Seizing on a recent NBC/WSJ poll (PDF) showing 60% of Americans continue to support offshore drilling, several journalists and pundits have implied that support for offshore drilling has not declined sharply in recent weeks. As I’ll show below, this is absolutely false.
Bill Schneider, National Journal:
Nor has the oil spill caused public support for offshore drilling to collapse.
Louise Radnofsky and Jean Spencer, The Wall Street Journal:
Public support for expanding the offshore hunt for energy is sturdy.
Jeffrey Birnbaum, The Washington Times:
Remarkably – at least so far – Americans are not running away from the need to find oil in the sea. According to recent polls, roughly two-thirds of those surveyed believe that offshore oil exploration is still a good idea. And that number has remained relatively steady even after weeks of massive leakage in the Gulf and the creation of an oil slick the size of Maryland.
Others, such as Politico’s Dianna Heitz, have sought to downplay the massive drop in support:
While the level of support has fallen, the drop-off has not been as sharp as some had expected, a finding attributed by experts to Americans’ overall concern about U.S. energy security.
Six major national polls released in recent weeks show that, in fact, support for offshore drilling has fallen off considerably in the wake of the disastrous oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico:
- A CNN/Opinon Research survey found that support dropped 17% between August 2008 and May 2010.
- A Rasmussen survey found that support dropped 14% between April 2010 and May 2010.
- A Fox News survey found that support dropped 16% between April 2010 and May 2010.
- A CBS News survey found that support dropped 16% (PDF) between August 2008 and May 2010.
- An Ipsos/McClatchy survey found that support dropped 14% (PDF) between March 2010 and May 2010.
- A Pew Research Center survey found that support dropped 9% (PDF) between Feburary 2010 and May 2010.
Here is what that looks like graphically:
And it isn’t just national polls that have shown a major decrease in support for offshore drilling. Several recent statewide polls have had similar findings:
- A Greensboro News-Record survey found that support dropped 14% in North Carolina between April 2010 and May 2010.
- A Rasmussen survey found that support dropped 11% in Florida between June 2008 and May 2010.
- A Public Policy Polling survey found that support dropped 14% (PDF) in North Carolina between April 2010 and May 2010.
- A Rasmussen survey found that support dropped 10% in California between April 2010 and May 2010.
- A Mason-Dixon survey found that support dropped 20% in Florida between June 2009 and May 2010. (H/T Think Progress)
- A Rasmussen survey found that support dropped 12% in Texas between April 2010 and May 2010.
The decline in support for offshore drilling is unequivocal. Pundits and journalists who claim otherwise should be held to account.




41 Comments




Pravda in high gear.
Pundits are highly paid corporate whores out to shill whatever swill their corporate masters dictate to them. The vast majority of pundits are a waste of the space time continuum.
People aren’t stupid, they can see the video and photos and it is an ugly picture out there.
Plan on the old tried and true diversion of a foiled domestic terrorist plot soon to get this nasty oil business out of the news. For God’s sake, corporate profits and political careers are at stake here.
PEW=SUNOCO OIL CO, WIKI IT
The time pundits are allowed on the air or in print should be based on the number of times there musings are proven accurate and stand the test of time. Make a statement that turns out to be patently false they lose one day of on air time or 1 less article a week. In time these a@@holes will be but a bad memory.
Thank you for this excellent diary.
Even with Rasmussen polls, support for offshore drilling has been dropping precipitously since the spill. By the time the oil hits the Gulf Stream, support for it will look like Bush’s approval ratings circa 2008.
When Fox and Rasmussen both show a drop in support of a right wing issue the Media hacks should have been asking why the NBC/WSJ was wrong.
But of course the hacks only get on tv to boost the one poll the Corporations liked.
We should not be drilling for oil in any water, anywhere, ever! What the hell is wrong with people.
We could display their right wrong stats with a moving news bar like CNN uses with break downs of those stats Tweety wrong about politics lets say 30% of the time, wrong about the Left 99% of the time wrong about how much the country loves Bush before 9/11 70% after 9/11 wrong 2% after Katrina wrong 65%
Numbers completely made up but categories of wrongness like the economy, Healthcare etc. Plus a special category for lies about facts we can google in 5 minutes.
That’s a rhetorical question, right?
*Bonus* if lie can be proven wrong by line 1 on google query response.
The U.S. public is the most ignorant, naive and easily manipulated electorate of any advanced industrialized nation in the world. Is the U.S. still an industrialized country? Time to educate the masses.
Unless the spill is fixed soon these numbers will only get worse. Whats the earliest Fishing can resume and oil will stop floating up on beeches? Until both those things happen the polls of voters in oil spill states will stay anti oil.
Agreed! :) how do we mesh the scores of being wrong on predictions David Broder is my bet for champ of that category.
With just outright lies? Rush and Drudge will battle for that title. I think we should score wrong predictions, as equal with Lies. But I am open to suggestions.
Mistakes will be counted as lies the press can always say I’ll get back to you or let me check google why judging mistakes from lies is hard and if the mistakes were kept to a low level we would not need to do this.
What does a X% drop mean – there is ambiguity in how the data is presented.
A 10% drop means support went from 60% to 54% (10% of 60 means support dropped 6 points)? Or from 60% to 50% (10% absolute drop)?
The numbers are just qualitative if you don’t explain how to interpret them. A better chart would show support at the different survey times.
Of course.
Something big is happening at the leak site right now! http://tinyurl.com/368ll3a
We’re up against Flush, Oliely, Beck, Oshanity and the likes of Faux spewing hate and lies practically 24/7.
My WKRG.com live feed, operating over 24 hours, went all “missing plug-in” on me a few minutes ago.
(Hate it when they lie like that.)
hit my link. BP is still up
Major explosion.
What…
or cave in.
click my link in post 19 it’s to the live feed from BP
Tony (mr toad) Blankley (Gingrich flack) likes to champion these supposed polls showing 60% approval for off shore drilling. It heartens him – he was despondent that people would lose their gusto for “drill, baby, drill.”
This has been continual for about 20 minutes now
Thanks, but zip, though video from other sites, e.g. sports.yahoo, works: was using the other one because I’ve never been able to connect at BP.
Maybe I should point out that I’m using linux.
Anyhoo, I’ll probably be able to get on later …
More than likely it’s the propeller-powered camera bot repositioning, stirring up the bottom. I have watched several of these.
The people united cannot be defeated!
That makes sense.
That is the problem, the people are divided.
I hope you’re right but the camera was still and everything just blew up. Debris everywhere. BP then cut the transmission and switched to what appears to be a completely different leak. Looped tape maybe?
There was one a few nights ago – when the silt or whatever cleared, an eel swum into the frame and hovered very near the riser.
There is no longer the time and other information on there. I think it’s now a loop.
Two minor corrections, Josh:
– It’s the Greensboro News & Record, although the fact that its Web site is News-Record.com frequently confuses people. (Couldn’t use an ampersand in the URL because some computer systems interpret that as a command.)
– That poll was simply reported by the N&R. It was neither carried out nor commissioned by the paper.
Jim White is upstairs!
Droplet Size, Which BP Cannot Control, Is Critical to Biological Effects of Dispersed Oil
I think they went to a loop for most of Sun night after the whatever-it-was. The time stamps made no sense, and stayed pretty much within a certain hour.
Wow the ROV is panning back and forth to some fan that turns on and off. WTF are they up to?
Damn – significantly more riveting than outerspace walks…