For those who don’t believe that Bradley’s personal life and sexuality may be used against him by officials or media critics, this gem of information was presented in a recent Vanity Fair article about Hillary Clinton, while on tour in the Middle East:
“Hillary told staff that she could not fathom how an army private, Bradley Manning, with psychological problems and a drag-queen boyfriend could single-handedly cause the United States unprecedented embarrassment just by labeling massive downloads as Lady Gaga songs.”
Were those comments verbatim, or just the ill-chosen words of the author? We probably won’t know, but one thing is for sure: they were published in a major pop-culture outlet, so there is no taking them back.
Here, is a good take-down of the allegation that Manning had “psychological problems.” As for the comments about Bradley’s sexuality, you can be the judge of that.
If Hillary did indeed say anything of the sort, it is yet another reminder of the Obama administration’s willingness, almost as retaliation for their own embarrassment, to disregard public outcry about Bradley Manning’s charges and detainment and the fact that he has not yet been convicted of any crime.
At a fundraiser in San Francisco in April, Obama told me that Bradley Manning “broke the law,” a legally irresponsible and inappropriate statement that could constitute the ‘unlawful command influence’ of any military judge or jury that may preside over Bradley’s case.
Should the President and commander-in-chief –or the Secretary of State for that matter– really be saying such things about a high profile prisoner like Bradley Manning who has not yet been to trial?
The release of the Diplomatic Cables may have been embarrassing for the Obama Administration, but the life (not political career) of the most important whistleblower of my generation hangs in the balance.
It seems unlikely that we will hear any response from Hillary about this. This administration seems content to say one thing and mean another. Remember the sad irony felt when former white-house briefer Ray McGovern was rather brutally arrested last January for standing up in silent protest during Hillary Clinton’s lecture about free speech at George Washington University?
Not to mention Obama’s unexpected persecution of more whistleblowers under the Espionage Act than any previous administration, while giving this speech about the Arab Spring,
“Through our efforts we must support those basic rights to speak your mind and access information. We will support open access to the Internet, and the right of journalists to be heard – whether it’s a big news organization or a blogger. In the 21st century, information is power; the truth cannot be hidden; and the legitimacy of governments will ultimately depend on active and informed citizens. Such open discourse is important even if what is said does not square with our worldview.”
Ironically, that sounds a lot like Bradley’s alleged chat logs, which are being held by the Pentagon as evidence that Bradley was ‘aiding the enemy.’
“I want people to see the truth, regardless of who they are… because without the truth you can’t make informed decisions as a public.”
Doubly ironic is that the cables Manning is alleged to have leaked have been hailed as a catalyst of the growing democracy in the Arab world.
The triple irony is that the greatest charge against him is that of ’aiding the enemy.’ Despite campaign promises our leaders act at home as if democracy is only good for us on their terms — in fact it just might be ‘the enemy.’ Or we are. Same thing, really.
Democracy, as the Arab world is showing us, is a do-it-yourself skill that requires courage, humility, and commitment to the truth– no matter the stakes. If Bradley Manning is indeed guilty, it is of these “psychological problems.” He is our Egyptian.
Logan Price is a member of the Bradley Manning Support Network. You can follow him on twitter @kstrel.



10 Comments

Thanks, Logan! I guess that you’re mentally unbalanced if you don’t accept things as they are. Odd, wasn’t it, about those mentally unbalanced guys who started the American Revolution.
the thing that caused the US to be embarrassed was not Manning. It was the State Dept. under Rice and Clinton collecting DNA samples of foreign diplomats; Crazy Horse 18 Gunning down in cold blood 15 people while laugh and joking all the while! These crimes are what makes us unsafe not Manning sexuality.
Hillary was here at FDL during the Demoncratic Primaries, IIRC. She proved herself to be an intellectual lightweight. She’s just in it for her own edification. Lowest Common Denominator is the way she rolls. Yay, Israel!
Thanks, Logan.
