The vitriol-filled right is busily trying to refute its role in creating the environment in which Jared Loughner carried out his horrendous attack on Saturday when Representative Gabrielle Giffords was holding a “Congress on Your Corner” meeting at a Tucson Safeway. While much of the walk-back by hate radio and hate politicians is in response to Pima County Sheriff Clarence Dupnik’s condemnation of Arizona as “the Mecca for prejudice and bigotry”, another aspect of Dupnik’s experience-based comments deserves equal attention. At the same news conference, Dupnik “criticize[d] the Arizona Legislature for pushing to allow weapons pretty much everywhere.” He then went so far as to say “[Tucson] is the tombstone of the United States of America.” That is an incredibly important point that should not be overlooked as the country looks to move on from this tragedy. Just as we need to dial back the hate in our social and political discourse, we also need to change the atmosphere which has idolized guns to the point that they are actively encouraged in state legislative buildings and where automatic weapons are given away with the purchase of a truck.
The Tombstone reference by Sheriff Dupnik (and especially having it picked up on the website of a television station with the call letters KGUN) describes the situation very well. Here’s a brief description of the most famous part of the history of Tombstone, Arizona:
The most famous event in Tombstone’s history was the famed Gunfight at the OK Corral, which didn’t actually happen at the corral, but in a vacant lot on Fremont Street. On October 26, 1881, members of the “Cowboys” had a run-in with Wyatt, Virgil and Morgan Earp with help from Wyatt’s friend Doc Holliday. 24 seconds and 30 shots later, Billy Clanton, Tom and Frank McLaury were mortally wounded. In many peoples opinion, it was this one event that has kept Tombstone alive for all these years.
How sad is it that America’s love affair with guns has kept the site of the famed Gunfight at the OK Corral commercially successful for nearly 130 years? Sadly, it appears that even the number of shots fired in the attack on Giffords and others in Tucson was the same as that fateful day in Tombstone, further strengthening Dupnik’s comparison.
Much of the blame for ginning up a pathological combination of guns with politics lies at the feet of the National Rifle Association. A randomly chosen example of the way this organization has infused political discourse with violent reliance on incredibly destructive weapons comes in this May, 2009 article in Roll Call:
And the NRA has been on the attack.
“We do whatever is necessary to win,” said Andrew Arulanandam, NRA’s director of public affairs. “We are proactively pushing a number of measures.”
So far, the NRA has hit many of its targets.
On Tuesday, the Senate passed a bill that would rein in credit card interest fees along with a Republican-sponsored amendment permitting concealed weapons in national parks. Another pro-gun measure has entangled a D.C. voting rights bill, proof that Democrats aren’t keen on voting against the gun lobby.
Note that even the “journalist” writing the Roll Call article invokes the imagery of the NRA being “on the attack” and that it “hit many of its targets”. But also note especially that the coupling of this violent rhetoric with very large amounts of money fed to both political parties has created the environment where “Democrats aren’t keen on voting against the gun lobby”. That is how we have arrived at the sick environment where even a “Democrat” campaigning for the Senate feels obligated to use a gun in one of his ads.
Of course, Manchin’s ad pales in comparison to real right-wingers when it comes to guns. Consider Grady Warren, a “sportsman” affiliated with the Tea Party movement in Jacksonville, Florida. If you can stomach it, watch Warren’s video reproduced on the upper right on this site (YouTube pulled it down because it is so offensive) where Warren tries to hide behind his claim to be “peaceful, but prepared” (check out his t-shirts with that slogan and lots of guns) but gets so worked up about non-white “illegal aliens” that he informs us that “either the government steps up, or the government will have to clean up”. Since this comes shortly after his claim to “sportsman” status (code for gun-toting, he also of course worked in the right to keep and bear arms), there is little doubt about why there will be the need to clean up. In another strange coincidence, note how Warren also rails against illiteracy, just as Loughner does in his disturbed videos.
