The tense saga of Raymond Davis, who shot and killed two Pakistanis in Lahore on January 27, continues. His trial in Lahore has been delayed again, with the next hearing date addressing the question of diplomatic immunity now set for either March 3 or March 14, depending on which report you believe. On Wednesday, Senator John Kerry visited Pakistan to deliver yet another threat of Congress cutting off funding for Pakistan if Davis is not released. In the meantime, analysis of records for the “businesses” with which Davis is associated in the US raises the interesting question of whether he recruits potential spies among students taking courses in international security.
The New York Times describes the hearing Thursday in Lahore:
A provincial court gave the Pakistani government three weeks on Thursday to decide whether the American official in custody for killing two Pakistanis has diplomatic immunity, a decision that amounts to a slap to the United States, the nation’s biggest donor and an ally in the fight against terror.
/snip/
The judge in Lahore, Chief Justice Ijaz Ahmad Chaudhry, ordered the Foreign Ministry to present its findings on Mr. Davis’s immunity in three weeks, a delay that is likely to intensify the standoff.
This hearing came the day after Senator John Kerry visited with Pakistani officials, including President Zardari, to argue for Davis’ release and presumably to threaten that Congress could withhold billions of dollars worth of funding to Pakistan if he is not released:
Senator Kerry, the chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and the sponsor of a $7.5 billion aid package for Pakistan, left Pakistan Wednesday night after meeting with top leaders, including President Zardari. He was confident, he said, that the Davis case would be resolved in the “next few days.”
It would appear that Reuters, and perhaps the people of Pakistan who are opposed to release of Davis, understand how the US Department of Justice operates when it comes to cases involving the war on terror or state secrets. From a Reuters article on the standoff:
While U.S. officials have said the Justice Department will conduct a criminal investigation of its own, it is unclear whether such a probe would lead to a trial.
The likelihood that, if he is freed, Davis will not face charges for his actions in Pakistan appears to be driving at least a portion of the outrage being exhibited on the streets.
Because the Davis case has all the hallmarks of Davis being an intelligence operative of some sort, there has been much public speculation about his US business activities. Not all of the information that is circulating appears to be correct. For example, many stories state that the Florida version of his business has never been registered with the state. Here is a partial screenshot from Florida public records indicating that Hyperion Protective Consultants, LLC filed registration paperwork in February, 2007 but was then dissolved by the state in September, 2008 for lack of an annual report:
The registered agent for the business in this filing is Gerald L. Richardson, Jr, who also is listed with the state as registered agent for a clothing business, Grynd Wear, LLC but doing business as Grynd Wear, Unlimited at this website. Grynd Wear and Hyperion listed the same Orlando address for their retail locations, but multiple reports indicate that the storefront is now empty.
An online resume for Richardson notes his association with Hyperion and indicates that before joining Hyperion, he worked as Prevention/Security Manager for a large firm in Orlando.
Although the Florida business has been dissolved by the state, an entity with a very closely related name is registered and still active in Nevada. There, it is incorporated as Hyperion Protective Services, LLC and lists Raymond Davis and his wife as Managing Members, unlike the Florida filing,where there is no mention of Davis. The address listed for the business appears to be a post office box in a UPS Store.
I have not yet found any definitive information on the Nevada registered agent, who is listed as Rachel Bender.
A very poorly written web description of the Nevada business links to the website of the Florida business, and so there is a direct connection between these similalry named businesses.
Although Davis has had multiple residences in the US, a Denver television station reported that he was living in the Denver area at the time of his arrest and even interviewed his wife.
The Nevada company is registered to operate in Colorado:
The registered agent for the Colorado filing is listed as Shadd Pease. A person with the same name comes up as working toward a Master’s degree in International Security at the University of Denver. From an online profile of Pease, we see that his resume is very similar to that of Davis, who also served in Special Forces:
The International Security program at the University of Denver held a “Global Security Career Fair” last October, where the CIA joined a number of other security agencies in recruiting among the students:
In conjunction with the career fair, the CIA also held an information session on Wednesday to explain what they have to offer and the characteristics they look for in employees, whether that be in the analytical field or the clandestine service.
