You are browsing the archive for Citizens United.

Imperial Philanthropy: Using Education Reform to Buy the Earth and Sky

11:23 am in Uncategorized by Doug Martin

Christel House Donors: Dell’s Official Flckr Page

(The following was first posted on B-Town Errant, Bloomington, Indiana:)

B-Town Errant Editor’s note: Doug Martin’s work supplies a kind of corrective to the simple “top-line” story and understanding of the education reform movement.  It can be understood to be “about” management and assessment to enforce a worldview where production is only quantifiable and quality must ape the measurements of assessment; and that’s the kindest way to phrase it.  But what is underneath it is a true “bottom-line” approach to the world.  The funders, the think tanks, the politicians, the investors, are all working towards the goal of imperial expansion. The best and most efficient way to assert your worldview is to own the world you wish to view.  Many of the recent scandals with corporate charter school organizations revolve around real estate manipulations.  Corporate Charters buy up old school buildings and install a kind of “puppet education” while they extort communities for rent payments.  When the puppet fails and the malfeasance is uncovered, the puppet takes the heat and the owners sit on the paper, blameless.  This is the US of A writ small.  This is foreign policy brought into your state and local governments.  Welcome to your own slice of the banana republic that is America.  Of course, as a resident and citizen of Indiana Mr. Martin focuses on the corruption endemic here, but pay attention.  All the names are the same and they are as entrenched in national politics as they are in state politics.  We are being eaten alive on all fronts.  D. Storm offers further examples of the “reach” of the imperialist and philanthropic class in italics.


As an employee of the corporate school reformers, Indiana’s Tony Bennett is drowning in new campaign funding. Out of the hundreds of donors to Bennett since he first surfaced in 2008, only a handful cannot be traced to the corporate school reform movement. To fully elaborate on all the anti-public education people and front groups the supt. has behind him would literally take months of work.  Thus, I have listed here a few new Bennett donors to boycott and be outraged with.

NOTE: The in-text links over the dollar amounts below open to PDFs.


If you’re looking for a public-friendly supt. of public education, steer clear of Angie’s List and its corporate “word-of-mouth wisdom.” The corporation’s co-founder and CEO, William S. Oesterle has given Tony Bennett one of his largest donations to date. A former partner of the venture capital firm, CID Equity Partners, Oesterle helped manage Mitch Daniels’ 2004 campaign. In the 1980s, he led the right-wing Hudson Institute, an Indy-based pseudo-research group closely tied with ALEC and funded by the anti-worker Koch brothers.

As Martin has noted time and again, these Privateers are all connected and all have a “vision” for dominating PROPERTY.  Oesterle is basically buying up the city as it becomes available via Daniels’ and the Indy Mayor Ballard’s “economic development” plans.  For example, earlier this year the IBJ reported on this, “City to give Angie’s List $4.6M to buy properties for expansion.”

Money for real estate acquisition is a major component of the $7.1 million in incentives the city of Indianapolis offered Angie’s List Inc. for expanding its headquarters campus to accommodate 500 more employees….

The city will also direct $1.5 million of its “Rebuild Indy” funds toward neighborhood and infrastructure improvements. Oesterle said a top candidate for upgrades is Market Street east of downtown.

Finally, the city will direct $1 million in federal tax credits toward Angie’s List. The tax credits would be applied to the newly acquired real estate, said Melissa Todd, vice president of operations at Develop Indy, the city’s economic development arm.

Angie’s List is still working on its master plan, but Oesterle said the company will consider building a parking garage and at least one office building. He said he’s looking to fill in “open spots” on Market Street and Washington Street.

Buying the Last Chance Towing property was a key piece of the puzzle, and the contract was struck late Friday, Gigerich said.

Angie’s List also will be eligible for as much as $7 million in tax credits from the Indiana Economic Development Corp., based on its plans to hire 500 people.

One commenter to the story offered some history (you know, that thing that’s supposed to instruct us on what to expect of the future when we repeat certain acts…):

It Must Be Groundhog Day…Again
> Deja VuAugust 16, 2011 5:31 PM

0/30/08 Angies List Adding 400 Jobs, Investing Millions Into Redevelopment 1/29/09 Angies List Laying Off 90 Employees, Triming Costs 6/12/07 Angie’s List Plans Expansion to U.S. Cities, Europe 11/09/07 Angie’s List Fires 38 Employees Did they collected the public incentives on this deal without creating new jobs and making the promised private investments?

