Here is a short video released late Saturday by the U.S. Coast Guard, showing part of the helicopter rescue of crewmen from the drilling platform Kulluk. The rig has been imperiled by multiple simultaneous engine failures aboard the oceangoing tug Aiviq, which was towing the rig from Dutch Harbor, Alaska to Puget Sound, for modifications, repairs and winter berthing.
Shown in the video are the Kulluk – the round vessel with a tall central tower, the Nanuq – the long, slender vessel, and the Aiviq – the vessel with the helicopter platform over its bow. The tug Guardsman, not shown in the video, is plotted on MarineTraffic.com as being close by. All four vessels haven’t moved much since they grouped together yesterday morning. Rather than get close to the shore and seek shelter from the ongoing major winter storm, as they had planned yesterday, they have decided to put as many miles as possible between the rig and the rocks.
Here’s from an Alaska news report:
“It’s precautionary measure. They weren’t in any immediate danger,” Mosley said. “As this continued to unfold, they just wanted to mitigate any potential issues with that crew onboard.”
Coast Guard helicopters were also able to deliver a ton of engine parts and technicians to the Aiviq, and the ship’s crew had two of its four engines up and running by Saturday morning, Shell said.
What started as 20-foot seas and 40 mph wind built to 35-foot seas and gusts to more than 50 mph, the Coast Guard said.
The weather and the combined weight of the Kulluk and Aiviq were too much for the tugboat Guardsman, which was unable to stop the vessels from drifting. By 5:30 a.m. Saturday, its towline had also broken free, the Coast Guard said. Saturday morning, the Kulluk was about 27 miles from the Trinity Islands and drifting at a rate that would have had it hitting the islands in as little as 12 hours, Mosley told the Associated Press.
“We don’t want it to go aground,” he said. “When a vessel goes aground, it’s directly played upon by the waves hitting it and having it hit something solid.”
In what Shell spokesman Curtis Smith described as “cascading assets into the theater,” another Shell-contracted ship, the Nanuq, had been sent from Seward at the first sign of trouble. It arrived Saturday morning. The Aiviq soon had all four of its engines running, and with the Nanuq’s help, was towing the Kulluk farther out to sea to the southeast late Saturday, Smith said. The plan was to avoid more bad weather and the worst-case scenario that the vessels could again drift toward land, he said.
And here is the current marine forecast for Kodiak Island waters:
Storm Warning
COASTAL WATERS FORECAST FOR THE NORTHERN GULF OF ALASKA COAST UP TO 100 NM OUT INCLUDING KODIAK ISLAND AND COOK INLET. WIND FORECASTS REFLECT THE PREDOMINANT SPEED AND DIRECTION EXPECTED. SEA FORECASTS REPRESENT AN AVERAGE OF THE HIGHEST ONE-THIRD OF THE COMBINED WIND WAVE AND SWELL HEIGHT.
Synopsis…A 952 MB LOW 175 NM S OF KODIAK MOVES TO BRISTOL BAY MIDDAY SUNDAY AT 959 MB…THEN WEAKENS AS IT TRACKS ALONG THE SOUTHWEST COAST THROUGH MON MORNING. ANOTHER PACIFIC LOW TRACKS TO 480 NM S OF KODIAK AT 964 MB MON MORNING…THEN MOVES TO 120 NM SE OF CHIGNIK AT 962 MB LATE MON NIGHT.Today: SE wind 40 kt increasing to S 50 kt in the afternoon. Seas 21 ft building to 28 ft in the afternoon. Rain.
Tonight: S wind 45 kt diminishing to 30 kt after midnight. Seas 22 ft subsiding to 15 ft after midnight. Rain and snow.
Mon: SE wind 25 kt becoming E 45 kt in the afternoon. Seas 15 ft. Rain and snow.
Mon Night: SE wind 50 kt. Seas 26 ft.
Tue: S wind 50 kt. Seas 30 ft.
As you can see, today is rougher than yesterday (I published yesterday’s forecast in an earlier post). The seas will come down on Monday, but another storm will hit Tuesday, perhaps worse then the one they are enduring.
It appears the tugs and barge are on a course of 200 degrees, with speeds averaging about 1.8 knots, which would put them about 90 miles further from shore when Tuesday’s storm hits.
So far, nobody has been reported to have been injured or lost. Lets hope it remains that way.
