Tuesday night the Oakland Police force, or their armed colleagues, fired into a crowd of unarmed American citizens at point-blank range. One of the weapons fired into those citizens struck US Marine and Iraq War veteran Scott Olsen in the face. Within minutes after that attack, Olsen was barely able to speak. Fortunately, Scott Olsen’s roommate was able to tell Keith Olbermann that not only was Scott conscious and speaking after the head injury, but also was able to walk into the hospital. Unfortunately, that roommate reports the injuries the Oakland PD (or one of the agencies Oakland summoned) inflicted on Scott Olsen’s head and brain are so severe that his treating physicians had to place him in a medically-induced coma.
…officials at Highland Hospital in Oakland said today that one protester, 24-year-old Scott Olsen of Daly City, a member of Iraq Veterans Against the War, was in critical condition.
The antiwar group said Olsen, a system administrator at a San Francisco software firm, suffered a skull fracture when he was hit by a “blunt object.” Olsen joined the U.S. Marines in 2006, served two tours in Iraq, and was discharged in 2010, the group said.
Video footage widely distributed on the Internet shows a protester, identified by the antiwar group as Olsen, being carried away by others with a head wound. While he lay wounded, the footage appears to show an officer tossing something – perhaps a tear gas canister – toward people trying to help him.
“I think it is a sad state of affairs when a Marine can’t assemble peacefully in the streets without getting injured,” said Jose Sanchez, executive director of Iraq Veterans Against the War. “We are pretty upset about it.”
The Oakland PD and their armed colleagues fired their “less than lethal” projectile weapons at point-blank range on trajectories parallel to the ground, rather than from greater distance on arcing parabolic trajectories. The latter trajectory minimizes kinetic energy (and hence injury); the former pattern maximizes kinetic energy and hence maximizes injury.
When projectiles hit our skull, the kinetic energy of the projectile propagates through the skull and throughout the squishy tissues inside. Chemical weapon projectiles such as tear gas canisters travel at velocities so high that the impact of these canisters can cause immediate fatal injuries. That happens when the weapons directly strike our relatively squishy throats. That can also happen when the weapons hit our skull so forcefully that they rupture blood vessels, causing massive intracranial bleeding.
Deadly injuries also happen when the chemical weapon projectiles slam into our skulls with force so great that the shock waves literally shear the long fibers–axons–which are part of our brain cells. The result–diffuse axonal injury–is part of the mechanism believed to be responsible for traumatic brain injury. TBI is our diagnostic name for the syndrome seen in patients who survive brain injuries. The more rapidly someone loses consciousness after non-penetrating head trauma, the more severely the brain has been injured. The longer someone remains unconscious (barring medically-induced coma), the more severe the head injury. The longer a post brain injury medically-induced coma is necessary, the more severe the brain injury.
Many vets who survived IED explosions on the roads in Iraq and Afghanistan were hit by blast waves carrying enough energy to pass through their skulls and across their squishy tender brains. Some of these vets will recover from those brain injuries. A great many others suffered brain injuries so severe that they will never recover.
I don’t know whether Scott Olsen survived AEDs or other brain-injuring attacks during his Marine service. I do know that like all Marines, he swore the oath that begins with the promise to preserve our Constitution:
I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same;
I also know that Tuesday night Scott Olsen stood on a street in Oakland as an American citizen, exercising his right as specified in the First Amendment to the Constitution that he pledged his life to uphold as a US Marine. And I know that Tuesday night, as he lawfully exercised the Constitutional right he risked his life to defend in Marine uniform, someone wearing the uniform of the Oakland PD, or the “law” enforcement agencies Oakland summoned up to squash lawful protest, fired the round that felled Scott Olsen.
From what Keith Olbermann reports, I know that when Scott Olsen lay stricken and motionless on the pavement a few yards from police lines, not a single one of the officers sworn to “protect and serve” came to his side. I also know that one of the one those “law” enforcement officers waited until civilians came to Scott Olsen’s aid, and then targeted them with the explosive “flash bang” grenade that exploded next to his head.
I also know that as of last night Scott Olsen was in critical condition. I know the impact of the injuries “law” enforcement inflicted upon him during his non-violent protest was so severe that it caused not only brain injury, but also skull fracture.
And I know that the deliberate policy of the Oakland Police Department, along with “law” enforcement agencies across America, to violently suppress First Amendment-protected public assembly, directly caused Scott Olsen’s injury.
