Obama’s EPA approves 42 of 48 mountain top destruction permits.
Did Obama throw Appalachia’s mountaintops under the bulldozers? Yes.
Same thing with Appalachian valleys.
At Coal Tattoo, Ken Ward Jr. shares this from EPA Director Lisa Jackson‘s press secretary:
…."We have concluded, under the law, that six projects of an initial 48 permits EPA reviewed, will not proceed unless adverse environmental impacts are further reduced. We will continue to follow the law and use the best science as we quickly and thoroughly evaluate over 150 pending applications to reduce harmful environmental impacts.”
“EPA decided not to provide additional comments on the remaining 42 permits after consideration of the nature and extent of project impacts. 28 of the projects have two or fewer valley fills. Eleven have no valley fills at all. None have more than six.
Gee, "only" 31 of the 48 approved permits fill valleys. Of those 31, 28 have two or fewer fills: so that’s as many as 56 filled valleys. The remaining three approved each fill fewer than six: so that’s as many as 15 filled valleys.
Out of 48 permits Obama’s EPA considered, they’ve OK’d filling up to seventy-one valleys. But wait, there’s more.
Obama’s EPA has nearly 150 permits left to review. At the rate they’ve been going, they’ll be rubber-stamping enough Bushie permits to fill another two hundred and thirteen valleys.
Grand total just from this batch of permits? 284 ancient valleys destroyed forever. Homes, communities, farms, lives: destroyed forever.
Changes we can remember? If folks do nothing, perhaps. Across Appalachia, residents and their supporters are doing something – a whole lotta something. Litigating, organizing, and sitting and walking with their neighbors and friends. Organizations like Mountain Justice Summer use non-violent civil disobedience as one of many tools in keeping the mountains tall, the hollows deep, and the people on their land.
Looks like the Mountain Justice Summer and other local campaigns as well as a whole lotta enviro attorneys will need help. Hope they get it. The more coal we burn, the faster we’ll bring hell upon today’s 10 year olds.



21 Comments

Alank’s great diary has a whole lot more on this.
Over at Daily Green, ‘Appalachian Apocalypse‘ gives the NRDC’s dismayed response to the Obama Administration and Lisa Jackson’s decision.
Kirk,
has there ever been a Legislator Field Trip to show exactly what mountaintop removal really does to an area, to review the hellacious damage all ready done?
As someone who lives not far from the all encompassing depression of the eco-rape of the Coal Region in NE PA, I can’t even begin to fathom the hideous destruction done by mountaintop removal. The damage is more than cosmetic, and more than ecological, it’s the decimation of the heart and soul of the land AND the people who live there.
Thanks for keeping this story going. Recommend!
Watershed impact studies are ongoing at WVU. I sent this enquiry to Prof. Strager last December:
He replied pretty quickly:
So, there’s much data collection and analysis.
Elliot, that’s a great question and a great idea. If there hasn’t been such a Legislator Field Trip, I hope folks in the Coal Region will organize some (hint, hint *g*)….
spreading the word.
Obama is sure turning out to be changey, but not in a good way.
Oh, but kirk, they build nice golf courses with scenic views, on top of them later!!! and other fine developments!!
in the 8th grade i went to a work camp thing in kentucky…here and there, we got to see local things..one was a strip mine..after seeing and being blown away by the beauty of the area, i was HORRIFIED. i mean horrified. it was indescribably HUGE. i kept bringing it up the entire time i was there. ‘it employs people’ same answer i get now.
there are people around here who will never be convinced that it is a crime to do this. ‘coal is king’. ‘it’s jobs’. to people losing their water supply for their land–wells affected for many square miles and no ‘water company’ to tap into, losing their homes near family and lifetime neighbors and nowhere to resettle, it’s tragic.
here’s a great article about the permits and the epa/doj dance going on right now, from charleston, wva.
http://www.wvgazette.com/News/200904270334
http://blogs.wvgazette.com/coaltattoo/
here’s a good ‘energy ‘blog through that paper..called coal tattoo.has a post about the recent storm flooding due to mining. gets into global warming, and the new ‘path’ project electric lines that isn’t just going to affect wva. haven’t seen much about the ‘path’ project, that is a whole ‘nuther thang.
gee, i remember when mountaintop removal was outlawed, that didn’t last long. seems so long ago.
Oh, Kirk
This is terrible. I am beyond disgusted with our new Prez.
Can’t wait to hear the Eleven-teen Dimensional Underwater Chess (TM) justifications for this.
Thanks for writing about this.
FunnyDiva
good on ‘ya!
dmac, thanks for those articles and your obsrvations – and FunnyDiva, I’m glad you like the diary. Hope you get a chance to rread alank’s, as well!
