A protest at the Fruitvale BART station in Oakland. Flickr photo courtesy of Michael Mees.
Updated to add: Fruitvale just won both the Grand Jury Prize (“the big enchilada, as the announcer said) and the Audience Award for U.S. Dramatic film at the Sundance Awards!
On Democracy Now this morning, Amy Goodman interviewed filmmaker Ryan Coogler about his debut film, Fruitvale, which tells the story of the murder of Oscar Grant by a BART police officer. The film stars Michael B. Jordan as Oscar and Octavia Spencer as Oscar’s mother, Wanda, and was produced by Forest Whitaker, among others. The movie has been a standout at the Sundance Film Festival. It reportedly was the subject of a bidding war; distribution rights were acquired by the Weinstein Company, which means that it should be playing in a movie theater near you later this year.
The two short clips that Amy Goodman showed during the interview, along with Coogler’s description of what it was like to make this movie, left me in tears. It reminded me that Oscar’s death is still an open wound that will never heal until Oakland stops marginalizing and brutalizing and killing young men of color. I’ve written fairly extensively about Oscar and police brutality in Oakland. This is one of the first FDL diaries I ever wrote, in anticipation of the Mehserle verdict back in July 2010 (which would turn out to be involuntary manslaughter instead of murder). This diary was written a year ago, on the third anniversary of Oscar’s death.
Ryan Coogler, the filmmaker whose day job is counselor at a San Francisco juvenile detention center, was compelled to make this movie because in the cell phone videos of the murder, Oscar was the same age as Coogler and “looked like he could have been any one of us.” And because he was angry and frustrated; the killing of an unarmed black man by police was, unfortunately, nothing new to Coogler as an African-American resident of the East Bay. Fruitvale (named after the BART station where Oscar was killed) begins with those cell phone videos and then flashes back to what Oscar was doing earlier that day.
I’ve read a lot of reviews of the movie; some of them focus on the fact that Oscar is portrayed in such a positive light. For those of us who are Friday Night Lights fans, the casting of Michael B. Jordan as Oscar is genius. For me, he’s a good match for the Oscar Grant that I have concocted in my head. I didn’t know Oscar, and it’s tempting to turn Oscar into some larger-than-life person. He wasn’t. But he was loved by his family and friends. He was Tatiana’s dad and Wanda’s son and Uncle Bobby’s nephew—we do know Oscar’s family now, because they have become tireless advocates for justice, not just for Oscar but for every victim of police brutality. Oscar was a young man who was trying to make the most of a hard day that New Year’s Eve and he did not deserve to be shot in the back on that cold fucking BART platform by a monster like Mehserle. If this movie does nothing else, perhaps it will help people to see that the cops are not always right, or righteous, and that until we really hold them accountable for these young lives they’ve taken, they’ll keep shooting first and asking questions later, as they did with Oscar and as they did in the case of Alan Blueford.
Unfortunately, the Oakland Police Department doesn’t seem to have any intention of changing its ways. Alan Blueford’s father, Adam, was back in front of the Oakland City Council this past Tuesday. Mr. Blueford was speaking out against the hiring of superpig and global security mogul William Bratton by OPD as part of a $250,000 consulting package. Bratton is worthy of a whole ‘nother diary, but suffice it to say that the last thing Oakland needs is more outsiders encouraging their cops to Stop & Frisk.
Police Chief Howard Jordan promised that racial profiling would not be a part of OPD policy. Nobody believed him, least of all OO livestreamer Bella Eiko/Jessica Hollie (below), who was another of the more than 200 people who addressed the City Council about Bratton during that marathon session on Tuesday. At 2 AM, the council voted 7-1 in favor of hiring Bratton. (The video that Jessica is referring to but that never makes it onscreen at the meeting is this one.)




40 Comments

Stealth rec’d for now, hotflashcarol.
Thanks, wendydavis.
