Update (Wednesday): The Guardian now has a story on this situation.
We learn from Dawn.com Tuesday that Raymond Davis, a US “consular employee” who killed two men on Thursday in Lahore, has been placed on the exit control list, barring his exit from Pakistan. Remarkably, Representative Darrell Issa led a small Congressional delegation that met on Tuesday with Pakistani President Asif Ali Zadari and Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani, seeking release of Davis, according to Pakistan’s Online International News Network. Those meetings came a day after State Department spokesman Philip Crowley declared that as a consular employee, Davis has full diplomatic immunity.
The story in Dawn.com opens with Davis’ exit from Pakistan being blocked:
A judge on Tuesday blocked any move to hand over to US authorities an American government employee under investigation for double murder, and put his name on the exit control list.
/snip/
“I am restraining him (from being handed over to US authorities). Whether he has or does not have (diplomatic) immunity will be decided by the court,” ruled Lahore High Court Chief Justice Ejaz Ahmed Chaudhry.
“An order is issued to put his name on the ECL (exit control list). The case is adjourned for 15 days.”
The story ends with this intriguing revelation:
When asked by visiting US congressmen on Monday to free Davis, Pakistan’s President Asif Ali Zardari said: “It would be prudent to wait for the legal course to be completed”.
After a bit of digging, I found this story on the visiting delegation:
A US congressional delegation Monday separately called on President Asif Ali Zardari at Aiwan-e-Sadr and Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani at PM House. The delegation included Representatives Darell El Issa, Todd R. Platts, Jason Chaffetz, Stephen F. Lynch, Brian M. Higgins and Raul L. Labrador. Mr. Stephen Engelken, Charge d’ Affairs, Mr. Thomas A. Alexander, senior Counsel (Majority) Committee on Oversight, Mr. Adam Pl. Fromm, Counsel (Majority) Director of Member Services and Mr. Scott Lindsay, Counsel (Majority) Committee on Oversight, were also present.
Pak side included Dr. Abdul Hafeez Sheikh, Finance Minister, Mr. M. Salman Faruqui, Secretary General to the President, Ch. Abdul Ghafoor, Chairman National Commission for Government Reforms , Ms. Hina Rabbani Khar, MOS for EAD/Finance, Senator Syeda Sughra Imam, Ms. Farahnaz Ispahani and Spokesperson to the President Mr. Farhatullah Babar besides Foreign Secretary Mr. Salman Bashir and other senior officials. Briefing media Spokesperson to the President Mr. Farhatullah Babar said that matters relating to Pak-US bilateral relations, mutual cooperation, fight against militancy, ROZs and security situation in the region among other related issues were discussed during the meeting.
But why would a Congressional delegation working on trade and terrorism control involve itself in the Davis case? More from the same link:
Babar said the Congressmen also raised the matter of Mr. Raymond Davis, involved in the killing of Pakistani nationals in Lahore, with the President. The President said that he appreciated their concern but the matter was already before the courts. It would be prudent to wait for the legal course to be completed, he said.
Requests for Davis’ release had already been publicly issued by the State Department. From AFP:
“He is a member of the embassy’s technical administrative staff and therefore entitled to full criminal immunity. He cannot be lawfully arrested or detained in accordance with the Vienna Convention,” said State Department spokesman Philip Crowley on Monday.
Crowley said Washington agreed with the US employee’s version of events: “In our view, he acted in self-defense, when confronted by two armed men on motorcycles.”
The video above brings the US version of events into question. Note that both of Davis’ victims were shot multiple times, which seems at odds with mere self-defense. Note also on the crawler near the end of the video where it is stated that some are charging Davis with being a spy. That is most likely the true heart of the matter. ABC News has done some digging on Davis and has come up with this bit of background:
Davis runs Hyperion Protective Consultants, LLC, a company that provides “loss and risk management professionals.”
