The crisis sparked by US “consular employee” Raymond Davis shooting and killing two Pakistani citizens in Lahore on January 27 heightened on Monday, when it was revealed that his victims were part of Pakistan’s “security establishment”, that a second Congressional delegation had intervened with the Prime Minister on Davis’ behalf and that the widow of one of the victims had committed suicide. Developments in the case continue at breakneck pace, with the story once again breaking into the Washington Post for Tuesday, where we learn that the US “has suspended all high-level dialogue with Pakistan” over the incident. Dawn fills in more detail on that suspension, noting that Pakistan’s President Asif Ali Zardari had been scheduled to visit Washington next month, but that trip now appears endangered. Further, we learn that Pakistan has added three more consular employees to the exit control list, preventing their departure from Pakistan. The unidentified employees are believed to have been in the car that rushed to Davis’ defense after the shooting, hitting and killing a third Pakistani who was on a motorcycle.
Here is how the Post describes the heightened tensions:
The Obama administration has suspended all high-level dialogue with Pakistan, a key U.S. partner in the Afghanistan war, over the case of an American diplomat the Pakistanis have detained on possible murder charges, U.S. and Pakistani officials said.
The case of Raymond Allen Davis, who has admitted he fatally shot two Pakistanis he said threatened him from a motorcycle while he was driving in Lahore on Jan. 27, has severely strained relations between the two governments and threatens to scuttle a planned summit among U.S., Afghan and Pakistani leaders scheduled for the end of this month in Washington.
The article goes on to describe some of the sources of tension:
In Pakistan, the issue has become embroiled in widespread anti-Americanism and suspicions, fanned by the Pakistani media and used for political advantage, that U.S. spies and intelligence contractors are secretly operating in the country. It has also posed a challenge to Pakistan’s weak civilian government as it struggles to wrest control of national security policy from the powerful military and fends off opposition political parties.
Further description of the various tensions within in Pakistan comes from the Times of India (it hardly needs noting that India is seen as benefiting from internal discord in Pakistan, but the newspaper had a hilarious editing failure, with the headline for this article staring off with “Tinkered, Tailored, Soldered, Spied”):
For instance, it turns out that even as Islamabad is publicly resisting American pressure, a section of the Pakistani establishment has revealed that the two men who were shot were in fact agents of the ISI, its spy agency. Adding to the confusion, the wife of one of the alleged robbers/spies died under mysterious circumstances in a Pakistani hospital after consuming poison, but not before she met journalists and issued a revenge call, demanding “blood for blood.”
Meanwhile, unnamed Pakistani officials also told the Express Tribune newspaper in Lahore that the Pakistani government’s “tough stance” on the whole issue was also a “reaction to the attempts by certain elements in Washington to implicate…the ISI in the November 2008 Mumbai attacks,” including the decision by an American court to summon top ISI officials in connections with the attacks.
This description goes beyond what was in the Express Tribune, which merely said the victims were part of the “security establishment” by stating outright that the victims were ISI. The article continues:
All this now makes it even more difficult for Pakistan’s civilian government to release Davis even if it now transpires, as was reported by the Express Tribune, that the two motorcycle borne men who were killed were ISI agents. An unnamed security official told the newspaper, which is brought out in collaboration with the International Herald Tribune, that the duo belonged to the security establishment and “found the activities of the American official detrimental to our national security.”
The Washington Post article also follows up on Pakistani accusations against Davis:
Further complicating the situation, a Pakistani intelligence official said that the two men Davis killed were not, as he has said, armed robbers intent on stealing money, his telephone and perhaps his car, but intelligence agents assigned to tail him. This official said the two intended to frighten Davis because he crossed a “red line” that the official did not further define.
It would be very interesting to know just how one crosses the “red line” to prompt an armed confrontation with security agents who most likely are ISI. The attempts to tie ISI to the Mumbai attack appears to me to be a more general accusation against US interests, so it doesn’t seem on first glance to fit as a triggering event caused by Davis himself, although it should be noted that Lahore is on the border where Pakistan and India meet, directly across the country from Afghanistan, so it is possible that Davis was investigating the attack.
More perspective on the widening diplomatic rift comes from Dawn:
The United States has put all bilateral contacts with Pakistan on hold until Islamabad releases an employee of the its consulate in Lahore, arrested for shooting down two men, diplomatic sources told Dawn.
