In my most recent post on the shell games being employed by the United States in its attempt to deflect responsibility away from General Stanley McChrystal for his practice of widespread detention and abuse of innocent civilians as a central feature of his COIN strategy, I obtained a clear statement from a spokesman from US Central Command that McChrystal does maintain command authority over Joint Task Force 435, the unit headed by Vice Admiral Robert Harward that is tasked with responsibility for Afghan prisons, despite press reports that created the impression he did not have such command authority. Today, while scanning the most recent photos uploaded to Flickr from the ISAFMedia stream, I found a very interesting photo:

Here, in full, is the caption that was provided for the photo:
CAMP DARULAMAN, Afghanistan – Brig. Gen. Saffiullah, Afghan National Army Military Police Brigade commander, holds a certificate presented by Vice Adm. Robert Harward, Joint Task Force 435 commander. The certificate was presented during a ceremony here April 5 in front of an ANA Military Police brigade. The brigade will complete the extensive training program prior to their assumption of detention facility security operations at the Detention Facility in Parwan. The brigade already conducts detention and corrections operations at the Afghan National Detention Facility in Pol-e-Charkhi. The event was another step toward the transition of the detention facility from the United States to the Afghan government. (Photo by U.S. Air Force 1st Lt. Joost Verduyn)
So it appears that the shell game has progressed to one prison already being handed over to Afghan control. With Saffiullah now in possession of his full color Military Police Training Certificate, he and his brigade are nearly ready to take over control of another prison. Somehow, I doubt that these changes will result in any improvements in the process for Afghan citizens who have been detained to obtain a hearing on whether they were properly arrested.



21 Comments







Ha! I want one!
Amazing how well they can photoshop out all the blood… and quite telling that they don’t do video.. so the screams remain inaudible.
Well, I did notice that the certificate is enclosed in a plastic sleeve. That makes wiping the blood off a lot easier…
Well, if it’s under Afghan control, then anyone held there doesn’t fall under NATO rules. Being that anyone under USFOR-A or ISAF that captures someone can only hold him/her for 96 hours.
Some enterprising young US personnel (I won’t reveal which branch) have been getting around this by bribing the ANA with cash, at which point the ANA take custody and let the US personnel in the field continue the interrogation past 96 hours.
There was an incident in January where a US unit ducked comms with a helo coming to pick up a detainee cheating-girlfriend-style, in an attempt to hold them past the 96 hour limit. It worked; the helo didn’t know where to land because the guy was “breaking up”.
Yeah, I was just going to say something like this: if the Afghans “hold” them, then you’re setting up more Salt Pits, where the govt can decline to prosecute abuse by saying they didn’t maintain custody. Somewhere there’s a Steven Bradbury memo from 2005 saying that after June 2004 the US no longer were occupiers in Iraq, which he purported did the same thing.
Exactly. That’s a lot of what led me to use the “shell game” term in the first place. I’m betting that many of the same US personnel are present doing much the same thing they would be doing with these prisons officially under US control, but with them under Afghan control, we now have the “out” of blaming the Afghans for any abuses.
*gah* We need to get our Senators behind Russ Feingold’s proposed Afghan Bill…
Thanks for that link. That’s a wonderful letter from Feingold. And he doesn’t even touch on the instability in Kyrgyzstan and how that could affect our major staging base.
As I mentioned at Josh’s post, it’s not just the Kyrgyz that are restless either in the neighborhood…! 8-(
We really need to git while the gitting is good…!
Here’s an interesting bit from Scott Horton today on the Kyrgyz uprising:
Supporting corruption while calling for transparency. Hmmm, that sounds just like our policy in Afghanistan.
Indeed, without Manas we would need a lillypad somewhere else.
Georgia and Azerbaijan are too far. The only ones that serve a similar strategic interest would be Iran and Pakistan.
I could’ve sworn we had two additional USAF ‘lilypads’ in nearby Kazakhstan and Tajikstan…?
Not like Manas…They’re both STOL.
The main workhorses the C-130′s and C-17′s are STOL aircraft…! 8-(
That’s not what they fly out of there.
Congrats, Jim, on being front-paged again…! *g*
So what sort of coursework is used to get this certificate, anyway?
* 5 semester units “Heavy Beatings: Theory and Practice”
* 1 unit lab “Enforcing Sleep Deprivation”
* 2 elective units in either “Sexual Degradation”, “Terrorizing with Police Dogs”, or “Inflicting Non-Traceable Injuries”
* Final exam entails successfully disposing of mortal remains without detection by media or out-of-prison authorities.
It’s most likely the Dyncorp 10 week interrogator class on top of a similar Military Police class.
Actually folks, BG Safiullah has been running the Afghan National Detention Facility for years. It is the facility in Kabul where OEF captured detainees are transferred to enter the Afghan Rule of Law. If you’re concerned about conditions in that facility, why don’t you ask the ICRC. They routinely visit his facility. No big secrets there. I take it you found the pic on JTF 435′s Facebook site. Jim, why don’t you request permission to visit the facilities? Can’t find a way to contact them? A little more tough investigative journalism might reveal their e-mail…on their facebook site.
Welcome back. And no, I don’t think I would enjoy your hospitality. The picture came from the ISAFMedia Flickr feed, as I clearly wrote in the post.
Thom, quit being such a blue falcon…lame, dude.