The first FDL diary I wrote about Occupy Oakland, back in November, was called “Justice Is Not Here Yet.” The title was based on a quote from longtime, prominent Oaklander Dorothy King to City Councilwoman Desley Brooks. Desley asked her old friend Dorothy why she needed to continue to camp in Oscar Grant Plaza; after all, she had made her point by simply being there. Dorothy responded by saying: “Justice is not here yet.”
I fear that justice may never find its way to Oakland. Almost every diary I have written since is about the latest injustice in our unfair city. Unfortunately, this diary is no different.
Photo by vision63
The Oakland Police Department Shoots Itself in the Foot. Literally.
Early on the morning of Sunday, May 5, 2012, Oakland police officer Miguel Masso shot and killed Alan Dewayne Blueford, an 18-year-old African American man, in East Oakland. Initial police reports (dutifully reported as true facts by MSM stenographers) indicated that officers on patrol came upon three young men, one of whom they believed was armed with a concealed weapon. The suspect fled, was pursued by one officer, and a shootout ensued. The suspect shot the officer and the officer returned fire, shooting the suspect three times. Both the officer and the suspect were rushed to Highland Hospital. The officer had non-life-threatening injuries to his lower extremities; the suspect was pronounced dead at the hospital. In the next day or two, the suspect was identified as Alan Blueford, who was on juvenile probation for burglary. So, to summarize: notorious East Oakland neighborhood; armed thug; heroic cop who barely escapes with his life. Game, set, match.
Except that’s not what happened. Not at all. The truth has begun to trickle out like Alan Blueford’s blood as he lay wounded and dying on the street for four hours. The gun allegedly found at the scene and allegedly belonging to Alan and reported as being as few as five feet away from Alan’s body or as many as 30 feet away from it—had never been fired. Officer Masso (whose name has not been officially released) shot himself in the foot.
Alan’s two friends were held by police for the next six hours. Alan’s parents were not aware that their son was dead until his friends were released from police custody. The friends told a different story, a story about how three teenagers were waiting on a corner around midnight for “some girls in a white Chevy” to pick them up, as Alan had told his father in the last phone call he made before he died. A story about how the cops rolled up on them with their lights out and their guns drawn, and how Alan did, in fact, run, because he was scared.
On May 15, 2012, the remarkably composed family of Alan Blueford appeared before the Oakland City Council. Alan’s mother, Jeralyn, told the council about how she and her husband, Adam, had rushed to the police station upon learning about Alan’s death from his friends. About how they had been told to “go sit down” and were forced to wait for two hours before someone finally came and told them that their son had been involved in a “gun battle” with police. Alan’s cousins talked about what a wonderful young man Alan had been, how he’d just been to the prom at Skyline High School and how he’d had been looking forward to graduating. The meeting was packed with people who had come to bear witness to yet another family’s grief, grief inflicted by OPD. We were all overcome by their courage in the face of such injustice, such outrage, such sorrow.
Except for the council members, many of whom fidgeted with their phones and seemed to be engaged in other, more pressing business. Councilwoman Desley Brooks, to her credit, at least demanded to know why OPD Chief Howard Jordan was not present to answer the Blueford’s questions. Unfortunately, Desley’s concern seemed to be about whether or not OPD had followed the established protocol for informing yet another mother that her young black son was dead at the hands of the police—rather than questioning the perfectly insane notion that such a protocol should even exist.
HoJo Doesn’t Know, So Don’t Ask Him
On the following evening, May 16, 2012, a handful of us attended a meeting of the Oakland Citizens Police Review Board. The original agenda of the meeting—which had been postponed from a much earlier date—was to address OPD’s response to Occupy Oakland. It was held in East Oakland in the gymnasium of the Allen Temple Baptist Church. Before the meeting began, we were reminded by the vice pastor (or whatever the fuck his title is) that we were not at City Hall, that we were in a church, and that we should behave accordingly. Because Jesus wants us to talk in soft, reverent tones when discussing dead teenagers and veterans with skull fractures and babies with tear gas in their lungs.
Police Chief Howard Jordan deigned to grace us with his presence on this evening but was unable to answer a single question. He could not comment on items he knew nothing about, which included most incidents of police brutality and fascism against OO as well as the mysterious events leading to the death of Alan Blueford. Citizens Review Board members seemed quite accepting of HoJo’s ignorance. Cephus “Uncle Bobby” Johnson, Oscar Grant’s uncle, told the board members that even though they don’t have any teeth, they could at least try to growl occasionally. It occurred to me that now we have “alumni” families of the dead—those strong, resilient, loving souls like Uncle Bobby who show up to comfort and guide the latest victims of police brutality.
