It’s deja vu all over again.
Back in May, I wrote a diary about Alan Blueford, the African-American high school student who was murdered by Officer Miguel Masso of the Oakland Police Department. Initially, OPD said that Officer Masso and Blueford had been in a “gun battle.” That’s what Blueford’s parents were told hours after they arrived at police headquarters seeking answers. They’d been notified by Alan’s friends (as opposed to police) that their son was dead. Police informed them that their son (and the officer that he supposedly shot at) had been rushed to Highland Hospital. Those were lies. It turns out that Officer Masso shot himself in the foot. Alan was apparently left to die in the street and was never transported to the hospital. The coroner found that Alan had not fired a gun. Officer Masso’s credibility has been further undermined by revelations that he may have been hired by OPD while he was still under investigation in a civils rights lawsuit filed against him when he was a New York city cop.
On May 15, the Bluefords appeared before the Oakland City Council asking for help in finding out what had really happened to their child. Chief Jordan was missing in action and the council had no answers for the Bluefords that evening, although one of them helpfully proposed that a more efficient next-of-kin notification protocol might be in order the next time the pigs blow a black teenager to Kingdom Come.
On September 18, frustrated by more than four long months of obfuscation and stonewalling by the City and OPD, Alan’s family once again appealed to the City Council, asking them to produce the police report on Alan’s death. Once again, the council promised that Chief of Police Howard Jordan would materialize. And once again, after a “10-minute break” that lasted more than a half hour, HoJo was a no-show.
Council chambers were packed with hundreds of supporters of the Blueford family from all segments of the community, including—but by no means limited to—members of Occupy Oakland. When it became obvious that no police report was forthcoming, the crowd began to chant, “Where’s Howard Jordan?” The council attempted to reconvene and introduce the next item, which was a resolution to name Oakland as an “International City of Peace.” Although the irony may have been lost on the council, it was not lost on the crowd. The next chant became the familiar standby: “No justice, no peace.” Council president Larry Reid abruptly adjourned the meeting, leaving the Blueford family without answers and the remainder of city business undone. A few days later, OPD leaked a “new” report that Alan Blueford’s fingerprints had been found on a gun at the scene. The Blueford family quickly responded, saying that OPD was continuing to slander their son and that the timing of the leak was suspicious and self-serving, given OPD’s ongoing inability to produce a police report.
The Bluefords and their supporters—in particular, members of the interfaith community—have vowed to return to the next city council meeting on Tuesday, October 2nd. Anticipating that another large crowd of people might show up and demand accountability from their elected representatives, City Administrator Deanna Santana is attempting to limit the number of people allowed to attend the meeting. In a series of off-the-record meetings with other high-level city officials, Ms. Antoinette Santana has proposed that the balcony area of the chambers be closed, reducing the current 214 seats by about half. She also wants to bar citizens from standing in the chambers or congregating immediately outside the doors, which has been a longstanding tradition. Instead, overflow crowds would be diverted to rooms with video feeds (and, of course, no access to the council members safely ensconced in chambers with a manageable group of 100 or so).
Edited to add this lovely bit of doublespeak:
“The primary goal is to make sure the city’s business moves forward and the public has a chance to participate in the political process,” city spokeswoman Karen Boyd said.
You can imagine how Oakland is reacting to this latest fascist fantasy dreamed up by the gang that brought you Scott Olsen. Stay tuned for an update on Tuesday.



34 Comments

My friend and fellow Oakland Radical Jan Gilbrecht has some great ideas on how to clean up this mess.
What in the hell is the matter with these people?!
Do you suppose the City Council is afraid of the PD? That’s hideous, but maybe not the dumbest question I’ve ever asked.
RaggMopp, I don’t think it’s a stupid question. Councilmember Rebecca Kaplan is now under fire from the cops because she may (or may not) have said that hiring officers like Masso is like moving Catholic priests from one parish to another. I think it’s a combination of fear and incompetence. Deanna Santana and Howard Jordan seem to be thick as thieves, however.
