Last Thursday, I presented evidence that builds a strong case that one of Raymond Davis’ functions when he is in the US is to recruit intelligence agents. On Tuesday, the Express Tribune in Pakistan presented evidence that suggests that Davis also worked as a recruiter of some sort within Pakistan, as well.
The Express Tribune quotes an official from the Punjab police on Davis’ ties to the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP):
“The Lahore killings were a blessing in disguise for our security agencies who suspected that Davis was masterminding terrorist activities in Lahore and other parts of Punjab,” a senior official in the Punjab police claimed.
“His close ties with the TTP were revealed during the investigations,” he added. “Davis was instrumental in recruiting young people from Punjab for the Taliban to fuel the bloody insurgency.” Call records of the cellphones recovered from Davis have established his links with 33 Pakistanis, including 27 militants from the TTP and Lashkar-e-Jhangvi sectarian outfit, sources said.
The Times of India picks up on this accusation, and spins it to suggest that Davis may have been double-crossing the US in an article with the suggestive headline “Did Davis double-cross US as recruitment point man for Taliban?”
American official Raymond Davis, arrested for double murder, had “close links” with Taliban and was “instrumental” in recruiting youths for it, the media here claimed on Tuesday, close on the heels of reports in the US that he was a CIA agent tracking movements of terror groups like LeT.
The “close ties” of 37-year-old Davis, arrested in Lahore on January 27 for killing two men he claimed were trying to rob him, with the Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan came out during investigations, ‘The Express Tribune’ reported quoting an unnamed senior official of Punjab Police. “Davis was instrumental in recruiting young people from Punjab for the Taliban to fuel the bloody insurgency (in Pakistan),” the official said.
I lean toward the explanation that the Express Tribune offers for Davis’ actions:
Davis was also said to be working on a plan to give credence to the American notion that Pakistan’s nuclear weapons are not safe. For this purpose, he was setting up a group of the Taliban which would do his bidding.
Isn’t it interesting that Davis’ “bull in the china shop” act has bungled so much in what may well be covert US activities in the general area of weapons of mass destruction? Could the inept way Davis has operated be more fallout from the grave damage done to the CIA’s WMD program when Dick Cheney “outed” Valerie Plame?
Although there have been some suggestions that Davis was in fact very high up in the CIA organization in Pakistan, and perhaps even acting Head of Station since the recent “outing” of the person in that post, I’d like to believe that Davis is a lower level functionary since he was so sloppy in how much incriminating material he had with him when the shooting incident went down. One argument in favor of this interpretation lies in the sheer number of “agents” the US has in Pakistan. From the Washington Post:
It is unclear how many of the U.S. mission’s personnel are private security contractors or intelligence agents, many of whom work alongside Pakistani agents on counterterrorism operations, including the CIA drone program. A U.S. Embassy spokeswoman declined to provide figures; according to data provided by the Pakistani Embassy in Washington, 3,555 U.S. diplomats, military officials and employees of “allied agencies” were issued visas in 2010, most of which were valid for three months.
Pakistani commentators and opposition parties have filled that vacuum of information in recent days with numbers of their own. In a recent newspaper column, Raoof Hasan, a media adviser to the chief minister of Punjab province, of which Lahore is the capital, wrote of “scores of other Raymonds roaming the roads.” Last week, the chief of Jamaat-e-Islami, a religious party, told a gathering of tribal elders that there are “thousands of Raymond Davises.”
Whatever Davis’ true assignment in Pakistan might have been, it is clear that this incident has had and continues to have a profound influence on Pakistanis’ opinion of the US and on US-Pakistan diplomatic relations. How the case will be resolved remains to be seen, but former Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi offered a very interesting take on the next steps during an appearance before the Rawalpindi District Bar:
“The whole nation is unified on the independence of the judiciary…free judiciary will help bring foreign investment,” said Qureshi. “Lawyers’ role in ending dictatorships and restoring democracy cannot be ignored,” he added.
Qureshi appreciated the role of Bar and Bench for the fight of restoring democracy in the country.
“Accountability is possible only by good governance and transparency…lawyers would have to continue their struggle for strengthening democratic institutions as they have done in the past,” said the former minister.
If Davis is to be released, it is certain that the release will be contingent upon the US promising to carry out its own criminal investigation of Davis killing the two Pakistani citizens. Does anyone believe that the US judicial system under Barack Obama and Eric Holder is independent enough for such an investigation to be credible?