This definitely sounds like a Monday night film thingamajig (forget what they’re called)
Recommended
Oh, that’s a good idea. There isn’t even a trailer yet, and I don’t know how long it will be before it’s available in theaters. But I am definitely looking forward to it.
Sorry to go off topic, but you’ll probably like this
http://www.neatorama.com/2013/01/24/Photographing-a-Giant-Sequoia/
I do like that, thanks! It’s pretty amazing to see the whole tree.
Rec’d, thank you hotflashcarol. I’m looking forward to seeing this film and hope millions of Americans see it when it hits theaters nationwide. Elevating public awareness of police brutality in all of its forms, especially the use of tasers, is very important.
Thank you, hotflashcarol, for staying on this story and for your diary (Diaries). The video clip at the end brings it all to life, heartbreaking that after such testimony only one counselor on the panel voted against spending funds needed to help the community in this manner. Shame on them.
Thanks for posting this, hotflashcarol. You are the one who originally opened my eyes to what happened to Oscar.
Yes, Isaiah; that was part of Mehserle’s defense. He said he had meant to grab his taser and grabbed his gun instead. Jury verdict aside, most people did not buy that. Tasers present a whole other set of issues, primarily because they give cops one more way to torture people.
Thank you, juliania. Jessica’s testimony transfixed us all because we know that she is sincere. She’s been out there documenting all of this police brutality for a long time. The one city councilwoman who voted against Bratton had been kicked off the Oakland Coliseum Board by the other councilpeople earlier in the meeting. The cynic in me wonders if she voted against Bratton just to stick it to them.
If not for those cell phone videos, Oscar would never have come to light. The police could have gotten out in front of it the way they always do, by lying about what happened and blaming the victim. FTP – Film the Police!
Thank you, hotflashcarol!!!
Recommended.
DW
Thanks, hotflashcarol. Watched Amy’s interview yesterday. I’ll be looking for that film to go into distribution for the general public, a must-see!
Recommended.
Thanks, DW and pastfedup. I just read that it is a nominee for the Sundance Grand Jury Award, which will be announced tonight. I am keeping my fingers crossed!
wow! Bella/Jessica really threw some zingers at the city council, bet those left a mark!! God for her!
She rocks. I was very impressed with what she had to say. She is well-known to the city council; I think they all put their helmets on when they see her approach the podium.
When Amy played the scene of Tatiana talking with her father about her fears for herself and Oscar I had to put down my paintbrush and cry in grief for a world where an innocent child must worry about such violence and the willingness of humans to treat each other so.
Sometimes seems like Oakland has had way more than it’s share of such evil. Thanks, hotflashcarol for helping us to stay aware of this heart rending story.
Hope it wins the award tonite.
Rec’d.
Thank you. That part made me cry, too, especially because I’ve watched the real Tatiana grow bigger and stronger and more beautiful at the annual memorials for Oscar, and because I have also been scared of the “fireworks” on New Year’s Eve in Oakland. It’s remarkable that the filmmaker was able to get such wonderful actors – including Octavia Spencer, who just won an Oscar – to star in this movie. Hopefully that will get people to watch it, despite the fact that it will obviously be a tearjerker.
Good to know I wasn’t the only one driven to tears by this segment of Amy Goodman.
It’s unfortunate that a fictionalized account had to be made to get this the attention it deserves. People in Oakland have been begging and pleading and making poignant and heartfelt speeches like Bella’s for years about Oscar and many, many other young people who have been the victims of brutal and unconstitutional policing. But the mayor and the city council people don’t cry; they often don’t even pay attention because they’re too busy texting on their phones or out of the room entirely. Oakland needs somebody to listen. Thank you for listening.
Wow, Bill Bratton? What a horrible decision. Lives will be lost. People will die. All because this servant-to-fascists is coming to Oakland. That’s just awful news. He’s got nothing that city needs, nothing at all.
