Michael Moore, the Academy Award winning documentary film maker who has been generally supportive of the Obama administration despite its stealth opposition to real health care reform (Obama has talked of the public option as a "sliver" and speaks now about "insurance reform"), has an open letter to President Obama up on his website asking if Obama really wants to be the new "war president". The answer, Michael, is: YES HE DOES.
In fact, the Associated Press and other news sources have reported that Obama already began his escalation BEFORE his primetime Tuesday address to the American people (I guess that Dick Cheney’s "dithering" remarks lit a fire under Hamlet’s back side). AP reports that:
Even before explaining his decision, Obama told the military to begin executing the force increases. The commander in chief gave the deployment orders Sunday night, during an Oval Office meeting in which he told key military and White House advisers of his final decision.
The Democratic President talked about his plans with key lawmakers but has not addressed all lawmakers nor has he addressed one of the key problems with the escalation, its cost (estimated to be $350 billion over 10 years if the escalation is for 35,000 troops). From the AP story again:
Gibbs said detailed discussions on costs would be held later with lawmakers.
So, not only does Obama apparently believe the war can somehow be paid for later (he opposes David Obey’s pay-as-you-go war tax on the wealthy), he has not even discussed costs with Congress. How’s that for transparency in government, folks, and did not Obama promise that his administration would be the most transparent in American history?
Michael Moore, no doubt Obama will talk about the firm resolve of our allies on Tuesday night. However, the Obama administration in this buildup to the escalation, as reported in the AP story linked above, only dwells on the Brits and the French and does not talk about Germany. How many more troops will the Brits send? 500, again according to the same AP story. That’s about enough to guard one parking lot in Kabul. Nor will Obama or his hirelings talk about the Germans very much. Germany currently is the number three nation with troops in Afghanistan (behind the U.S.A. and the U.K.). But due to a scandal over the former Defense Minister lying about civilian deaths in an air strike called for by the German army but executed by the American Air Force, German resolve (never strong to begin with) has weakened and the German people and their nation turned against the war. This issue is discussed at length in length at the diary, "Germany’s Top General Quits Over Afghan War Cover-up of Civilian Killings; US Implications" here at Firedoglake.
So Michael, you were late in recognizing that Obama really never was a progressive or a Democrat, as Sen. Paul Wellstone used to say, from the "Democratic side of the Democratic Party." Michael, you know more about health care reform than just about anyone (what a great documentary "Sicko" is), so surely you noticed that Obama shied away from a public option (which he supported as a state senator in Illinois). He called a White House conference on health care in February that failed to include a single speaker for single payer, he broke a campaign pledge to hold "all healthcare meetings in public and televise them live on C-SPAN," instead meeting behind closed doors in secret with insurance companies. He then began talking about "insurance reform" and the public option as but a "sliver" to his real program (never really defined in detail). Now we have the messy bill in Congress that Dennis Kucinich has called "the wrong approach; a bailout for insurance companies."
So too on Afghanistan, Obama has broken campaign promises.* (See note below). Recall that he did campaign on escalating the war in Afghanistan BUT ONLY talked about sending 2 more brigades there: that’s less than 8,000 soldiers. Obama already in February sent 21,000 more troops to Afghanistan (and countless civilian contractors like Blackwater). So he has already escalated once far exceeding his campaign promise. And this is about the only campaign promise Obama has NOT broken. He’s broken pledges on bringing change, on bringing new faces to Washington, on FISA telecom immunity, on renegotiating NAFTA, on DOMA, on DADT, on hiring no lobbyists in his administration, on increasing taxes on those making more than $250,000 per year, on closing GITMO quickly, on doing away with forced renditions, on state secrets, on passing no law until 5 days have elapsed before it has been submitted ("sunshine before signing" legislation) and a host of other issues.
Obama campaigned as a stealth candidate and has broken virtually every campaign pledge he made. Only Goldman Sachs and Wall St. have received their trillions of dollars in largesse from Obama through the bailouts. For workers and the unemployed: they get a White House conference that will doubtlessly feature those progressive, people-oriented Obama economists, Larry Summers and Timothy Geithner, in a few days on unemployment. Obama was quick to talk about the cost of true health care reform (and all of his estimates mysteriously projected for 10 years, not one, thus swelling the apparent cost to the people). But with war, Obama has no problems with not even talking or considering the costs even with Congress. That will be done later. So Obama’s escalation fits in perfectly with the rest of his actions in the past year: all public relations and pretty speeches. Expect more lies and more vagueness (especially regarding a pull out date, he will not mention one for sure) on Tuesday.
Sorry, Michael but you need to pick up that patented bull-horn megaphone of yours and trumpet this message: Obama is a fraud, a complete sellout, a nonfighter for the progressive platform he ran and won on.