So this is how Shell Oil rings out the year during which they hoped to start extracting oil from under the bottom of the Arctic Ocean.
Update – Sunday 2:00 pm: The so-called “Unified Command” held a press conference in Anchorage at 1:00 pm Alaska time today. I attended telephonically. The Unified Command is the U.S. Coast Guard, the Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation, Shell Alaska and Edison Chouest Offshore (owner of the drilling rig Kulluk). They are maintaining a “Joint Information Center” during the ongoing emergency. The Alaska DEC representative on the Joint Command, Steve Russell, described the Unified Command, saying how hard the State of AK worked, developing the “Unified command.”
I posted comments at this diary throughout the conference. Here’s my summary:
What I got out of this press conference was:
1). Aiviq and Kulluk walked into this storm blithely.
2). At least two people have been injured.
3). USCG does not want to talk about why their cutter left the scene early Saturday.
4). Shell is backing off from earlier descriptions of the multiple simultaneous engine failures on the Aiviq being caused by fuel contamination. No mention in the presser of the USCG offloading “900 pounds” worth of new fuel injectors onto drifting Aiviq for those engines Saturday. This may be more important than is readily apparent.
5). There is nobody aboard the drill rig.
Should Tuesday’s storm part the lines again, like Friday’s did, it will be extremely dangerous to get anyone back aboard. Pumps are on automatic, but to re-hook for a tow, winches would have to be manned on the rig. No wonder they are putting as many miles as possible between them and the rocky coast of Kodiak Island eh?



46 Comments

Shell Oil Alaska has just posted an update, as of 35 minutes ago:
and who will be footing the bill for all the Coast Guard assets being diverted to this fiasco?
Thanks for the updates. Did they not know of any severe weather when they started? Maybe they have some ‘splainin’ to do.
Gee will shell get a bill from USCG I sure hope so. I guess this is just another promise trust us we know what we’re doing from shell. WTF was anyone thing in trying to move these with a storm on the way do they think Mother Nature really give a rats ass on their F*&^%$# schedule.
Thanks ET for the update.
Did they not know of any severe weather when they started?
It is winter time in Alaska. The storms sometimes succeed each other so closely they need march permits to proceed. The one pounding these vessels, has its northern coattails up where I live, 430 miles away.
Just off hand, sounds like a psychotic or wanton/wreckless decision. Along the lines of the BP wrecklessness…..
Bloomberg published an article this morning that contradicts Shell’s assessment of “everything has been under control – is under control – will be under control” meme:
Also, the Bloomberg article notes:
So, at the conclusion of the 2012 season, Shell’s two drilling rigs are either stranded or distressed in Alaska, with one costing US taxpayers millions in USCG funds, and the third key component, the Arctic Challenger, has yet to prove its oil containment and recovery dome works, even in flat calm waters.
Shell just posted the following:
I’ll try to attend telephonically. If they let me. My last contact with them was being escorted out of Bellingham in August by two security cops.
Who could’ve predicted? /s
Wonder what government service has to be cut to offset the cost of this operation?
They’re letting me in. Apparently the word “firedoglake” sometimes opens doors. I’ll let you know how it goes.
That is really heavy weather. Good time to be in Harbor.
Not to mention gusting to 80 to 100 kt.
excellent!
I’m in.
Something interesting to note is that this is being held by an organization called the “Unified Command.” The web page displays logos of – from left to right – the USCG, Edison Chouest Offshore, Shell Alaska and the Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation.
Already, Shell is trying to hide in a tiny forest.
Shell shill calling the people backing him up at conference “the United Command.”
Another Shell shill describing the incident from beginning. Leaving out key details, like why the Aiviq lost propulsion . (It was fuel contamination that got out of control in a 50 degree roll while trying to re-attach lines to the Kulluk).
It’s PR guy framing
Shell shill has used the words “safety” or “safely” numerous times already.
“Close to a hurricane last night” as weather deteriorated while repairing Aiviq. “Over 250 people working in this command to – blah, blah…
AK DEC guy begins talking about how hard the State of AK worked, developing the “Unified command.”
correction – what I thought was the 2nd Shell shill was actually a USCG captain. Heh…
Sean Churchill – interim commander, Shell AK. Brit.
Reports two minor injuries.
Two questions: first, is the USCG being reimbursed, or do corporations consider such rescues as governmental largess?
