In a perfect embodiment of the vapidity of Glenn Beck’s tea party movement that is infesting the National Mall today, we see in this morning’s Washington Post that Bruce Springsteen’s iconic war protest song "Born in the USA" is once again being misused and abused. The sentiments embodied in Springsteen’s song are directly in opposition to everything Beck and his movement represent.
Here is the Post, in its story about Beck’s rally:
Garlikov was among a rapidly growing crowd of activists milling on the Mall, from the foot of the Washington Monument to the steps of the Lincoln Memorial, as dusk approached Friday. Bruce Springsteen’s "Born in the U.S.A." blasted from an enormous sound system across the reflecting pool. Vendors sold rally-themed T-shirts and buttons.
Note again that Beck is claiming that his rally is to "restore honor" to America and that "proceeds" of the rally will go to his Special Operations Warrior Foundation. It would appear that one object of the rally for Beck is to glorify war and to praise the Special Operations forces who have been at the heart of the most outrageous actions by our troops that are fueling anti-American sentiment around the world. (For background on the horrible record of Special Operations forces, read Jeremy Scahill or Google my name along with "Stanley McChrystal").
So, the mental giants that make up Beck’s movement think that in Springsteen’s song they have found the ultimate mericun anthem. They feel it both glorifies war and it proclaims the superiority of being born in the USA. Take a minute to read the lyrics on their own, and then listen to Springsteen while watching the lyrics scroll past:
Clearly, Springsteen is not glorifying war. He is pointing out the horrible intersection of war waged by the ruling political class with the lives of the individuals who have rifles thrust into their hands with instructions to go kill the "other". The "other" today is brown, rather than yellow, but beyond that little has changed since Vietnam. Furthermore, Springsteen is pointing out the horrible fate of those soldiers who are "lucky" enough to return home from these wars. There are no economic opportunities for them, and Springsteen captures that desperation perfectly.
Today’s news has a tragic reminder of how that hopelessness plays out.
Beck’s rally today will glorify killing brown people while claiming to raise money for the education of the children of soldiers killed in action. But, the Washington Post points out an important point:
A footnote on the rally’s Web page explains that donations will go first toward the cost of the event.
One wonders just how much money Beck himself and headliner Sarah Palin will be paid from these "proceeds" before the scholarships are funded. Somehow, I suspect that very little money will be left over after "expenses".



172 Comments







Bruce ain’t gonna like that.
Yup. I didn’t take the time to go back and get links, but Bruce has a history of coming down hard on right-wingers who abuse this song.
Oy
Beck introduces the merit badge
Goldline will have to pay Springsteen in gold for the copyright infringment case that hopefully pop up.
I bet Goldline is minting Beck pieces. I’m sure his profile will be belaureled
Heh… “belaureled”
Can’t you just imagine a parodic song about Beck with that title? Of course, it would have to be written that he was “belaureling” himself.
I’m sensing an essence of Nuremberg in the set design
I bet Sarah and Glen both get paid more than Bruce will even if he sues them for stealing his song.
Only Repubs and teabaggers could so persistently and ironically choose rock and roll songs that completely undercut the very things they want to say.
You’d think they’d have learned by now “to just say no” to rock and roll… unless the lyrics were written by a RWA Christian.
Tweeted and Facebooked.
Yep, they’re better off sticking to Lee Greenwood.
Call me when Glen can get half the crowds the Immigrant Rights Protesters got in one city never mind 102.
Call me when the Media finally reports that fact.
Call me when the Media points out how much more Free Press the Tea Baggers get than the Immigrant Rights Groups.
Call me when Politicians in Washington start jumping like they do for the Tea Baggers when Hispanics complain about Racism and the lack of jobs in this country as Tea Baggers scream Keep the Bush Tax Cuts.
That, sir, is a post. Please write this up as a Seminal diary and I will Rec the snot out of it.
I’m waiting for the rally to end and to get final estimates of the crowd that I can trust. I may have to do this using Fox numbers:(
Hell, there was an immigration reform rally in DC five months ago that drew over 500,000 people, utterly dwarfing today’s Kochtopus production. Yet if you weren’t a blog reader or dialed in to the immigration-reform movement, you likely never heard about it as it didn’t get anywhere near the wall-to-wall coverage that the Kochtopus production’s getting.
