Over six and a half years have elapsed since March, 2003, but much information has become available in the past year to help us reconstruct a number of important events that month. The evidence points convincingly to a conscious decision by the Bush administration to engage in overwhelming use of torture in a last-ditch attempt to provide another false justification for a war which was still launched, even as the justification then in use also was being shown to be false.
When the OLC memos authorizing torture were released last April, one of the biggest stories to emerge was that Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was waterboarded 183 times in March, 2003, as discovered originally by Marcy Wheeler. Noting that March, 2003 also was the month of the US invasion of Iraq, the question then arose whether KSM was waterboarded in an attempt to extract a confessed link between 9/11 and Saddam. There now is significant information to allow a "yes" answer to that question.
As McClatchy discovered in the Senate Armed Services Committee report, Major Charles Burney confirmed to investigators that interrogators at Guanatanamo were under pressure to produce a link between al Qaeda and Iraq:
A former U.S. Army psychiatrist, Maj. Charles Burney, told Army investigators in 2006 that interrogators at the Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, detention facility were under "pressure" to produce evidence of ties between al Qaida and Iraq.
"While we were there a large part of the time we were focused on trying to establish a link between al Qaida and Iraq and we were not successful in establishing a link between al Qaida and Iraq," Burney told staff of the Army Inspector General. "The more frustrated people got in not being able to establish that link . . . there was more and more pressure to resort to measures that might produce more immediate results."
It is not too big a stretch to suggest that if the Guantanamo interrogators were under such pressure, then KSM’s interrogators at the black site where he was waterboarded were under similar pressure. In fact, further support for this idea is found in the CIA OIG Report released in August. On pages 112 to 113 in that large pdf file, we learn of instructions to interrogators at black sites:
Agency officers report that reliance on analytical assessments that were unsupported by credible intelligence may have resulted in the application of EITs without justification. Some participants in the Program, particularly field interrogators, judge that CTC assessments to the effect that detainees are withholding information are not always supported by an objective evaluation of available information and the evaluation of the interrogators but are too heavily based, instead, on presumptions of what the individual might or should know.
Today, we have a piece of information that fits into the passage above in a very interesting way. Note again that KSM was captured on March 1, 2003 and the invasion of Iraq was on March 20 (Iraq time). In today’s Telegraph, we have this very important revelation from the ongoing UK investigation into the Iraq war build-up:
However, Sir William Ehrman, director of international security at the Foreign Office from 2000 to 2002, told the inquiry: “We were getting in the very final days before military action some (intelligence) on chemical and biological weapons that they were dismantled and (Saddam) might not have the munitions to deliver it.
“On March 10 we got a report saying that the chemical weapons might have remained disassembled and that Saddam hadn’t yet ordered their re-assembly and he might lack warheads capable of effective dispersal of agents.”
Keep in mind that the Bush administration was pushing two lies about Iraq and al Qaeda at that time. First, they tried to establish a direct link between Saddam and the 9/11 attack. In addition, though, another lie repeated incessantly was that it was necessary to remove Saddam from power because he posed a risk of giving his weapons of mass destruction to al Qaeda.
Now we know that on March 10, more evidence became available that Saddam’s WMD’s were likely still dismantled and therefore not readily available to anyone. That makes the Bush administration claim of a danger of transfer of WMD’s from Saddam to al Qaeda "unsupported by credible intelligence" and makes the decision to proceed all the way to 183 applications of the waterboard even more despicable if the intent was to elicit a link known by other means to be false.
On March 20, the invasion of Iraq proceeded. No WMD’s were found. Hundreds of thousands died and millions were displaced from their homes. The Obama administration still refuses to press charges for torture or for waging war under false pretenses. Yes, Abu Zubaydah was waterboarded 83 times in August, 2002, but March, 2003 stands out as the month when the US lost its soul by relying on torture in an attempt to produce further false pretenses for waging aggressive war.



20 Comments







Jim,
http://www.cbc.ca/world/story/2009/11/26/rice-iraq-british-inquiry.html
Happy Thanksgiving from Gate 6, waiting on a plane…
Thanks for that link. Yes, they so wanted that attack to have been from Iraq…
Happy Thanksgiving to you and safe travels.
thank you for the diary jim, it goes very niceley with mine, U.K. International security Told Blair there were No wmd’s Before the attack on Iraq
Happy Thanksgiving, perris. Yes, I meant to link your diary but then got distracted.
America’s soul was gone long before that, we have been lied to and led into several useless wars like Korea and Vietnam before that.
We have been fed the ultimate disgrace to this country by our military. You see a military with nothing to do is totally useless. So what better way to stay relevant, than to have things to do like fight wars.