You’re absolutely right. I want to write another diary about Bratton but it requires a lot more research. My hunch is that it’s way more than a bandaid for all the gun violence that has been plaguing Oakland. Bratton’s connected to all sorts of Homeland Security and private global risk venture firms. It wouldn’t be the first time that Oakland was a testing ground for domestic warfare. The next protest is always right around the corner and the generalized violence gets people prepared for the police to crack down on us hooligans.
oh god
Book Salon up with Michaela Walsh’s Founding a Movement: Women’s World Banking, 1975-1990 hosted by Bethany McLean
Bill Bratton:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_J._Bratton
I hope you do that diary, hotflashcarol. If you do it, then it will be read and appreciated.
Some serious further information on the city council members is also necessary.
DW
I look forward to your diary. This man must be exposed, and Oakland must be warned. Danger is coming. Your comment about his associations, and entanglements with global state violence, is right on. We know the state experiments in Oakland because the media won’t cover Oakland violence because, well, Blah people don’t matter.
This is very scary. Thanks for covering this. And for the heads-up about the movie. I’m going to be sure Lisa Derrick knows about it, maybe we can get the director to come for a Movie Night some Monday!
It is my hope that ,”Fruitvale” and “Dirty Wars”, might become the two most influential films at this year’s Sundance Film Festival. Both address fundamental societal issues, that might be, somehow, related.
DW
A bit more on Bratton:
http://www.kroll.com/library/WilliamBrattonBIO.pdf
He certainly is admired … in certain circles …
DW
Bratton??? I missed that
He’s the one who led the UC Davis pepper spray
coverupinvestigationWe are all indeed Oscar Grants.
A friend, many years my junior, told me he was having an art opening for a group of artist friends, back in 2002-2003. They had gotten a good deal on an Oakland hall, and were planning a festive celebration. “Don’t do it,” sez I. “Why not?” he asks, clearly puzzled. “We can’t get a hall for such a good price anywhere else but Oakland.” And not understanding me, he added, “The people of Oakland are like people anywhere. They won’t threaten us.” I replied: “I’m not worried about the people of Oakland. It’s the police.”
Sadly I was right. The cops came in and busted up the gathering, for unspecified reasons. Being artistic after dark, or some such.
If you want to hit on Bratton’s UC Davis angle I can probably point you to some people to talk to. Maybe it won’t be that much, but then again …
Thanks everyone, I will definitely do a Bratton diary. There is a ton of stuff to look at (somehow I missed that he did the UC pepper spray investigation; the man is EVERYWHERE). A lot of my Facebook friends posted all kinds of links about Bratton that I need to check out. There was one speaker at the City Council meeting who listed a whole bunch of issues of concern about Bratton’s background; he suggested that stop & frisk was a red herring. That caught my interest, although I don’t necessarily agree that it’s a red herring; I think it’s more like the tip of the iceberg.
Thanks, Teddy. I’ll try to keep an eye on it and figure out when it’s actually available to the public.
In the meantime, another film of interest for Lisa might be The Waiting Room, a documentary about 24 hours at Highland Hospital in Oakland. You might already be familiar with it.
Also looking forward to seeing Dirty Wars, thanks for the reminder.
Thank you for staying on this hotflashcarol. I look forward to the film. As always, I will continue to look forward to your diaries.
Having been raised in and lived in the East Bay, (’59-’04) I can tell you that OPD has been out of control for decades. It breaks my heart that Jerry Brown did not clean that shit up when he was mayor. You sre correct in your assertion that ther it will not change until merderers are held accountable.
A quote from the announcement of the Sundance Film Festival Grand Jury award:
As I mentioned in the update, Fruitvale also won the Audience Award.
What telling the truth about this all war all the time everywhere from small town to the entire planet culture driven by money and desperate clinging to power has brought us gets awards at film festivals. It gets international journalism awards. It gets other kudos, too.
I wish it also gave me more hope.
Thanks, hotflashcarol.
There is also a short interview with Ryan Coogler on the Sundance site here talking about the film:
http://www.sundance.org/video/meet-the-artists-13-ryan-coogler/
wow. very powerful posting and video.
highly rec’d to everyone.