I using that thanks writing now.
Aargh. Just had a mention of “warriors for Christ”. That’s going to play well in Muslim countries…
The whole rally is God and War. I turned it off when it got to the merit badges.
The rally is a very potent cocktail made up of militarism, patriotism and religion. I had hoped that it wouldn’t be as large as it appears to be, but unfortunately it is. Scary on a number of levels.
It’s nowhere near as big as the antiwar and pro-immigrant rallies that got far less attention from the national corporate media.
Racism and classism. Period.
Just over a thousand, according to Beck. Considering he’s been planning this for months now, I think that number is pathetic. Don’t let the camera angles fool you.
just over a thousand? Link please
Beck told it to the crowd when he first came on the podium. He said he got those numbers from the media in attendance.
Looks like more than that to me. Hope you’re right. Now MLK’s niece is speaking. Again…wtf?
Speaking of abusing musicians’ works, the use of Aaron Copland’s music is especially ironic…and offensive.
Yes, that is grating, isn’t it?
Yes it is. I’m a great fan of Copland’s work and I suspect this butchery is not something he would approve of. Shameful.
I completely agree. Blergh.
sounds like y’all are watching this live on some network ? ayfkm ??
C-SPAN
oy
MSNBC was showing a live shot from the traditional rally earlier – 4-5,000 attendees, how many at Beckstock ?
Seconded No tv here any numbers we can trust for Beck stock?
Too many.
Glen claims to represent a Majority of America and hates Immigrants not even all Hispanics support Immigrants Rights. Immigrants are a minority so if Glen can’t match our numbers then his claim of representing a majority of Americans flies out the window.
The Press also can’t justify then all the coverage they give Glen and the Tea Baggers. Imagine the Size of the Immigrant Rights Marches or the Million Man march if we got the same amount of Press Coverage.
Glenn Beck doesn’t even come close. Yet the GOP/Media Complex slavers over his every word.
Glenn Beck hates that song! You can google his views on it!!
If you are a veteran and you are looking for a job in the construction trades check this out:
http://www.helmetstohardhats.org/
The list of involved unions is wonderfully long. Lots of apprenticeships in all areas of construction plus there is a guestimator for how much you might earn too.
gotta go, bbl
excited about Christy’s return for Book Salon later today
I wasn’t aware that Beck paymasters Rupert and Wendi Murdoch were Born in the USA.
from twitter
707! Synchronize watches.
For some reason “Fanfare for the Common Man” has always annoyed the fuck out of me, both musically and pretentious-title wise. So I’m not sad to see these assholes using/abusing it.
This thing is like a big long church service [zzzzzzz] – LOTS of God n Jebus.
Fanfare is taken from the third symphony, and is quite powerful in that context. However, it’s been so bastardized, watered down and over-used through the years that it has become annoying, maybe even pretentious…which fits quite nicely with the overarching Beck narrative. Again, I’m pretty sure Copland would not approve.
Oh come on! You expect a group of people who think Beck is god is going to listen to lyrics? What they hear is,
“Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah
blah, blah, blah, blah blah.
BORN IN THE USA
BORN IN THE USA
BORN IN THE USA
blah, blah, blah, THE USA……”
Exactly. But I think they also hear “kill the yellow man”.
Oh, I’m sure they do. The point is that most people don’t listen to lyrics, especially if they like the tune. My older brother is way bright but absolutely refused to believe that “Lola” was about Ray Davies’ one stand with a drag queen, even though he would sing along, “….I know what I am and a man is a man and so is Lola….” He got mad at me when I pointed it out to him.
Wait, those Are the lyrics, right? lol
LOL!
Anybody else creeped out by the Red White & Black color scheme? And his logo?
I’m creeped out by the whole thing. I would like a FULL camera span of the “crowd”. Once again the press is only showing one area
Dunno – my whole creepiness meter is busted anymore ..