A key question as this story continues to unfold will be whether Davis (or Hyperion) was directly employed by the consulate or if he was working as a contractor for another entity such as Erik Prince’s Xe. At any rate, if requests for his release were deemed worthy of direct requests from a Congressional delegation to Pakistan’s President and Prime Minister in separate meetings, it is probably safe to assume that Davis’ “technical” responsibilities in the consulate were not insignificant.
Also note that Crowley claimed that Davis’s victims were small-time thieves who had robbed another victim shortly before they encountered Davis:
The diplomat, Raymond Davis, “had every reason to believe that the armed men meant him bodily harm. And minutes earlier, the two men, who had criminal records, had robbed money and valuables at gunpoint from a Pakistani citizen in the same area,” said Crowley.
There is no mention of the earlier robbery in the Pakistani news video above.



40 Comments

It also seems like the State Department waited a few days before they started claiming immunity.
Note, too, that Crowley–at least in that quote-doesn’t endorse the burglary story, just the two armed men story.
And remember that at first Crowley was saying that the Raymond Davis name was wrong. He has stopped saying that now.
The plot thickens.
But, youda thought the U.S. could get its talking points straight. But youda been wrong.
“why would a Congressional delegation working on trade and terrorism control involve itself in the Davis case?”
Because he may be a killer, but dagnabbit, he’s OUR killer?
Who’s SUV was it that raced to the rescue, killing another motorcyclist? It’s not like Xe’s/Blackwater’s mercenaries don’t have a habit of running around in SUVs with no regard to the civilians.
That does fit the M.O., doesn’t it?
Wait till we find out that Hyperion has been giving
donationsbribes to Issa’s re-election fund.Short answer? David is a fucking spook. We need him back. He’s got intel on the Iranian nuclear program.
I moss udit. *Davis!
Recommended.
Disgusting. The Department of State is looking like a real “petting zoo for criminals” at the rate they are going. Here’s just another data point regarding a 2005 incident: “Sexual Assault and the State Department: Two Lousy Tastes That Go Lousy Together” (posted by Jeff Fecke at Saturday, December 15, 2007).
My previous understanding was that diplomatic immunity was not adjudicated by a court, but was dictated by the kind of passport one held. If Davis has a diplo passport, he’s got a get-out-of-country-free card. If not, no.
But I can see our intrepid Chairman Issa make a heroic move to hustle the contractor onto the CODEL flight, can’t you? Would that it would end badly for Issa if he did.
Davis is apparently an important thug. He will be released as soon as the appropriate tributes to the appropriate Pakistani officials are paid. When Davis gets freed, then he will pay tributes to the American officials. One hand washes the other. More than fair.
Great Reporting, Jim. This is the kind of news that no one like Issa wanted the general public to know. So it shall be.
One report I saw said that Davis was on a “visit visa”. You are right, though, the type of passport and visa will play a big role in what happens next if the rules are followed. Of course, this is the US dealing with Pakistan, where the rules are viewed merely as general guidelines by both sides…
Plausible.
SIX U.S. Congresscritters traipsing several thousand miles to Pakistan, when Congress is in session, to plead for the exit OK of a U.S. homicide perpetrator possibly protected by diplomatic immunity? And whom the U.S. would undoubtedly lack jurisdiction to prosecute?
Within a hairsbreadth of unbelievable.
Thanks for keeping your eye on this, with everything else going on.IIRC, they did the same thing on the name issue for the CIA station chief who was called home (claiming that the name was wrong).
Not that things ever come around to bite anyone in the butt, but I’ve seen stories from the area invoking the Siddiqui US trial with respect to what Pakistan should do with Davis.
Thanks for the, uh, very interesting report (and a lot of good “digging” to get the intel, uh, info). And good commentary.
My first thought??? He’s a spook with intel, and he’s our spook with intel. So we want him back, if for no other reason than to grill him & get whatever “goods” he’s got. Go read up on your John Le Carre, etc.
