[Ed. note: Here's an important personal reminder of the toll that anti-gay electoral politics and policies have taken on fellow citizens.]
By late 2004, I was out of my parents’ house. I’d just barely gotten the hell out of there not even a full year before. And I was happy to leave. Flash back two years to 2002. By that time, 9/11 had happened, yet instead of going after Osama bin Laden everyone was discussing war with Iraq. You know this already. I lived with my very conservative, very religious family. And they were all ready to blow the fuck out of some innocents. Needless to say, they didn’t like it when I became very active against the war. They didn’t like that I talked about it all the time. They didn’t like when I’d go to school wearing pins and stickers saying "How many Iraqis per gallon?" and other slogans.
I’m telling you this so you know I was already on their bad side. My stepdad hated me. I mean that. He actually hated me. He threatened to kill me… but we’ll get to that later. At the time, he was just mad because I’m a crippled intellectual type instead of a "manly" man who goes out and does yard work all day.
Flash forward a year, I outed myself as gay.
Actually, I didn’t even really out myself as gay to my parents. I’m not that stupid. No, instead, I wrote a letter to a friend telling them all about it because it was killing me. I couldn’t keep it in anymore. Well, the pillow your head sleeps on at night is not a good hiding place for a letter, it turns out. My stepdad came home drunk the night I wrote it, and it had slipped out of the pillow. He read it. . . .
From that point on, until I moved out, my life was hell. I couldn’t tolerate anything. I’d just gotten paralyzed a year and a half before this happened, you know? I spent an entire year just making my family feel better about my paralysis. I had to work to get them through my problems. I’d subsequently lost all my friends post-paralysis, except those who were friends with me through my cousin. I lost my friends because my paralysis made some of them "question God". It made others just plain uncomfortable around me.
Anyway, I had a rough time. My mother informed me that I was not "allowed" to "be that way" in her home. She asked how I could do that to God. She said she didn’t know if she could love me the same. My stepdad, who hated me enough already, openly called me queer and faggot all the time. Just to try to get under my skin. Then he threatened to kill me. I left some dirty clothes on the floor. He said if I ever did it again I wouldn’t wake up in the morning. When he and mom fought, he’d threaten to leave her, and he’d always mention I "thought I was queer".
My conservative Republican parents bought into all the anti-gay lies. They believed every bit of propaganda they ever heard. They listened to Limbaugh and others who were boldly discussing their hatred for gays.
By 2003, gay people had started to become a wedge issue. This was while I still lived at home. In fear of being killed. All alone and friendless. With no support. And then these people in this Republican party started to demonize gays. This was discussed in our household – before and after the outing incident. My parents called around asking about different mental hospitals or "conversion camps" where she could send me to change or just disappear. Eventually, when she started getting return phone calls, I told her it was a phase. Who wouldn’t?
I was stuck in my home, living in fear of my parents. Sitting with them, tensely watching some Republican politicians and party leaders talk about how disgusting gays are. Listening to my parents talk about how right Falwell and Dobson were to blame 9/11 on the fags and women. This was what my teenage life was like.
And you know I owe it to people like Ken Mehlman. This guy helped engineer the vicious anti-gay campaign that started sometime around 2003, so it could be fully developed by the 2004 election in which eleven or so marriage amendments passed in states. In 2006, another crop of amendments passed, including in my state, Alabama. This guy didn’t back off from using fear-based rhetoric. He didn’t tone any of his words or his mailers down. He and his party were as disgusting as ever and they hurt people. I spent so many years of my life being scared, not of what someone might think, but of actual death. At the very least, actual hospitalization for something that did not deserve it.
I didn’t start coming out to most people til I was twenty. And not to my parents (again) til I was twenty-one. I couldn’t, though. I live in a conservative area. I was going through all of this during a time when people were stoking the dangerous fears of uneducated and ignorant people. Hate crimes increased. After I finally moved out, a kid was killed about fifteen minutes from where I live just for being gay. I knew people brave enough to come out in high school who had their cars and houses trashed on a regular basis. When gay people talk about coming out of the closet, it’s not all easy or safe.