And now the loathsome Alveda King is speaking; you know the one who called marriage equality the equivalent of genocide.
But, hey, she’s a King, right?
Scary that a relative of King is lending her voice to this modern-day Nuremberg rally. How many people of color are in that crowd, exactly?
I don’t know, but there sure are a lot of token blacks there…at least performing and speaking. Must be getting paid alot by “Freedom Works’. Hey, it’s a gig.
Who’s this Tucker chick/ Is she the relative. Now there’s a black preacher up there.
I wonder how much she got paid 13 pieces of silver perhaps?
This is the great rebranding of the tea-party.
I think he’s doing a smashing job.
It turns my stomach but optics are optics.
I don’t think there’ll be a Pat Buchanan at the ’92 GOP convention moment.
At the very least we’ll be able to tell the wingnuts to “rise above the hate” once they default to their racist fulminating.
Beck’s endlessly smarmy blathering about MLK – does this really sell to his zombie flock? How do they overcome their decades of Rush programming that King was a murka-hating degenerate commie, etc etc?
This shit is just fucking surreal.
The MSNBC feed makes it look like the audience is 10 people in uncomfortable-looking straight-backed white chairs.
Of course they scored Alveda King. Quel coup!
Good point will Rush be silent about Glen’s strange love for MLK?
I don’t think she’s saying exact;ly what they want to hear. I notice she managed to diss queers. I guess The Gay don’t rate the same place in “the family of Humanity” as the Black do.
Someone always got to feel superior to someone else.
That’s why I had/have so much respect for Coretta. She didn’t have to take on homophobia, but she did, squarely. And she knew her husband would have.
This “music” is revolting. Just fucking horrid.
My question is, who is the current William F Buckley Jr? What conservative has the credentials and the guts in combination to point out to the rest of the lemmings how destructive and un American this latest incarnation of the John Birch Society is? Who is going to stand up this time and shout “Enough”? People (rightly) accuse Democrats of being cowards but there isn’t a spoonful of guts in the entire conservative movement.
You find him you find the hope of the Republican Party right now its the Nazi Party that has all the Hopes.
tru, Tweety’s still waiting for a Republican to step forth and dis Rush
Well, Tweety is an idiot of course but it’s more than Rush that needs to be dissed. It’s the whole tribal, xenophobic thing.
Yes Yes!!
WTF is wrong with this country…this garbage is live on c-span.
I will not watch it! Yuck, Beck. He is a virus as was Hitler…………
The number may be higher, but as others have pointed out, the anti-war demonstrations that drew millions were ignored by media, while this farce of easily less than five thousand is all over the media.
Less than 5,000 hmm I need to find a link confirming that
MLK’s rally drew 200,000 to 300,000.
“Heaven’s unlimited bank account..” WTF?
Here’s a live shot from the Rally…
hahahahahaha
AP is already inflating the numbers: “tens of thousands”
Thanks I will run with that tens of thousands is not a crowd over 50,000.
CBS News has estimates based on aerial photography of between 78,000 and 96,000.
Hysterical…I think Angela Seabrook, whom I have never found to be very effective, did, I believe, say hundreds of thousands…..thanks for the update.
Alveda can go to hell. She wants prayer in school and no more choice.
Alveda: “I have a dream .. ”
Not one bolt of lightning anywhere ..
Great. More fucking stupid, moronic, grating sonic pollution “music.” Hallelujah and run me over with a bus…
Photos are starting to come in. I’d like to see an aerial shot.
How are you going to get one of those? isn’t DC still under a no overflight ban?
I don’t know. Even to media?
No idea.
So who’s putting money on a someone starting a “draft Beck for prez” movement? This is the perfect setup for campaign spots…
I’ll take the bet….
God, this endlessly shopworn, moth-eaten “genius-of-murka, greatness-of-murka” purple prose would make even Uber Huckster Ronnie roll his eyes ..
Didn’t these chowderheads get the memo? “Born in the USA?” is anti-American.
http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2010/03/glenn_beck_calls_bruce_springs.html
GREAT catch!