Grady Warren epitomizes why it is not just hate speech alone which created the atmosphere for Loughner’s attack and guarantees that there will be others like it to follow. It is the coupling of this violent hate for all non-whites with the gun culture that is so dangerous. The NRA and similar “sportsmen” oriented groups have fostered an elevation of guns to the forefront of political discourse, so that campaigns like Joe Miller’s rely on parades of people packing automatic weapons and similar weapons show up at other political events. Note also that the NRA’s relentless campaign to allow the automatic weapons ban to expire is behind Loughner being able to use such a large magazine of bullets in his attack.
Our country is headed down an extremely violent course, and I fear that Jared Loughner is merely the tip of the iceberg. How many more disturbed individuals will see his action as a call to arms amid a society that is permeated by the hate speech that specifically invokes gun images and language?
I leave you to contemplate a portion of the lyrics from the Lynyrd Skynryd video above:
Well hand guns are made for killin’
They ain’t no good for nothin’ else
And if you like to drink your whiskey
You might even shoot yourself
So why don’t we dump ‘em people
To the bottom of the sea
Before some ole fool come around here
Wanna shoot either you or meMr.Saturday night special
Got a barrel that’s blue and cold
Ain’t no good for nothin’
But put a man six feet in a hole



43 Comments

The vitriol-filled right is busily trying to refute its role in creating the environment in which Jared Loughner carried out his horrendous attack…
And as usual – the Mainstream Media aka The Liberal Media is helping the right in its efforts. The recurring theme – in an endless loop – Both Sides Do It and Everyone needs to knock it off.
Oddly, I don’t know any liberal, anti-gubmint, language-fixated, gold-backed-currency gun nuts.
What’s the correlation between the % of U.S. males owning guns & taking v*agra?
In Arizona, any incoherent lunatic can buy a gun, no waiting period, no registration. Gun CONTROL does not mean NO GUNS. Get with the program, Arizona!
Agree with me? http://upc.bz/0166
Thanks for this. How did we get from Lynyrd Skynyrd in 1976 to so many people thinking that concealed weapons permits were normal in 2011? This isn’t normal and we haven’t gotten here by just evolving. The NRA needs to be exposed as the criminal facilitator it is.
They got to work almost immediately trying to move the focus away from the guns when this happened. Not.this.time. Not.ever.again.
In answer to your headline question. Has there ever been any doubt? Peace
Heh. And they like BIG guns, too.
The gun fetish armed him but the hate merchants motivated him to act.
Reposting what I observed earlier on another thread:
Well, this morning the MSM are dutifully being “balanced” in calling for “both the Left and the Right to dial it back.” And I just listened to some Republican congressman talking about his heightened “security measures” for his staff — like it’s the RIGHT that feels endangered.
This is properly an empirical matter, but no one is gonna take the trouble to tally up the aggregate relative right vs left threats and eliminationist rhetoric and attacks. Expect shortly for Sarah Palin to be broadly spun as a “Victim” here. And, you bet’cha she will find a way to capitalize on it.
Somebody needs to ask the question, if both sides are equivalent in “doing it”, why are only left leaning people and institutions being attacked?
Peggy – completely OT – left a post at Caturday – Patchy has gone; he had a huge tumor in his chest.
I’m off to work, with heavy heart.
Precisely. And there are lots of weapons and lots of unstable people out there who have been affected by the messaging.
One could continue the repartee but the point has been made.
What a sorry state of affairs.
As a prefatory qualifier to the following, I have shot guns most of my life, did time in the Army infantry, am a certified Range Safety Officer, and currently target shoot and hunt (the latter of which has given me a respect and understanding for life and environmental conservation that I might not have had otherwise). However, I despise the NRA. To give those who have not encountered its politics and literature, I’ll let you in on the sort of promotional material I receive from them several times a year. They of course ask me to join and send them money. But what is disturbing is their use of fear to illicit the desired response. Every cover letter is a vitriolic, biased, over-the-top screed of reactionary bullshit telling me how the likes of Pelosi and other Big Brother/Big Government control freaks hate me, my guns and, with no motivation other than their essential evil, would love nothing more than to take away the fundamental prerequisite to my personal freedom: my guns. Of course, I’m paraphrasing, but that is the gist of the message. If their PR people are at all competent and indeed have their finger on the pulse of their audience, this reflects a disturbing cultural development that was non-existent over a generation ago.