The sources said that the dispute could affect three major events planned this year: President Asif Ali Zardari’s visit to Washington, the next round of US-Pakistan strategic dialogue and trilateral talks involving Pakistan, Afghanistan and the United States.
/snip/
They also want [sic] that the US Congress is currently considering budget proposals for the next fiscal year and the diplomatic row could affect $1.5 billion of annual assistance for Pakistan as well.
Escalation of the crisis is also seen on another front, with three more Americans being placed on the exit control list, banning them from leaving Pakistan:
Three more Americans, besides US official Raymond Davis who fatally shot two Pakistanis in Lahore, have been prohibited from going abroad, said an official.
The government barred the three more US nationals from going out of the country on allegations that they were in the vehicle that crushed a man to death in Lahore after Davis was involved in the shooting, the Express Tribune reported Monday.
Davis was arrested after he shot dead two people riding on a motorbike at a busy intersection in Lahore Jan 27. He called up the US consulate after the shooting and a team rushed to help him. The team’s vehicle collided with a motorcyclist, killing him.
The article does not identify the consular employees.
Stay tuned for further developments.



49 Comments

Oh Boy! Talk about the cobra and the mongoose. The CIA has put the American government in a pretty patch. The Pakistan army and security apparatus control the convoys into Afghanistan, and can shut them down in a New York minute. This will all be sorted out, but the US is going to pay a very high price in cash and diplomatic coin to bail itself out of this one.
‘Further complicating the situation, a Pakistani intelligence official said that the two men Davis killed were not, as he has said, armed robbers intent on stealing money, his telephone and perhaps his car, but intelligence agents assigned to tail him. This official said the two intended to frighten Davis because he crossed a “red line” that the official did not further define.’
Look! They did what they were sent to do. They frightened him and look what happened! That red line must have been something pretty ominous, but then again we still have no idea who shot Bhutto.
‘Soldered’, indeed.
Yup! Oil convoy bombed in Pakistan!
http://www.cnn.com/2011/WORLD/asiapcf/02/07/pakistan.oil.tankers.attacked/index.html
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-south-asia-12037634
Predictable!
Oh, yeah. Recall just a few months ago when they closed one of the main crossings and many tankers were torched while waiting to cross.
The widow of one of the Pakistanis appears to have suicided. By whom?
Well, US policy in the region seems to be soldered together in a pretty crappy way, so maybe it wasn’t really a typo…
Right on schedule. (Although these attacks have continued at a low level even after the crossing was re-opened a few months ago.)
We’ve got to stop going into other countries and treating their citizens as target practice. No wonder Bush can’t leave the country!
Davis knew he was being followed, bet on it.
We’re in a pretty pickle now.The CIA has been out of control nearly since it’s inception.
Makes one wonder what they’re doing with all those poppy crops they’re destroying. I just heard heroin use is up in my state’s high schools. Just great!
Well, you know it’s nearly impossible in Islamic countries for a womon on her own unless her family REALLY likes her.
If Pakistan knew what was good for them, they would extricate themselves from all American influence as soon as possible.
Not this time. On her deathbed she explained everything in detail. She killed herself because she thought there would be no justice.
Davis must be pretty important for the U.S. to go thru all of this, and so publicly in Pak.
Has anyone known a CIA agent that isn’t a certifiable paranoid kook? I haven’t and I have known a half dozen or more.
What did she say? Link?
Sounds fishy that she killed herself because she thought there would be no justice. Usually, a person might wait and see if there was justice.
Betrayus does have the problem of transporting Oil and Fossil fuel to the Oil and Fossil Fuel wars. But tanker trucks are useful targets to train the youngsters to fight in the Clash of Civilizations.
In fact attacking tankers, paid for by us taxpayers, is the new national sport in Pakistan.
It is reported and linked in yesterday’s post. Click the first link in this one.
This incident and the way the U.S. is handling it provides yet another reason for young Muslims to to enlist in anti-U.S. organizations.
Thanks
The response of the the American public to the events in Egypt and Pakistan should be a demand for the break up of the CIA. All the agents implicated in war crimes should be prosecuted and, if convicted, their assets should be seized. That would go a long way to paying off the national debt.
read the link to the WAPO that Jim provides. tells a great deal. it appears davis is being treated like we treat people. No due process and the state department is upset. They say in that article that we will do whatever it takes to get this guy back. who is he? what does he know.