Hey PW! I haven’t been around these parts lately except for some lurking. But yeah, somebody clued Beck in. And while he was at it, he in formed his minions that “This Land is Your Land” was unAmerican. C’mon, Glen. Shpw a little originality. Woody Guthrie is unAmerican. Jeez. That is SO old. I mean, everybody knows THAT! (no snark tag needed, i hope)
Well, i think he’s stupid in an IQ type of way. But he’s not stupid in an “I can make alot money off these assholes” way. And I think he understands his relationship with Goldline and is just fine with it.
Was it really necessary to throw in just how much you hate the people who are in SpecOps? I understand that you are antiwar. Not a problem, I know many people who are antiwar. Most of whom are veterans like me. But the impression that I got was that you also hate those who joined the military. That I really don’t like at all. SpecOps soldiers are people.Very very smart people. Not thugs, not murderers. You take minor incidents and blow them up into general statements that condem every one of them. Why? Navy SEALS, Army Special Forces and DELTA force, USAF and USMC even the Coast Guard are in Special Operations. Yet you paint them all with the broad brush that says these are not people. Why?
Like I said, my problem is with how Special Ops has been abused. Read any of my posts about McChrystal and you will see. Their purpose has been totally hijacked by the neocons to spur anti-American sentiments through their reliance on disappearing people without due process, hiding secret prisons from the Red Cross, torturing and even digging bullets out of the victims in an attempt at coverup. Special Ops does have a use, but Cheney and Rummy started their decline into a lawless group and Obama isn’t doing nearly enough to restore them to a proper respect for the law and international treaties.
Beck sounds like a televangelist. I didn’t realize he was so religious…….
Yup, good Mormon boy…
A dry drunk “religious sober absolutist” is a dangerous person.
Whatever the count, I would still submit that Beck is a crazy, scary, ego-maniacal, dangerous MF.
Like some historical sociopath that denied his Jewish heritage? Yes one dangerous sick MFer….
I was afraid someone would write a terrific speach for Beck. Nope, it’s a rambling mess that has no point.
It is but it a total emotional appeal to unreason…so, it should go over well. We’ll be hearing what a great speaker and genius Beck is.
So to was Hitler’s appeal to the German people based on non reason and pure emotion driven by nationalism. The Final Solution was the result! What is Beck’s solution? A remake of “The night of long knives?” This man is a virus! I’ve seen his ilk before. He is a virus!
There’s no reason to fear Beck’s speech. He’s been fueled far more by people like us giving him attention that he does not deserve than by anyone else. The key is to give him and the Half-Governor and other opportunists like them all the attention they deserve from us: NONE.
It’s hard when the mass media that most Americans use insists on shoving him in our faces and eardrums everywhere we go, whenever we turn on our TVs or computers or open our newspapers.
Which is why noting the much bigger rallies that get much less media attention is important.
Beck & Palin only get coverage because they increase ratings and hits. It seems like people enjoy the circus more than the substance. We create that circus and even legitimize the clowns when we treat them like serious people who deserve a response. Stop giving them attention and wait for them to go away.
I’m sure the German people felt the same way – “he’ll just go away if we ignore him” – before Hitler came to power
Watching Beck repeatedly conjures up the image of Greg Stillson.
Well, according to Beck, it only men that built Amerika. so, the queers have been left out and now, the wimmin
Yep, every pronoun is “men” and “man,” in a way that seems slightly deliberate. L. Ron Hubbard’s writings were full of that too.
He’s going to cry.
This is all just a handful of lizard brain words endlessly rearranged – America, greatness, God, greatest, great, America, God, America, greatness ..
Beck: “American Scripture”
And now he’s abusing the Gettysburg Address.
This is their actual position; their vision of America IS a religion. And you better “believe” in that religion, or your apostasy is quite enough to justify the war against you, and your heresy requires your ultimate death.
Nicely stated.
Christian Caliphate!
Amen, nicely stated.
Then they should not be able to use our National Mall…(I posted this elsewhere…) He can call for theocracy, but we would need a new constitution. Does he want that, too?
Very well said Kelly.
