As the oil hits the reefs, offshore bars and beaches of the Gulf of Mexico, are we faced with another Exxon Valdez catastrophe? Yes. Can we learn from that disaster in how this ongoing tragedy is documented by artists? Absolutely. Here is some of how we can do it. You may add your suggestions too.
I. In 1989, the internet did exist, but not many people had access. Graphic interfaces that led to the many free web browsers were limited, and didn’t do much. Few people had cell phones. The cable news paradigm as we now know it didn’t yet exist. CNN was there on Prince William Sound, but not in a big way. National and Anchorage newspapers were much healthier then than now, and made earnest efforts to cover events. The same was true of NPR and Alaska’s outstanding Alaska Public Radio Network. The influence of AM talk radio was much more primitive than it now is. Blogging was pretty much limited to what were called "newsgroups."
In 1989, when local Alaskans and interested independent journalists descended upon the scene, they were limited in methods they could use to document the ongoing tragedy by technology, communication and basic logistics. The technology was bulky, and mostly analog. The communication grid at the sites of the spill was limited to VHF and Single Sideband maritime and aviation-based radio. The logistics of getting there in late winter, miles from the ports of Valdez, Cordova, Whittier or Seward, was convoluted, and most charter boats and planes were already chartered or overbooked for the cleanup by the third day of the spill.
Environmentalists were mostly limited to helping in efforts to save individual animals once the animals had been brought to Valdez, Seward or Anchorage. There was no real time coverage of the growth of the spill by any parties outside of the mainstream. From the beginning of the spill, Exxon and the USCG attempted to attenuate and spin how the outgoing flow of information was handled. Over half the people Exxon flew into Alaska or Valdez on the morning of the spill were attorneys.
From the moment of the Exxon Valdez oil spill, I was involved with artists who were or are also ecologically motivated. In the ensuing years, I’ve worked with several artists who documented aspects of the EVOS (Exxon Valdez oil spill) through visual, graphic and audio art. In the early 1990s, I toured with bronze sculptor Peter Bevis, as we presented his compelling castings of victims of that and other spills. We called our presentation "Artists as Environmentalists." There have been tenth and twentieth anniversary gallery shows in Alaska that have looked back on this. The most recent, produced by Homer’s Bunnell Street Gallery, SPILL: Alaskan Artists Remember, toured several communities last year.
In this collaborative process, I’ve learned a few things that might help those who hope to create visceral, living art about all the dying that is beginning to occur. Here are some suggestions:
II. In covering the Gulf tragedy, artists should attempt to capture the essence of what this is – a massive wave of death. There will be many compelling stories of people who manage to deploy a boom or clean an oiled bird, or come up with an innovative idea that might actually have a beneficial local effect. Documenting these instances is a good thing, but try to present the small and heartening victories in a realistic overall context.
As often as possible, artists should try to partner with local ecologists and environmental activists, from the areas where damage is happening. Try to understand these people as individuals, and visibly show them physically performing their tasks.
Avoid contacts with national environmental organizations. They do not understand what motivates independent artists. If you don’t make cute watercolors or coffee mug logos for brochures, fundraisers or auction events, they don’t understand you. Nor do they want to.
Try to find venues that can help you live stream what you are documenting. Hopefully, viable nodes for dissemination of images and artistic impressions of this will develop over the coming weekend. When they do, spread the word, possibly steering artists and other documentarians toward those sites that are becoming most effective.
Seek out folk musicians, rappers, slam poets and other artists who have a following among the very young. Develop some new collaborative co-ops for the purpose of truthfully recording what is going down.
It is likely that the spill will hit Cuba. If you are or know an artist with Cuban connections, you might consider getting your travel permissions going right now, as it sometimes takes a while to get all the papers in order.
BP, the USCG and Homeland Security will all give dozens of dog-and-pony shows in communities either in the line of fire, or recently slimed. Attend these events, and record the impressions of locals who came to them, especially right after they’ve been fed the inevitable total line of crap, such as "we will make you whole again."
III. Please add any further suggestions you might have in the comments.
Artists can uniquely portray ecological catastrophe. They can partner with ecologists, environmentalists and community activists, to give perspective on what has happened that nobody else can.
