One of the greatest problems with the two-party system is that it’s adversarial by nature. Polarization is unavoidable. Republicans have embraced this flaw with gusto: they have abandoned their formerly conservative fortifications and planted their flag in outer space. Democrats, predictably, have abandoned their formerly liberal position in an effort not to be seen as extreme, and rushed to take over the former Republican stronghold and relabel it “moderate”, while Republicans continue to smear them with the “extremist liberal” brush. Concerning the Affordable Care Act (ACH du lieber), Republicans, true to form, are screeching about “death panels” and “job killing”. The Party of Jesus obsessed about death – no surprise there.

Do more people have access to affordable healthcare? (Photo: Adrian Boliston / Flickr)
Democrats, meanwhile, by default are left with only one strategy: defend this monster. “Folks can afford health coverage now who could never afford it before.” So say the (formerly liberal) pundits. But, is it true? Is Obamacare affordable, and for whom?
I obtained coverage under the “Pre-existing Condition Insurance Plan” (PCIP) last October. At that time, my bank account had a balance of $16,000.00, give or take. Today, it’s less than half that, and the bills are still pouring in. Monthly premiums take $347.00, that’s almost four g’s/year, with a $2,750.00 deductible. “Preventive care” is free – but in practice, this is preventive care: “Hi, doc. How ya doin’?” ”Fine, just fine. And you?” ”Me, too, doc, I’m just fine, too.” That’s it. That’s “preventive care”. And, to be fair, it is free. But, should you be foolish enough to add, “…but my neck hurts every time I write a check” – that’s a bridge too far. That requires a diagnosis, and now you pay, until your deductible is satisfied. While you are paying down your deductible, coverage is paltry, miserly even. I was responsible for virtually all charges, as a blizzard of “explanation of benefits” letters cruelly advised me.
I went in for some tests in order to determine the status of my pre-existing condition, they did some biopsies and genetic work. Concerned about cost, I questioned my doctor about the charges. “I won’t know until after the insurance company gets back to me.” I called PCIP. “We can’t say until we get the bill from your provider.” The process is completely opaque, and nonstandardized. Charges from one “provider” to another can appear to come from different parallel universes. One “procedure” that was prescribed, I insisted on a quote beforehand, and paid it at the time of the service. Since then, I have received bills amounting to more than four times the amount I paid, for that very procedure! Outraged, I called the provider last week, still haven’t heard back after five business days. I called PCIP – the folks there are terrific, really, but they are just as trapped in the system as its “primary victims” – us. I was told, “It’s a vicious circle. Providers have up to two years to submit charges on any given service. Keep a careful record of all your disbursements.” –In case of what? A lawsuit? How am I going to afford a lawyer? We have the too-big-to-fail banksters for a model. The Big Sick insurance giants will come up with increasingly complex instruments to fleece subscribers, and government regulators, underfunded, thwarted and hampered by the same process that defanged the financial regulators, will be steamrolled.
Here’s the gist: AHC may be affordable to some. It will certainly prevent financial ruin, for the well-to-do, due to catastrophic illness events. Subscribers will be protected from hundreds of thousands of dollars of charges. But, for the people who really need the coverage, for the majority of those who will sign up for the various plans, for us, this is not coverage, but a financial death sentence. Most of us are already under water, and an additional financial burden of ten thousand dollars or so could drown us. And here is where you will find the death panels, or the “Individual Mandeath” panels: folks self-administering intra-cranial lead injections to keep their entire families from ruin. Too dramatic? Wait and see.
I just got another $1,200 or so in bills this week, for services rendered in April! I’m afraid for the future, thanks to Affordable Health Care, and that, friends, is not good for my health. Six years ago, I had what I call real coverage, through insurance my ex had per her employer. Emergency appendectomy – no problem. No deductible. $23,000+ in charges. My copay? Four hundred bucks! Now, that’s what I call coverage. But that kind of coverage is a thing of the past in today’s privatized, financialized world. There will be no change until We The People get so fed up that we decide to seize the reins. The only difference between Romney and Obama is, Romney will get us there faster.



9 Comments

Great post. Your last sentence is one reason why I’m not fearful of a Romney victory. Recommended.
Rec’d, and thank you so much for the gory details. I haven’t had health insurance since my COBRA ran out about 13 years ago, IIRC, but not for lack of trying to obtain something I could even remotely afford. I’ve been self-employed since then; periodically I look for insurance but always give up in frustration. Is your $2750 an annual deductible? Which would mean that you have to pay nearly $7,000 yearly before the plan pays a dime? Yikes. And I assume that many things are not covered and that you need to be an insurance industry executive to understand the policy. We are so fucked.
No it appears out-of-the blue on your credit.
“The only difference between Romney and Obama is, Romney will get us there faster.”
Perhaps the most politically salient point. Recognize we’ve been Uncle Tom’d, let Romney finish crashing this financial train wreck we call government and start over.
glossolalique–
You (and psalongo) are spot on.
BTW, the ACA does help those Americans that it was intended to help–the top 1 to 10%, who have always had the ability to pay health insurance premiums, but were denied health insurance coverage due to “preexisting conditions.”
Otherwise, the ACA wouldn’t have been designed to exclude millions of lower income Americans from coverage.
Mad As Hell
Thank you, glossolalique. I’m sorry that you find yourself in this situation, but I do hope your words of warning will penetrate the wall of Democratic Party rhetoric and make people understand that the “Affordable” Care Act is a curse, not a blessing.
Curses and blessings are often opposite edges of the same sword. That a policy at any price is available to those with pre-existing conditions is an incremental improvement at best but still an improvement. Having been in the position where there simply was no policy to be had from anywhere at any price I can tell you that paying twice the price of a mortgage to insure my family, while an absolute curse to be sure, was a blessing every time the little plastic E-ticket (insurance card) got us past the admitting desk. Not everyone with a pre-existing condition will run out the lifetime limit (those are gone now too) on multiple policies over time but we have. Since my daughter was born my pay has never come close to size of the medical expenses except for four out of 24 years. Fortunately the dice came up in our favor the two years we were hanging in the wind with no effective coverage. I’ve been blessed to be able to keep finding employment with benefits and now there’s two years left (if the job holds, right?) before my little uninsurable gift from god faces the market alone. Today the law says there are exorbitantly expensive options for health insurance available. I fully expect all that to go away. I predict that the next congress will attempt to eliminate The Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA), and succeed. If people mattered, things would be different.
Expanding the insurance industry’s revenues – that’ll bring down costs. We have their word on it, after all.
The entire rotten edifice needs not to be incrementally chipped away at, but torn down and rebuilt to serve working people rather than investors.
Of course, this was deemed politically and economically impossible by the serious people who matter.
Funny, we can turn on a dime, implement radical changes to our social fabric, and issue blank check after blank check when it comes to The War on Terror…
Making health insurance available to people with pre-existing conditions at least sounds like an incremental improvement, yes…but that pricey, restrictive program only benefits a very small percentage of the uninsured: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/23/pcip-pre-existing-condition-insurance-plan_n_1296952.html We can do so much better than that.