
Current containment buildings and cooling towers at the Vogtle Electric Generating Plant in Burke County, GA. (photo: NRC)
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission has granted a construction and operating license to Southern Co. for two reactors to be added to its Plant Vogtle facility in Georgia. The OK is the first granted by the US regulator since 1978.
The NRC approved the license over the objections of its chairman, Gregory Jaczko, who wanted the license to stipulate that the units would meet new standards recommended by the agency’s Fukushima Near-Term Task Force (NTTF) report:
“I think this license needed something that ensured that the changes as a result of Fukushima would be implemented,” Jaczko said in an interview after the vote. “It’s like when you go to buy a house and the home inspector identifies things that should be fixed. You don’t go to closing before those things are fixed.”
The NTTF recommendations, geared toward improving safety and preventing another disaster like the one still evolving at Japan’s Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power facility, have still not become official government rules–some are projected to take up to five years to draft and implement–and so, for now, the new reactor construction will get to pretend the Tohoku quake and tsunami, and the resulting core meltdowns and widespread radioactive contamination, never happened.
The Vogtle reactors are of a new (or, let’s call it “new-ish”) design. The AP1000 reactor was just approved by the NRC in December, over the objections of numerous scientists and engineers, who saw claims of innovation insufficient to counter the dangers native to any Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) design. Upon examination, many of the “improvements” to the AP1000 look more like ways to cut construction costs. Even so, a single new AP1000 is expected to cost anywhere from $8 billion to $14 billion dollars–and, it should be noted, no US nuclear facility has ever come in anywhere close to on time or on budget. The US government has already pledged over $8 billion in federal loan guarantees to cover construction of the Georgia reactors, since without the government backstop, no private financial institutions will invest in such a high-cost, high-risk project. Southern Co. has already spent $4 billion preparing the Vogtle site for the anticipated new construction.
“I cannot support this licensing as if Fukushima never happened,” said Gregory Jaczko after the Thursday vote–but thanks to the four other commissioners of his captured agency, licensing as if Fukushima never happened is exactly what the NRC did.



25 Comments

Damn them and damn Obama (for the loan guarantees).
Well, damn Obama for other things as well, but this is the licensing nuclear reactors post.
Let’s see. Howz things in San Onofre today?
Oh. I see. It’s still shut down:
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lanow/2012/02/san-onofre-nuclear-plant-still-shutdown.html
And people are really concerned. What unfortunate timing. You’d think they could at least get some duct tape or something and fix the leak in the shut down plant before green-lighting more of them.
Get over it: the purpose of US government regulatory agencies is to green-light the profits of major corporations and to enhance the wealth of already well-to-do individuals.
He really has turned out to be something hasn’t he. Then there’s the alternatives. We are so fucked.
Yes. This is a sad day for the anti-nuclear activists in Georgia. I think they mounted a long strong fight. Hopefully we now have a number of people here in Georgia educated that would not have been. We are not going away and will be nipping at their heels, especially the funding by scurrilous rip-off of the Georgia Power rate payers.
We are also beginning efforts to get in motion actions to break the Southern Company’s monopoly as a power provider. There is a lot of interest here in solar, both for personal use and the manufacture of units.
In fact anyone wanting to sign our petition may do so here.
http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/legalize-solar-power/
Endless tax dollars to the thieves and destroyers of everything. Doesn’t speak well for our species. Oh well.
So what kind of odds do you people figure for a tsunami in Georgia?
Think the nuclear industry learned anything since 1978?
How about that global warming apostate?
Heh.
“Think the nuclear industry learned anything since 1978?”
Yes, they learned how to get the fucking reactors licensed again. It’s done with loan guarantees from the president who gets sizeable bribes er campaign contributions from the nuclear power industry.
BP blows up. Let’s deep water drill some more in the Gulf.
Fukushima melts down. Let’s build more reactors.
Gah!
Here is my theory about the end of the world. The oligarchs continue on with their push to absolute power. Societies around the world decline. Most people are very poor. A bacteria or virus takes out, say, a quarter of the population. The problem is that there is an unusual number of techs and science that die who know how to maintain the nuclear power plants. Some of the plants melt down. As this happens societies panic and collapse even more. More nuclear power plants melt down. We all die.
Hubris defines us. Is it too late to do anything about it?
In this case it’s also by the State PSC granting Georgia Power rate increases to forward the cost of construction.. Wall Street has learned the lesson and now won’t risk money on their development. So they have in essence given the power company taxation power to fund their follies.
God, I think I just wrote a scifi movie.
Yet more evidence Mr. Levine of our fully corrupted corporate fascist nation/state/empire . . . and the erected and annointed offals who govern and regulate it all.