41 Comments

The answer to your last question is “NO”. Raymond Davis must have been trained by Inspector Clouseau. Truly incompetent.
Great post, Jim. Recommended.
“Does anyone believe that the US judicial system under Barack Obama and Eric Holder is independent enough for such an investigation to be credible?”
Give Davis a joint and drop him off at an anti-war demonstration and prosecution is guaranteed. :)
“Although there have been some suggestions that Davis was in fact very high up in the CIA organization in Pakistan, and perhaps even acting Head of Station since the recent ‘outing’ of the person in that post, I’d like to believe that Davis is a lower level functionary since he was so sloppy in how much incriminating material he had with him when the shooting incident went down.”
You are assuming it is a meritocrisy with only the best and brightest getting promoted, but that just isn’t the case. I wish I had a link to it, but not too long ago there was an article talking about how Bush admin screw-ups are being promoted by Obama to where they can scew up even worse than when they were under Bush.
LOL. You don’t need a link. Just watch Washington. It’s pathetic. But great if you are an eleventy dimensional chess playing bipartisan hack.
Either he has some real dirt but what can be worse than what we already know about Pakistan? Or yes Raymond might have been creating dirt?
The FBI bomber in Oregon recently comes to mind so does Jose Padillia. All this high level Washington visits by Senators and threats to cut off Pakistan’s aid was not there for Valerie Palme so obviously something is different this time something bigger than the WH lying about Saddam and Niger Uranium.
Just what exactly is unknown so lets speculate imagination is one of our best tools.
Jim,
democracynow had a short segment at the very end this morning on Davis. Think it was Guardian reporter. Think your & ew coverage has been much more in-depth, but you might want to review it to see if there’s any nuggets. The focus was keeping it secrud in the western press, checking with WH (Guardian did that too) before printing, long after it was widespread in biggest Eng language press in the world (Indian, I think).
“Intelligence Recruiter”…….bwahahaahahahaha…sorry. Considering the super duper secret agencies have done nothing but create chaos and destruction everywhere they go, it’s far to funny to refer to them as intelligence. More like hired goons.
If Davis is to be released, it is certain that the release will be contingent upon the US promising to carry out its own criminal investigation of Davis killing the two Pakistani citizens.
No Pakistan wants more money and no Pakistani will believe any promise by America that we will try a spy for killing Brown People. Lots of Pakistani’s have relatives in America relatives who can tell their relatives back home there will be no trial.
Does anyone believe that the US judicial system under Barack Obama and Eric Holder is independent enough for such an investigation to be credible?
Bwahahaha! Snark Tag needed Barak Obama was a Constitutional Lawyer true but I suspect Jon Yoo and O shared a few classes.
The NYTimes lies??? Say it ain’t so, Joe. Jason Blair, Judith Miller ring a bell?
Indiana Deputy AG who suggested using live ammunition on demonstrators has been fired. Couldn’t happen to a nicer guy.
The NY Times is a CIA managed operation… ie they are right in there at the highest levels of management.
“If the American people knew what we have done, they would string us up from the lamp posts.”
-best G H Bush quote ever.
The world owes you Julian Assange.
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Jime White:
Awe man, this is HUGE!! If the Indian and Pakistani press can expose the corporately sponsored terror recruitment and organizing, then the entire “war on terror” goin back to the 1967 War in Palestine will be exposed as a Reichstag Fire to justify American (and Israeli) imperialism and military oppression. This is why I have been callin’ on FDL lawyer types to start trackin down the history of the corporitization of the military and the State Department since 2001.
Awe man, I been tellin’ ya that the wheels are comin’ off of our Imperial bus but I really didn’t think it would happen so fuckin’ fast!!
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, THERE IS NOWHERE FOR THE BASTARDS TO HIDE ANYMORE!!
Citizen TCU:
The democracy movement has comepletely disarmed our destabilization and war-by-proxy efforts that have been goin’ on at least since the late 1950′s but certainly in the ME since 1967. This is not goin’ to go well for establishment politics in this country…now it’s more important than ever for us to get our military the hell out before their used as cannon fodder for the corporate mercs.
A few years ago, as reported by the print media, General MCchrystal while in London made comments about Pakistan to be “chaosistan” (paraphrasing). He knew something then what we are learning now.