/snip/
Also in attendance at the Global Security Career Fair were the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency, Immigration & Customs Enforcement, U.S. Army JAG, Army Recruiting, U.S. Marine Corps JAG, Boren Fellowship, and the State of Colorado Division of Emergency Management. Both the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives and Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS) plan to reschedule their campus visits after having to cancel due to unforeseen circumstances.
The massive growth in the number of government and contractor intelligence personnel, coupled with Davis’ company appearing to have integrated a student in the Denver program in international security into the firm, led me to wonder whether Davis might play a role in recruiting personnel into intelligence. Remarkably, when we list the various places Davis has lived, we find academic programs in international security that appear to be very similar to the Denver program near each location.
For the home office in LasVegas, we find the UNLV Institute for Security Studies. For the Orlando operation, there is the Global Peace and Security Studies Program at the University of Central Florida. There also is a business address and residence reported for Davis in Vail, Arizona, which is not too far from Tucson, where the University of Arizona is implementing a program to offer an International Securities Studies Certificate. At least one report also mentioned Davis having spent time in Lexington, Kentucky, where we find that a student can also concentrate on International Security. With five out of five of Davis’ known locations for living or conducting business being “target rich” environments for people being trained for intelligence careers, it is very hard not to come to the conclusion that Davis’ business function in the US may well be in recruiting for an intelligence agency or contractor.






53 Comments

I probably shoudn’t say anything (hahaha) but actual diplomats don’t travel heavily armed with disguises at hand. While our presumably pseudonymous Mr. Davis may have been attached to the US Embassy, he was based on his armed status prima facie not a diplomat in any meaningful definition of the word and thus should not enjoy the protection of diplomatic immunity.
Firearms and disguises are not diplomatic tools.
You know, it really doesn’t help my reporting on this story for you to have chosen that particular screen name…
Heh, sorry. If it helps, it’s highly unlikely our Lahore shooter is actually named that either.
In any case I’m with the Pakistani protesters except being against capital punishment. Lock the bastard up and throw away the key.
Thanks for staying on top of this Jim.
I do think they tried to send Kerry as the carrot after the stick, since he did cultivate a lot of friendships in connection with the funding bill (wonder why they didn’t send Lugar as well?) and Kerry did, for the first time, offer some remorse for what happened. Obama hasn’t even done that, with his casual reference to *it’s too bad that a coupla Pak dudes got killed and all, but the higher principle is, ya know, we’re the US and we get by with that crap”
The other thing no one is mentioning much are the US Vienna Convention violations for not cooperating vis a vis the SUV drivers. That topic – and the pedestrian killed, the others injured and the guns waved around – it’s the dog that doesn’t bark bc there is no legitimate US claim to not hand those guys over or for them to have any kind of immunity.
I’m sure Pakistan found the US investigation part reassuring. After all, the investigations of Guh Rahman’s killing, the shipping container killings, Dilawar, the torture lawyers, al-Libi’s torture/suiciding, the recent DOJ “victories” in courts declaring that torture and torture killings are states secrets, etc. – well, that’s the stuff of inspiration. Just ask Egypt.
Senator John Kerry visited Pakistan to deliver yet another threat of Congress cutting off funding for Pakistan if Davis is not released.
We gave Pakistan Billions for years and for years they would not let us step on their land to hunt Ossama we gave because a nuclear Pakistan falling to Ossama was a nightmare.
We gave even though most of the money was stolen and not used to help make life better in Pakistan.
But one American probably a spy shoots a Pakistani and is rightfully jailed and now Kerry wants to cut off Pakistan’s aid?
What about Ossama taking over and getting Nukes what about all the money we *cough* invested in making Pakistan a better place for the people to live so they would not choose Islamic Fundamentalism?
Where the heck was Kerry when the Bush WH outed Valerie Palme? Raymond Davis seems to be protected by the Left Hand of Satan just who the heck is his Clout? Who is his GodFather?
We know Pakistan has nukes and missiles we know they sell that tech to anyone who will pay just what could Raymond possibly know that could top what we already know about Pakistan?
Jim I like your evidence Raymond is a spy but Senator Kerry threatening to cut off aid to Pakistan confirms it for me he is a spy.
Americans get arrested all over the world in countries that torture people in prison but America never threatens to cut off their aid money.