Photo by glennshootspeople
Why on Earth Would Anyone Bring a Shield to An Occupy Oakland Protest?
On May 22, 2012, the Public Safety Committee of the Oakland City Council met to consider a proposed ordinance “prohibiting the possession of the tools of violence at a demonstration.” You might think this was a proposal that would ban the use of rubber bullets, beanbag rounds, tear gas, flash bang grenades, batons, tanks, LRADs, and other weapons that OPD has routinely used to quell peaceful protest. But you would be wrong. This is an ordinance that would make sticks, paint balloons, spray paint cans and makeshift shields—as well as ordinary items like water bottles and camera tripods—illegal if you happened to have them in your hands in the vicinity of a demonstration. You wouldn’t have to actually do anything illegal with these items; you could be arrested for just having them. OO’s kickass Antirepression Committee member Laleh Bahbehanian schooled the council on just how fucking ridiculous and unconstitional such an ordinance would be. Countless occupiers addressed the council, bringing potentially illegal items up to the podium with them. OO ustreamer Bella Eiko’s spectacular rant/meltdown began with a salient observation about how you can’t possibly tell the citizens of a town represented by the Oakland Raiders that they can’t have shields. Many speakers talked about how this was nothing but a distraction, another attempt to draw the attention of the press back to Occupy Oakland and away from asking nosy questions about dead black kids.
HoJo Still Doesn’t Know, And If You Ask Him Again, He Will Snatch Your Ass
Last night, on May 23, 2012, OPD held another meeting in East Oakland at Acts Full Gospel Church, near the Coliseum BART station. The purpose of this “town hall” meeting was to answer questions from the community about the killing of Alan Blueford. HoJo refused to answer people directly; instead he forced them to submit their questions in writing. He started obfuscating and telling lies right away. People began to turn their backs to him and put power fists in the air. Chris Moreland, a well-known and well-loved member of the OO Tactical Action Team, began to heckle HoJo. After less than 30 minutes of “answering questions,” HoJo and his homies decided to call an end to the meeting and leave. Chris and other occupiers and citizens continued to verbally engage the cops as they made their way out of the church down a narrow hallway. Chris is the tall guy with the bullhorn. He’s at Santa Rita Jail right now, charged with battery on an undercover officer. Eyewitnesses beg to differ. Chris wasn’t arrested on the spot; they waited until the crowd dissipated and he walked to back to the BART before they kidnapped him. He was taken away in a squad car with two cops sitting on either side of him in the back seat.
Friends of Chris have called for support at his arraignment tomorrow afternoon and at a demonstration tomorrow night. This coincides with the weekly Fuck the Police march, of which Chris was a founder. Chris’ mother, who has never attended an Occupy protest, has asked people to be respectful and avoid property damage. I think we all want to honor her wishes, but people are sad and mad and we have had it. I’ll be there tomorrow night and I’ll let you know what happens.





14 Comments

My dear hotflashcarol,
thank you for this, and may the Great Bear (or whatever you like) be with you.+ Too many HoJo\s around –and the SOB\s keep getting elected. This is tha saddest part to me.
xoxox,
(the other, Canadian) HotFlash
This is a great post, hotflashcarol, and so hard to read, knowing how adrenaline-laced you all must be continually. I do not know how you all support that; the periodic crashes must be rough as hell, and to have all of it be so community-wide must make the air fairly shimmer with outrage that bounces back and forth from history to the present….and back again. Your recognition that there are now ‘alumni’ representing the murdered speaks volumes.
A similar group is the group of murdered gay men who travel to various communities to aid the next victims in the chain of gay hate crimes.
(I keep deleting what I write; my thoughts seem so inadequate to the continuing narrative of injustice piled upon outrage spiked with an underlying knowledge of the limited power to find remedies in the face of the Oakland institutions that don’t even pretend to tell any of the truth, or be accountable.}
I’ll try later, okay?
Just keep bearing witness, hfc. The outrage meter must be getting near the “Overload” stage. Rec’d.
Thank you so much, my Canadian friend. The Great Bear suits me just fine. I wish I had something more hopeful to write about. This stuff gnaws at me if I don’t write it down. I appreciate people taking time to read it, and to care what happens here.