I wish I could be as certain that Scott Olson will fully recover. Sadly, I cannot be. None of us outside his hospital can. If his severe head trauma with skull fracture is similar to that of many patients I’ve seen, even his doctors may not be certain he will fully recover.
But we can all be certain that the descent of American law enforcement culture and practices towards a paramilitary force that occupies our nation, at the increasing peril of our rights and our Constitution, deprived Scott Olson of his healthy brain and body, at least for a time.
To stop the same derangement from destroying our Republic, we must peacefully reclaim our public spaces and our First Amendment rights to assemble and petition for the redress of grievances from the people who go to work with guns on their belts, and from the rulers who order those public servants to take arms against us. We must use our speech and our consciousness to peacefully reclaim America and her values and her law enforcers from the oligarchs behind the 1% and their progressive, deliberate extinction of our Republic.
The oligarchs hiding behind Shock Doctrine and forced austerity as they kill off our Constitution and loot our future know exactly what they are doing. FDL’s readers and the Occupy movement know exactly what the oligarchs are doing–and why.
What the Oakland PD and their armed colleagues did to Scott Olsen shows us all what the oligarchs will do to us if we let them. Which is why we must stop them by any peaceful means possible.
Defend the Republic: support Occupy.



58 Comments

tweeted and recommended — thank you dr murphy
Thank you, Suzanne!
Excellent post Kirk, recced.
I’ve been writing here at FDL anticipating this and giving people suggestions what people can do. The video that you might have seen was by Matt Kresling who took the KTVU footage and made it easier to see what was happening.
One thing we have this time vs. the 1960s is a plethora of footage that we can use to show the abuses and track the offenders.
This is something that the media will not do, but if we do it, they will run with it. KTVU had the footage, but they were still going with the official story that the police didn’t use flash bang grenades. They were claiming that what you were seeing were protesters setting off fireworks.
The Oakland police need to be shut down.
This entire episode calls out for a federal civil rights investigation. Isn’t right to assemble still in the marked-up Constitution?
I can think of a few other things that need to be done to the Oakland PD.
Recommended, Dr. Murphy. Thank you.
Rcc’d, Doc.
Excellent post, thank you. Very well said.
Unfortunately, Teddy, Attorney General Eric Holder is the top federal law enforcement official in this country and he, like Barack Obama, fully supports the two tiered system of what passes for justice in this country. The 1% can do anything they want to anyone they want anytime they want to do it. The 99% are subject to the corrupt application of the laws without recourse.
This is the United States today. There will be no federal civil rights investigations because the federal government has been capture by the kleptocrats.
We are on our own and no one is coming to rescue us. We have to win this revolution or we shall perish.
Sounds grim, but make no mistake. We are going to prevail so long as we remain united because we are legion and they are few.
They can run but they cannot hide.
Venceremos!
Well done, doc. Recommended.
rec’d & tweeted. Thank you, Dr Kirk.
recc’d and tweeted.
Reposted at Progressive Alaska, Dr. Murphy.
People need to remember that this happens every week in the West Bank to peaceful protesters. Some, like Emily Henochowicz (lost an eye to a rubber bullet) and Tristan Anderson (in a coma for almost four years from the same projectile that severely injured Scott Olson), are American.
But 99% of those injured or killed in peaceful demonstrations in the West Bank are not Americans or European nationals. They are the Palestinians themselves. Until we understand the linkage between peaceful demonstrations wherever they are, we will not win. Until we fully support the peaceful Palestinians, we are part of the 1%.
Recommended.
I agree.
recommended
Only the working class can save the working class.
Excellent post.
rec’d.
Thanks Doc.
Thank you Dr. Murphy.
What do we do when the police become the criminals?
Does Mr. Olsen have medical coverage? Is there some way we can help him or his family with the expenses they must be facing?
Other than the number killed, how are the responses to Occupy different than the responses of governments of other countries to similar situations? If bashir assad has to go, why not 0?
The Oakland PD and their armed colleagues fired their “less than lethal” projectile weapons at point blank range on trajectories parallel to the ground, rather than from greater distance on arcing parabolic trajectories. The latter trajectory minimizes kinetic energy (and hence injury); the former pattern maximizes kinetic energy and hence maximizes injury.
Its my understanding that non lethal weapons are lethal at close range. Tho police are informed about this information by the salesmen of these weapons.
So there is no excuse lets try the police for murder. Lets get the names and photos if possible of these police on the net and descriptions of what they did on the net.
Police kill people in countries with no press all the time, police kill people with press only when the press does not push the story so lets push lets get the details out there on the net forever every time these police get a divorce, child custody case, police violence complaint heck a new girl friend googles them this information will be on the net.