Never mind send a senator to make that threat. Never mind Bush had no problems outing Valerie Palme .
Nope this guy is a spy, connected, and probably hopefully has some real dirt.
“The likelihood that, if he is freed, Davis will not face charges for his actions in Pakistan appears to be driving at least a portion of the outrage being exhibited on the streets.”
Why ever would they think that? Just because we’ve pissed away all our credibility since the turn of the century with our righteous holy wars and selective compliance with international treaties? Not to mention an endless litany of retarded xenophobic statements from Repub politicians. (Yes, they do watch the international news even over in Pakistan. The fiends.) How barbaric of those Paki’s. Why, who knows what they might do to Ray Davis in prison.
Kerry visits Pak to deliver an empty threat IMO. Dya think, with drone attacks & X-border ops, the U.S. is in any position to retaliate against Pak?
Boyofboy, Jim. You sure are into the details of this story. Good work.
Kerry does know Pakistan is a poor country right and with rising food prices being part of what sparked Egypt’s protests likely going higher since China’s winter wheat crop is a bust and huge parts of Australia are flooding any threat to cut off Pakistan hands their nuclear weapons to Ossama.
In fact I’m surprised Pakistan is not demanding more aid after all they have Nukes we can’t let them fall anymore than we can let a major arab oil producer fall.
What does Kerry really hope to accomplish by wasting his time?
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Jim White:
Question: “Does Raymond Davis Recruit Intelligence Agents in the US?”
Amswer: “Do Rabbits fuck?”
Since January 25th our corporate wars have come home at incredible speed. What is playin out in Madison Wisconsin is an extension of the anti-war democracy movement that is takin down governments in North Africa and the Middle East. Since our military has been hollowed out and contracted out, the recruitment of intelligence agents from publically funded colleges and universites is the new ROTC.
The wheels are comin’ off our corporate government and the democracy movement that started in Cairo and extended all the way to Madison is growin’ all over the US. The time is right for progressives to start organizin’ around and inside of the labor movement, the Democratic Party, NGO’s and 501C3′s.
Ask the questions, read the action reports but for Christ’s sake get out on the ground and do some work! See you all in Madison or wherever else the fascists are threatening the people.
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, FEAR IS JUST A FOUR LETTER WORD!!
Great original reporting from JWNN, once again… Isn’t it nice that all these sleazeballs have websites and dummy corporations hither and yon? And what IS it with the bad writing/spelling? If these are the diplomats, I’d hate to see the grunts.
Whats the latest in Madison how is the mood of the crowd do any normal people support the governor on this? Talking heads on tv will support anything but this is a little much even for a Tea Bagger to swallow.
Thanks, hag. Yes, the garbage these folks churn out in producing cover stories is just staggeringly bad.
Citizen TCU:
Kerry is the surrogate for Hillary who has absolutely no credibility or legitimacy in the eyes of the world, especially the Muslim world…he also hopes to get Mrs. McClinton’s job. He is Obama’s “Jessie Jackson” in the Middle East…my God what does THAT say about the state of our government or it’s intelligence?!
Kerry’s visit is a “good will” gesture (yeah, right). If the Paki’s don’t want to play the game on this one they won’t. Cut our supply line to Afghanistan by refusing to allow our supply convoys through and it is the end of the mission.
My money is on Davis being involved in an intelligence operation mounted against the Pakistanis. They know it, and whatever it was, the operation was sensitive enough to get them really pissed. One of the early reports out of Pakistan was that the two individuals gunned down by Davis were ISI agents. Then they weren’t. I’m thinking the first report was correct.
Kerry is our Jesse Jackson and whats wrong with sending Jesse Jackson? Maybe Jesse passed on this because its such a bad plan?
I agree Kerry wants her job but sometimes you just have to say No rather than get stuck doing a job where you know you can’t win.
Citizen TCU:
Can’t get there until this afternoon or evening…maybe not until tomorrow cuz I got a date with a syringe full a cortisone. I have heard from one brother on the ground that there are even more than the 5,000 that were in the rotunda the last 2 days and rumors are speadin’ like wild cannibus that there is somethin’ goin’ on beween the Governor’s office and security people to try and clear the grounds before Ed Schultz goes on the air tonight. Kinda like the speculation in Cairo about where the army was gunna come down and when.
