Today, Fred Griesbach, AARP Campaigns sent me one of those unsolicited e-mails telling me all about AARP’s wonderful work in defending Social Security and Medicare, and then asking me for a donation, so they could continue working their magic. Here’s my reply.
Dear Fred,
I know about AARP’s willingness to compromise on Medicare and Social Security for the sake of deficit reduction, and I’m Mad As Hell About it!
Trying to manage fiscal policy by using projected surpluses or deficits as targets is a stupid and harmful distraction from what needs to be done for full economic recovery. It’s a fool’s game which AARP and all the other “veal pen” organizations are playing. Responsible fiscal policy uses Federal spending to produce full employment, price stability, and other important public purposes. It is not policy that is targeted at producing particular deficit, surpluses, debt-to-GDP ratios levels as goals in themselves. Those numbers are best determined by the operations of the economy; and not by futile efforts of the Government to cut social programs or the safety net.
As long as AARP supports a deficit reduction focus in the area of fiscal policy, and retains Bill Novelli, their resident deficit hawk, as CEO, I won’t donate a dollar to its efforts. I will also do whatever I can to see to it that other organizations representing Seniors replace AARP as the leading voice for older people.
As far as I’m concerned AARP can stick a fork in it; ’cause it’s done!
Warm Regards,
Joe Firestone
(Cross-posted at All Life Is Problem Solving and Fiscal Sustainability).



12 Comments

Joe Firestone – this is an easily accessible article about why one should rip up an AARP card.
Recc’d.
What I would appreciate is a simple, 3,4 bullet point method as to why I should support, and more importantly, tell others that MMT is superior to the Keynes theories which I have pointed out and illustrated to other before this current situation.
I can easily explain that the private sector is not providing demand, and that the Fed sector should, and people would be better off with demand stimulus.
Explain to me how I EXPLAIN that MMT is superior to that basic premise, if it is?
Joe, I gave up my ‘card’ long ago. What’s unfortunate is that AARP members don’t do comparison shopping or they would find they can do better than what AARP offers.
Doubt that your letter will get read but appreciate the effort.
Great letter.
I got an email yesterday from someone saying they got an AARP robocall, offering to connect them with their legislator and tell them to preserve Social Security and Medicare as-is. No public statement of course, but it means they know they’re taking major brand damage over this, and are spending big dollars to convince their members they’re doing something other than what they are.
I guess they got your letter
;)
I got one of those as well. On my answering maching. Dunno how long the robo rambled, my machine cuts off after 2 minutes.
Boxturtle (probably wise for them to use robos, they wouldn’t like talking to me)
I like the “warm regards,” Joe. Nice touch.
AARP is an organization for retired people who made 6 figure salaries and have investments (probably over seas where they are not taxed) that they live comfortably on. It is not and has never been for those of us with vanishing pensions and Social Security.
Thanks. But I think it’s much more likely that they got your great piece on this subject.
Thanks John, I tried to keep it short, in line with the advice you’ve been giving me.
AARP is an old organization. In the time of former Senator Claude Pepper, if I recall correctly, it was the repository of “grey power” in Washington, DC. In those days it wasn’t a sellout and no one dared to cross them.
These days it’s staffed by pros, a lot of whom aren’t gray beards at all. They’re just out of touch, and have been taken over by professional marketing people. They’re no longer willing to make politicians hurt when they cross AARP. They need a house cleaning, a new CEO, a new staff, and very frankly should not employ anyone under 50.
Thanks for your comment, Kelly, I’m taking this under advisement and working through some thoughts. Hope to have a blog post soon that will address it.
Bruce, comparison shopping is the key. AARP would shape up if they found themselves losing people to more militant groups.
Yes…for a number of reasons.