Education reform is a good “story” but is proving to be only that, a story told by the owners in order to manipulate communities into agreeing with their “imperial” goals of purchasing the ground we all walk on.  As the law continues to create more and more “precedent” to bolster the power of the property owner, we find ourselves in the hands of fewer and fewer actual owners wielding tremendous influence, politically and legally.


This Betsy DeVos outfit changed its name to American Federation for Children after the old front group got busted breaking laws in Ohio. Kevin Chavous, a former Hoosier and now a leader of the Black Alliance for Educational Options, sits on its board of directors. Besides Chavous, AFC includes Pennsylvania hedge fund manager Joel Greenberg, hedge funder and Democrats for Education Reform’s Boykin Curry, Carrie Walton Penner of the Walmart family, and Florida corporate school reform funder, John F. Kirtley.

Last year, the AFC’s  Indiana-registered PAC funneled millions of Walton Family and DeVos money into Indiana and six other states using the Terre Haute office mailbox address of right-winger lawyer James Bopp, Jr., most despised for his work with the Supreme Court’s Citizens United case.

However you view the law and our apparently extremely flexible constitution you must find it difficult to imagine that the idea that money is speech is a “just” one.  The “Citizens United” ruling wherein corporations were affirmed to be “people” and where “money” was affirmed as speech effectively removed the barriers to the outright purchase of, well, everything.  Not only are elections and representation commodified but really all things became objects to be traded in the US of Hedge Funds.  It is massively heartening to discover that at least one state sees the error of this.  The Montana Supreme Court has said NO, NOT HERE, to the “Citizens United” Way.  Some detail on the Montana case is offered in this report from the Billings Gazette, “Supreme Court upholds state ban on corporation spending.”

The Montana Supreme Court on Friday overturned a lower court’s ruling and reinstated the state’s century-old ban on direct spending by corporations for or against political candidates.

The justices ruled 5-2 in favor of the state attorney general’s office and commissioner of political practices to uphold the initiative passed by Montana voters in 1912….

McGrath’s majority opinion is replete with references from books by Montana historians discussing successful efforts by the Copper Kings in Butte in the late 19th and early 20th century to control the state by influencing legislative and judicial decisions through bribes and applying political pressure on at least one governor.

“This naked corporate manipulation of the very government (governor and Legislature) of the state ultimately resulted in populist reforms that are still part of Montana law,” McGrath wrote. “In 1906 the people voted to amend the state Constitution to allow for voter initiatives.”

Rolling Stone’s Matt Taibbi offers his usual intelligent response on these issues in an interview on Current TV.


Co-founder, in 1974, of Resort Condominiums International (RCI), DeHaan runs a charter school in Indiana and several in other countries. She is also a member of the American Diploma Project, sponsored by the business roundtable/governors reform group, Achieve, Inc. One of Bennett’s earliest funders, DaHaan also sits on Mitch Daniels’ Bill Gates-supported Education Roundtable.

The depth of influence on US education via Achieve and ADP, which is one of four “standards” by which states measure “success” in education, would be hard to overestimate.  Christel Dehaan might simply be perceived as an example of what I offered above: the best way to promulgate your worldview is to own the world.  Dehaan actually is very active in her “philanthropy”–she’s established 5 schools on 4 continents–and her foundation is pledged to “breaking the cycle of poverty.”  Maybe it’s just me, but this seems a bit of a disconnect when the very practices one employs in order to own the largest timeshare vacation exchange network in the world.  Dehaan sold off RCI in 1996.  That’s 22 years of wealth accumulation.  What to do next?  Establish my own version of morality on the world!

Ah, Rich, white woman, we love you!

Of further interest is that the “democrat”, Mary Sullivan, who just proposed a ridiculous bill to create a “friendly” assessment for schools (way to reach for the lunatic in “competition” parameters!) has also received healthy contributions from Christel Dehaan.  But Republicans are her most prominent investment, besides the poor children “of color” around the world.  But you likely know my take on this by now.  Christel Dehaan is “seeding” her future, her worldview, by “training” children in impoverished areas to perform a proper role for the global ownership class.  I mean who else reads this kind of publication, “The Resort Trades“?