If ever the rest of the world would be laughing at America and shaking their heads in wonderment and disbelief that we could sink lower than we already have, the Beck Rally and the swooning press — especially the swooning press — has to be it.
The press, especially with the help of CNN and FOX News takes a no-nothing, formerly drug addicted radio shock jock and catapults him into the spot light with free publicity and never mentioning the mass exodus of advertisers from his show. Only in America . . . where the almighty dollar reigns supreme!
Thanks MSM for dumbing us down just a little further. I keep thinking you have helped us hit bottom but somehow you always manage to shovel a little more dirt out for us to sink lower!
I doubt even Goebbels would have had the chutzpah to claim Anne Frank for his cause. But that’s just what we’re seeing Beck trying to pull off.
I’m from NJ and this song, like so many of Bruce’s, really connected with so many of us who grew up in the dead man’s towns in that area. The idea that this song was patriotic in the way the teabaggers define patriotism it’s just so preposterous as to boggle the mind. I remember seeing a clip of Reagan on the news back in 84 at a campaign rally and they were playing this song and I was speechless. Couldn’t believe it. Another story about people liking the way a Springtsteejn song sounds but not listening to the words. Some clown of an assemblyman in NJ proposed “Born To Run” as the NJ state song. Somebody had to pull him aside and say “Um, it’s about getting out of this shithole.”
We just got back from there. We parked at Roosevelt Island and walked over. It was crazy crowded. My goal was to get close to the front so we could see – that was impossible. We saw two black people. One of them was selling NOBAMA pins!
That sort of thing is common in DC. There are a lot of African-American merchants who like taking money from right-wing tourists in this way. They get a kick out of knowing that a) this is just about the only time those white people will ever willingly buy something from a black person, and b) they can go turn around and donate the proceeds to a cause the right-wingers would hate.
I saw elsewhere on line that they get the proceeds after the rally costs are paid. The entertainment industry contract: a percentage of the net, not the gross, and they have accountants to make sure the net is zero or negative.
Which is how record companies keep all but the biggest bands in something resembling indentured servitude. You’re literally better off making your own CDs and selling them in the street or online.
What a terrible rambling incoherent speech! I see he’s finally getting a bit of applause, tho he’s using some of Obama’s talking points interestingly enough. Oh, somebody’s crying it so beeotiful!
Most look sedated
We are great because we kill people! Hell yeah!
U.S.A.! U.S.A.!
And we do it because Jeebus tells us to.
Rally theme song…
Beck is clearly a second class citizen. He is a slave to Goldline. They own him lock, stock and barrel. He way too stupid to understand that. He would still be locked up if Raygun had not let out all the loonys.
And what that says about his followers is especially damning.
Shorter Glenn Beck: We are the ones we have been waiting for.
LOL. My 123 was supposed to be a response to A420 @ 119. Looks like I was responding to myself as it is now.
The people behind Beck are being pretty rude, getting up and walking up and down the steps, not paying attention.
Except for the guy waving the Christian flag…
Why would anybody pay attention? He’s not saying anything that makes any sense? some guy was crying from boredom Murdoch wasted alot of money televising this.
Beck doesn’t even have notes, I guess he thought The Lord woudl inspire him…WRONG!
I consider it victory for smart people everywhere
I think someone said he was only going to bring bullet points and god would inspire him. Rock on Becky until you fall.
Dare I ask what a “Christian flag” is?
One of these.
Oh, yuck, it looks like something from one of the Crusades. Of course, that’s probably the point.
I’m hearing reports that the rally is huge and they are listening in rapt attention — who ARE these people?
I don’t think those people are capable to listen in “rapt” attention. They may just be numb.
They are the majority.
I am glad to see the folks here at least take the threat Beck represents seriously. I have watched a good bit live and am speechless at how CNN is covering it.
Tens of thousands are at Beckestock? How many tens?
Sheez, I went off and did some chores and this fuckhead is STILL speechifying?
Maybe he’s going for Castro’s record.
I know, when is he gonna stop? where’s the hook? get him off the stage, I bet his ratings go down after this debacle.
Hey! Palin is crying. Or “crying.” That’s Beck’s job!!!