If Davis applied for admission to Pakistan as a diplomat and was admitted as such, wouldn’t his status depend on treaties, conventions and common law? It is my understanding that the Geneva Conventions are not exactly clear on these issues, and much has been (historically) left to common law, reciprocity, and individual country interpretations. If Davis’ immunity is not absolute (and I really haven’t seen a definitive answer to this), then Pakistan may have some standing to hold on to him while reaching their own determination. On the other hand, the U.S. has lots of other pressure points that they could very quickly employ in a much more discreet and subtle manner. For instance, the U.S. State Department and DHS could instruct their embassies and consulates to give extra “scrutiny” to Pakistanis seeking visas to visit, study, or work in the U.S., they could unleash ICE in the Pakistani communities throuout the U.S., funds transfers could be held up or “lost” in the system. I would be watching for these other types of pressures being utilized and ramped-up over the next few days.
Yes. Force Pakistan to release this blatant criminal and….oh, provoke a full scale revolution in Pakistan. Just like Egypt and Tunisia the last few days only way more violent.
Talk about unintended consequences. No surprise to see “brainbox” establishment tool and plutocrat Kerry, “hitting the ball outta the park” for the cause of neo-liberalism. Could the Pakistanis please detain him too and throw away the key. They would be doing the world a favour.
As for “Mr Davis” or whoever he really is. Let justice (Pakistani) take its course. A swift trial and life means life is what I’d expect. Time for every country on the planet to stand up to the pathetic attempts at US-thuggery and call Obama LLP’s bluff.
Let Davis stay with his keepers in Pakistan. Rename the 7.5 billion aid package the: Ray Davis Block Grant For Progress and give it to the state of Wisconsin. Pretty good trade – everybody happy, even Davis who surely is enjoying the international spy-guy intrigue.
Errr. Afghanistan. Supply lines. Cut. Errr. Suggest the US is not in the driver’s seat here. Even if the US is too stupid to realise that.
Ok I’ll try and watch ed if I can I guess the Gov doesn’t want Wisconsin crowds to be to big when Ed does his show. But to clear the area especially when people know cameras are coming that could result in violence.
I hope you got a camera and tape recorder hidden someplace safe the lesson from Egypt the Right learned is beat or rape the press and no pictures no net.
Any bets the Gov of Wisconsin has an internet kill switch he could just shut off the power for the city its inelegant but should work.
Gee, I hope they don’t torture him…that would get Kerry and Obama really mad.
Davis was on to something. The odds are it had something to do with Pakistan’s nukes. Hard to see any other reason why the Admin would push so hard on this one, and so openly, given how costly it is for them in Pakistani public opinion. Even so, it is a huge mystery. Someone said that he must have crossed a ‘red line’. What was that line? Did he think he was going to be executed on the spot, and drew first? He’s a highly trained professional. What would have pushed him to take the risk he assumed by shooting his shadow?
One thing is certain: the US government really wants him back and out of danger. I guess they know what can happen if he goes into ‘rendition.’
Those supply lines and tanker trucks have already been disrupted and damaged, and the U.S. has made its pitch to Pakistan on that issue. That trucks have continued to be detroyed and hijacked shows that Pakistan is not the most reliable partner. I don’t know whether Obama wants to go to the mattresses over Davis, but the U.S. is hardly helpless and impotent if they want to make an issue out of this. Another concern of the U.S. is that any successor to the current government in Pakistan could be much more hostile toward what we see as our interests, so destabilizing the current Pakistani government by really pissing off its people could result in something much worse than disrupted military supply lines. On a long-term basis, the loss of Pakistan as a transit point for military supplies would be a hard loss to take, but the U.S. could find a very short-term work-around if they were determined to force the release of Davis. Yes, the U.S. needs Pakistan to resupply our military in Afghanistan, but Pakistan is not China.
I think this is how they will spin this story…he’s not a killer but actually a hero.
BTW great reporting Jim and thank you!
He was covering for his Skull&Bones brother trying to determine how they could choreograph the theft of the 2004 election.
Ye gods, did “Chet Uber” compse that “very poorly written web description of the Nevada business”?