Here’s a remembrance of animals, from the EVOS disaster.



46 Comments

I have places for artists to stay.
What organizations do we trust? Huffpo had a list but some turned out to be BP. WTF?
They do that.
On the morning of the EVOS, the Anchorage port captain for a tugboat company I had worked for called me after flying to Valdez and back. He told me that Exxon had flown in some people – probably from a company like Wackenhutt – that were dressed very Eddie Bauer, and were posing as environmentalists. Exxon was paying them to object on behalf of their facade organizations, to the use of dispersants. The reason – Exxon didn’t have enough to do what was considered to be “the job,” but wanted environmentalists blamed. Note that yesterday Limbaugh suggested environmentalists caused the fire on the rig, to help push cap & trade legislation in congress.
Thanks for what you are doing, Mary.
I’ve posted a version of this essay at my place that includes four pictures of Peter Bevis’ visceral bronzes, made of victims of previous oil spills.
Hey My bf is someone who cares a lot about the environment and hes a really good artist. He started on a 3 by 5 ft (something like that) acrylic painting that will be finished end of this week, before the BP spill occured. It has whales, dolphins, the world with a girl holding a world with a figure that says Oil Sucks with ocean behind it, really hard to explain but its modern and a lot of color, any suggestions on how to auction it off for a fund raiser or recognition for him and the cause let me know? He went to school for fine art and all of it has wild life in it.
Thanks for the great post, Edward. Because it’s so heartfelt and sincere…and direct.
I’ve read some of your comments, btw, on other threads. And all I can say is: what integrity.
I’m sending love vibes and “powerful resolve” vibes your way as well as to any and all who are in positions of implementing action-response.
Am focused/will continue to focus on the spiritual aspect, the quantum-world aspect, the holographic “reality” aspect, the consciousness aspect.
My “speciality.”
Outstanding.
Recommended.
The Sierra Club acts as if posting a picture of a flaming oil rig as part of their front page slide show is proof of their commitment to…
Recommended
Great post ET.. Hopefully there will be some/many photo journalist who will create a mosaic in pictures of the wildlife and environmental disaster in the gulf.
Drill Baby Drill… my ass we lose so much from such events…
Sometimes I wish I were an artist as opposed to a mere wordsmithy. I would fashion a contrast between a hurricane and an oil spill. One is a natural disaster that wreaks havoc upon man-made works, the other is a man-made disaster that wreaks havoc upon natural works.
The artistry would be derived from equal representation of tragedy, ala corporate media, and leaving the viewer to determine which is worse. I would think a mirror should be involved.
… their commitment to fundraising on the backs of the victims of environmental catastrophes you betcha!
Well, sort a-kind a. Critters and other living things take pretty big hits in hurricanes.
I am just heartsick about this catastrophe.
Were the workers who died union members? I understand the failsafe valve, intended to stop the flow of oil, failed. I understand other countries require a different mechanism, but our country makes these “failsafier” valves voluntary. I wonder how much the voluntary requirement cost in campaign contributions? When will we learn that these captains of industry cannot be allowed in traffic without serious adult supervision?
Artists? They don’t fit into the presentation profile of our website. We no longer do, you know, humanity.
Can we find some birds covered with oil? That always gets the waterworks (and checkbooks) going at our luncheons in Manhattan.
I thought about that too, and you are correct. The following season after a hurricane, the leaves of a tree are of tremendous size to make up for fewer leaves on the tree because the branches are stripped of twigs. The workaround on spilled petroleum products does not exist.
Yep. That is right. Plus, stupid oil spill cannot be forecast.
Artists should flock to the LA shore and document this in a way that will teach us all how to change our ways.
Who among us can vow to NOT DRIVE FOR ONE DAY A WEEK? Every week forever?
Or who among us can give up our car, our jet ski, our powerboat, our …you name it.
We are all hypocrites.
Me included.
We drive BP. Without us, there is no BP.
and because we are… the planet is dying.
sorry, maudlin is called for.
Awesome idea, ET…! *g*
There’s almost always an appropriate opera clip for real life situations, and there’s one for this situation too, in a broadly speaking way.