LeSigh, great read, thanks for all you do.
Short, terse, to the point, well done. N yes, most of us FireBaggers know this . . . ;-)
No need to grenade the rest of us in yer foxhole.
Whether it is by your scenario or an atmosphere and oceans boiling from our destruction of the forests and the reflective ice and our effluence I have become convinced man learns but very very slowly from science and history and it is not likely these hazards will be appreciated soon enough, And yes it may be too late for either. even if by miracle the people wake up today.
I think Will Smith did that movie, and IT was a remake of one from the 60′s or so I think.
*G*
Good tho, nice.
Problem is this empire of ours, this global infestation of empire by the 1%, is fucking up so much shit besides the masses. I gotta believe it will all collapse of its own volition and mama nature’s interference LONG before a virus breaks out . . .
I also think, half the world’s population will be disappeared one way or another in the next 20 years from wars, global warming, starvation, exposure to the elements, and more.
BTW, if you never saw that Will Smith movie about the virus, and him in NYC saving the last of the humans on the planet, you must. IT’s chilling as all hell.
I Am Legend.
;-)
The older version is black and white, Vincent Price in the role Smith plays in this one. Watching them both in the same week or day has an impact on one, it does. ;-)
I think the what really get’s me is not going back the nuclear energy itself. But relying on a technology that is ancient when doing it.
I just get the feeling that this entire country never really has left 1959, sometimes.
Especially when better stuff is available or will be shortly.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/blog/2012/feb/09/accelerator-nuclear-reactor
Yes, that too! I noticed that. It’s an interesting scam brought to you by the PTB..
I was just talking with my brother earlier today and he said it doesn’t really matter where you live, something will get you – nuclear meltdowns, aquifers polluted, drought, etc.
http://brief.ly/~Ewop6
(spam free)
http://fairewinds.com/content/arnold-gundersen-fresh-report-fukushima
http://www.care2.com/causes/fukushima-fallout-low-levels-of-radiation-in-us-milk-contaminated-marine-life-in-japan.html
We can dovetail from CNG to hydrogen cars.
We can, including for job creation, replace the damage of the
corruption in the last century: replace some mass transit.
Turn the flip side of the coin: take advantage of flexibility /
computer apps.
Our puppets only pretend they never heard of mass transit.
C this 2:
http://www.denmark.dk/en/servicemenu/News/FocusOn/CopenhagenersLoveTheirBikes.htm
Actually, though cars are more passenger-mile costly, the RR’s
simply couldn’t make a good return on passenger rail in the U.S.
So the govt took it, but now they want to shaft that.
Privatize the profits, socialize the cost is too good for you
when they can simply shaft you.
Same as in health care. Shafting labor is to no good end, same
as taking on only risk free customers and letting the risk
cost shift to you anyway, but only after it’s too late to help them.
With labor: helps raise the min. wage, “Terms of Trade” elsewhere, leaving your own people, and the education system, wasted.
Should be higher wages there, because of union. High wages here,
because of unions.
Not slavery.
If you complain:
Kent State
Oakland
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TEimw0EU1ss
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ELKzmZK5Dec
Everything’s a double edged sword. We will get through this
and find this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=77IdKFqXbUY
Everything you say here is true, we could do all those things and many more.
Nonetheless we are not. We haven’t even any plans to begin. There are at least a dozen things occurring presently that could individually each and every one end life as we know it, and we need to solve each of those, and it must be done with dispatch at this point.
Here is a link for you……it is a Jared Diamond video giving an 18 minute talk on why societies collapse (a must view IMNSHO) :
http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/en/jared_diamond_on_why_societies_collapse.html
We are up to our chins in shit, and…..I gotta hand it to ya….really I do(no snark)…..you are busy scouting about for a pony.
Color me all ate up with cynicism. Maybe I’m just old now. I don’t feel old at 54. Especially when I’m in front of an audience with a guitar in my hands. But maybe I’m old.
But maybe……I’m just well informed.
Drought monitor Feb 7th:
“As a result, moisture deficits increased through most of the area, and drought conditions intensified in several broad regions. Most notably, D4 expanded into part of southern and east-central Georgia and southern South Carolina. The last 365 days were the driest such period on record at a number of locations, and most of the region recorded only half of normal precipitation during the last 6 months.”
how are they going to cool it?
how does “recommended ” work?
this was in that section, now it’s not.
Here’s Markey; with his brief quote about ‘taxpayer money’ seeming to be his worry, I didn’t realize he had many, many more objections:
‘Markey to NRC: Vogtle Reactor Vote Is an Abdication of Duty’
http://markey.house.gov/press-release/markey-nrc-vogtle-reactor-vote-abdication-duty