Max Blumenthal and Joseph Dana created a riveting video in Jerusalem, on the eve of President Obama’s Cairo University address. It showed hatred toward our president by young Israelis and Americans. It was seen over 500,000 times. Now it has been removed from YouTube
Max produced a number of videos while in Israel and the Occupied West Bank, in May and early June. They document several aspects of the occupation, current Israeli internal politics, and give glimpses of the ongoing Jewish identity crisis there, particularly among young people. Max has interviewed people on farms, in the military, in politics, and on the street. He ended one video report from within the posh Milken-Dobson exercise club, in a Jewish settlement on stolen Palestinian land.
I’ve been following Max’s career closely, since he spent a week or so with us in Wasilla last September, as he investigated Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin’s ties to extremist groups. He’s maturing rapidly as a journalist, and articles from his trip to Israel and the West Bank, covered by Max’s own blog, The Daily Beast, Huffington Post and Mondoweiss, are quite riveting.
His June 5th video, Feeling the Hate in Jerusalem, was posted at Mondoweiss and Huffington Post. Then at YouTube, quickly followed by hundreds – if not thousands – of blogs around the world. Even NPR‘s Tampa affiliate interviewed Dana.
Huffington Post removed it on the next day. Max defended his video in a post called, Censored by Huffington Post and Imprisoned By the Past: Why I Made Feeling the Hate in Jerusalem. Blumenthal’s defense of his work is compelling:
The criticism of my video raised an interesting journalistic issue: Is reporting any less credible when interview subjects are drinking alcohol? Of course not. Journalists interview people at bars all the time, especially in broadcast packages. Beer does not, to my knowledge, contain a special drug that immediately infects drinkers with white supremacist sentiments, violent rhetoric, and anti-democratic tendencies. I get drunk as much as any social drinker and I have never called for “white power” or declared, “fuck the niggers!” as one of my interviewees did. No amount of alcohol could make me express opinions that were not authentically mine. If anything, alcohol is a crude form of truth serum that lubricates the release of closely held opinions and encourages confessional talk.
The notion that the racist diatribes in my video emerged spontaneously from a beery void is a delusion, but for some, it is a necessary one. It allows them to erect a psychological barrier against acknowledging the painful consequences of prolonged Zionist indoctrination. And it enables them to dismiss the disturbing spectacle of young Jews behaving like fascist soccer hooligans in the heart of the capitol of Israel and the spiritual home of the Jewish people.
Yesterday, YouTube pulled Max’s video for "terms of use violation." At the same time, YouTube is going through a lot of internal debate on how to deal with the large amount of material now coming in from Iran.
Jewish Voice for Peace is starting a petition effort on Max’s behalf. Here’s from their post that asks you to take action:
Blumenthal and Dana took a video camera to downtown Jerusalem and asked kids on the street – mainly Americans in Jerusalem over the summer – how they felt about Obama. The answers they heard: mainly hardcore racism enhanced by expletives, homophobia, Islamophobia, Arab hatred, and a lot of ignorance. Youtube also just took down another video of a Palestinian forced to slap himself by the Israeli Border Police. A pattern is emerging. We know this kind of hatred and extremism is a real phenomenon in our Jewish communities. It needs to be unearthed and looked at with the same seriousness we want to see in any community confronting its own extremists. As we seek real peace in the Middle East, the stakes couldn’t be higher.
Write to YouTube and ask them to put this video back up.
If you go to this link, you can watch the censored video, and quickly show your support for Max Blumenthal and Joseph Dana – and for the First Amendment.



18 Comments







Glad you did this piece, ET.
Rec’d
ET !
Excellent and Rec’d !
Thanks for bringing this to our attention, ET. I’d love to see more “mainstream” peace-oriented Jewish groups, like J Street and the Tikkun community join in the effort as well. I will contact YouTube.
Thanks, ET.. deserving of attention and our help.
Very distrubing!
I went to the censored video link, and the site took over my computer.
Twice.
Only way out is to kill your browser, if you have something like Windows Task Manager running (for all users), or you’ll have to power off your computer.
gannonguckert,
I looked to see if I can get back into edit to check and/or remove the link. I can’t. Thanks for the warning.
Right now, I’ve opened the link on Safari in another window. Vimeo is slow and sensitive. What I do is start the clip, then immediately stop it. Then I wait a long time, as the vimeo loads.
It works on my computer.
Vimeo sucks, except it is often better in HiDef than YouTube ever is.
Link disabled.
LM,
Maybe this helps prove why helping Max is so important.
I got the link to work. It is carried by an organization that might be being overwhelmed by one thing or another.
That was my presumption, and I am sorry. Provide the link again and I will restore it.
Thanks.
This link restored in original post.
I didn’t request the link be removed.
Before it was removed, Ms ET signed up for Max, using the link. Here’s the reply she got from JVfP:
I signed the petition on the JVP web site but was a little annoyed that the petition didn’t allow me to edit their message and put it in my own words. Tried to find an appropriate link on the YouTube web site itself for feedback of this sort, but the site doesn’t appear to have a general email comment address, at least that I could find. Plenty of mechanisms to report abuse but not so much to dispute complaints by others.
the video with the obnoxious idiotic drunks calling everyone faggots ??
no big loss imo ..
Here is another version of Max’s Video at YouTube. I have no idea whether the YouTube administrators know it is there. It has only been viewed 2,951 times, and has been up since June 10th.
Also, the blog mondoweiss is now running another diary on a request from Naomi Klein, Noam Chomsky and Neve Gordon, regarding the jailing of an Israeli peace activist, who attempted to stop the demolition of Bedouin shacks.
In vino veritas. Ugly, but true.
Thanks Edward.