Second: why drill in the Arctic when this country does not need oil but is exporting oil to other countries?
I know the answer to No. 2… drill EVERYWHERE so oil companies will make more money (while the GOP bitches about government spending).
Sean Churchill
backing away fromcovering up earlier reports of severe fuel contamination being responsible for multiple engine failures.Rachel d’Oro (AP) asking for further info on injuries. Both on Aiviq. No details. Both back at work.
Questions on USCG pre-approval of tow. USCG Cpt. Mehler saying Shell went “above and beyond what would be normally required.”
d’Oro asking about status of unmanned rig, asking for details. Churchill trying to change subject. Successful.
Shell terminating conference, as he assures everyone that “you all have to get back to work.”
He’s angling for a job. “Above and beyond” would be checking the damn Weather Channel before setting out
Rachel d’Oro presses – “Why did this tow proceed with severe storm predicted?”
Indeed. They obfuscated over d’Oro’s last question, then called it all “over” and left the room.
Shell AK posts “Mehler: All decisions made during incident were made by Unified Command,” on twitter, which wasn’t what I thought Mehler indicated.
More trying to hide Shell behind the other agents in this clusterfuck.
What I got out of this press conference was:
1). Aiviq and Kulluk walked into this storm blithely.
2). At least two people have been injured.
3). USCG does not want to talk about why their cutter left the scene early Saturday.
4). Shell is backing off from earlier descriptions of the multiple simultaneous engine failures on the Aiviq being caused by fuel contamination. No mention in the presser of the USCG offloading “900 pounds” worth of new fuel injectors onto drifting Aiviq for those engines Saturday. This may be more important than is readily apparent.
5). There is nobody aboard the drill rig.
Should Tuesday’s storm part the lines again, like Friday’s did, it will be extremely dangerous to get anyone back aboard. Pumps are on automatic, but to re-hook for a tow, winches would have to be manned on the rig. No wonder they are putting as many miles as possible between them and the rocky coast of Kodiak Island eh?
thanks very much.
If I were the person in charge, I’d want to see the maintenance records asap
thanks ET
Thank you for this report. I send some money to the USCG because they need support and as I sailor I may need them. I’ve been involved with USCG rescues and these people are amazing.
Oil industry… is there anything they do right aside from sponsor PBS?
All politics & environmental issues aside,THANK FSM FOR THE US COAST GUARD!
Thank you, ET. We’ve been following your reports.
They sponsor PBS to kill PBS. That’s evil with a happy face.
Thanks, openhope, Elliot and others. Any more developments and I’ll probably post a new diary, rather than another update.
UhOh
reports that the drill ship is adrift
tow lines broke
http://www.seattlepi.com/news/article/Drill-ship-adrift-again-after-towlines-break-4155799.php
And from ET’s update:
Good fucking grief! Someone’s going to be hurt before this is over.
Strange story. First off, this time of year it would be practically impossible to make a tow from the Aleutian Islands to Seattle without transiting through at least one Pacific storm. It’s the Gulf of Alaska, for christsake–famous for harsh winter weather.
Next, if contaminated fuel is the cause of engine failure (and contaminated diesel fuel isn’t so rare as to be uncommon, though it is uncommon to be associated with commercial fuel providers) then replacing the injectors will not solve the problem. The only solution is to completely drain the contaminated fuel, clean the tanks and clean all the fuel lines and pumps. Furthermore, if that tug got bad fuel, then there are other ships floating out there with bad fuel, and I’m having a problem wrapping my head around the contaminated fuel theory. As for “50 degree roll with fuel lines disconnected”, something serious was going on if fuel lines were disconnected in that weather, so contaminated fuel can’t be entirely ruled out, or maybe that’s just not true. If they brought aboard “900 lbs. of injectors”, maybe they plan on just to keep changing injectors as they fail–nah, that is one hell of a job, you just don’t screw one out and screw in another because disassembly is required. Just a weird story all around, to the point that I’m really skeptical. The Coasties are usually straight up when commenting on problems with shipping and with rescues, but as we saw in the Gulf, not so much when oil is spilled (not that this has anything to do with a spill, I’m sure it doesn’t).
excellent points, reddog – all of them. The USCG has been unusually praiseful of Shell throughout the 2012 drilling season up here.
So the obvious question is … why wait till Winter?
Supposed to be a reply to reddog