On Thursday, the Christian Science Monitor reported that the design of the new cap system that appears to be stopping the flow of oil from the blown out BP oil well in the Gulf of Mexico is remarkably similar to a design offered anonymously by a plumber:
Six weeks ago, Robert Bea, an engineering professor at the University of California, Berkeley, received a late-night call from an apologetic "mystery plumber." The caller said he had a sketch for how to solve the problem at the bottom of the Gulf. It was a design for a containment cap that would fit snugly over the top of the failed blowout preventer at the heart of the Gulf oil spill.
Professor Bea, a former Shell executive and well-regarded researcher, thought the idea looked good and sent the sketches directly to the US Coast Guard and to a clearinghouse set up to glean ideas from outside sources for how to cap the stubborn Macondo well.
When Bea saw the design of the containment cap lowered onto the well last week, he marveled at its similarity to the sketches from the late-night caller, whose humble refusal to give his name at the time nearly brought Bea to tears.
On Saturday, the Christian Science Monitor was able to reveal the mystery plumber’s identity:
His name is Joe Caldart, a married, 40-something blue-collar guy with five kids and three hound dogs living in St. Francis, Kan. Mr. Caldart has 907 Facebook friends. He likes the band Rednecks & Red Dirt, watches "Family Guy," and cites the 1978 Burt Reynolds flick "Hooper" as one of his favorites.
As to his decision to go public, Caldart says in an interview with the Monitor, "My wife was, like, ‘This is kind of scary, I don’t know if you should [go public],’ and I said, ‘Yeah and no.’ But I also felt like people should know that here an average guy submitted something that maybe helped."
Caldart’s design was inspired by his experience as a plumber:
The current design is "a steel cap, and underneath it is the internal plug and on top of that is a piston and the flow tube in the middle, and coming down the left side is the warm water inlet tube," says Caldart. "I made that sketch on May 25th."
Caldart, who first started plumbing as a teenager, says he originally sent BP three sketches depicting a flange and plug design similar to those used in high-pressure hotel plumbing on May 25th. At that point, he says he was told by BP that they were not working on stopping the leak, but simply capturing the oil.
With the very encouraging news today that the decision has now been made to keep the cap in place with the flow blocked until the relief well is able to kill the well from below, it is truly refreshing that a design submitted freely by a concerned citizen was able to be implemented with such apparent success. As I pointed out in a diary yesterday, a major issue in American society today is that we are forced to rely on experts who are selling solutions to the problems of the day. Sadly, our government relies far too often on the very experts who have caused the problem to provide more failure in the form of failed solutions. I applaud the more open process that somehow resulted in this implementation of a genuine solution, freely offered by someone who at first didn’t even want their name mentioned.
Thank you, Joe Caldart, for your service to our country and our planet. You are a true hero.




29 Comments







Great story – thanks Jim
Good to know!
Yeah, what a great story, thanks for sharing it Jim!
Rccd of course!
Thanks and congratulations to Joe. Well done.
“I applaud the more open process that somehow resulted in this implementation of a genuine solution, freely offered by someone who at first didn’t even want their name mentioned.”
The more open process known as America.
The government does not have all the answers and the ‘experts’ hand-picked by the ‘ruling class’ are not necessarily the ‘best and the brightest.’
Of course, Obama, and not the plumber was the first to step in and take credit for capping the well.
“Either we will be able to stop the flow, or we will be able to use it to capture almost all of the oil until the relief well is done.”
http://blogs.forbes.com/energysource/2010/07/16/obama-takes-credit-for-bp-well-cap/?partner=aoltix
“we are forced to rely on experts who are selling solutions to the problems
of the daycreated by by these selfsame experts.”If Caldart had at first given his name, they could not use his idea without paying him. BP would rather continue to poison the ocean than to pay an outsider for a good idea. It would have taken weeks and a team of lawyer if BP could not steal the man’s idea for free albeit given freely (but importantly anonymously) of his own will.
With the very encouraging news today that the decision has now been made to keep the cap in place with the flow blocked until the relief well is able to kill the well from below”
Well – NO
Seems we have a seep – the floor near the hole
methane
BP refuses to give US more frequent pressure data despite request
Seems BP is determined to make this worse.
Yes, I’m trying to monitor the BP spill cam feeds to see the seep. I saw one camera briefly swing by something that looked like a very bad leak and even thought I was capturing video of it, but the capture didn’t work out. That camera hasn’t looked back at that spot. I don’t think BP wants anybody seeing how bad things are.
How is it that the US government is allowing BP to dictate the terms of what the press is allowed (or not allowed) to report on this catastrophe? Where is the outrage about that? The entire journalistic community should be presenting a united front in the demand for full access. This irritates me, to put it nicely.