To hear Ken Mehlman tell it, though, all he needed was a direct phone call to the former President of the United States, and a press team to field inquiries about his revelation. Mehlman will never have to face the consequences I had to face. Or others whose fate was much worse. People died for this. People were tortured for this. The guy who was killed near me? He was beaten, stabbed and burned to death by "friends" who lived with him.
While I’m glad that Mehlman has had such a good time with his coming out, and while I await his best-selling book, the profits of which will no doubt never fill the coffers of pro-gay organizations, it is not the same for all of us. And our pain and our struggles can be directly linked to his actions. And he doesn’t care. He offers no sympathy, no apology.
He, like any other Republican, is not in the business of identifying with everyday Americans. He’s not interested in connecting with us, nor is he interested in hearing what hurts us. They live inside a bubble in which the only thing that matters is their self-interest. They are out of touch. He risked nothing coming out. He was never in any real danger. In fact, it’s probably only opportunism which is causing him to come out now. He’s probably being paid handsomely by the GOP to make them look more gay friendly, after they learned that the electorate is increasingly gay friendly.
These people are monsters who just don’t give a fuck about you. They never have, they never will. I’ll stand by the real LGBT community’s side against people like him every day of my life.



28 Comments




It ain’t like Mhelman even has the decency to ask for forgiveness for all the harm that he has done. He expects people to welcome him in his hour of need.
Unfortunately your personal experience with coming out is not very unusual. It is the kind of pain that so many people have to go through. One of the biggest outrages about it is that so often the worst of the pain is inflicted by the family on whose love and support you should be able to count.
Yep and let’s not forget what he actually said about his coming out:
Seriously, it was very “difficult” for him not to say who he was “in public life.” I had sleepless nights for two years, terrified that someone would snap, or someone would search my room again, or some friend would turn on me and tell my mom everything. And this guy had to deal with… not being able to go to the press about being gay.
PS. I contacted AFER about this. They are being very nice to this guy. These are the people who spent weeks in a trial talking about how the stigmatization of gays leads to suicide, depression, drug use and other things and makes us unstable and now they’re embracing the guy who expanded the use of the closet and inflicted horrors on gays.
I was pretty polite in my email, because that’s just who I am, but I’m really upset with AFER. I gave them money.
This reminds me of the way Rachel Maddow has spoken of being a teenager and watching Pat Buchanan’s Repulican convention speech about the culture war, how she felt personally attacked by his rhetoric.
When Ken Mehlman admits that he has the blood of suicides and hate crimes on his hands, then, maybe then, he can be admitted to polite society to begin an apology that will last the rest of his life. He is despicable.
Yeah so far he’s not admitting anything.
Actually, he has apparently done an interview with The Advocate. Right after I finish reading their piece on the Pentagon agreeing to meet with partners of gay soldiers I’m going to read his interview and see if he offers any sort of apology. Not holding my breath though.
Brilliant essay, as usual, indie. Thanks for this. Hopefully it will get some traction.
I hope so too. I know that some of the prominent posters on this site are gay so they’ll probably at least read it if they don’t necessarily like it. Also thanks!
I’ll be sharing it around Facebook, Twitter and my own blog this evening.
get this crossposted! Great stuff as always indie. thanks.
And those of us who aren’t gay are going to read it, too. It’s important to hear how the repression of a minority has directly impacted individuals, so that the majority understands what needs to be fixed and how to make it right (although it will never be completely right save for those who are born into a just and free society of the future).
Thanks for being here and sharing.
Thanks!
To the GLBT blog? Okay I will. I just wrote something else for my blog (I’m tireless lately) so I’ll cross post THIS to the GLBT blog and then in a couple hours I’ll cross post this to my own blog.
Quite a rough road you’ve travelled. You’ve paved the way for others with so much more courage that this guy, who had access to resources that you didn’t have, and he won’t make a dent of a difference. And he has Ann Coulter to help him come out now. His is no story of courage.