I felt so very bad for this young man and his family when it first became news last spring. And now to read that it is dragging on, with so many questions unanswered and no justice for the family, my outrage again is about to erupt.
How dare the City Council cater to the Oakland Police!?! That COuncil is the biggest bunch of cowards. From the reports I remember, it seemed like this young man was shot in the back, while the police chased him.
I usually try to remind myself that police are only human beings working a tough job, but I put the Oakland police right up there with the LA police in terms of how scarey they are, and how often they do nothing but pick on people.
Yes, elisemattu, OPD ranks right up there (or maybe down there) with LA and the Oakland City Council obviously has no control over them.
How do you shoot yourself in the foot when shooting at someone else? In the army people shot themselves in the foot to avoid combat maybe officer Masso knowing he was facing a lawsuit wanted a disability payday? Can disability pay be taken away in a lawsuit? If not then then he had motive to shoot himself in the foot and blame someone else.
If not my next theory is that he was drunk or high after all policemen get trained to shoot a gun this was not an accident.
Police stick together yes but this seems excessive just how did this cop get hired with a lawsuit pending does he have political friends or relatives in Oakland and the police dept?
Also good questions, Things. Supposedly Masso was chasing Alan and Alan shot at him and he shot back and shot himself in the foot – at least I believe that was one version of this ever-changing story. They have covered up and/or withheld evidence for so long that we may never know the truth. Now Santana’s trying to limit the number of people who are even allowed an audience with the council. It’s beyond shameful.
Ah, Oakland…you great City of Peace!
I was going to ask if OPD going into federal receivership were still on the docket, but I did follow a lot of links, and discovered the answer is ‘yes’, and that decision will be made in December.
Alan Blueford’s prints on a gun were suddenly discovered?
Police stick together yes but this seems excessive just how did this cop get hired with a lawsuit pending does he have political friends or relatives in Oakland and the police dept?
A Supplemental Needs Trust (sometimes called a Special Needs Trust) is a specialized legal document designed to benefit an individual who has a disability. A Supplemental Needs Trust is most often a “stand alone” document, but it can form part of a Last Will and Testament. Supplemental Needs Trusts have been in use for many years, and were given an “official” legal status by the United States Congress in 1993.
A Supplemental Needs Trust enables a person under a physical or mental disability, or an individual with a chronic or acquired illness, to have, held in Trust for his or her benefit, an unlimited amount of assets. In a properly-drafted Supplemental Needs Trust, those assets are not considered countable assets for purposes of qualification for certain governmental benefits.
Such benefits may include Supplemental Security Income (SSI), Medicaid, vocational rehabilitation, subsidized housing, and other benefits based upon need. For purposes of a Supplemental Needs Trust, an individual is considered impoverished if his or her personal assets are less than $2,000.00.
Although there are Medicaid rules that say that the Trust cannot be used for housing or food, these rules have to be interpreted carefully. For example, there is no restriction on purchasing an accessible home or making accessibility adaptations to an existing home and having the Trust own or pay for them. Likewise, although foodstuffs are not strictly allowable under the rules, social events such as dinner parties are; likewise, vacations and entertainments are permitted.
Just as importantly, Trust funds are not subject to creditors or seizure. Therefore, if the disabled beneficiary should ever be sued in a personal injury or other type of lawsuit, the beneficiary is not a “deep pocket” because monies placed in the Trust are not subject to a judgment.
http://www.nsnn.com/frequently.htm
My bold Officer Masso I am willing to bet has talked to a lawyer about how to protect his assets he just needed to be disabled. Officer Masso set up this shooting to protect his assets from lawsuits.
I deserve extra points for digging this information:)
Just what kind of Clout does this guy have that the police chief and city council are both willing to take bullets for him? Is he protected by the Prince of Freakin Darkness himself?