I don’t think Davis will be let out on a promise that he will be prosecuted in the US. The Pakistani’s know what that promise is worth. They will demand a pound of real flesh, not the cotton candy they’ve been offered so far. When the US raised the ante and then sent Kerry over, they also showed the Pakistani’s that they could raise the price. Who is teaching basic bargaining theory over at the WH? Are they extrapolating from the wonderful job they did on the Health Care Fiasco. Let me into that poker game!
That leaves where we were yesterday. Why did the US show its cards so early? Davis has got something that is valuable enough to throw away years of diplomatic capital. Like Norske, I’m wondering if the real secret is not the one they are hiding from the rest of the world, but the one they are hiding from American citizens. Was Davis an agent-provocateur?
Think sabatoge of the nuclear program.
“Could the inept way Davis has operated be more fallout from the grave damage done to the CIA’s WMD program when Dick Cheney “outed” Valerie Plame?”
It’s an interesting theory. Might she be able to publically answer it?
Pakistani Federal Govt is in a very strange situation. They would like to release R.D at the command of their “master” but it would mean big trouble for them through a backlash from people that mind end up in regime change. The provincial govt. of Punjab is mostly in opposition to Zardari and his stooges and it would make every efforts to make Zardari and Gilani look super poodles.
That’s a keeper.
According to printed reports in Indian and Pakistani print Mr. Davis was issued a diplomatic visa in Islamabad after the shooting incident. And “revised” diplomats list after the arrest of RD showed his name. His name was not on the diplomats list that was issues a few days earlier.
The US wants Raymond Davis released.
news report, Feb 15
http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20110215/ts_nm/us_pakistan_usa
Or is that only propaganda for American consumption?
Dawn, Feb 16, 2011
Raymond Davis does not enjoy blanket immunity: Qureshi
http://www.dawn.com/2011/02/16/us-should-realise-pakistans-sacrifices-in-terror-war-shah-mehmood-qureshi.html
Shah Qureshi has been quite vocal even after meeting with Senator Kerry that Davis should rot in a Pakistan jail (or worse).
Might Kerry and the Shah be on a different agenda than the one publically proclaimed by the O-man?
http://www.thenews.com.pk/TodaysPrintDetail.aspx?ID=4180&Cat=13&dt=2/23/2011
I wonder if the truth about this will ever be known?
Did this guy kill three people? did he shoot one person in the back, who was trying to get away?
Initially the us said he was not a cia employee. now it’s admitted that he is.
It’s astonishing, that the President of the USA is speaking publicly about this.
This is very interesting.
details details!! quibbles! /s
“Does anyone believe that the US judicial system under Barack Obama and Eric Holder is independent enough for such an investigation to be credible?”
Only if they still believe in the Tooth Fairy, the Easter Bunny, the Sandman, Santa Claus and monsters under the bed.
No admissable evidence, state secrets. Oh yeah, it will be a short trial.
I wonder what kind of interrogation techniques the Pak has? This may be a real coup for people who want to know the truth. Ask him about Kennedy and 9/11. (just kidding)
weird:
London, Feb 20(ANI): Double murder-accused US official Raymond Davis has been found in possession of top-secret CIA documents, which point to him or the feared American Task Force 373 (TF373) operating in the region, providing Al-Qaeda terrorists with “nuclear fissile material” and “biological agents,” according to a report.
Russia’s Foreign Intelligence Service (SVR) is warning that the situation on the sub-continent has turned “grave” as it appears that open warfare is about to break out between Pakistan and the United States, The European Union Times reports.
http://in.news.yahoo.com/cia-spy-davis-giving-nuclear-bomb-material-al-20110219-224833-452.html
waste of time, I don’t think that story is worth looking into.
sorry.
Here’s the latest from the AP where they talk to someone high up in the ISI:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/02/23/AR2011022305040_pf.html
The ISI is upset because Davis wasn’t acknowledged to them as CIA and they say they don’t know how many CIA affiliates are in Pakistan. It also talks about the visa mill called the Pakistan Embassy in Washington, which gave away hundreds of visas without the usual vetting.
“I wonder what kind of interrogation techniques the Pak has?”
Well, they know water-boarding, solitary indefinite detention, and drugs are OK. If he really pisses them off, the old “death by natural causes” technique is OK too.
Just ask the USG.
“Does anyone believe that the US judicial system under Barack Obama and Eric Holder is independent enough for such an investigation to be credible?”
Errr. The rule of law has completely broken down in the United States quite some time ago. Didn’t you notice?
“Pakistan’s intelligence ready to split with CIA” runs deeper than Davis because of the US cozying up to Pakistan’s arch-enemy India, which endangers Pakistan security.