Oh, wendydavis, what is there to say? I’ve run out of words – it seems like I am writing the same story over and over. Actually, it doesn’t just seem like that. In today’s Chronicle, it says that there have been nine OPD officer-involved fatal shootings since May 2010 and that eight of them have involved African-American males.
The craziest thing is that in spite of our reputation as being the most radical protestors this side of Egypt, Occupy Oakland – and the community at large – keeps trying and trying and trying to work within the system, to get our elected representatives and our police chief to do something, anything. The hours spent marching in the streets are about the same as the hours spent at city council meetings and town halls and churches and courtrooms. None of it is working; something’s gotta give.
Thank you, RC. Yes, the needle is buried on that meter; you can’t even gauge it any longer. People (like me) who don’t usually attend the FTP rallies have promised to be there tonight, because this has to stop.
Howard Jordan is a notorious liar. He lies with complete confidence in his impunity, too, which gives you an idea of what sort of assurances the Oakland city administrator, the mayor, and the city council have given him. One can assume that as long as he protects their fancy selves, he’s good to go, no matter what else happens.
Thelton Henderson (I believe it was) said that Jordan was “better” and more responsive to court orders than the man he replaced, but that’s a low bar indeed.
From what I’ve seen of Jordan — his little smirk as he lies, his complete and utter contempt for the people of Oakland, his arrogance and dismissal of the people’s outrage — I’d put him in the psychopath category, right along with George W and Sheriff Joe.
With the likes of him in charge, it’s little wonder that OPD continues to run roughshod over the rights of residents and citizens, continues to abuse and murder with impunity, and continues to act as if they can get away with it forever.
As for Chris Moreland’s arrest… I’ve seen how well he handles both police harassment and civilian challenges. He’s very good at it, and he knows and observes boundaries. I cannot imagine him committing physical battery against anyone, police or not, undercover or not. But you know, people are charged with “battery” for being on the receiving end of a policeman’s rubber bullet or baton blow. People are charged with “battery” for breathing near an officer.
People are charged with “battery” in retaliation for being lippy, as Chris, bless his heart, most definitely is.
It’s a bogus charge on its face.
But again, OPD’s culture of impunity is what makes such BS charges possible.
ChePasa, that’s all exactly right. The latest news is that Chris has been charged with six counts of battery on an officer and one count of assault on an officer with a deadly weapon. There were many eyewitnesses and even those of us who were not there (I missed that meeting) know that’s not how Chris conducts himself. But who ya gonna believe, OPD or your lying eyes?
The same is true of Alan Blueford – his family and friends cannot fathom the idea of him even having a gun, much less pointing it at a cop. OPD is really good at one thing: getting their story out first and forcing people to defend themselves not just against whatever bogus charges they may be facing, but character assassination as well.
Thanks for this post, hotflashcarol. So difficult to endure yet another injustice, piled on all the other injustices and violence perpetrated by OPD and their masters. Much respect, my heart goes out to you, Occupy Oakland, and the people of Oakland.
Very moving post, thanks so much for sharing this story with us. It’s good to know the community isn’t just accepting this police behavior because it’s a lot easier to do that sometimes.
Thank you, pastfedup and GA_spoken. Your support and kind words mean a lot. The people of Oakland really do deserve better than this and I hope someday we get it. It’s not going to happen unless we demand it.
UPDATE: Chris Moreland was arraigned today in misdemeanor court. The six battery and assault on an officer charges were dropped and he was charged with plain old Disturbing the Peace. Which is still BS, but whatever. This is their MO – issue statements and press releases with inflammatory language, book people on outrageous charges, then quietly back down later. Good news for Chris, but infuriating nonetheless.
Thanks for the update, glad he was released. The false charges obviously are for the purpose of having the press and MSM spread the lies to propagandize and fool the general public. Arresting and falsely charging an individual like this ought to be made a criminal offense for which the arresting officers could themselves be criminally tried. The odds of that becoming a law imo – slim and none, unless some severe arm-twisting can be done to the lawmakers.
Yes, thanks for letting us know about Chris. I do understand why so many minorities prefer the term ‘decolonize’ to ‘Occupy’. I’m beginning to prefer it myself.
Stay strong; we’ll send all the good stuff we can through the ether, to you, and as pastfedup said, all oppressed Oaklanders.