Reported here and below, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has lined up with a key provision of Goldstone report debate at the outset of debate on the Gaza war this morning at the U.N.:
UN urges ‘credible’ probes into Gaza war
October 14, 2009UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon urges Israel and the Palestinians to conduct, without delay, “credible” domestic probes of war crimes allegations during the Gaza conflict, a top UN official said Wednesday.
Ban “calls upon all of the parties to carry out credible domestic investigations into the conduct of the conflict without delay,” UN Under Secretary General for political affairs Lynn Pascoe told the UN Security Council.
“He hopes that such steps will be taken wherever there are credible allegations of human rights abuses throughout the world,” he added.
Pascoe noted that Ban’s call dovetails with a key recommendation in a UN report that accused both Israel and Palestinian armed groups of war crimes during the three-week Gaza conflict over the new year.
The damning report by a team led by South African jurist Richard Goldstone, a former international war crimes prosecutor, also directed Ban to bring its report to the attention of the UN Security Council for follow-up action, which could be a referral to the International Criminal Court.
(Note to Israel Lobby: any anti-Ban smears at hand?) Tomorrow, the UN Human Rights Council takes up the report:
Human Rights Council to discuss recent UN probe into Gaza conflict
October 13, 2009The Human Rights Council announced today that it will hold a special session on Thursday to discuss the report of the recent United Nations fact-finding mission on the Gaza conflict that took place at the start of the year. . . .
The mission, headed by Justice Richard Goldstone, found evidence that both Israeli forces and Palestinian militants committed serious war crimes and breaches of humanitarian law, which may amount to crimes against humanity, during the conflict in December 2008 and January 2009.
Presenting his report to the Council late last month, Justice Goldstone called for an end to impunity for those found to have committed human rights violations.
“It is accountability above all that is called for in the aftermath of the regrettable violence that has caused so much misery for so many,” he said.
Justice Goldstone urged the Council to implement a number of measures, including a referral of the mission’s report to the Security Council, since neither the Government of Israel nor the responsible Palestinian authorities have so far carried out any credible investigations into alleged violations.
Meanwhile and empowered by the Goldstone report, the divestment movement in the U.S. courageously marches on, university by university. Yesterday the University of Wisconsin took on Israel’s bulldozers:
UW must divest from Caterpillar
Sam Stevenson
October 13, 2009Israel is a criminal nation. This statement has been a verifiable fact for many decades and continues to gain support with each new violation of international law Israel commits. Most recently, a U.N. report authored by Richard Goldstone — a South African judge and self-proclaimed Zionist — found that Israel (and Hamas) committed war crimes and (quite possibly) crimes against humanity earlier this year during the Israeli invasion of Gaza. During that war the Israeli army killed more than 1,300 Gazans including 437 under 18. They also wounded nearly 2,000 Gaza children. In contrast, the Israel Defense Forces suffered 13 causalities, nearly half victims of friendly fire. Tens of thousands of Palestinians were left homeless in the war’s aftermath. Even before the war, figures as diverse as President Jimmy Carter and Archbishop Desmond Tutu had compared the conditions of Palestinians in the occupied territories to those of blacks in South Africa under apartheid.
. . . The UW system has an endowment that is invested in a long list of corporations. One of those corporations is Caterpillar — the manufacturer of the bulldozers that the IDF employs to tear down Palestinian homes — to the tune of nearly $400,000. The tuition dollars we give the university every year fund this system and makes us, in part, responsible for how and where this endowment is invested. A brief review of the facts makes it clear the UW System Board of Regents must follow historical precedent and withdraw endowment funds from companies doing business with perpetrators of war crimes.
In the past, the UW has divested from countries and companies that are complicit in violations of international law. These include South Africa, Burma and Sudan. In fact, the UW System Trust and Fund Policy states it will “seriously reconsider” investments in companies that “violate, frustrate or subvert” international law. Cases involving Caterpillar’s complicity in violations of international law as well as the legality of Israel’s demolition policy are currently being litigated; indisputably, compelling evidence of criminality exists. Other universities in the U.S. and Europe have already divested from Caterpillar for these very reasons.