WE ARE AS A COUNTRY ARE IN GREAT JEOPARDY BECAUSE OF THE ACTS OF OUR LEADERS. WHAT GOVERNMENT IN THEIR RIGHT MIND WOULD DEAL WITH THIS ADMINISTRATION? One major issue we need to deal with, THE WORLD KNOWS OBAMA SUPPORTS TORTURE AND DICTATORS AGAINST THE INNOCENT PROTESTERS. IF THEIR GOVERNMENTS GO ALONG WITH HIM, THE PEOPLE WILL RISE UP AGAINST THEM.
Not so much how important he is as to how much he knows. The fear also that Pak intelligence will know how to squeeze the info out of him.
For a government that would throw it’s own mother under the bus to advance it’s agenda they sure are going about this rather strangely.
Just by their actions they have shown the Pakistani’s that Davis is a high value individual. It appears that Davis used a fake name when he applied for a visa so I don’t think the diplomat angle is going to fly for a defense. http://www.thenews.com.pk/TodaysPrintDetail.aspx?ID=29956&Cat=5&dt=2/8/2011
I think Pakistan is going to shake down the U.S. big time for this as the U.S has very little bargaining power. The threat of aid with drawl will not mean much as China is ready to move in an set up a base there. http://bbs.chinadaily.com.cn/viewthread.php?tid=659356
Whatever the outcome we will never get the real story.
This one appears to have been for real, in the attempt at least. She was only 18 and married for a short time. When the attempt happened, there had been a flurry of press that had come out that indicated the back room deal cutting had been successful and that Davis was going to be released after a perfunctory ruling on his diplomatic status and she was distraught.
The odd thing is recovery for awhile before she died but a doc might chime in on that. JW probably has it more available, but IIRC, she took poisen that was used for rodent control.
ooops – see they answered this below already. If you had been following the story, though, it wouldn’t seem as out of place as it might coming in now. It really did look as if, after the Clinton intervention, it was all going to be swept under the rug – so much so that some members of Pak’s parliament were calling for a treason investigation of Zadari.
Latest From Pepe Escobar. Revolt Being Dissolved, WAS Televised.
Whoops, my 8:58 is on the wrong thread, sorry Mr. White, my bad.
This is Egypt in miniature. We’re scrambling, spinning, and throwing money at a problem to cover up illicit activity, spying and murder. This time it only involves one guy instead of an entire government.
I hope the Pakistanis prosecute him to the fullest extent of the law. The man killed two people on the street, he should be held responsible. After they find him guilty, though, I hope they don’t execute him.
Yep.
As has been reported (don’t know if FDL/MyFDL have covered this) there are likely huge issues regarding India, bombings in India, ISI, and more . . . all likely with US culpability.
Pakistan could very well get REAL pissed at us over it all.
A couple of other things are going on recently as well.
The actual preliminary report that was tendered to the court by the Foreign office made the finding that Davis is not a diplomat, but rather is “a non-diplomatic staff member of the US Consulate, who was given a certain level of immunity but not absolute immunity”
http://www.thenews.com.pk/TodaysPrintDetail.aspx?ID=3817&Cat=13&dt=2/6/2011
That source indicates that they are examining whether the “limited” immunity would cover the use of excessive force, carrying an “illicit” weapon, “boarding a vehicle with fake registration number and possessing objectionable material.”
And apparently that “objectionable material” might (they very much set up this implication) have included: “telescope, binocular, maps, masks and such like things.” A Financial Times story adds GPS trackers to the list. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/496571c0-338c-11e0-a388-00144feabdc0.html#axzz1DOAdUgKV
And apparently the issue of identity is still a real issue – whether that is as to whether Davis is “Davis” or as to what names appear on the visa given.
Two different barristers in Pak have filed petitions with the Lahore High Court in the case. One, the Ghazi Petition, seeks turnover of the Minister of the Interior’s file on Davis. Another, the Jafree Petition, seeks a directive from the court for Davis to also be prosecuted for forgery (I’m wondering a bit about the translation and whether they mean fraud) for applying for the Visa under a fake name.