Issa leading the delegation? huh, that’s a good one. Guess someone’s giving Issa another bribe, which is no big surprise. Issa’ll do jest about anything if the bribe-money’s big enuff…
Oh, and plus: Issa can *relate* well to crooks ‘n spooks, being one of the former, himself.
Yes, when I was checking for useful YouTubes, I saw several linking Davis and Siddiqi.
Too many people that work for the Federal government have a habit of shooting off their mouths whenever a member of the press is nearby. They can’t help it.
Nice to see GOP lawmakers who wanna destroy social security by trumpeting the debt taking a very expensive trip, not only the congress critters but their staff going along for the ride. Wonder if there are dancing boys in Pakistan like in Afghanistan. Maybe that’s the draw for the closeted ones.
Now now. Can’t hold car theft against him. He’s a GD US Representative!
Darrell El Issa? That sounds kinda…mooslimy.
I was wondering when someone would spot that. His Wiki does state that he is of Lebanese descent.
Rana also said that Davis, charged with murder of two motorcyclists in Lahore, did not hold any special privileges as a diplomat. Referring to Article 49-2 of the Vienna Convention, he said that diplomatic officials only hold privilege when they are on duty, but Davis was in Pakistan on a business visa. Davis is being described by the American media as a security contractor from a Florida-based firm, Hyperion Protective Consultants, LLC.
From: http://dugg.pk/%E2%80%98accused-us-diplomat-holds-no-special-privileges%E2%80%99-102207.html
Hyperion Consultants. They assert they are in the “protection business”
http://hyperion-protective.com/
They appear from their web site to sell small building alarms. From their web site it’s not possible to discern any reason for them to be conducting business in Pakistan, they appear as a small supplied of security devices.
Not car theft. Arson.
Issa has a personal wealth of around $250 million that he got mostly through selling car alarms. That’s his voice in the most famous “Step away from the car!”
Maybe we’ll get lucky and they’ll hold on to Issa and his cronies as well, maybe even charge them with being accessories to the crime! One can hope…
Yes, I thought holders of diplomatic immunity held special passports.
In addition, I always believed that there were two exceptions to immunity: drug related offenses and criminal murder.
I’m sure on the former, drug trafficking, but less sure on criminal murder.
We should respect his heritage and call him by that name consistently from now on. I’m sure the teabaggers will LOVE it.
Darrell El Issa: Securing the freedom of alarmists worldwide!
Eleventy-dimensional
Oh, c’mon, Teddy. You know that was just a typo in the story I quoted. Possibly even an auto-correct in their software…
Heh.
Yes, let’s all start following the Vienna Convention because that’s how we can get our murdering spy back. Well, we don’t know it might not have been murder but instead justified homicide and he may not be a spy but boy oh boy he is somebody. They didn’t work this hard to get Gulet Mahmoud back from from the people who were torturing him for a week or so but they did send FBI to help with the questioning. I guess Issa was busy at the time.
The reference to the Vienna Convention is just another example of the law may become a tyrant’s whim. What about the Geneva convention and Bush’s gang declaring it “quaint”. These guys are comic book characters with too little self awareness to realize how ridiculous they appear. It is sad that even with every advantage and cheating like hell, they still lose.
Hey, put Issa in a line-up and see if anybody in Pakistan can identify him? He’s the tall one. Heh.
Especially if you spell it Dar-El Issa and pronounce Issa like “Esau”.
Oh, SNAP! :-)
Margaret I call that or something like that a huge BINGO.
There is money and more behind this shit . . . Issa has no business being there I don’t think, seems like a GOP gambit . . . which makes me wonder why did Obma admin approve this little junket . . . which I HAVE to assume they DID approve it.
Or, did the WH get FORCED into letting it happen (politics behind the scenes wonder what kind of leverage THAT would be)?
GreenH, yep, this stinks . . . n Issa makes it stink even more.
MZ, you just triggered a thought, Issa has something dirty on either Mz. or Mr. Clinton and it’s not stained dresses. He leveraged WH thru SecState . . . hm m m .
Great read Jim thanks! Rcc’d . . .