I’ve used this before specific to hurricane Katrina. There’s an opera by Puccini, Manon Lescaut named for the tragic heroine. After a whirlwind romance, in defiance of social norms, she dies tragically of exposure and neglect in the Louisiana estuaries.
One could think of the character in any number of voices; that of the sea, or the land, or a mother bird; the most evocative phrase is at the end, the small gap where solo, Manon sings “Non voglio morir!” [I don't want to die!]
Sola, perduta, abbandonnata [Alone, lost, abandoned]
A keeper.
This is a great link, ET.
We need to press the media, and model this ourselves; this tragedy is not an oil spill as at Valdez. It is a spilling: ongoing, continuous, unending, as yet unstoppable. The lying company whose spilling this is updates their ‘estimates’ of volume almost daily. And they have no solution for ending it.
So — we cannot continue, ourselves, to call this a spill. Nor must we allow the media to dismiss it as a spill. As awful as a spill would be, the much greater magnitude of this spilling must be conveyed in every mention.
(Thank you, ET, wonderful piece, recommended, Tweeted, and FaceBooked)
The performance is great, isn’t it? I just love Gheorghiu.
But more to the point, isn’t it a bit eerie that this specific piece of the opera is staged in some Louisiana estuary?
Much less Manon’s attitude; so scared, so ambivalent, so tragic.
l’ hora tomba invoco I invoke the hour of the tomb.
and
Non voglio morir! I don’t want to die!
Yes. And it’s not like Louisiana has seen tragedy or grief recently.
I wonder if the oil company stooges will spin this is ‘concentrated wealth’…
Haunting.
Everyone I talk with is just devastated by this spilling (h/t Teddy). It is unimaginable the reach and depth of the death and destruction. We will never be able to catalog it nor will there ever be compensation sufficient to encompass this disaster.
The idea that it could probably have been prevented, well, there is no putting that genie back into the lamp, so to speak.
I am sure there will be thousands of artworks made everywhere across the planet by artists who are “feeling” this horror.
You are right. We need to speak about this in current context.
They would just love the ‘spill’ to be a static thing.
Artists and I also wish the musicians would join in. Even I a dedicated lifetime environmentalist am overwhelmed with the realization of how close we are today to killing the planet forever. Simply doing some kabuki over adding a few alternative sources of energy to keep our lives unchanged will ensure its death. We must send the message that our whole life style must change along with our perception of the planet.This in the Gulf I believe is much more serious than the Valdez debacle
This at home and with images and music can go along way to expand the message that we can’t afford to lose many more large chunks of ecosystem. . I wish you well.
That’s really true, newt and Teddy. That the mass was moving is evident in all the press talk, but that it’s continuing to spill really isn’t.
Oy! So easy to be mesmerized, despite FDL and Seymour and ET’s efforts.
ET, this spill puts me in mind of Ricki Ott’s phenomenal book on the ExxonValdez oil spill, “Not One Drop”. (You hosted at FDL Book Salon.)
Someone that I know in Texas told me that one of Exxon’s first moves was to book up all the small planes in the Cordova region, with the result that when the media finally got up to Prince William Sound, it was hard for them to get in the air and get good photos. (I’m not sure how true this was.) I don’t know whether this is accurate, or merely urban legend.
I have no idea what the flying limitations are in the Gulf of Mexico at present, but it would not surprise me if BP wanted a ‘no flight zone’, or else had purchased all of the local small planes and pilots.
This disaster is on a scale beyond human comprehension; I was thinking earlier that it will be generations of damage.
This is interesting.
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2010/4/30/862414/-BP-Oil-Platform-Spill-Disaster-is-CHENEYS-Fault-UPDATED
OFG, tonight on the Ed Schultz program, he had a segment with an attorney for some local fisheries in the Gulf of Mexico region who said that Cheney made some regulations changes, perhaps as part of his Secret Energy Task Force.
If his claims are true, another $500,000 in safety equipment would have added another layer of prevention. But BP didn’t have to do it in the US (primarily from a rule change instigated by Cheney). They are required to have this extra safety layer in Norway. However, as a disclaimer on this comment, I’m no expert so can’t independently assess the accuracy of his claims.