Thanks logan. If any one has “psychological” problems, it’s Hillary Clinton. She is one cold cookie. On September 6, 2006, Hillary Rodham Clinton voted against a bill sponsored by Senators Pat Leahy and Diane Feinstein that would have limited the use of cluster bombs, the barbaric weapons that litter the landscape of Iraq and Lebanon (via Israel) with munitions that explode when touched, killing civilians.
These type of weapons, have no valid national security purpose at all, and just inflict horrible injury randomly on civilian populations, and particularly children who tend to pick up things and play with them. Most civilized nations have banned their use.
Before the vote, Diane Feinstein displayed photographs of Iraqi children who were multilated and horribly disfigured by the exploding cluster munitions left around by U.S. Cluster bombs.
Then, five years later. . .
On April 21 of this year Libya denied using cluster bombs, but Clinton said she was disturbed by reports the weapons are being used in fighting between Gadhafi’s troops and rebels. Do you believe it! She had the nerve to say that she was disturbed about reports of cluster bombs?
“Were those comments verbatim, or just the ill-chosen words of the author? We may never know, but one thing is for sure: they were published in a major pop-culture outlet, so there is no taking them back.”
Well gee, yes, all sorts of assholes published “Al Gore said he invented the internet”, and there was no taking it back.
The words attributed to Hillary are obviously far from a quote, and the basic premise, that someone could mislabel a huge stash of intelligence docs “Lady GaGa”, and by that alone go undetected, is of course absurd and criminal stupidity on the part of the government.
But if you just need another reason to bitch about Hillary, don’t let me rain on your parade. I hear World News Daily has a bunch of accurate quotes for you to get heated about. Sorry they don’t qualify as “a major pop-culture outlet”, but in time, who knows?
The only thing more shocking than Hillary’s comments is that any of us are shocked by them.
This woman has been, is, and always will be an opportunist who will say whatever she feels she must in the moment to preserve (read: serve) herself and her sham party until the bitter end (which, for the party at least, is not far off, by the way).
Yes, I remember that vote. Hilary has always been one giant WAR Inc hawk. I guess she’s getting well-paid by the MIC. Why should Clinton care about serfs & their serf kids in distant foreign lands getting killed and/or, for that matter, serfs from the USA being sent to foreign lands to get killed???
Hilary Clinton got HERS big time. The rest of us can go Eff ourselves.
P.S. I can believe that Hilary Clinton has the nerve to say “anything” that will inure to her personal gain & benefit. Anything. She is a greedy craven venal liar out to make as much money for herself as possible. Ditto for her husband. The end.
Yep. Your first sentence is the first thing that came to my mind. Shocked that Hillary said *something* like that?? No, not at all shocked or surprised.
Plus it’s clearly evident that the Obama Admin has closed ranks about Pfc Manning, and they are all spouting out the same bullsh*t hype about Manning. First we get Pres Obama, Pfc Manning’s boss as Commander in Chief, telling the world that Manning is guilty before Manning’s even been brought to trial. Now Clinton is dissing Manning for his gender preferences and saying Manning is mentally unsound.
Citizens should take note of what happens to whistleblowers in the Obama Admin. It ain’t pretty. Just ask Shirley Sherrod.
“Should the President and commander-in-chief –or the Secretary of State for that matter– really be saying such things about a high profile prisoner like Bradley Manning who has not yet been to trial?”
Emphatically NO! And for all those Obamabots who have been posting here at FDL lately telling me how horrid & terrible I am for not unquestionably supporting Obama to the enth degree, I say: WTF??? WHY would I support Obama when THIS is how he behaves and clearly encourages/instructs his Secy of State to behave.
Thanks for posting this info about the perfidy of Hilary. Whether she said those exact words or not is pretty much irrelevant. The intention is very clear: to diss and further villify Pfc Bradley Manning before he’s been brought to trial.
Both Clinton & Obama vaunt themselves out there as these great *legal* minds with their fancy-@ss law degrees. So there’s not excuse for how both of them have RUN THEIR MOUTHS about Manning. It’s unconscionable. I protest it.