Who is he related too? has blackmail on, is blowing, I have not seen this level of coverup since Mayor Daley’s Nephew killed that guy in Chicago.
http://www.eastbayexpress.com/ebx/oakland-police-officer-involved-shooting-of-alan-blueford-raises-questions/Content?oid=3295686
How do you get hired with torture on your resume?
http://www.eastbayexpress.com/ebx/oakland-police-officer-involved-shooting-of-alan-blueford-raises-questions/Content?oid=3295686
There is no way proper procedure was used to hire this guy someone interceded and decided to ignore proper hiring procedure. Just what is procedure to hire someone as a policeman in Oakland? That information would I am sure reveal a bunch of snark worthy comments.
Torture aside this guy was a walking lawsuit waiting to happen someone with Godfather clout interceded.
The leak about Alan’s fingerprints on the gun came out in an SF Chronicle political gossip column rather than during the council meeting or as any sort of official announcement from OPD. From that link, a quote from an unnamed law enforcement official: “There is no willingness (in Oakland) to accept any amount of (police) force.” Um, yeah, you might say that, Mistah Protect and Serve. This has been an ongoing concern in a community where the cops like to beat and cage and kill people, especially young people of color.
Yes, you do get extra points for looking into all that! It’s astonishing that a police department — under threat of Federal receivership for behavior similar to what Masso’s accused of — would hire him. I’m not surprised that they’re protecting him now. They are probably hoping this all just ends up in another civil settlement that the taxpayers can cover for them.
And speaking of taxpayers footing the bill, here is another outrage. I’m all for protecting pensions in most cases but this is ridiculous when cities are going bankrupt.
Thank you, hfc, for this excellent diary. I am really becoming concerned about the degree of militarization of police forces, everywhere. Mr. Blue has noticed a lot of military “mobile command posts” (that is what he sees painted on the sides of these small buildings) being transported over the last couple of years. He’s also noticed that military conveys now travel in much smaller conveys (he supposes to not attract attention), and that there is an increase in “private carrier” transport of said military vehicles, equipment and mobile police units (command posts, etc.).
Sorry, didn’t mean to veer OT. There sure seems to be a pattern developing in which police are “shooting to kill” much more prolifically than then did at one time. What happened to the days when a policeman shot a suspect or even known assailant in the leg to simply stop them, in order to arrest them and let the judicial system decide their fate? And, I understand that this situation is even worse or more heinous, than the one that I just described. (Unfortunately, my screwed up DSL connection keeps me from viewing the video, at this time, but I look forward to watching it later.)
Love your enthusiasm. Brought a smile to my face when you said “. . . fellow Oakland Radical . . .” Heck, most people won’t even self-identify as “liberal.” Good for you. And please do post an update.
Highly recommended.
Blue
ThingsComeUndone–
Thanks for the info about the Supplemental Needs Trust (or, Special Needs Trust).
This legal instrument would not apply to immediate family, but it could be helpful to a couple of friends.
Thanks again.
Blue
A demonstrated willingness to torture and brutalize could actually be considered a useful qualification if that’s a good fit with routine department procedure. If orders come down to street level that might require such behavior, you want someone who has proven they won’t balk or go soft when it comes time. Someone the brass can trust to do the job.
Thanks Blue. The militarization of our local police forces is certainly not very far off topic. It’s just another step in the process of turning regular citizens into enemies of the police, instead of community members they’ve been sworn to protect – i.e., someone they might try NOT to kill even if they feel threatened. The video is just the trailer for the 1984 movie; I bet you’ve seen it before. It’s the first thing I thought of when I heard about Santana’s machinations – those giant screens where we get fed our daily propaganda from the oligarchs.
You are welcome :)
I agree but this is illegal so while yes a torture loving cop might be considered an asset by the police a cop who has gotten caught doing this does have a bullseye painted on him for future lawsuits.
The police may think tax payers are on the hook if a rogue cop gets caught and they are scott free but in this economy a lawsuit very well might lead to layoffs of cops and at the very least a hiring freeze.