IF, however, this man is correct then:
– what it says about SCOTUS allowing Cheney to keep the Energy Task Force documents secret is a national disgrace and an international scandal (er, am I repeating myself, since Cheney is involved…?)
– Cheney’s former oil-energy-pipeline company Halliburton evidently did work on this rig, which implicates that company also.
– perhaps the American public will have a chance to rethink whether zero regulations are actually cost-effective
– if we have regulators, they have to actually… regulate, rather than act like a bunch of captured tools.
We need to learn to live like poor people. Being poor is honorable. Waste not, save the planet.
We need to find out every subsidiary of B.P. and boycott them.
I believe that Seymour reported on this in one of the very first posts up at FDL about this disaster.
The cost of the damage is going to be a very large multiple of a half a mil. . .the audacity of BP and their ilk in taking this risk w/o safeguards of any kind is off the scale.
Incredible. And the lives of how many are in the balance, people, animals, plants, air, water, all the creatures that depend on this ecosystem, on and on.
Thank you.
The ExxonValdez occurred at vernal equinox; think of it as death in childbirth for millions of organisms.
This is spring in the Louisiana region, although I’m not familiar with the lifecycles and nesting and spawning patterns there. But it’s spring; life should be pulsing in those estuaries.
And our national energy plan is what, exactly…?
(I’m not blaming Obama; he’s catching up from years of disastrous ruin and oil companies running the government…)
Thanks for front-paging this diary. I was gone to a fundraiser, so missed the time when I might have reflected better on commenters.
I don’t know if you caught it, but BP has as a matter of policy cut back on maintenance and has endured quite the string of spills, explosions and problems.
Anyone remember the Alaskan oil line that BP had failed to clean with their “pigs?” Anyone remember the explosion in Texas City or whatever last year?
By the way, don’t disparage oil companies too heavily. At least oil works. Biofuels are getting greater use under Obama even though they are more polluting and less effective not to mention we trade scarce arable land for fuel. Wind power works less than 10% of the time on average.
We need sensible policies that are based in reality. Ethanol is a total loser yet Obama is seeking to increase our use of it. Carol Browner approved MTBE even though she knew it leached into water supplies under Clinton. That lady is just another DC Madam.
I am an Organic gardener by trade, I am not dismissive of protecting the environment, but oil is our most efficient fuel. BP had gutted their safeguards as the record shows, that can’t be tolerated.
Greg Palast raised an interesting point re BP in the first hour of the Shannyn Moore radio show Friday in Alaska. He maintains that BP, not Exxon, owns the failures of Alyeska (the company responsible for oil spill cleanup along the trans-Alaska pipeline and in Prince William Sound back in 1989) at the time of the EVOS. Palast is right that BP has a long record of expense cutting, as you’ve observed.
This post hoped to spur interest in getting artists wanting to document the most recent iteration of this kind of failure in touch with each other and so on.
Thank you for this post EdwardTeller. The history is important. You have touched on the long term impact in a few of your posts and comments. Have you ever written a longer history of the long term impact on the community and wildlife?
Coming on the heels of Katrina and the added issue of hurricane season making this worse, it might be helpful to know how we can help Gulf Coast families through this terrible tragic mess while they are still recovering from Katrina.
Thanks for the great post ET. Having been one of the very first on the EVOS, and knowing the area as well as i do, the thing that sticks in my head is the screaming silence i experienced. Not being an artist i wish i could have captured that. I would say to any artist get to know what it feels before it falls. This thing is another gaping wound in our beautiful body.
My wife and I were fortunate to spend a couple of weeks each year between 1984 and 1988 on parts of the Sound that were trashed in ’89 – the Knight Island archipelago, in particular. We’ll always remember how much vibrant life we witnessed there, especially in places like Ingot Cove in Upper Passage, which was totally slimed and still is. The silence is still there, and will be when my son is my own age.
And I just wonder what the oil spill will look like after it is hit with a hurricane.
It is an undersea oil gusher.
Maybe we should start with a poetry contest and then song writers could put whatever inspires them to music. I think everyone is sort of overwhelmed.
On the scale of the dust bowl?
What I am recommending is that artists actually experience the reality of the spill, either before or while they create their art.