There’s really no hope for this country, I fear. If there is, it certainly won’t be in my lifetime. And why do I say this, you might ask? Well, actually, no one asked, but I’m going to answer anyway. It’s because you can never, ever underestimate the collective stupidity of the American public.
We just had the most dispiriting Presidential debate in the history of so-called political discourse. Two candidates who are so closely aligned on nearly every single policy issue that they’re probably soul mates. One is a congenital liar who wears magic underwear and the other one looked bored, annoyed and like a human punching bag. Despite the media’s fondness for politics as entertainment, any fool could see that neither of those clowns up there really won on style, substance, congeniality or the evening gown competition. But, of course, someone had to win. The public demands it. And the winner was Romney.
So a week later, a Gallup poll comes out and finds that Mitt has overtaken Obama in the polls – or at least he tightened the race up quite a bit. And thus, the proverbial lemmings – that constitute the largest portion of the voting population – just move along with the tide. But then again, that’s pretty much what the entire presidential election has become. Obama gives a convincing speech – “He’s on my side. I’ll vote for him.” Romney gives a debate performance of some dubious quality – “What a man – I’m for him!” And so they react to the latest mindless stimuli.
But what causes me even more resigned despair are the people that really believe in either of these guys. And the problem is, there are millions of them. Tens of millions of true believers, ardent supporters, my political party do-or-die. And that boggles my mind. Voting against their best interests. Ignorant of what’s really going on inside the carnival of lights and costumes. People, who sometimes know just enough to justify their position and will fight tooth and nail to defend it, but miss the big picture. They’ve got one jigsaw puzzle piece in their hand, and they are sure they seeVersailles. And their candidate is the best – and he’s going to win, by gum.
I’ve heard progressive Democratic or liberal people say, “I’d love to vote for a third party candidate, but until they have a real chance of winning, I have to vote for Obama.” And this makes me nuts. Who are you waiting for to make it a viable possibility? If all of the voters who have been let down by this corrupt system voted for Jill Stein or Rocky Anderson (or even Ron Paul) – it would move the goalposts – would change the direction of the Democratic party at least – or it might even finally elect a worthy candidate. But instead of doing that, they wait for someone else to magically make it happen. They don’t give their money to the Green or the Justice Parties – they give it to the Democratic Party. They vote for them, canvas for them, get out the vote for them and leave it to another election, another decade, another century for anything better to even possibly take place. If they can’t win (despite the obvious superiority of their policies and positions), they won’t vote for them, it’s as simple as that.
It’s the new boss, same as the old boss – but at least he’s a winner. The third party candidates, despite being quite often, moral, decent people who are not bought and paid for unlike our current choices, are tossed aside as losers. It doesn’t have to be this way, but it is, because people want the simple, quick, “efficient” solution. And, they want a simple winner that doesn’t require them to think too much, or do too much, or go out of their way too much.
It’s the same thing everywhere you look.
Walmart’s, McDonald’s, Bank of America – all these corporate players – people won’t lift a finger to move their money, shop at a local store instead of a big-box one, eat healthier – because it’s too much trouble or inconvenient for them. So, they keep the corporations afloat that ruin lives and health and dictate regulations and policy to their political puppets. And the people – the struggling, the poor, the marginalized, the working classes – keep making excuses for why they’re helping keep this wretched, self-defeating system afloat – without lifting a finger to actually change things or make a discernible difference. Or, they just keep raging against the machine that they’re helping to keep permanently in place.
You can’t get a majority of people to go along with anything except collective obedience, blind allegiance and unrelenting conformity. But, at least they’ll have backed a winner. Only problem is, the losers are all of us.



16 Comments

It’s conformity through fear for both parties, comrade.
Don’t leave the hard work to your grandchildren, A-merkins.
“Winning isn’t everything, it’s the ONLY thing.”
–Vince Lombardi
What a contemptible lie! In sports, as well as politics. But what you are seeing, Kate, is the logical extension of sports analogies into politics and economics. There are a lot of people in this country who will vote for someone just because they think they will win, only so they can brag about pulling for the winning team to their friends and neighbors. They’ll turn their coats in a heartbeat if the situation changes.
There are sports analogies here as well. Native Clevelanders who are Steeler fans, or Raiders fans in Denver, or pick your NFC East rival fans in Texas. I lived in Denver when the Broncos made their back to back Super Bowl victory runs. It was amazing how many people went from silver and black to blue and orange for a year or two, then switched back as soon as the Broncos started their inevitable decline.