If we had an independent free press, they’d be united, pressing for access. If Obama wanted the public to know, he could dictate the terms.
I think if we have a “seep.” it is pretty much game over.
Everyone has seen videos of dams starting to leak and how long it take for a total failure. This dam has 2.5 billion barrels of oil behind it.
I have BEEN to St. Francis, KS. If anyone else here has, then you know how even more remarkable this is.
I’ve spent time in Lyons, which is not too far away, so I can guess.
”I direct you to provide me a written procedure
for opening the choke valve as quickly as possible without damaging the
well should hydrocarbon seepage near the well head be confirmed ”
Thad Allen to BP
from the tweet I sent you Jim. Is Adm Allen saying we are totally dependent on BP for info on Day 90 – ayfkm ???
Sounds like it. And that’s just criminal.
Goodnight, folks. Thanks for a great discussion.
Rep. Ed Markey on BP motivation to ignore leak and possible disaster (FROM CNN):
“If the well remains fully shut in until the relief well is completed, we may never have a fully accurate determination of the flow rate from this well. If so, BP — which has consistently underestimated the flow rate — might evade billions of dollars of fines,” Markey said in a letter to Allen released Sunday.
Using ships on the surface to collect 100 percent of the gushing oil would allow scientists to calculate the flow rate — a figure that the government would use to determine how much to fine BP, Markey said.
Seems you can’t trust a large corporation – who’d a’ thought that? /s :-)
With all due respect, where is the proof this plumber’s idea was ‘the solution’. Sounds very tinseltowny movie romantic, but wouldn’t be the first time that multiple people came up with similar (note similar) designs (and we’re talking sketch here)
Where’s the beef? The sketch? Wouldn’t BP or gov specialists have contacted our Joe to confirm details? Idea? And I doubt there was much Einstein on this cap, the execution and dificult circumstances, depth et al are 99%.There are likely multiple possible solutions for a well fitting cap, but I.bet they would all look similar.
Don’t intend to be a killroy, but this is too much of the melodramatic ‘little guy safes the world’ touchy feely for me.
I just rewatched ‘independence day’ just to get that cheap bubble gum taste….
Read the CSM articles in detail. They draw the line from Joe to the professor at Berkeley whom he worked through to submit the idea, so his came with a bit more behind it than many in the 300,000 ideas submitted. There is a quote from BP in one of the articles saying they “might” have started on pretty much the same design before they got Joe’s sketch, but they don’t offer any proof of that either.
See hackworth1 @7
No, BP wouldn’t have contacted him. They have it now. It’s theirs. It’s
proprietary to them. And what’s proprietary to BP is held tighter than Mordechai Vanunu. What’s proprietary to BP is more sacred than the shroud
of Turin. What’s proprietary to BP is theirs…THEIRS…like the flow rates, and the pressure readings, and the contents of corexit. And the government? Please! It hurts when I laugh.
I would be interested to know to whom or what you would not give the benefit of the doubt.
***Edited in Moderation***
BP is fucking us over and now has the government by the short and curlies:
There’s been no announcement yet that the drilling of the relief wells has resumed.
***ModNote: Attempts to inflame and antagonize are not allowed. Your comments are subject to moderation***
All I can say is, this is what makes America great.
The plumber we used when we set up our small R&D facility is a genius. One-eyed and toothless, but a truely marvelous human being. There isn’t room here for me to write all that I learned from him. He and his girlfriend (he’s white, she was black, living outside Rising Sun, (klan country) MD) adopted her crack-baby grandson(the father’s doing life in DE), and now she’s died and he looks after the child full-time. He told me that the Ed. people in the county were really happy with him because he’s brought the kid from obese to normal.
Anyway, I just wanted to put in a ‘cheer’ for plumbers. Many people don’t know it, but to be able to get a License one has to have 7 years of apprenticeship. When you consider that Med. School is 4 years…
Teddy Partridge is upstairs!
Sunday Late Night: Dianne Feinstein Caps Her Career Against Fun
Amazing. Simply amazing. Proving once again that corporate minds think in circles while real innovation happens at the small business level. A plumber from Kansas stopped the leak. Amazing.
CNN has this story…
“When seeps are detected, you are directed to marshal resources, quickly investigate, and report findings to the government in no more than four hours,” retired Adm. Thad Allen said in a letter to BP Chief Managing Director Bob Dudley. “I direct you to provide me a written procedure for opening the choke valve as quickly as possible without damaging the well should hydrocarbon seepage near the well head be confirmed.”
Man! That Thad Allen really knows how to give an order!
When EPA ordered BP to stop the corexit, where was it BP told them they could put it?
WTF?
This just goes to show you you don’t need a fancy piece of paper that costs $160,000 or more to get things done.