“Our concepts and methodology has been perfected over the years, leaving the best service this market has to offer. How, you may ask do we accomplish such an extravagant boast, allow me to explain!!!!!!”
There is already talk of a prisoner swap for Neuroscientist, Aafia Siddiqui, sentenced to 86 years in prison in the U.S. for trying to shoot her marine interrogators at a U.S. base. There is so much going on behind the scenes because I don’t see any other way to account for all of the pressure from both sides. What Davis was doing, and what the ISI agents following him were doing may eventually be disclosed, but it was likely sensitive and embarassing for both countries.
All funding to pakistan needs to stop. they are the biggest threat on the planet. they will be responsible for nuclear weapons use by directly, thru stealing by terrorists or supplying to another crazy country. They are biggest trainer of terrorists also, where do you think money to training camps comes from. US aid.
Every cent of the money given to pakistan goes to increase nuclear arms. It’s time to stop all aid to them and tell them to give up al quaeda. It’s their ISI game that they don’t know where the terrorists are holed up.
It’s time to stop supporting this dangerous country.
I’d go for that, but it’s only fair if the Pakistani’s are allowed to non-fatally shoot Davis whilst “escaping” first.
I totally agree. The reason Kerry went to Pak was to deliver just such a message.
Great investigative reporting, Jim. Amazing what you can find via Google or other search engines, isn’t it.
Davis is obviously with the spook world, and my read is that he was captured when he bungled his operation (or his escape).
You make a good case re his activities in the U.S. Please keep up with this great work.
Look. The US faces problems much more massive much closer to home. Neo-con fantasy bomb-into-democracy campaigns in Asia are irrelevant on every level except that where they provide sinecures to idiot, neo-liberal stooges.
If Pakistan falls, Afghanistan will be a disaster one hundred times worse than Vietnam. The rescue helicopters at the end, pulling folks out of the embassy building will all get shot down. It will be carnage.
But never mind that. The US is facing a possible #Jan25th as its economy collapses and corruption accelerates exponentially right across the board.
You shouldn’t be concerning yourselves with “geo-politics” any more. You aren’t in that game any more. It’s obvious to more or less everyone except the US itself.
I was wondering about the official line, that “Davis” was being chased by two guys, (either on one or two motorcycles, still not sure which) that wanted to rob him. Were they going to stop him and steal his wallet, guns, car.. or just have him pass the stuff to them through the window? “” just doesn’t fit the action.
knut, your analysis seems spot on. Davis is a highly trained person who was being persued by two possible ISI agents. They wanted him stopped. For what reason? Must have been very critical. And our consulate knew the reason, bc they sent the SUV to extract him. Did Davis call them? or was he being followed by them?
This is better than the Bourne series.
Highly trained? The balance of his actions in a volatile foreign country suggest that he is a gung ho, fascist thug with no compunction at all about shooting “brown people” and the neanderthal level of sophistication typical of the wingnut fringe of the US right wing. Bourne fantasies purport to show a hero who is clean, anti-establishment and on the side of good. Davis is on the side of pure evil, without a shadow of doubt.
On the SUV. Have the Pakistanis got the driver/passenger yet?
The court is acting properly by asking its foreign office to confirm whether Davis had immunity. But the underlying theme here is a high stakes game of chicken, indicating that conditions in Pakistan and its relations with the US are both volatile.
Whether an individual has diplomatic immunity is ordinarily up to the foreign government posting the individual. Diplomatic immunity is acknowledged by a host government at the start of an assignment.
The usual consequence for someone with diplomatic immunity – assuming Davis had it at the start of his tour and the US is not attempting to apply it retroactively – who sufficiently irritates the host government is for the host government to declare that person “persona non grata” and to have them sent home by the foreign government. Examples would include committing serial violations of the law and persistently abusing social norms or local customs.
Spies are tolerated, though their activities abuse formal diplomatic relations, so long as their activities remain with bounds. Getting caught spying is one way to go out of bounds, though foreign governments routinely strenuously deny that their spies, those with diplomatic cover and those operating nakedly without it, are spying. Committing a major crime in public would be another. The UK and Russia are just finishing a tit for tat expulsion of purported spies.