The student idealists of the Israel divestment movement, following the path of the successful South Africa boycott movement of two decades ago, are the best hope for justice in Palestine. Aside from the direct pressure of divestment on Israel, the effort puts pressure from the left on the Democratic Party and the Obama administration, highlighting their hypocrisy and subservience to Israel. Great learning experience for Poli Sci and other students about what is at stake and about the bipartisan imperial policy. Foreign Policy in Focus’s Stephen Zunes writes:
The [Goldstone] report, authored by renowned South African jurist Richard Goldstone, detailed the results of the UNHRC’s fact-finding mission on the Gaza conflict. These findings included the recommendation that both Hamas and the Israeli government bring to justice those responsible for war crimes during the three weeks of fighting in late December and early January. If they don’t, the report urges that the case be referred to the International Criminal Court (ICC) for possible prosecution.
The Obama administration has declared — in the words of U.S. ambassador to the UN Susan Rice — that such a recommendation is “basically unacceptable.” It has insisted that any legal remedies be handled by the respected parties internally. Since neither Hamas nor the Israeli government will likely prosecute those responsible for war crimes, the administration’s action will essentially prevent these Palestinian and Israeli war criminals from ever being brought to justice.
. . . The Goldstone Commission report cited in detail a whole series of violations of the laws of war by Hamas, including rocket attacks into civilian-populated areas of Israel, torture of Palestinian opponents, and continued holding of kidnapped Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit.
What has upset Obama administration officials and congressional Democrats, however, was that the report also concluded that Israel’s military assault on Gaza was “a deliberately disproportionate attack designed to punish humiliate and terrorize a civilian population,” citing Israel’s deadly attacks against schools, mosques, private homes and businesses nowhere near legitimate military targets. These conclusions echo detailed empirical reports released in recent months by Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and the Israeli human rights group B’Tselem, among others.
. . . Though Rice had argued just a few months earlier during a UN debate on Darfur that war crimes charges should never be sacrificed for political reasons, she reinforced Assistant Secretary of State Philip Crowley’s insistence that the report “should not be used as a mechanism to add impediments to getting back to the peace process.”
Students, alumni, is your college or university funding the bulldozers that flatten Palestinian homes or human rights protestors? Is it financing apartment blocks for illegal settlements in the West Bank? Learn, then learn the most important lessons by acting for justice.



28 Comments







Why Goldstone report matters: Pay particular attention to reason #3, what Falk calls the Legitimacy War, and how the present negative publicity for Israeli atrocities, whatever the official outcome, helps the divestment movement and the cause of justice for the Palestinians:
An oversight not to provide people with the website of the bovement to boycott, divest from, & sanction Israel:
http://www.bdsmovement.net/
are you saying that there’s something bovine about the boycott?
Tried to edit that but got back here a little too late.
Don’t sweat.
So you calling for a complete investigation of Hama’s actions also?
Will that include their murders of the PLO guys in the hospital?
I would enjoy seeing full investigations of both sides. They need to be stopped from dragging the people of the region endlessly downward.
Excruciatingly obviously, I support the Goldstone report recommendations, which ask both Israel and Hamas to make credibly independent investigations of war crimes within the next 6 months.
Excruciatingly obviously, I support the Goldstone report recommendations, which ask both Israel and Hamas to make credibly independent investigations of war crimes within the next 6 months.
Oh, really? What is excruciatingly obvious is your anti-Israeli bias.
Students, alumni, is your college or university funding the rockets that fly at Israeli homes and schools? Is it financing a prison cell for Gilad Shalit, kidnapped more than two years ago? Learn, then learn the most important lessons by acting for justice.
Being against the actions of the Israelis in Gaza isn’t a bias. It’s a respectable position. The Israelis weren’t acting for justice there. They went to bring vengeance and terror instead.
What is excruciatingly obvious is your anti-Israeli bias: The title of the diary.
Thanks for posting this. Don’t pay any attention to macaquerman. He will never recognize that the Zionists are the criminal aggressors and the Palestinians the only ones with the right to defend.
And yeah, sorry, mac, it’s ugly, but in a real war there is summary execution of collaborators and spies, especially those who help murder over a thousand of their fellow citizens. It’s a wonder Abbas is still alive.
Sorry to you also, Evelyn. I never will recognize that either group should be denied self-defense or that either group should murder civilians of either group.
Your defense of summary execution of people lying in hospital beds in the name of realism marks you as a morally absurd person.