Immediately, DeHaan was asked, why not retire and live the dream-life? Why work long hours, fund all of your organization’s administrative costs personally and expend such a great deal of energy? Besides, breaking the cycle of poverty seems so overwhelming; what difference can one person make?
She answered with a smile, “I know that I could be sitting on a yacht somewhere in the Mediterranean, sipping champagne. But, I’ve been given this marvelous opportunity to make a difference. I think it’s possible to help break the cycle of poverty throughout the world, one child at a time, and I feel compelled to do all I can.”

Today, Christel House has been responsible for changing the lives of more than 2,700 impoverished children around the globe at five learning centers, including Mexico, India, South Africa, Venezuela and Indianapolis.

And Indianapolis…hmmm.  At any rate, I wonder if they serve Christel House Coffee in Indy somewhere?

Perhaps we can also ponder the relationship between global travel for the obscenely wealthy and their “charitable” impulses.  Anyway, I’m inclined to view this as simply another kind of Western invasion as aggressive in its own way as a military invasion.  A charitable intervention seems far more insidious to me.  Here’s one way to think of it (and other consequences) in this paper by Ole Kamuaro, “ECOTOURISM: SUICIDE OR DEVELOPMENT?”

The Masai from Loita Hills, some 320 km southwest of Nairobi, have been fighting a fierce battle to prevent an indigenous forest, traditionally known as Naimina-Enkiyio or the Forest of the Lost Child, from being turned into another ecotourism destination. Having experienced the devastating effects of tourism at the nearby Masai Mara National Park, they are determined to preserve their sacred forest, which for generations has been under their management and control and carefully kept as a sacred place for worship and communion with Masai deities.

Though largely pastoralists, the Masai here are also small-scale subsistence agriculturists who have used resources in a sustainable manner. As a result, the forest is still dense and rich in biodiversity, with abundant wild flora and fauna, plants which serve as herbal medicines, sufficient water sources, and pastures on which to raise healthy cattle.

Undoubtedly, their spiritual and material way of life will degenerate rapidly if tourism intrudes. As one local person in the neighbouring Masai Mara reserve said, “Tourism has been allowed to develop with virtually no controls. Too many lodges have been built, too much firewood is being used and no limits are being placed on tourist vehicles. They regularly drive off-track and harass the wildlife. Their vehicle tracks crisscross the entire Masai Mara. Inevitably the bush is becoming eroded and degraded.”

Of course, all of this is for sale, right?

DEAN WHITE: $50,000

Now a billionaire, White inherited his father’s mega-billboard business. For fun, White, now in his 80s, dabbles in real estate deals and develops hotels. White recently gave Mike Pence $100,000 in donations to run for Indiana governor. White is listed #281 on Forbes’ list of America’s richest.

Nothing really needs to be said here, does it?  Pence and Billionaires for Billboard America?

MIKE WEAVER: $10,000

Weaver weaves real estate deals for the Vearus Group.

There’s a lot of money to be made from property deals in the charter school industry, so Bennett’s real estate funders are worth keeping a close eye on.

Tony Bennett is doing the dirty work of arranging for more government handouts to the freeloading top 1 percent.  It’s time to let the public know, while there’s still a public left.

As Doug Martin shows us again, Indiana is full of “imperial” adventure; it’s as real here as it is in Eco-Poverty Magnate Christel Dehaan’s international training compounds.

Murdoch’s Wireless Gen. and EdisonLearning Donated Money to Tony Bennett

11:58 am in Uncategorized by Doug Martin

Tony Bennett, Superintendent of the Indiana Office of Public Instruction

Tony Bennett, Superintendent of the Indiana Office of Public Instruction, photo by House Committee on Education and the Workforce Democrats

As the Indiana State Board of Education decides to hand over Indiana’s so-called “failing” schools to EdisonLearning, Charter Schools USA, and Rupert Murdoch’s Wireless Generation today, it is important to note that both Edison and Wireless Generation have donated to Education Reform Idol Indiana supt. of public instruction Tony Bennett’s campaign chest. In fact, Wireless Gen. even lavished money on Mitch Daniels and Indiana Republicans, the month before Murdoch acquired the company.

Freshly clabbered by public school advocates like Leonie Haimson, Diane Ravitch, and others in New York City, and thus losing out on a $27 million contract with the schools, Wireless Gen. will now “partner” with the New Teacher Project (whose CEO is Ariela Rozman, who also sits on the board of Indy’s corporate reform group, the Mind Trust) to run Washington Community High School in Indianapolis. EdisonLearning is taking over a school in Gary.