Why do this? to show the police their will be consequences for their actions, their actions will not be forgotten, their will be no later political career in their future.
We show the police that punishment will be swift certain and it will hurt Forever. Current Criminal Justice theory states swift certain punishment deters crooks so we use their theory on them.
Will the local Prosecutor do his job? If he/she won’t will Obama have the Justice Dept do anything? What about local Vets groups what are they saying?
Vets die in Foreign wars supposedly to bring freedom to other countries then die in America trying to express the Freedom’s they fought to defend?
Bush logic suggests we invade Wallstreet and liberate America. WallStreet not the WH runs the country.
Oakland is far from Wallstreet why this violent overreaction does the local police chief or D.A want a political career in Right Wing Politics? Did local businesses demand the police do something? We need local political intel on the chief of police and the D.A.
I hope Scott Olsen’s family makes a public statement.
Doctor, Paraphrasing the (in)famous Ben Franklin statement: we may have what we call a “Republic”, Sir, but I’m not so sure we can keep it (or that we really want to)…
And to think I just razzed some others about “phrase puppy parsing” just now (I suspect I’m almost maxxed out on my hypocrisy limit here ;)
Otherwise, that stated, I just posted on a different thread that I hope those who pray are praying for Scott Olsen, that he recovers swiftly and completely. And thank you for an articulate, thoughtful post from a physician’s perspective — that’s something we’re not often privy to at FDL.
Relatedly, if you (all) haven’t done so already somewhere else, etc., everyone please go to Wikipedia and search the terms “direct democracy”, “deliberative democracy”, “consensus process” and “collective”; and then if you have time, perhaps go over the U.S. Constitution/Bill of Rights.
And then let me say this: If I were Her Eminence, the Most Excellent Core Mistress Hard Drive Server over all the Interverse, never again would Wikipedia need to allocate precious (bandwidth) time begging for chump change.
The person who fired the skull-fracturing missile knew he was doing it to Torture someone. It was pre-meditated.
Since it was indiscriminate, and done to change someone’s political stance, perhaps it could also be called Terrorism.
One thing’s for sure: It’s Treason to wage War against American citizens.
The time for this Monster’s arrest is long overdue.
Hey Kirk!! What is happening is horrible. Here is a link that says it all: https://fbcdn-sphotos-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-ash4/305712_10150337527027286_712982285_8298050_681707440_n.jpg
Police Violence HAS to be Terminated!! They have been Militarized are are using that training on our Fellow PEACEFUL US Citizens and not on Foreign/Muslim Terrists…. For shame especially as Scott Olsen, Marine, served two tours in Iraq, this is sure pissing Veterans off…
Quan is learning the fine art of flip flop.
All of the Non-Lethal Technologies have been ‘field-tested’ on the Palestinians…! 8-(
Excellent, and thank you for it. Rec’d.
Oakland Police Department: Satin America’s Death Squad at war with Denim USA workers.
A Major League fastball can cause brain damage if a batter is hit in the head, which is why they all wear helmets now. That’s far less kinetic energy than from a smoke grenade out of a grenade launcher. I don’t know what those morons were thinking when they shot right into the crowd.
It’s also hard to believe that anyone will ever be disciplined for this.
Go to Iraq Veterans Against the War (ivaw) to make a donation to Scott Olsen’s recovery. They also have contact info for the mayor of Oakland.
http://ivaw.org/
What did Anthony Bologna get for his pepper-spray thuggery? Transfer to Staten Island and a loss of some vacation days. He should have been fired. If they figure out who tossed that missile at Scott Olsen, he/she should get the boot, too, along with Oakland’s interim Police Chief Jordan.
As long as we recruit our police officers from the ranks of discharged combat vets and as long as municipalities accept military training in lieu of actual police training, this kind of thing is only going to escalate. It’s natural enough when everybody is seen as an enemy.
Plus, even if the authorities happen to be motivated to pursue this one, all those cops look much the same in riot gear.
My bet is that they won’t be motivated, though. It’s hard to believe that if they cared about senseless violence from the police that they would have let this operation happen.
Some of the skills are the same, but philosophically they are very different jobs. Don’t know how much extra training is required, but there should be some, even for former MPs.
Well I do know a little about it and of course they have to go to the training academy and so forth but many municipalities no longer require a degree in law enforcement to be a cop if that person has served in the military. That goes for a jet mechanic the same as an infantryman, the same as an MP. Makes zero sense.