What’s the weather like in DC today? Is it really hot?
partly sunny, 84F
Thanks. That’s fairly warm and DC is very humid. Those people are going to fall asleep if Beck goes on too long.
Anyone wanna bet that Al-Qaeda is recording the video feed and creating special segments for distribution throughout the Muslim world, letting all who would watch see for themselves that Americans hate Muslims and want to keep killing them? (And of course throw in footage of the aftermath of a few predator drone strikes on a few wedding parties, to underscore the point?)
ok. i have it on now. Just who the fuck ARE these people?? where’s that wash-up rock & roll guy?
anybody nekked in the reflecting pool? or is that a brain bleach thought?
Hugh Jass? Is there a Hugh Jass in the crowd? C’mon, I’m looking for Hugh Jass…
I think he was spotted with Al K. Holic.
They’re all there to the right with Ben Drover
Wonder if any of the handful of conservative Republican Jews that I know are watching this, and if they’re willing to admit to themselves what it means?
Trust none of what you hear
And less of what you see
This is what will be, this is what will be
-Springsteen
What he is talking about goes well beyond Beck. Beck is the just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to American lies and bullshit.
I’ve always thought that this song was his reaction to the Bush administration saying that they create reality. One of my favorite songs of all time.
Come on. There was one year left in the Bush Administration when this song came out. It’s about the future for America. It goes well beyond the Bush Administration. And yeah, he stumped for Obama in 08, but I seriously doubt he’ll do it again. Maybe Obama can get Elton John for 2012.
Where do they get fanny-pack belts that big? Most of these people are at least 100 inches in circumference.
What I want to know is where are all of those right wingers claiming it was “insensitive” to have a mosque at ground zero pointing out how insensitive it is to have a racist, war mongerer giving a speech at the same place and on the same date that MLK gave his speech of peace and inclusion???
Links anyone? No??? you mean it’s only Muslims that can be “insensitive”???
Sarah Palin: “I raised a combat veteran. They can’t take that away from me.”
So, her kid joins up and puts his ass on the line, yet somehow it’s all about her.
Yep, it’s like they’re not paying attention to anything around them, isn’t it?
Umm, I know this may be a little stupid, but are Beck and Palin getting paid for this and, if so, by whom?
See PJEvans@109.
http://starling.rinet.ru/music/bruce.htm#USA is an interesting perspective on that song. I don’t think you can blame people for not listening to the lyrics of a song too well when superficially it is very suited to dumb patriotism (and since the song is only shallow, the superficial look can be excused).
Beck is a clown who says whatever comes to mind without thinking. He has no pride and no shame and will do whatever his masters ask for a buck. The followers are obviously just plain stupid. I guess the fluoridation in the water is working.
Aye an abuser he is…
When eyeballing a couple of pieces(just to see if they would give an official estimate of numbers) I saw this qoute.
“I ask, not only if you would pray on your knees, but pray on your knees but with your door open for your children to see,”
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5iDM-ObH1Ys1fPXvRNCNEGrVOl2PgD9HSMPPO0
Matthew 6:6But thou, when thou prayest, enter into thy closet, and when thou hast shut thy door, pray to thy Father which is in secret; and thy Father which seeth in secret shall reward thee openly.
7But when ye pray, use not vain repetitions, as the heathen do: for they think that they shall be heard for their much speaking.
Good Luck trudging through Glenn’s crass distortions.
Hope the DJ put on “Fortunate Son” after Springsteen.
“Red, white, and blue . . . ” – makes you want to sing along.
Oh great, we have finally exported something to Japan:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/29/world/asia/29japan.html?_r=1&pagewanted=2&partner=rss&emc=rss
I saw Springsteen during his 1985 tour… Lyrics aside, Bruce did little to dispel the notion (popular at the time) that it was in fact a pro-USA song http://is.gd/eNKMp http://is.gd/eNKQv his marketing team had him open each show to a blaze of fireworks and a titanic backdrop of the American Flag.
As laiki above notes, its hard to blame people who only listen to lyrics at a superficial level…which is especially true given the patriotism of the times and the marketing of the Album/tour by The Boss’ media team.