these people get up in the am and turn on faux and friends and listen to old dookey and that hag,,they load their gun to take to work, get in the car and turn on am hate radio,,they get to their crappy job that they cant stand and work for a boss they think is a librulllll..they listen to the drug addic limbaugh tel them how bad their lot in life is…
after work, they get in their car and listen to hate radio all the way home,,they get home and turn on faux news and listen to more hate,,
no wonder they are un hinged,,,,
Oh no! Oh I’m so sorry. :(
Truth be told Giffords was more Right than Left. Blue Dog. Peace
Yeah FOX. Peace
Not to diary whore too much but here’s my 2¢ from yesterday: Gun Culture and ‘Collateral Damage’
You do realize that by continually ending every comment with the word “Peace” it makes you appear to want anything but peace in response.
Trite and hackneyed becomes more the perceived intent.
Gabby Giffords voted for Civil Rights vet Rep. John Lewis (D-GA) over Hedge Fund manager’s wife Pelosi for Dem leader–and as the wife of astronaut Mark Kelly– Gabby strongly opposed the Obama Administration draconian cuts to NASA.
She, very reluctantly, voted for a Healthcare ‘reform’ that contained equally draconian cuts to Medicare & Medicaid.
As a person who worked for Bobby Kennedy’s NY Senate campaign & McGovern over Nixon in 1972–and a backer of the 1st Amendment– I warn against equating vigorous criticism–with incitement to violence.
Every member of Congress–and every President–is elected with connections to various political, intelligence & financial community agencies.
And as a wise man said. “Guns don’t kill politicians, intelligence & financial community agencies do.”
I favor beefing up the Secret Service face to real threats–not gutting the 1st Amendment–because Rush Limbaugh is a blow-hard!
Not that I would usually want a cretin like Grady Warren to get attention, but I think people really need to watch his video that I linked. It really crystallizes the mixture of hatred and gun loving that has fueled our current situation.
Also, I am not calling for the free speech rights of Warren, Palin or anyone else to be abridged. What I am calling for is for their rhetoric to be exposed in all of its ugliness and for them to face the social ostracism that such irresponsible actions should provoke.
How many times have GOP pols told Dems if you vote for that you better not come to my state, my district etc implying violence? Clinton was threatened by Jesse Helms and the Orange one said something to someone about not coming to his Catholic neighborhood after the Healthcare vote.
If GOPers can treat the President that way then its no wonder we got GOPers shooting everyone.
Fellow is insane. Talk radio motivated an insane person and this is something Beck and Fox should have anticipated. But Obama used “if the bring a knife I will bring a gun” macho man talk in his speeches. It is the right calling for “2nd Amendment solutions” that is different from the left’s macho man talk – but to the average voter I suspect Obama’s macho man talk will mean it is a problem of BOTH the left and right – and once more Obama will have made the left weak.
Gun control will bloom into a bill to ban the type of weapon used, followed no pressure from Obama to pass anything, followed by NRA/GOP freedom talk and donations that kill the bill. Nothing will change – because everyone talks mean – and it is just insanity.
Oh yes – I forgot – Obama’s poll numbers will go up 2 points after his next “tone it down and get bi-partisan” speech.
How did we get here? Fear, declining quality of life, a non-functioning democracy, waning freedom, loss of community as a result of the isolation of atomized consumption, . . . ? Gun culture, as we see it today, is largely an expression, a symptom of fear, powerlessness and hopelessness. Perhaps if we can fix the underlying cultural, economic and political causes that contribute to these anxieties, then the gun nuttery will fade? It is a question of freedom. Will we collectively have the courage to act free or will we cower behind the reactionary, negative, bogus power of our guns?
Oh no!
The NRA was formed just after the KKK was banned.
Coincidence?
or intimidation?
What would the Right Wing echo chamber do if an african-american or mexican person shot a R congressperson?
I believe we should agitate for a concealed carry law in DC, Might have some interesting results.
Oh, I’m so sorry…
No doubt everything will be fine when Holy Joe and the Fatherland Security Committee look into the situation. There will be hearings, committees appointed (no doubt led by Alan Simpson) and Obama will make a couple of pretty speeches. Sorry about being a cynic but I have just lost faith.