Six hundred and ninty billion dollars to the defense Dept. budget was signed by Obama, or healthcare for seven years for our people.
How many jobs could that create in the Country, or how many of our problems could it fix. Yet our representatives put the military first, over our people and even Country.
Yes we lost our soul when we send our young people to fight and die, to keep our useless military well funded.
Thanks, Jim. Recommended. Jim, my backpack is so full of thoughts on this subject, it’s probably best to leave the flap strapped down.
Thanks, Jim!
I have to wonder if some pieces of our soul hadn’t already escaped even before March 2003 (otherwise, how did GWB get elected?) but I definitely agree with you that it was a watershed moment. Not in a good way.
recommended
It’s funny how it took this long for something so obvious to begin trickling out… And even now it hasn’t gone much beyond McClatchy. Alway looking forward, you know. Great, if depressing, post, Jim.
Yes, George W. Bush was the source of all our problems, America was bucolic before that, and now that a Democrat is in the White House, America stands tall, restored, just like Reagan.
Yeah, I guess that’s why I fawn on Obama all the time. Yes, the US has done a lot of immoral things before. At a lot of those times, for example Vietnam, there was much more of a response from the people and the press about what we had done and even some effort to try to prevent a repeat.
Part of the two party dynamic is to create false extreme poles which are used to divide and conquer.
Given Obama’s developing neo conservative record, that dawg don’t hunt no more. If you shoot neocon from the hip, its no different than if you think about it for a while before loading and locking.
Binyam Mohamed’s case is going to cause the release of more information. He was captured in Pakistan in April 2002 and in July 2002 he was sent by the CIA to be tortured for 18 months in Morocco. The British High Court judges ruled last Friday that all information regarding his torture must be released. The UK has been hiding its involvement in torture with the US by using the state security excuse/lie.
http://www.andyworthington.co.uk/2009/11/26/uk-judges-compare-binyam-mohameds-torture-to-that-of-abu-zubaydah/
Rachel Aliene Corrie (April 10, 1979 – March 16, 2003)
Thank you!
“At a lot of those times, for example Vietnam, there was much more of a response from the people and the press about what we had done and even some effort to try to prevent a repeat.” ; if you saw the moyers Journal about LBJ,etc.,
http://www.pbs.org/moyers/journal/11202009/profile.html
you would know the ‘powers that be’ were pushing for volunteers for the Army back then; it is by having the ‘volunteer army’ that they take the power of peoples protestations out of the equation. Add to that how they now manage the media(contrast all the pictures coming out of Nam with what you ahve seen re Iraq/AfPak and you know what I mean).
Add in al the media ‘entertainment’ regards war and the proliferation of video games that are based on war and it’s obvious that the ‘powers that be’ want to preclude the public from really knowing what war entails.
9/11 WAS NOT another Pearl harbor but it got sold as such.
If yer gonna run an empire, then you’ve got to expect retaliation for subjugation like 9/11 was. If yer gonna freak out that people fight back, then that’s testament to the fact that these people either don’t have the stomach for the brutality that their empire entails, or they’re gonna use any opening to crack down at home.
Thanks Jim
I’ll have to catch up on it tomorrow when I have more time
I think this Country lost it’s soul along time ago, when we bought in to capitolism and the making of money being more important than Country or People.
Put that with our Militarism and you have a recipe for disaster.
Put on top our Countries attitude that we are the greatest, and the other Countries of the world are ours to use, and they should look up to us. This doesn’t make for a beloved Country or people.
It’s a wonder that more 911′s don’t happen, when we are occupying two countries, and have our military spread out all over the world, and are trying to dictate to others what they must do.
The best way to be loved, respected, and have people not wish to harm you is simple. DON”T PISS PEOPLE OFF.
Thanks for this. Those with the capacity for empathy in this country have been waiting to exhale. Waiting for justice and accountability after the horrifying travesty of the torture. Yes the wars truly horrifying. But the perverse and horrifying underbelly of torture, … who called it recently “the perversion of power”. I put on my black arm band because I was so horrified by the torture and horrified that my leadership that I trusted was not acting out of moral sensibility and addressing the nightmare. So now there is a double trauma. Trauma of the program. Trauma of its being normalized or minimized by an administration that is not cleaning up the immorality.
The soul has often been compromised, sadly. Like when Reagan cut federal funding and seeded an exponentially increasing homeless population. Fewer caretaking mental health facilities, etc.
And the collusion of corporate (psychopathic) agendas with the US government power and control imperialism and greed of the players … the citizenry has got to wake up to the scope of all this.
Libby, what about NAFTA, DOMA, FISA, PATRIOT and the like which all passed with Democrat support? Remember the effective death penalty act?
Democrats roll over for Republican crimes and then only feign outrage when advantageous politically.