Which creates a question in my (cynical) mind — could Davis have been a double agent, employed by India to engage the TTP? That would explain Kerry’s apparent position on abandoning Davis to the Pakistanis. A little Sharia punishment may be just what Kerry wants for Davis.
MSNBC lied about him being a CIA contractor yesterday.
If U.S. officials are funding the Pak Taliban, is that not a possible violation of U.S anti-terrorism laws and a serious criminal offense, possibly warranting imprisonment?
Should this not be fully investigated here?
How high up did this decision go? If this went to the top, might impeachment not be warranted?
And now there’s this:
Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) agency’s relationship with the CIA has been put into question after the shooting death of two Pakistanis by Raymond Davis, a contracted agent of the United States, AP reported Feb. 23, citing an obtained unreleased ISI statement. An unnamed ISI official told AP that the ISI had no idea who Davis was when he was arrested and that the ISI fears that there are hundreds of CIA-contracted agents operating in Pakistan without the knowledge of either the Pakistani government or the ISI. The ISI knows and works with senior CIA officials in Pakistan, the official said, adding that it is upsetting that the CIA would secretly send other agents to Pakistan. The official said that the ISI is currently not talking to the CIA at any level, even the most senior level, and that in order to regain support and assistance from the ISI, the CIA must start showing more respect.
“fallout” by Catherine Collins and Douglas Frantz
review:
” investigative journalists Catherine Collins and Douglas Frantz document masterfully, the claim that Khan’s operation had been dismantled was a classic case of too little, too late. Khan’s ring had, by then, sold Iran the technology to bring Tehran to the brink of building a nuclear weapon. It had also set loose on the world the most dangerous nuclear secrets imaginable—sophisticated weapons designs, blueprints for uranium enrichment plants, plans for warheads—all for sale to the highest bidder. Relying on explosive new information gathered in exclusive interviews with key participants and previously undisclosed, highly confidential documents, the authors expose the truth behind the elaborate efforts by the CIA to conceal the full extent of the damage done by Khan’s network and to cover up how the profound failure to stop the atomic bazaar much earlier jeopardizes our national security today.
Fallout takes readers inside the CIA’s covert operation to penetrate the Khan network and exposes the agency’s desperate and ultimately flawed plans to sabotage the nuclear programs of Iran and Libya. In vivid scenes and convincing detail, the book reveals how the CIA recruited a family of Swiss nuclear traffickers to spy on Khan and help bring down parts of his operation. Collins and Frantz also take readers behind closed doors in the hallowed halls of power in Washington and other world capitals, where they chronicle how the U.S. intelligence agency later enlisted the most senior officials of the Bush administration to protect CIA assets by pressuring the Swiss government to destroy a staggering amount of evidence and derail the planned prosecution of a team of U.S. intelligence agents who violated Swiss laws.
More than a high-stakes espionage thriller, Fallout painstakingly examines the huge costs of the CIA’s errors and the lost opportunities to halt the spread of nuclear weapons technology long before it was made available to some of the most dangerous and reckless adversaries of the United States and its allies. ”
I tend to believe the rule of parsimony applies here. Davis is a low level CIA operative or CIA contractor. The Pakistanis probably were robbers. He used excessive force. The consulate showed reckless disregard by sending the SUV on a rampage through town. There was an apparent effort to change Davis’ diplomatic status after the fact. The Pakistani courts will have to sort this out, or the U.S. will have to compensate the victims.
This is a rather amazing incredible accusation and the other claim there may be “thousands of Davises” is horrifying.
I like the idea of transferring Davis to the International Criminal Court to ensure better objectivity and fairness.
What kind of ‘secret’ operatives goes around with all that equipment and cell phones & stuff? It’s almost like something out of a bad or comic spy movie.
It’s called projection
Wow.
At least now we know why Petraeus jumped right in with that idea that all those burned Afghan children had had that done to them by their own insurgent parents to make us look bad. That’s just the sort of deviousand twisted shit we pull, and you can’t very well think any better of other people than your self-knowledge allows you to think of yourself
I can hardly wait until the tens of thousands of mercenary spooks start rotating back here ever more frequently. Hanging out the shingles. Cold eyed realist, special ops experience, have gun, will travel.
Merlin was a disastrous gambit in Iran when Plame was around. It seems like there is continuity more than that things went downhill after Plame left. Is there any chance Davis was involved in picking drone targets?