I wonder if Officer Masso and other cops who shoot unarmed people are war vets and maybe have military records that showed they did similar things in Iraq and Afghanistan? Or maybe they were Blackwater Mercs and did even worse if I were the family of Alan Blueford I would be asking if he served in combat in the military or as a Merc and try and find his service record to see if he did similar things during wartime.
For either Officer Masso is a psychopath and got through police screening ( I assume there is some kind of psych screening to be a cop) or he learned this behavior during war.
Any word on how the Feds are viewing this case if anything this should push them to take over the police dept.
TCU–
You say, “I wonder if Officer Masso and other cops who shoot unarmed people are war vets and maybe have military records that showed they did similar things in Iraq and Afghanistan? Or maybe they were Blackwater Mercs and did even worse.”
Ditto.
Further, I wonder (especially lately) with the “rash of disgruntled employee/employer shootings,” if more than a few of these folks haven’t served in one of our many wars. (In no way, am I intending to disparage or vilify our service members. Worked many years for the DOD, Dept of Army and Dept of Air Force, as a civilian. Just want to make that clear.)
No doubt the increased pressure of “record unemployment” (in my lifetime, anyway) could cause an escalation of violence, but I would not be surprised if part of the mix was a military combat background. (I think that we could depend on our crack “lamestream media” to play this type of background down, if it were so.)
Blue
There have already been layoffs and hiring freezes in Oakland; the police department’s response time to serious emergencies was more than 10 minutes a few months ago (I haven’t checked into it more recently but I can’t imagine it’s gotten any better). They are spread way too thin. Their jobs are scary and stressful. None of that makes it OK for them to kill people, especially in situations like Blueford’s which appears to have been a “stop and frisk” of a group of black teenagers hanging on a street corner in East Oakland committing no crimes. Somehow that just doesn’t happen as often to groups of white kids in other parts of Oakland. Hmmmmmmm.
I don’t know what percentage of OPD or other police forces are vets, but I know that question comes up all the time. This story is cause for concern:
Further, I wonder (especially lately) with the “rash of disgruntled employee/employer shootings,” if more than a few of these folks haven’t served in one of our many wars.
I bet they also listen to Right Wing Hate radio and joined White Power groups in the army. I agree most army people are not psychos but the army did ease up on who got in the army during the Afghan and Iraq wars. Raven used to rant about this happening in Viet Nam.
Only then is was education they eased up on these days crooks gang members and White Power types were let in.
Police brutality numbers should rise the Vets need peaceful non stressful jobs not more stress in urban war zones.
But they’re perfectly suited for urban war zones. Shoot first, ask questions later. It’s a Brave New World, for sure . . .
http://www.eastbayexpress.com/ebx/deanna-santana-tried-to-alter-damning-report/Content?oid=3341245
Thanks, tambershall. I know about that. Nobody has clean hands in this debacle, least of all Santana. She is quite a piece of work.
OPD has a loooooooong history of police violence. It has never been cleaned up. Years ago I worked in the security dept of a major hospital in San Francisco. I used to hear all kinds of stories about both the SF and Oakland police being murderous and cruel. I have witnesses the cruel part personally. It certainly won’t be cleaned up now that the one percenters are running a little scared.
This isn’t just Oakland. Police are out of control all over the country. Big egos (are weak egos) drunk w/ power and no accountability. The press rides teachers, but most cops can barely read. They have difficulty filling out forms comprised of check boxes. All reports follow scripted formulas.
Heck, my father died as a result of injuries sustained in a car accident in 1998, when the car he was driving was hit by a cop on his way to a bogus crime scene. My family lost the criminal hearing, but won the civil suit when the dispatch tape (which was non-existent for the criminal hearing) clearly showed there was no call, which was the cop’s primary defense.
You wanna know police out of control? The cop in question is STILL on the force, is STILL causing problems within the force.
This isn’t limited to Oakland. Only a lunatic would want to go out and defend a community with weaponry that is far exceeded by that of the criminals. That’s what many in the police force are, today. The police get handguns; the criminals have Uzis.