It’s not clear what info Jafree has on Davis’ real name or the name(s) appearing on his Visa, but it does complicate a diplomatic immunity claim if a diplomatic Visa was issued to a false name.
Also – if Davis was operating under a false name and the US gov knows it, then under the US national security act they are/should be prohibited from putting into media that is or will be domestic media, false information (propaganda) about him.
Re: the SUV & its occupants, some of the reports about it included information that as the SUV ran over and killed the Pakistani citizen, the people in the street began to crowd it and the person in the SUV brandished weapons and threatened the people to help make their escape. Which would give you a whole second car full of weapson carriers in a place where they aren’t supposed to have them.
And a bit more – this is mostly an op piece and may not be reliable, but it hints at what some of the pushback may be.
http://nation.com.pk/pakistan-news-newspaper-daily-english-online/Opinions/Columns/08-Feb-2011/Is-Pakistan-a-playground-for-US-spies
The piece raises the possibilities that Davis might have been doing surveillance on Pakistan’s nuclear resources and might have been meeting with extremists to try to promote an incident/incidents in Pakistan that might give the US cover for a strike that would actually be directed at taking out nuclear resources. AGAIN- – an op piece only with its own agenda. But it does purport to provide inside info on what Davis was doing before the killings.
“Reportedly, according to the information revealed during the investigations, the US citizen had met some militants over lunch in a posh and exclusive diner in Lahore’s red-light area before going to Mozang for a personal meeting with another contact. This information is elicited from his cell phone record. But still Raymond’s personal details are a mystery. His name is suspect; he speaks fluent Urdu and Pushto; his profession and qualifications are false; and the US diplomats are hedging all quarries about him – all these are the hallmarks of an accomplished spy working in a target country.”
Another voice, in addition to the allegations in the petition, saying his qualifications are false.
If there were any nuclear backstory, that might highlight why so many are so wound up over this.
Or not – like I said, it’s hard to know what’s reliable. Everyone has an agenda
PJ Crowley, at least, has said that “there is an issue w/the name.” It was always couched as, “The reporters have got the identity wrong.” But I would bet it was designed to cover their ass on the alias front.
I wonder if any Pakistanis currently indefinitely detained in Gitmo can use this to their advantage?
All the more ironic as he is said to be fluent in Urdu, meaning he’s got better language skills to defend himself than a lot of people who got thrown in Gitmo.
Jim. Are they going to arrest the other three and are they all going on trial? How likely?
It was often claimed on Condi Rice’S behalf that she was “fluent in Russian” (and half a dozen other languages). You have to be very cautious around the cv’s of fascist operatives, even relatively minor ones. Still, it could be true. And if not, the irony is indeed delicious when one considers Guantanamo. And what of the many “drone victims” who got zero due process whatsoever….karma’s a bitch sometimes.
There are some foreign language YouTubes that merit closer looks because they purport to have copies of the false documents that Davis was said to have been carrying. They give close-ups of the docs, so we might be able to get some info from them. Of course, we would know nothing about their authenticity, which is why I haven’t spent any time going that direction yet.
Well they won’t have to rendition him to Egypt to get whatever information they may be seeking. Maybe they can set a new world record for number of times waterboarded on consecutive days(the US holds the current record). The US gov’t. is so dirty on prisoner treatment that anything they say will look pathetic and foolish.
Here comes another episode of Black Bush looks really stupid doing all the wrong things trying to cover up all the other wrong things that were already done. Isn’t that a form of looking back.
The story will come out here and the US gov’t. is not going to like having this go public. Does anyone support what we are doing in this case specifically and then throughout the world generally because I do not.
It’s even more wide spread than that… In Baluchistan…
Militants blow up gas pipelines
Some significant snippets…
let’s think about this a moment. Shooting dead “brown people” on the streets of their own country when very probably you are involved in subverting that country’s civil and military governance, and expecting a free pass from those same “brown people” and to be allowed to leave that country scot free? Websters? Shorter Oxford. Hubris? What’s the entry? Whatever it is, you could substitute with what I’ve just written I think.
Btw, here’s ISI’s retort…
Murdered motorcyclists ‘not intelligence operatives’
…A Pakistani intelligence official has strongly condemned the baseless and malicious report in a section of the press which alleged that the two motorcyclists shot by American national Raymond Davis in Lahore recently were intelligence operatives.
