift in pushing their case. In fact, many that have been working in the second and third tier publications have followed the lead on what the wapo and nyt pundits say; these wanna-bes do not point out any problems with the big pundits. Thus, by the time the little guys make it to the big time, they have the rules internalized and continue in the same vein. The big time pundits are very attuned to the repug way of thinking and find no reason to fault it. Therefore, for example, cutting SS to take away unneeded income from the “greedy geezers” is a perfectly acceptable way of thinking about the “little people.”
yes, they have always been union bustin yuppy finks. They probably only went after nixon because he stepped on the toes of the blue bloods in the republican party. The lead investigative reporter in that event was actually a major republican.
Given that they (for the most part) are little more than propaganda arms of the insular and condescending Beltway corporate elitists who proudly boast about their inherent supremacy, their death could not come a day too soon. Good bye and good riddance, I won’t miss them. They have become a miserable parody of themselves with their lack of integrity and slavish addiction to the whims of their corporate overlords.
Looking by the trend I am guessing the same editors will be full of praise for the 8-figure payout recent HP CEO got for doing something obviously wrong with an employee and will cite it as a model example of fair compensation which rest of the country has to emulate regarding its CEOs. Looks like WaPo is worse than an infomercial which we know right away is an infomercial and is at-least honest regarding its funding source and the product it is trying to sell.
Indeed, that’s what the MOTU want and like: squeeze as much work out of the peons, forcing them to work in unsafe toxic work environments, so that the serfs will die asap.
Palin’s “death panels for granny” was quite disingenuous and quite the lie. It’s her backers and handlers who truly want to institute early death for seniors; it’s much cheaper that way. That’ why they want to force people to retire later: they HOPE that the proles will die on the factory line.
Try to rent and watch Paul Schrader’s film “Blue Collar” with Harvey Keitel.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Collar_(film)
Eye-opening, and then can be “chased” with Michael Moore’s “Roger & Me.”
The class war has been in place from the beginning of this nation, but too many citizens cling to the very outdated notion that we’re all still pioneers and cowboys out on the “wild frontier” allegedly with all these “options” and the ability to make tons of money if only we “work hard enough” and are “rugged individuals.” It’s so far from the truth as to be laughable, but many fools out there cling to these glamorized, romantic notions – much propounded by movie flack & fake Zombie Reagan – along with their guns ‘n ammo.
For a better take on what it was really like in the “olden days,” rent & watch Clint Eastwood in “Pale Rider,” which is actually a pretty accurate depiction of the class war during the CA gold rush. *Some* unscrupulous types made a ton of $$$ during the gold rush; the rest were peons or slaves (the Chinese) who got trampled under.
Not much has changed, imo.
Wasn’t Carly also at HP? She made out well, also…taking care of one’s own. I recall few details, but hints were that some of her actions may have been illegal…not pretty but she certainly got a lovely parachute.
Just heard this am re. the latest mine disaster with the folks still underground: company claiming they will not be able to pay the miners. Wonder what other kind of property they own?
I think they realize that fully, but they aren’t talking about it bc they want us – the credulous rubes in what remains of the middle class – to continue investing in securities. So they don’t talk about the lack of movement in stock prices.
Frankly, stock prices are like housing prices in some ways (disclaimer: I’m almost totally ignorant about economics, don’t own property, although I own some securities, I’m no expert). Both became, I believe, wildly inflated and over-valued, but all at the time when our “esteemed leaders” – both in business and politics – were cheering on all citizens to buy, buy, buy…. while at the same time, off-shoring jobs, whole industries, nearly all manufacturing, etc, to mostly third world countries.
It would be a real joke, except for the deadly serious affect on the lives of “average citizens.”
ACK!!
Don’t get me started on Carly Fiorina!! Gah: Fiorina is classic case numero uno (but not the only one by long shot) of corporate welfare entitlement queen on steriods.
After running Lucent into the ground, someone on the “old boys network” kicked Carly upstairs to HP, where she literally ran HP into the ground. Dave Hewlett & Bill Packard were pretty unassuming men, who lived frugally and ran the company frugally, never overspending in flashy ways.
Once Queen Carly arrived, it was all: buy me a LearJet, I need an onsite beautician, I’m flying hither and thither to all of these hot shot conferences, gimme gimme gimme. The employees loathed her because of her arogance and disdain for them, highlighted, of course, when Queen Carly sent over 3000 jobs to the third world.
When she finally ran HP into the ground bc of her complete incompetence, various Hewlett & Packard family members got together and kicked her out. Of course, as a shareholder I had to pay to fire her with a big fat buyout of $millions. HP stock plummetted, and it’s only recently that it’s climbed out of the basement (and now it’s gone back down again after BUYING off that guy that they fired for sexual harrassment). AGGRAVATING.
Yet conservatives in CA constantly sing the praises of Fiorina for her purported excellent business expertise. I often wonder what universe these fools live in, or if, for them, Fiorina has proven her “chops” by ripping off everyone in sight and walking away with millions. It has certainly worked that way for Palin, too.
Go figure. I am so ticked off about Fiorina because I am truly fiscally conservative.
Well that figures, doesn’t it? No doubt the owners are rolling in clover and could give a sh*t about the miners, I’m sure. They’re all sociopaths.
You should make a Jerry Brown ad…you tell the story so well. That claim for business competence is clearly nuts. I had written last night I had heard Hannity making that his claim on behalf of Romney….all this business experience. Right, like W.
Thanks for the tip on the Paul Schrader film.
You might be thinking of Ben Hamper and his book, Rivethead. Hamper wrote about GM as it existed in the 1960s and 1970s; it changed a lot over the course of the next 30 years, but the physical demands of labor still could take their toll even though technology improved the environment. When Hamper wrote about working in the auto industry, it was very dangerous. I worked as an engineering student in a plant in the late 70s and remember being freaked out nearly every day I had to go out on the plant floor — it’s a wonder every worker didn’t go home injured every month.