OT: Waves to Margaret. Now that you’re gainfully employed I’m not often on a thread with you. Hope you are doing well!
hiya doc! Excellent work, as per usual.
Great to “see” you again !
Hi Molly. Overall, I’d rather be earning.
And you probably know…we have had police brutality/homocide cases. Wearing the uniform does not protect against criminal conduct, does it? Certainly not against damages/liability (not to say that fixes things).
What is inappropriate about calling the Oakland PD criminals? They’ve been criminals since Huey Newton and Bobby Seale were teenagers in Oakland. They are an occupying force and a preview of what’s coming for the rest of America. I’d be willing to bet that the coward who fired the ‘kill shot’ atOlsen, a Marine veteran, never served a day in the military. We’ll never know because no individual will ever be brought to justice for this cowardly act. Does the term ‘Kent State’ jog any memories?
Attempted murder. Try the bastard cop. Now.
“What the Oakland PD and their armed colleagues did to Scott Olsen shows us all what the oligarchs will do to us if we let them. Which is why we must stop them by any peaceful means possible.”
Hey doc, what is “peaceful means” don’t work?
do we become slaves?
I suggest that the 99% Occupy the Polls!
Americans should turn out en masse on election day and refuse to vote for any of the candidates, Obama included. We knew that he is owned lock, stock and barrel by Wall Street and the Military Industrial Complex/Criminal Cabal.
Americans shout disrupt the election and demand a new slate of candidates, remove every member of Congress, install an Attorney General with some testicles and go after the criminals who have helped bring us to this state.
Americans Should Demand:
Universal health care as a right or Medicare for all
Public campaign finance
Term Limits
Outlaw usury
Criminalize revolving door lobbyist activities
Death penalty for public malfeasance and family destitution – The Chinese have this one perfectly right. A 1.00 bullet to the head.
I suggest that the 99% Occupy the Polls!
Americans should turn out en masse on election day and refuse to vote for any of the candidates, Obama included. We know that he is owned lock, stock and barrel by Wall Street and the Military Industrial Complex/Criminal Cabal.
Americans should disrupt the elections and demand a new slate of candidates, remove every member of Congress, install an Attorney General with some testicles and go after the criminals who have helped bring us to this state.
Americans Should Demand:
Universal health care as a right or Medicare for all
Public campaign finance
Term Limits
Outlaw usury
Criminalize revolving door lobbyist activities
Death penalty for public malfeasance and family destitution – The Chinese have this one perfectly right. A 1.00 bullet to the head.
Great post, Dr. Murphy. What happened to this kid breaks my heart in so many ways.
Last night on Democracy Now: Full and exhaustive coverage including video and interviews.
Last night on The News Hour: Nothing.
Yes, we are angry, and I agree with most of your grievances, but I don’t go along with revenge “death penalty”. Please think before you spout.
We don’t need a set of testicles on an AG, just legal integrity. But that starts with the Pres who is AWOL.
I like your idea of Occupy Polls — let’s do it!
This story should already be much bigger than the Brian Stowe attack that the MSM went crazy with because alleged gang members were involved.
Their Sponsors like Chase Bank and Chevron would not like it if they go off message i.e. tell the truth.
Thank you, Kirk, much appreciated.
Always good to see your thoughts … and to learn from your professional understanding and humane perspectives.
Recommended to the thoughtful consideration everyone who visits FDL.
DW
Thanks to the many folks who are sharing their knowledge and comments here – and thanks also for the recs and kind assessments of the post. For those who wish to, please feel free to share / tweet widely.
I do understand the anger with corrupt officials, but I’d most appreciate if this thread isn’t used to advocate for executions or for exploration of any strategies to defend our Republic from the oligarchs that go beyond non-violence. There are other places on the Web to take such discussions, should one wish.
Ack – just read “Occupy the polls”
Folks, if IIRC, obstructing the voting place in Federal elections is chargeable as a Federal felony. Also, for many Americans – especially those in historically disenfranchised groups – the right to vote is sacrosanct.
Even if obstructing polling places weren’t a criminal act under Federal Law, physically preventing others from voting would dramatically undermine the Occupy movement’s legitimate claim to support democracy.
[On another note, those who publicly advocated for mass physical blockade of polling places -could place themselves or sites carrying the advocacy at substantial risk.]
I understand the frustration with the corrupt two party system and how it has replaced our democracy with corporate rule, but obstructing voters won’t restore our democracy. I’ll assume this suggestion came with nothing but the best intentions, but the idea is dangerously and powerfully counterproductive. If anyone suggests it elsewhere, just say no.