“We can deliberately destroy thousands of Gazan homes, the Gazan parliament, the Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of Interior, courthouses, the only Gazan flour plant, the main poultry farm, a sewage treatment plant, water wells and God knows what else.
Deliberately.
After all, we’re acting in self-defense. By definition.
And what right do the Palestinians have to defend themselves against this?
None.
Why? Because we’re better than them. Because we’re a democracy and they’re a bunch of Islamo-fascists. Because ours is a culture of life and theirs is a culture of death. Because they’re out to destroy us and all we are saying is give peace a chance.
One look at the ruins of Gaza ought to make that plain enough. ”
http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1254861893834&pagename=JPArticle/ShowFull
That’s pretty much the same shit from the Israelis that Evelyn embraces for Hamas.
Might be nice if the grown-ups were in charge.
Don’t you ever get bored with hasbara talking points?
Don’t make me send you back to camp, bb.
I think that i was agreeing with the stuff you posted @10.
What’s your problem with that?
If you insist on calling me an al Qaeda camp follower..I will have to keep reminding you that, in your own words,..you are a proud Zionist. Just curious..Grumpy and you must read the same hasbara manual? Tell ‘Grumpy’ that Shalit is a prisoner of war; not a kidnapping victim. A reminder that Israel broke the ceasefire is in order. The same propaganda does get boring.
bb, you’re still writing and thinking irrationally.
I want you to tell me what it was that I said in comment 11 that caused you in 15 to start busting my balls with your bullshit about hasbara.
“A reminder that Israel broke the ceasefire is in order”
Then go for it: remind us when Israel broke the ceasefire, preferable without ignoring the Hamas rockets that never stopped: not during the “ceasefire,” not to this day.
“Shalit is a prisoner of war”
Just like the Palestinians in Hasharon Prison, right?
Thanks very much for the link. Derfner puts things perfectly.
You’re welcome. Amazing that article showed up in the Jerusalem Post as it is one of the most pro Zionist ones out there. Israel’s ambassador to the United States, Michael B. Oren, gave up his American citizenship to take the job. Israel, unlike the US, doesn’t allow dual citizenship. Maybe you knew where he came from, but others might not.
********
“Israeli Government Contradicts its Own Self-Defense Argument
Information on the Israeli Government’s own web site shows that its self-defense argument for its military operations in Gaza is flawed ”
http://mwcnews.net/content/view/33738/26/
*sigh*
From the letter quoted above:
I can’t be bothered reading the rest of this person’s statement, it having been commenced with this kind of nonsense.
Too bad, cause he may well have something worth reading in there.
As for the Goldstone report, I simply do not understand how the Israelis think they are helping themselves by the infliction of misery on the Palestinians. It makes no sense whatsoever. Likewise the Southern Lebanese.
Incidentally, anyone interested in some of the unfortunate history of the Jews living in the Arab world might read
“Dhimmi: Jews and Christians under Islam” by Bat Ye’Or. Very interesting book.
and Fairleft seems even handed to me.
To make a case for divestment you have to make the case that “Israel is a criminal nation.” It’s an easy and obvious case to make. First of all and most obviously: building settlements, entire towns and city neighborhoods, on occupied land. That’s criminality under international law, and there really isn’t any question there, the apartment blocks are right there for everyone to see. Recently, also very obviously and almost officially (look at the name the Israelis gave their invasion), collective punishment of the Gaza civilian population for voting in and supporting Hamas. Similarly with the collective punishment of the civilian populations who support Hezbollah in Lebanon. The last two are international criminality supported all across official Israel, and by most of the Israeli population.
What would we do around here without you critiquing the words of others? A suggestion..stop the name calling and swearing. Both are put downs of the opinions of others in a less than civil manner. The one thing you never do is present facts. Why is that?
perhaps you’ll be so good as to answer the question that I posed to you.
and you’ll also perhaps notice that there was neither name-calling nor swearing until your commencement with more “hasbara”.
You play your game with many and that is what I referred to. I am not responsible for your actions. Here is a video I’m sure you will enjoy..or not, as facts are not your favorite thing. You’ll find the words of the video at the site.
*******
“I am Israel”
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MSCMXUHwF-A
you are or should be responsible for your own actions. don’t fling mud and complain with it comes flying back.
your video is as idiotically one-sided as ever. as long as you present one side of a long and dirty war what are you doing? what are facts when they’re but half of the facts?