NOTE: On Obama breaking his campaign pledges on Afghanistan (the linked story has links to the campaign speeches):
In major foreign policy speeches in August 2007 and July 2008, Obama did talk of sending “at least two” more U.S. combat brigades — made up of between three thousand and four thousand troops each — to Afghanistan. However, the 21,000 troops he has already sent far exceed any troop increase he discussed publicly before the election, even before the 30,000 or so more he’s expected to announce he’ll add to that number in Tuesday’s speech.



31 Comments

It doesn’t matter what He wants after tomorrow He will be the war President, and every death and injury, and ever dollar spent will be on His soul.
He and He alone fell for the bullshit He was sold, and there is no one else to blame this time.
Exactly right, iremember54. Obama now takes the same seat that George W. Bush held so effectively for 8 years! But with Obama, I think he only gets 3 more years. His escalation will tear not only the Democratic Party but the nation apart.
I was fooled once, but won’t be fooled again.
He came accross as a smart man, Oh what fools we were.
Recommended. IMO he is not talking to the American public tomorrow, just to the military – hence the location and audience he has chosen. Is he going to level with them and tell them that their military careers will be spent in Afghanistan protecting poppy fields and drug shipments?
If all the people and their thinking about this war mattered to him he would address the entire nation from the oval office. Once we gave him what he wanted he’s through with us. Maybe, like LBJ, he’s already decided he doesn’t want a second term.
I read Michael Moore’s piece, and IMO he is correct. It is well worth reading.
fflam, fyi Michael Moore’s agent is the notorious brother of Rahm Emmanuel. Am wondering if that has a lot to do with the slack MM has shown BO? Am just sayin…..
recommended… thanks for this
am going home to call congresspersons about health care medicare for all S703 and also getting out of afghanistan.
but as kucinich points out re Afghan, the congress already wrote out the check for funding for this escalation. forget our mandate of 2008.
Um, he was a war President when he took office. Are you guys being intentionally obtuse?
He campaigned to send more troops to Afghanistan. He never intended to pull out troops in Afghanistan. You are attacking Obama for something he never promised.
To compare him to Bush is stunningly ignorant and irrational.
This is the fourth blog to post this garbage. It’s pathetic and you sound more like Republicans. Get a fing grip!
Sorry What7. You wrote: “He campaigned to send more troops to Afghanistan.”
Correct, but he campaigned to send only 2 more brigades to Afghanistan. That’s less than 8,000 troops (see the diary above with links to Obama’s promises if you don’t believe me). He earlier this year, in February, escalated already by sending 21,000 more troops to Afghanistan. Tuesday he will call for at least 30,000 more. So is sending 51,000 more troops (that will cost $51 billion a year) more to Afghanistan the same as promising to send less than 8,000 there (that would cost less than $8 billion a year)?
I think not. It’s not the same promise at all. It far exceeds what he said he would do. It’s yet another broken promise coming from this broken promise, stealth candidate.
Thanks Libbyliberal about that info about Moore having Rahm’s brother his agent. I didn’t know that. What you write makes eminent sense.
yeah, fflam, when I saw MM’s latest movie and thought he was holding back a lot on Obama’s relationship with the corporatists … and then on interviews the same thing was happening … and then one of my brothers told me about Rahm’s agent brother (apparently with a violent temper …) … I suspected that might have a major impact, though circumstantial speculation.
the reason I worked for Obama and NOT HRC was because she was about militarism and he wasn’t. He kept talking about concern about Pakistan which made me uncomfortable, but 80 million people or the majority wanted the end to the war(s) and he certainly was enjoying their assumption.
What’s really amusing is this insistence that “health insurance reform” be “revenue-neutral,” but war? Put it on the credit card!
yeah, cass, kucinich emphasized that congress okayed $130 billion for this escalation already.. no wonder everyone acts like it is a done deal. Ron Reagan on his radio show said that this Aghan war will cost $30 billion a month at least. good God!
why does the USA always pick its fights with countries 1/10 its size, with a military 1/1000 or less? Panama? Grenada? Dominican Republic? Iraq, Vietnam?
What a bully.
I think the USA should start a war with a country that has a chance.
Say, Russia, or China.
Then, maybe all the pro war Americans will learn what being in a war zone is like.
What it means to be “collateral damage”
Unfortunately we have elected a foolish man with no courage as our president and our country is going to suffer for it. After eight years of Bush and four years of Obama our country will be on the brink of becoming a middle of the road country too burdened with debt and wars to stop its decline. Years from now they will ask why did the American empire fail and the present and past president will surely be discussed. This might sound bizarre but in a couple of years we may wish GWB was still in office, Obama has the potential to be the worst president we have ever had.
There is some hope that Obama will mix in an olive branch for the Talban to at least nominally join the war against al Qaeda if the US gets out.
I wish Michael Moore would join me in continuing to back the President and oppose the war at the same time, which I do.
Unfortunately the people who agree with me are getting silent, let’s speak up.