Jane has a fresh post ready: Sarah Palin’s Political Career May Already Be Over, But If It’s Not, It Should Be
They won’t ban the Glock 9mm semi-auto handgun. It is a huge seller. Popular with Police and the Public. There must be millions of them in the US.
They will go after the extended capacity clip. Then they will fail.
Probably be a good idea to ban handguns at Political Events. That too would likely fail.
Mr. Bipartisan will indeed blame “both sides” , which is of course, complete bullshit.
The R Party, The Tea Party, Libertarians and their Media Conglomerate have been explicitly provoking gun violence against Democrats and Liberals.
NYT must have gotten hit with a total barrage of angry emails about the “both sides are guilty” crap they had out yesterday. Because today, in their lead editorial, they zigged a big zag and laid it squarely in the lap of the Republicans and the Tea Party, mental instability acknowledged.
Me, I’m just astounded at how quickly the “don’t blame it on the guns” stuff got out there. The bodies weren’t even cold this time.
As for all the mental instability stuff? With all due respect to Jeff Kaye and others, I could recite you para and para from the Aafia Siddiqui competency hearings, where there’s more than enough reason to suspect that the party putting the suspect on trial is also responsible for the insanity itself. The judge ruled that “sane enough” not “sane” is the criterion. It obviously was down at Sportsman’s Warehouse.
I’m just very, very leery of all the mitigation that goes on so immediately that always seems to make it okay that every time we have had a Democratic president since 1980, we have militias, tons of guns, tons of NRA, and bombings, shootings, and standoffs that we’re all supposed to think have nothing to do with the climate surrounding us.
That’s one persons opinion. And you know what they say about opinions? Peace
Look to the oligarchy for what is allowed and what is not. Peace
My feeling is that the Americas gun “fetish” is non partisan. That dosent mean that its not demagogued by the right (and very occasionally by the left) but that it cant be shown that people who self identify with the right are completely unique in unwillingness to, ban handguns for instance. Some people feel that as long as the state is going around in polite society strapped, then bans in the US will remain unpopular. There is a very simple but consistent logic to that. No matter that if it ever came to shooting at each other, the stockpile of civilian guns would accomplish nothing more than to be confiscated and-or get the owners killed quickly. Or that if there were a civil war or revolution (which is what is implied by “2nd amendmmant remedy”) better, much more effective millitary style weapons would become availble to those who were going to use them (they always do). Its an emotional condition that says more about our American society and its hardwired system of economic, ethnic and political repression , than it says about most gun owners.
Actually I do believe I have seen similar sentiments expressed by others.
So it’s not just one person’s opinion.
Nope. I’ve called you out on it, and so has bmaz, and others.
It occurs to me that if the Dems don’t push back on the NRA and the “not our fault” Repubs, there are an awful lot of crazies out there who will see it as proof that violence is not only acceptable, but lauded and welcomed.
All the “don’t blame us” rhetoric is just fueling more fear, hate and anger.
There’ll be a lot more threats — which won’t be reported in the MSM — and at least one more spectacular killing.
Right on the mark. Warrior worship, Patriotism, American exceptionalism; add it to the mix.
Me, too. Condolences.
Indeed.
Slogans toward a solution for right and left (if decline of community is part of the root cause):
1. “Face your fears without a gun”
2. “Have you hugged a gun nut today?”
:)
Excellent comment! Thanks.
OK, i’ll back off the gun debate. Let’s talk about why Loughner wasn’t already in mental health treatment? If any of the reasons had to do with lack of availability, bad commitment or mandatory treatment laws, lack of publicly funded facilities, poor insurance coverage or medical care…i can STILL point to the right…and never have to talk about the availability of guns.
Somewhat OT: In addition to writing “Saturday Night Special” to rail against handguns, Skynyrd also recorded “That Smell,” the best anti-drug rock ‘n’ roll song ever recorded (surpassing Steppenwolf’s “(Goddamn) the Pusher”). I always thought that instead of saying “Just Say No,” Nancy Reagan should’ve just taken that song on a boom box everywhere she went.