The report had claimed that the death of intelligence personnel was the reason behind the government’s reluctance to free Davis and that it was in retaliation against the summoning of a top official of the Inter Services Intelligence by a US court.
The intelligence official regretted that such a speculative report appearing on the front page of a major newspaper on such a sensitive matter, which was sub judice and detrimental to the security interests of Pakistan, was published without any confirmation from the concerned quarters.
The official vehemently denied that there was any link whatsoever between the summoning of the ISI official by a US court and the Lahore incident.
The intelligence agency reserves the right to initiate legal action against the paper, said the official
“that might give the US cover for a strike that would actually be directed at taking out nuclear resources. ”
the nuclear weapons in Pakistan are worrisome in the extreme.
That may be. But we have used ours and so far none of theirs have been used.
Victims’ identity: Intelligence officials refute claim
Intelligence officials have contradicted a report published in The Express Tribune, which alleged that the two motorcyclists killed by Raymond Davis in Lahore were intelligence operatives.
The report had claimed that the death of the intelligence personnel was the reason behind the government’s reluctance to free Davis and that it was in retaliation to the summoning of a top ISI official by a US court.
The official regretted that such “speculative reporting”, appearing on the front page of a major newspaper on such a sensitive matter, which was sub judice and “detrimental to the security interests of Pakistan”, was published without any confirmation from the concerned quarters.
The official vehemently denied that there was any linkage whatsoever between the US court’s summon and the Lahore incident.
The intelligence agency reserves the right to initiate legal action against The Express Tribune, said the official.
Published in The Express Tribune, February 8th, 2011.
There is at counterpunch.org for Tuesday a piece, I think by David Lindorff, which researches Davis’s employment – supposedly a security firm in Florida which is simply a store front, does not actually exist though it has a website. None of the phone numbers connected with it are legitimate. Provides other details in the article as well, that I had not seen in mainstream press.
But two hours ago ABC came out with the same story and it says it has 4 Pakistani intelligence officials for it
http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/ray-davis-shooting-pakistan/story?id=12869411
Which doesn’t mean it’s true, but there are so many agendas and so many pressure points for news outlets taht you can’t trust much of anything.
Supposedly some or all of the local investigation (not necessarily what the ministries have) is going to be made public Feb 11
http://tribune.com.pk/story/116115/raymond-davis-case-police-findings-to-be-made-public/
BTW – immunity, if it existed, would exist under the Vienna Conventions. I seem to recall, though, that our Department of Justice has held that in the case of non-uniformed combatants (spies and saboteurs) Conventions Don’t Apply.
Howdy Mary, Like the ABCNEWS said, “The Express Tribune was the first reported it.” I call you that I’m Pakistani (intelligence) officials but I calls you or the reporter could confirmation it? Of course not, they had called every major news in America. Bottom line, is it confirmed from the same Express Tribune and their news page has been deleted from their website.
Also the news from Pakistani Interior Ministry’s Intelligence Bureau [IB], officials from the IB have denied the two murdered Pakistanis were intelligence operatives and said they might sue the Pakistani newspaper that published this story.
By Greg Miller and Karen DeYoung
Washington Post Staff Writers
Thursday, February 10, 2011; 12:00 AM
Davis identifies himself as an American and repeatedly pleads with his interrogators to help him locate a passport that he says went missing shortly after he showed it to police at the crime scene.
A Pakistani intelligence official told The Washington Post that the motorcyclists were intelligence agents; a spokesman for Pakistan’s main intelligence agency denied that Tuesday.
“U.S. and Pakistani officials” agreed that the police report, written in Urdu, indicates that the two Pakistanis who were killed had robbed two individuals earlier in the day and taken their cellphones, which were found in their possession at the crime scene. These robbery victims came forward independently after seeing television coverage of the crime, saying they recognized the two Pakistanis who were shot by the U.S. official.
The report indicates that at least one of the motorcycle men cocked a weapon and aimed it at Davis while he was stopped at a traffic signal, but that neither of the Pakistani men fired.
“One cocked a pistol and pointed it at him,” a U.S. official said.
The two slain Pakistanis were found in possession of five cellular phones, a Rolex-style watch and four different
types of currency, the report indicates.