That’s almost enough punishment for me to let up on the guy, haha.
Indie, I applaud your bravery in the face of such ruthless anger and hate. I hope that your world today is filled with good things. We stand with you.
Thanks! I’ve been on my own for so long that I think my family is regretting treating me the way they did. We still talk and everything, they just know I’m into dudes. They don’t really share their opinion either way about it.
I’m a pastor, and I’ve done funerals for folks who committed suicide rather than endure what you went through. I’m glad you didn’t go that route, and doubly glad you shared this story here.
Mehlman is clueless as to what his work at the WH and RNC did to so many people. If the enormity of that ever sinks in with him, he’s going to have a helluva lot harder time coming to grips with his political past than he did coming to grips with his sexual orientation.
I’m glad you survived and got out of what sounds like a very hostile, dysfunctional and dangerous home situation. :)
Good to see you here indie. I’m registered over at teh Orange, and read you quite often, but never comment due to the sewage over there.
I wonder if they’ll start calling you “firepants.” LOL!
the cowardice of guys like Mehlman is one thing…the hypocrisy and cynicism is another. Mehlman is from my generation – Gen X. None of my high school friends who were gay came out until college – the stigma of being gay was palpable during the mid 80′s in Texas. Had they come out their junior or senior years they would have faced some real ugliness from their classmates, if not actual violence. When they found support in college, or grew up enough to accept themselves for who they were and not what someone else wanted them to be -the choice of living a life without secrets and lies was real easy for them to make.
Guys like Mehlman and Larry Craig never had the guts to be who they were; they were always trying to be what someone else wanted them to be. Compromising yourself like that leads to further compromise until your moral center is no more, and you can advocate for truly evil things like Mehlman’s Republican Party did and not think twice about it. Intellectually they knew what they were doing when they tried to drive yet another wedge between folks who can respect the dignity of others – no matter their differences – and those who can’t.
Heh. Firepants.
Well I don’t like to brag, but…
Yep. It’s not about morality with people like that. It’s about opportunism. They’re completely disengaged from emotional attachments to society, community or any sense of a morality that binds us all. And yet they proclaim their faux morality every day when they say that those of us who are gay are the immoral ones.
Thanks! I had to take a break. I’m going through a lot of things in my personal life, and while I can take criticism of my writing, the rhetoric gets way too harsh over there sometimes. When I’m feeling normal, I have a thick skin (try being a crippled gay guy in south Alabama, haha) but right now, the truth is I’m just not feeling like myself.
Thanks, I’m glad I escaped too. They’re still just as dysfunctional, which is funny. In fact I just found out the other day some things people have lied to me about. I’m so glad I don’t have to see them daily.
Thank you for this, and thanks for the empathy and understanding. To be honest, I was suicidal for a long time, in my teens. I was convinced I was going to hurt myself, and then, I just didn’t. The scary part was that back then I didn’t have a reason not to. I just… decided against it. These days I’m doing much better and I almost never have suicidal thoughts anymore, though I do deal with some pretty severe anxiety and depression.
I REALLY loved your last sentence, a whole lot. That is exactly my entire issue with this whole admission. He seems to think the part of him that’s gay is the bad part. No, it’s not. It’s not even “bad” that he chose not to tell anyone for 43 years. I try not to judge people dealing with things in their own ways (though I think more people should just effing come out already.) What’s bad is his participation in a belief system which perpetuates all of this hatred and which prolongs the feeling that gay people need to be closeted, and need to be subjected to this torment. And he’s never going to repent for that. I can’t give him a pat on the back.
Great piece! Frankly, I think that forgiveness is often over-rated. There may be a time for that later on, but certainly not before Mehlman has exhibited some decent signs of remorse, which, so far, he has not.
Thank you so much for posting this here.
I know it is important to heal anger by forgiving those people like Mehlman. But I feel like KarenM, forgiveness is over-rated when we know that people DIED directly as a result of his heinous behavior, actions, strategerizing, etc.
I hope he is confronted about this in person, sometime when he is on David Letterman or somewhere else promoting his book. Fucker.