See BACKING OBAMA BUT NOT THE WAR,
http://seminal.firedoglake.com/diary/16936
So um….healthcare reform, the one thing that could actually HELP everyday American people if done right, needs to be deficit neutral. Does Obama feel that any of the wars we’re in needs to be deficit neutral also? This President, one that I and so many Americans had so much hope for, seems to come off progressively weaker over time.
It’s all very simple, really.
Kill for peace.
Works every time. The killing, that is.
What fun are “moral principles” if you don’t get to exercise them selectively?
Michael Moore should spend a little time reading Arthur Silber:
Wherein We Gaze into Our Inerrant Crystal Ball and Espy a Deadly Rat
but he, and other (D) captured Lefties, may have to make a choice between the incredible predictive abilities that derive from more accurate mental models of the American political system, and their comforting Faith that the Democratic Party is the One True Path for Progressive Change, via ‘more and better Democrats’ change from within, primary the Blue Dogs, or whatever.
$30 billion a year… wow…not month. oy vey. I was overtired and wrote month. My eyes are just glazed over with all these horrifying big numbers. Must be throwing everyone into shock. Now we say billions used to be millions. Trillion now in place of billions. Billionaires now not millionaires club. The trickle up system of oligarchical thievery. Reverse Robin Hoodism.
hey ART, you always get very concisely right to the bone! Thank you. As I listen to the Afghan War speech tonight that oxymoron will resonate. Rachel M.’s expression “ethical freakshow of a universe.”
Thanks, ll!
Can’t take credit though. It’s a slogan from the 1960s.
I read this in one of the first Vietnam Vet newsletters. The full quote is “Killing for peace is like whoring for virginity”.
Do you want peace?
Odd question..anything I’ve written made you think I don’t?
You are great. Sorry.
The saying from the 1960s was, killing for peace is like fucking for virginity.
Again, you are great. I’m sorry.
Perhaps you misread at first the intent of the whole quote..ie..killing will never bring about peace. Truce declared..because we agree with each other..’g’.
I’m sorry to say that I’m forced to agree with you as much as I wish that this were otherwise. I voted for one of his opponents during the primaries feeling very uncomfortable about what I considered to be negativities such as the lacking of real convictions and leadership qualities. What with with Obama having won the Democratic primaries and McCane as the Republican candidate I reluctantly voted for Obama as the lesser of two evils. Now that I see my earlier concerns happening I’m not at all sure that McCane really was a lesser evil.
What really amases me is how The Obamiacs seem to believe that Saint Obama’s the second coming and that he can do no wrong. As Obama’s war escalates I believe that we’ll see our thousands more of American casualities and our country’s economy collapsing. The U.S. will join the rest of the third world.
My reply to 12 was actually meant for 13. My bad!
Something to consider…NOTHING GREAT IS EVER ACCOMPLISHED THROUGH CONFORMITY…Stop blaming Washington DC for OUR (YES I SAID OUR) difficulties…WE ARE…WELL WE USED TO BE…UNITED…
Do you remember the traitors and terrorists that started this country and fought against the CROWN??? They had integrity…courage…morals…they started a revolution because they cared about not only their own future but also that of their children…OUR GOVERNMENT NO LONGER CARES ABOUT YOU OR YOUR CHILDREN…ASK BUSH…CHENEY…OR OBAMA…
So if you want change, you have to FIGHT…just like in history…if you think that talking works…hahaha…how has that been working for us…
The US Government that we are supposed to run has been selling off our future and that of our children…KILLING Americans with poor health care…sending them across seas to fight for oil and lying about it…
…ARE YOU AMERICANS REALLY AS STUPID AND LAZY AS YOU APPEAR…I guess so.
I challenge you to exercise your FREEDOMS…HAHA you do not have any more… Its all over …YOU HAVE ALREADY SOLD OUT YOURSELVES and CHINA HAS BEEN BUYING…But maybe if you pray (hahaha) Jesus will save you…Because we all know that he is on your side…Empires generally collapse on the average of 250 years…its time…say Goodnight GRACIE.
And we have been doing it to OURSELVES…AND I AM TO BLAME. STAND UP AND TAKE RESPONSIBILITY WITH ME…I cant wait to watch American Idol on my new SONY WIDE SCREEN…WOW Its Almost as BIG as my ass.
I love being programed by my television and I LOVE to be scared into conformity.
It might be added that all excess of promises Obama makes somehow favor corporations over the people. BO is a bought and sold figurehead of the Corporate States of Amerika. What a sad predicament he has put the country in.
I’m inclined to agree that our country is on the verge of a revolution. I am not fully empassioned – yet. I’m getting there. Undoubtedly. When I start reading about bankers who amassed millions going to buy handguns for protection, I have to believe it’s coming. Just a matter of time. When enough of us are poor, without a home, or money to support our families, it will happen. If not sooner.