America plays the role of abused partner in its relationship with China. Although the Asian giant repeatedly injures U.S. industry by violating international trade rules, America has responded, almost exclusively, by pleading and begging for China to stop.
China says it’s sorry. And continues to violate the rules. America respectfully beseeches China to discontinue manipulating its currency, and China says it will. Then it allows the value to increase a completely insignificant amount. Still America does nothing. Nothing. It simply accepts the abuse.
U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., and Michael Williams, senior vice president of U.S. Steel stood with me Wednesday at a press conference in Pittsburgh to urge President Obama in his meetings this week with Chinese President Hu Jintao to announce that America is done with soft talk. We want President Obama to tell President Hu that America has heard enough promises; the United States is bucking up and pulling out that big stick that Teddy Roosevelt carried in foreign policy negotiations.
This is a rare issue on which politicians, Republican and Democrat, manufacturers and organized labor all agree. Here’s what Sen. Casey said at the press conference, “In my estimation, and that of a lot of Americans, the time for talking is over. The time for action is now.” He, Sen. Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, and Sen. Debbie Stabenow, D-Mich., plan to introduce legislation next week to force the federal government to hold China accountable, to enforce compliance with World Trade Organization (WTO) rules – rules that China agreed to comply with when WTO countries permitted it to join even though it is a non-market economy. . . .
Mr. Williams described the effect of China’s unchallenged trade practices on American steel production:
“Our facilities in Pennsylvania and throughout the United States are among the most advanced in the world:
- We make the highest quality steel for the most demanding applications;
- Our technology is world competitive; and
- Our workers are second to none in skill and know-how.
However, the more than 21,000 U.S. Steel employees nationwide, and the more than 4,700 employees here in Pennsylvania, know all too well that we do not always operate in a fair global marketplace. Instead, we are often faced with the reality of a distorted market – a market where we have to compete against job-stealing dumped and subsidized imports from countries that abuse the rules to gain a false competitive advantage.
No country more than China hurts all American manufacturing by the way it artificially undervalues its currency – making its exports artificially cheap and making competitive imports from the U.S. and elsewhere artificially expensive.”
Here are the facts: American industries have found that they can produce products, ship them to China and price them lower than Chinese competitors. But all too often, China prohibits sale of the American-made products on the mainland.
Sen. Casey gave an example, C.F. Martin & Co., which manufacturers its world-famous guitars in Eastern Pennsylvania. Martin tried to register its mark to sell its instruments in China. But it has been unable to do that because a Chinese manufacturer already registered the mark and is counterfeiting the guitars. “To say it is unlawful does not begin to describe the gravity of it,” the senator said.
In addition to countenancing counterfeiting, China provides illegal subsidies to its export industries, violates international regulations forbidding forced technology transfer when American companies seek to manufacture in China and deliberately undervalues its currency to falsely lower the price of its exports.
When Mr. Williams, Sen. Casey and I all said this must be stopped with enforcement of international regulations, someone in the audience asked if that would prompt a dreaded trade war. That won’t happen because we already are in a trade war. The United States simply is not fighting back. We are playing the passive partner in a perverted relationship, repeatedly allowing the abuser to pound us.
Mr. Williams said it best:
“U.S. Steel wants a strong America. To have a strong America, we need a strong manufacturing base. To have a strong manufacturing base, we need strong enforcement of international trade regulations.”
Sen. Casey agreed, “Our government must take every step necessary. It is not enough to say to the unemployed, ‘We are trying and we are asking.’”
Wield the stick, President Obama.




8 Comments

Obama won’t weld that stick. The political show in Congress is heart wrenching to watch daily. The only way I see of correcting the situation is to put an end to NAFTA, CAFTA, and all other free trade agreements. We have to start over with better and more fair trade agreements. We also have to work on how our patent laws can be protected and also kept from being gamed in this country by industry.
Yes, but even if NAFTA and CAFTA were renegotiated, the new terms would have to be enforced!
Attacking China is wrong headed.
It’s the WTO itself which needs to be dismantled. No nation should be subject to the barbaric rules of the WTO.
For a trade agreement to be good, it must benefit the working people of both nations. Such litmus tests are not part of the WTO, thus the WTO needs to be replaced.
I agree that “The United States simply is not fighting back.” but that’s because President Obama doesn’t even believe in the United States having a coherent industrial policy. If he did, then he’d be bringing corporate tax policy into alignment with the desired industrial policy. But that’s not what he’s doing. What he’s doing is pushing for a flat corporate tax rate with no loop holes. That just screams: I do not believe in industrial policy.
It has been obvious for a very long time that America needs to massively ramp up it rail and light rail infrastructure. That’s something that PA steelmakers could be a huge part of. But it’s simply not going to happen in a world run by the WTO, IMF, World Bank and neoliberal Presidents like Obama.
So what good is it, (NAFTA CAFTA WTO ) now you know it is like so many “agreements” labor contracts, treaties with the Amerindians, or …
Made to be broken, like they say about laws.
Free trade… ? that is the givaway, that they called it “free” cheap trick, nothing free about it, but full of hurdles and exceptions and less than selective enforcement.
Better with no rules, and just protect the country on a day by day needs basis, with tarrifs slapped on those things that upset the economy, and the well being of Americans. Let those other up and coming countries worry about their own problems… (and let the offshore traitorous class of american business interests go over seas and help em.) Free one way expatiation fast track! One time opportunity.
You are right: America needs an industrial policy!
And, amazingly, the Washington Post agrees that China is cheating and must be stopped: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/01/18/AR2011011806900.html
China? Sorry, but I disagree. You see the problem is all these corporate entities that pretend they are American. After all the tax breaks and taxpayer subsidies, these greedy MFers still close down and move where they can get the resources and labor cheaper. They are cutting off their own noses in spite their face. They care not for American workers, but for making money. If they weren’t going to China, it would be some other cheap nation similar to it. You can’t blame China at all for this.
Well, it’s time to fight instead of shilling for Democrats, Leo Gerard. It’s time to tell Obama that you no longer stand with him. Quit saying you respect him. Tell the rank and file to support any candidate but a Democrat or a Republican. Start acting like a real union leader.
Here’s the advice Ian Welsh is giving citizens today:
“The RNC is asking for 2.5 trillion in spending cuts over 10 years. Assume Obama and Dems split the difference (remember, Obama wanted a freeze already, anyway). 1.25 trillion.
The effects of that on the US economy, such as it is, will be catastrophic.
If you can work right now, do. Earn as much money as you can, reduce your costs as low as you can and get ready for the next downturn. It’s going to be ugly. Jobs will continue to be shifted out of the country, Americans will continue to be turned into debt-serfs..”
Urging Obama to “wield the stick” is as useless as urging my dog to recite the Preamble. It isn’t going to happen because it’s against his nature. It’s time for you to “wield the stick” on Obama. Tell him you will no longer support him.
Given the actions of Ben Bernanke’s FED, it seems rather laughable to label any other nation on the planet as a “currency manipulator”.
As for China subsidizing development, good for them. We should do the same.
The bottom line is that if China was ever foolish enough to actually follow WTO guildlines, it would destroy their economy in much the same way that the WTO has helped to destroy the rest of the worlds developing economies.
Rather than burning down China, we should be burning down the WTO. As for our domestic economy, if we need subsidies and/or other forms of protection then so be it.