And alank: so glad you got in touch with Dr. Strager – great question. I’m looking forward to checking out his links.
thanks to both kirk and alank. two great diaries.
yer ‘welcome..those are two great sources of info.
wsaz-tv also does quite a few stories on these issues. there are not many tv stations or newspapers in these areas. this one is out of charleston and huntington. where i am, in seohio, except for ou’s woub, tv stations are out of columbus-2 hours away, or wva-2 hours away. i watch the wva station.
forgot to add, we had a ‘tour’ of the mine. we drove for a Long Distance across a desolate, butchered area to get to the place where we viewed the wall..where the guy in our group explained the seams of coal being under layers of earth.it was pretty much closed that day. reminded me of a ghost town. equipment of such a large scale that i couldn’t fathom how it even worked, how you even got into it.
it was one of the creepiest, scariest places i have ever been. i wanted to get out of there asap. the many hundreds of feet high wall and as far as we could see long, was cool though. but not cool because of what had to happen to see it. i was stunned. i had never seen anything like that. didn’t know it went on. i kept thinking, you could get accidentally lost here and noone could ever find you. scary. (i was into indians, tracking and hiking at that point.)
it really was eerie. i still get that feeling when i see photos of it, like alank’s diary and the same photo used on the blog i linked.
like i said earlier, laws were passed, enforced in the courts, just a few years ago, what happened?
Here’s an example story on the PATH project. Its hideous. The beneficiaries are major corporations, primarily.
http://www.theshepherdstownobs…..e0109.html
The inefficiency of long distance power line transmission is well-established. Energy loss is proportional to the extent of the transmission lines. More power has to be generated by burning fuel and more CO2 in the atmosphere to deliver the same amount of electrical power further distances.
http://westvirginia.sierraclub…..round.html
http://pennsylvania.sierraclub…..-line.html
Not to mention the blight and disturbances imposed by such a system.
observation:
obama has clearly flipped on mountaintop removal.
observation number 2: in the very specific area that didn’t vote for him.
observation number 3 is a question of sorts: is this payback?
not cool. not change I can believe in.
Seconded.
Everything I’m reading is that Enhanced Geothermal is here right now. Drill baby drill three, four five kilometers down ALL OVER THE US, not just where there are hot springs.
Shoot unheated water down. Let it flow over the hot rocks. Suck it up another pipe It doesn’t have to be boiling, because you’re using a binary turbine. The liquid inside the turbine has a lower boiling point than water. Are coal plants using this technology on there turbines?
The hot rocks only last for ten or twenty years. Then you have to give that well a rest, but it will come back, because the earth’s heat is a constant. All that drilling is a lot of VERY SUSTAINABLE work for the United Mine Workers Geo Thermal Drillers.
It’s not perfect, because you can bring up some nasty gasses from underground, but unlike wind, it’s a stand alone replacement for coal right now. It carries only a fraction of the environmental impace that coal has. GeoThermal spread out over enough wells is very reproducible.
In the summer you can run the turbine faster, by adding some solar heat in spring, summer, and fall. Enhanced GeoThermal runs better in the winter (especially in northern states), because the air is cooler.
The bulk of your costs up front are in the drilling and mud logging.
I’m not against wind or solar, but until the battery technologies improves, they are not stand-alone replacements for coal in much of the US.
The political culture of this country has become incorrigible. Can’t stop the banks. Can’t stop big coal. Can’t stop big oil. Can’t stop Halliburton. Hey, at least Blackwater’s more-or-less toast. Them we can stop at least.
does it bring up floride gas?
thanks kirk. recommended. i’d already read alank’s article. both really good.
AFAIK, methane, hydrogen sulphide (H2S) and carbon dioxide (CO2) are the three most commonly occuring gasses faced by geothermal drillers. Not sure about FL, so thanks for bringing it up. Not sure how much drillers run into it, nor what the options are when they do.
this is why the insane endorsements for Obama from people whose teenagers liked him set my teeth on edge. from mccaskill to caroline kennedy, from pat leahy to ted kennedy to tom hayden, they got in line.
and look what their devotion brought them (I’m bitter; I voted for Edwards and then Clinton and I fully believe neither would have done this).
my browser decided to ‘go away’ yesterday right when i was going to post/edit this link into my comment—
http://www.wsaz.com/charleston/headlines/44458937
is a poll on reclamation. but they don’t mention that it shouldn’t be done this way in the first place.
it is an example of what happens locally, that people get caught up in reclamation conditions, that the mining is inevitable so focus on what’s gonig to be here later kind of thing…
wsaz is a great resource. and they pay attention to letters, so, be explicit and don’t be abrasive, they listen. goood bunch of people who care about the area/people and want to present all sides of an issue.
thanks alank..yep, ‘path’ is an ugly snake creeping and people don’t even know mcuh about it yet.
Thanks for taking the trouble to introduce the resource here.
Yes, the reclamation question assumes the highly destructive surface mining practices are a fait accompli, when they are not — in fact — at least in the case of the pending permits.