For 2009-2010, Bennett’s donors are both local and national corporate school reform players, and many of them also funded him in 2008:

EdisonLearning: $2,000

Wireless Generation: $1,000

James Bopp, Jr.:  $250 (corporate lawyer of Citizens United; used his Terre Haute law firm’s mailbox to funnel millions of Amway-Besty DeVos’ American Federation for Children money to “school reformers” in Indiana and throughout the country)

Bopp Coleson, and Bostrom: $2,500 (law firm of James Bopp, Jr.)

Therese Rooney: $10,000 (daughter of J. Patrick Rooney, the man who started the Educational CHOICE Charitable Trust and was a national leader in the voucher movement)

Patrick Byrne: $5,000 (

Luke Messer:  $175 (School Choice Indiana)

Heather Neal: $150 (works at IDOE) Read the rest of this entry →

Letter to the Indiana Chamber of Commerce: Hoosiers Say No to Charter School Scammers

12:36 pm in Uncategorized by Doug Martin

Dear Kevin Brinegar, CEO, Indiana Chamber of Commerce,

Not content that Citizens United Terre Haute lawyer James Bopp, Jr. and your lobbying against the Disclose Act made it legal for undisclosed corporations to endlessly fund the destruction of democracy, the Indiana Chamber of Commerce now has the nerve to call Vigo County School Corporation Superintendent Dan Tanoos a “bully” for exposing the charter school scam. Such hypocrisy sounds like a typical case of what psychologists call “projection” on your part. Isn’t being a “bully” a prerequisite for joining your brotherhood?

To anyone looking, last year’s award the Indiana Chamber of Commerce bestowed upon Tony Bennett, Indiana Superintendent of Public Education, sums up your quest to bulldoze education out of this state.  As an opportunist like his wife, Bennett selected two charter school cronies to his educational transition team in 2008: Mr. Derek Redelman, the Indiana Chamber of Commerce’s own pseudo-researcher who founded the Indiana Charter Schools Association and worked at the Koch-funded Hudson Institute; and Don Willis, the Mitch Daniels, Jr.-donor formerly of Imagine Charter Schools, who broke Indiana’s Open Door Law in Fort Wayne.

Last I heard, Imagine Schools illegally operates as both a for-profit and non-profit organization (if you could update me on this or clarify Imagine’s IRS status, it would be highly appreciated, since the government will not comment), and Dennis Bakke, their CEO, has a long history with your governor going back to 2001 with the AES-Indianapolis Power and Light Company merger, where IPALCO stockholders and workers lost millions, including their 401k packages, after Daniels, Jr. dumped his stocks

Sadly, you and Mr. Bennett wish to use “Play Dough Economics” to teach these same psychopathic tricks to Indiana kindergarteners, so they, too, can grow up to steal the pensions of their former teachers just like big Wall Street criminals do. The governor is your perfect orbitofrontal lobe damaged hero, in this regard; as recent neuroscience suggests, there is a fine line between the Jeffrey Dahmers of the world and the Republican leadership.

A policy brief to you and your MBA-friends-turned-fake-educators: we do not need a sociopathic society where schools become profit-making factories and kids gobble and throw up I-STEP test answers like Big Macs and boloney. And honestly, the Indiana Chamber of Commerce has no right to tell teachers they should work as slave laborers in charter schools run by the rich who use rental schemes to rake in millions of taxpayers’ money.

After apologizing to Superintendent Tanoos and those working daily with the fine children of Vigo County, Indiana, you should pass along to Mr. Bopp, Jr. (and Counterfeit Christian, Dennis Bakke) the words Eugene V. Debs spoke from his prison cell to a reporter in 1919 on the real meaning of Christ:

            I told my friends of the cloth that I did not believe Christ was meek and lowly but a real living, vital agitator who went into the temple with a lash and a krout and whipped the oppressors of the poor, routed them out of the doors and spilled their blood and got silver on the floor. He told the robbed and misruled and exploited and driven people to disobey their plunderers, he denounced the profiteers, and it was for this that they nailed his quivering body to the cross and spiked it to the gates of Jerusalem, not because he told them to love one another.

I’m waiting for Redelman and your Republican friends to include that quotation in your private school and charter school curriculum.

 Dr. Doug Martin