Those folks vote the same way and are proud of it. They think they’re smart. They’re not. And when it’s clear that the ruling oligarchy is collapsing, they’ll be cheering on the revolution.
Recc’d.
“And when it’s clear that the ruling oligarchy is collapsing, they’ll be cheering on the revolution.” Well, there is that.
I’m not so sure that the problem is stupid, uninformed people and blind party loyalists – there never has been a shortage of those. And yet we still got the New Deal, SS, Medicare, etc. all of which eventually had broad support across the political spectrum.
The big differences that I can see are 1) the countervailing pressure from the labor movement and the competing ideologies of socialism and communism that convinced the PTB back in the 30s, 40s, 50s and 60s that they were better off cutting deals with the proles than risking outright rebellion is basically gone in this age 2) the concentration of media ownership in the hands of the plutocrats and large corporations which has suppressed or marginalized any information and opinions that are at odds with the prevailing right-wing ideology 3) the influence of corporate money on election funding which has played a major role in the marginalization of progressives in both major parties (yes, there actually used to be Republican progressives). It’s hard to have a major party be an opposition party when it’s beholden to the same corrupting forces it’s ostensibly opposing.
Yes, the American people are collectively stupid but people are generally made stupid by their environments. And we definitely have a cultural and intellectual environment designed to make people stupid and oblivious to the forces shaping their society. As John Lennon once sang:
Keep you doped with religion and sex and TV
And you think you’re so clever and classless and free
But you’re still ****ing peasants as far as I can see
But I guess in our age we’re being kept doped with smart phones, i-Pads and Facebook
“Yes, the American people are collectively stupid but people are generally made stupid by their environments. And we definitely have a cultural and intellectual environment designed to make people stupid and oblivious to the forces shaping their society.”
Quite. So were the a lot of the English in the 1630′s, the French in the 1780′s, and the Russians of the early 20th Century. Look what happened. The historical parallels are by no means identical, but they definitely are there.
One of the biggest assumptions that got burst in each case was the conventional wisdom that “it can’t happen here.”
Oh, yes. It can. It will unless the PTB wake the hell up from their “we’ve got it great!” revel. I know which way I will bet.
I think you underestimate the counter-revolutionary potential of misinformation, comrade Barbarian.
And I thought I was a pessimist, thinking revolution is inevitable, and possibly civil war with millions dead, were America’s unavoidable future.
You make me feel like an optimist. That is very strange to me. I kind of like it, though.
I think you overestimate both the intelligence and real power of our ruling classes, and underestimate the majority of my fellow Americans. Underestimating Americans is at least as foolish as underestimating Russians or Germans or British or Afghans or Iraqis or well, anybody.
“You can fool some of the people all of the time, and all of the people some of the time, but you can’t fool all of the people all of the time.”
–Abraham Lincoln
I have my own addendum to Lincoln’s statement: Some of the time, you can’t even fool most of the people, and that’s when they take you down.
America is getting closer and closer to that last, IMHO.
Yeah, I think we’re in agreement. I think the lid has been kept on the bottle by the preoccupation of folks with gadgets, celebrity gossip and the like and, as I pointed out, by the weakening and marginalization of the countervailing forces of the labor movement and competing ideologies.
For a while many folks could say “Isn’t it terrible about those poor people losing their homes and jobs” while deluding themselves that they were somehow insulated and immune from those things suffered by the less worthy. But as more and more people are affected and realize that they were only lucky and not immune then their calculation changes.
I certainly hope were not in for the likes of the French or Russian revolutions but I wouldn’t mind seeing half a million people gathered on the National Mall protesting the Catfood Commission or the indifference of the Obama Justice Department to the tidal wave of white collar crime we’ve endured.
Shall we make it a bet, then?
“Television is the opium of the masses.” Ragg Mopp.
Does anyone remember the demise of the Soviet Union? There were young capitalists dancing in the streets. Even some of my neighbors. They cried, “Socialism is dead, Capitalism rules!”
I’m going like, “Oh, Jesus, here we go.”
I doubt that any of them had a fucking clue what either of those words meant.
Nobody that I know personally, has a clue to what’s going on. They don’t know any more than they see on the evening news. Maybe what passes as news is part of the problem.
Amerikans have a self centered mean streak that crosses all political and economic boundaries. The propaganda machine may feed this beast but it didn’t create it.
Now that you mention it …
Agreed.
Now let us see if we can think of anyone (any nation/people) that doesn’t.