It is highly unusual to detain, let alone try, someone who actually had immunity, even for alleged criminal behavior. That defeats the purposes for which it is granted.
Getting at the facts is the hard part. The most likely scenario is that Davis was spying. We don’t know whether he was working on nuclear counter-proliferation or attempting to smuggle drugs. It seems apparent that he determined that he was in a kill or be killed situation, and killed. Two men, who might have been domestic security agents, died. The SUV driver(s) are long gone and won’t be found.
This is a major embarrassment for Pakistan, especially if Davis found out damaging information, and for the US. It is tragic for the families of the dead, too. We don’t know whether the shooting was justified and are unlikely to find out.
Diplomats travel with armed guards routinely. In hot spots like this, though it’s almost certainly against the rules, I imagine they sometimes travel armed themselves. If Davis was granted full diplomatic immunity, he can be sent home, but not tried in Pakistan. To do otherwise is a breach of treaty and custom.
That said, emotions are high because of the deaths of both a civilian and two apparently armed domestic security agents. And that’s without getting to whatever Pakistan is or may be doing that Davis was sent to investigate. There will not be a short resolution to this affair.
Nice work, Jim.
Scott Horton has more, including confirming that Davis’ grant of immunity requires more than his holding a government employee passport: he has to have been recognized as having immunity by the host government.
http://harpers.org/archive/2011/02/hbc-90007995
We don’t know the answer to that, neither does the local court, which is why it asked its foreign office for an answer. No doubt, Washington is furiously negotiating with Lahore on that issue, since whether he had immunity seems as murky a subject as what Davis was doing in Pakistan.
Asserting that a private security contractor – Davis was not a recognized employee of State, DoD, etc. – has diplomatic immunity is not routine. It may be unheard of in Paris or London, but sometimes done in unstable regions. Clearly, Davis was not engaged in normal diplomatic or consular work. My guess is that keeping as many people from finding out what he was doing is the only common interest the US and Pakistan have in this affair.
Murder isn’t covered by the Vienna Convention. Specifically,
Murder is considered a grave crime.
It was interesting to hear what American consular official Constance Beale said about the proposed Davis — Siddiqui swap today. She said, “The two cases are completely different. One is a diplomat and the other is a terrorist.”
I think she was confused, Aafia Siddiqui was a neuroscientist, not a diplomat.
Heh. You beat me to it.
The massive increase in spooks is what strikes me as important. Spooks who will be needed here more and more as the Wikileaks smear story shows.
For instance I assume among the Wisconsin protesters are a dozen or more representing several interests.
Agreed. I think I need to spend some time looking at that growth in intelligence personnel and agencies.
True. But it doesn’t matter. Once public opinion hits a critical mass favoring real change, all of the spooks and secret police in the world are powerless.
If sending billions to the Pakistani government is deemed to be in America’s best interests- and I’m not saying it is- then how does them holding one spy/thug/operative who panicked and lost it in typical American fashion and started emptying magazines into brown people change whatever voodoo geopolitical calculus made sending those billions in American taxpayer money there seem like a bright idea?
Here’s an idea: instead of propping up dictators and exporting state violence and otherwise making a mockery of the principles we loudly and self-righteously espouse at every opportunity, we begin actually honoring those values and stop providing people the world over with good reasons to continue hating us?
If Davis is a spook , he’s not very good at it. It appears this is the second time he’s been caught.
As per Dawn: http://www.dawn.com/2011/01/28/us-official-guns-down-two-motorcyclists-in-lahore.html
“A senior police officer told Dawn that Raymond David was among four people who were detained by security personnel near Lahores Sherpao Bridge on Dec 9, 2009, when they were trying to enter the Cantonment area in a vehicle with tinted glasses. They were armed with sophisticated weapons. The intervention of the US consulate led to their release, the officer recalled.”
It makes it understandable why he applied for a visa under a false name.
Also the poor bugger that got run over by the Prado that was racing to Davis’s aid was running with false plates and fled the scene. You can bet they got spirited away real quick.
“He said the Prado used by David’s other colleagues bore a fake registration number (LZN-6970) which was originally issued to a Suzuki Cultus car. “
Thanks for that. I hadn’t any references to that earlier incident.