Thanks…just to think of the stress of all of that. There was a recent piece in Parade magazine about a daughter who went to visit (iirc) and began to understand why her dad never wanted them to know where he worked///what it was like. How sad.
PBGC is one of many government agencies/functions the rich want abolished because it does not benefit them “enough”.
That darn $4500 per month payout limit does not cover restaurant tips
I can understand that; many people work in environments one can only liken to sausage-making. We love the product but don’t want to see it made.
What amazes me is that in spite of the magnificent work Discovery Channel’s Mike Rowe has done to show what dirty jobs are like and how necessary they are to our everyday lives, that WaPo’s editors and journos can still be so dismissive.
But they have help hiding the truth. I’ve tried for two years now to work on video documenting autoworker’s jobs. The biggest barrier is the auto and parts manufacturing companies; they don’t want any video taken because it will disclose proprietary information.
I just want to say to them, “Look, everybody in the industry including your vendors knows what you do and how you do it. It’s not a secret. Only your demands of workers is secret.”
[edit: btw, I want to recommend a video of Mike Rowe speaking at TED. What he says about our denigration of work is remarkable.]
Washington Post plus Fiscal Times plus Pete Peterson equals elite managed media.
Is it the bonafide conservatives of the likes of Pres. Teddy Roosevelt or Pres. Eisenhower or the Paid MSM Media singing the praises saying conservatives are saying it. After HCR bill I have gotten careful reading MSM articles and most of the times for crappy illogical ones I do not find any names just some baseless conservatives or progressives. It is a subtle sophistry at work in writing articles implying something which is not true and stating the opposite as true.
MSM Media is supposed to be a watch dog but looks like it has become a Guard Dog for the status quo of gross incompetence, greed and unethical actions. Now if we want to read some hard hitting true journalism one has to turn to Rolling Stones of all the places, FDL of course and HP sometimes
Absolutely. If she’s “smart enough” to get rich, they feel she must be doing everything right.
Yes, that’s it!
Thank you very much for that info.
going to look for that book.
just got it from the library, rivethead:
From a review:
thanks again.
Thank you for that- he is delightful.
Worse.
The instigators of MOCKINGBIRD were Frank Wisner, Allan Dulles, Richard Helms and Philip Graham. Graham was the husband of Katherine Graham, today’s publisher of the Washington Post. In fact, it was the Post’s ties to the CIA that allowed it to grow so quickly after the war, both in readership and influence. (8)
MOCKINGBIRD was extraordinarily successful. In no time, the agency had recruited at least 25 media organizations to disseminate CIA propaganda. At least 400 journalists would eventually join the CIA payroll, according to the CIA’s testimony before a stunned Church Committee in 1975. (The committee felt the true number was considerably higher.) The names of those recruited reads like a Who’s Who of journalism:
• Philip and Katharine Graham (Publishers, Washington Post)
• William Paley (President, CBS)
• Henry Luce (Publisher, Time and Life magazine)
• Arthur Hays Sulzberger (Publisher, N.Y. Times)
• Jerry O’Leary (Washington Star)
• Hal Hendrix (Pulitzer Prize winner, Miami News)
• Barry Bingham Sr., (Louisville Courier-Journal)
• James Copley (Copley News Services)
• Joseph Harrison (Editor, Christian Science Monitor)
• C.D. Jackson (Fortune)
• Walter Pincus (Reporter, Washington Post)
• ABC
• NBC
• Associated Press
• United Press International
• Reuters
• Hearst Newspapers
• Scripps-Howard
• Newsweek magazine
• Mutual Broadcasting System
• Miami Herald
• Old Saturday Evening Post
• New York Herald-Tribune
Perhaps no newspaper is more important to the CIA than the Washington Post, one of the nation’s most right-wing dailies. Its location in the nation’s capitol enables the paper to maintain valuable personal contacts with leading intelligence, political and business figures. Unlike other newspapers, the Post operates its own bureaus around the world, rather than relying on AP wire services. Owner Philip Graham was a military intelligence officer in World War II, and later became close friends with CIA figures like Frank Wisner, Allen Dulles, Desmond FitzGerald and Richard Helms. He inherited the Post by marrying Katherine Graham, whose father owned it.
After Philip’s suicide in 1963, Katharine Graham took over the Post. Seduced by her husband’s world of government and espionage, she expanded her newspaper’s relationship with the CIA. In a 1988 speech before CIA officials at Langley, Virginia, she stated:
We live in a dirty and dangerous world. There are some things that the general public does not need to know and shouldn’t. I believe democracy flourishes when the government can take legitimate steps to keep its secrets and when the press can decide whether to print what it knows.
This quote has since become a classic among CIA critics for its belittlement of democracy and its admission that there is a political agenda behind the Post’s headlines.
written by ex-mil intel Steve Kangas (RIP)
Katherine is dead….
Please note that the 4500 is a MAXIMUM, not a Minimum. I have a worked as an engineer for 25 years for GM/Delphi. Prior to the takeover, I could have retired at age 55 with a pension of $3500/month which would drop to 2600/month at age 62 when SS kicked in. Now if I retire at 55 I will get $1160/month. This is NOWHERE near the $4500/month, and is a cut of 66%.
If I had worked to age 65, I would have got $4460/month. But now I will get $2850/month, which is a loss of 30%. There aren’t too many places to live on $2850/month, which has to pay for rent, health care, and utilities.
I am fortunate in that I can still save and plan. But I know many people that retired at $3500/month with health care coverage, and within 2 months were trying to pay for their own health care on a $1200/month pension. They didn’t have an option to change their plans.