I have been influenced by the health care system in ways. At the age of nineteen I married my childhood sweetheart, Bill. He was older than me by only one year. I worked as he finished college and went to medical school. As Bill moved from medical school to his residency and to the practice of emergency room medicine I witnessed the disintegration of continuity of care and the escalation of costs. Bill continually fought for his patients. He was dismayed at the power that the corporate structure began to exercise over him and his patients.
Bill was diagnosed with viral encephalitis in 1987 and died in 1989. The health care policy he was covered under was one of the last high quality policies to be written. While he was sick the insurance company changed the coverage for me and our children. Fortunately, Bill’s coverage was very good. I think that they were afraid to discontinue him because of his profession. This would not be the case today. The medical insurance industry will slice and dice anyone they can. Doctors do not have the influence they used to.
Ten years ago I remarried a wonderful man. Ron and I started a new business together and had coverage under Kaiser. We were able to keep that coverage until the Dot Com Bust. We are in the illustration field with a specialty in 3d. Many of our clients went under. We had to let our health insurance go.
In early 2002 we found new insurance. Kaiser would not take us back due to preexisting conditions. During the next two years Ron had an intestinal bleed and open heart surgery. I had breast cancer twice. The health insurance company decided that my cancer was not covered at all because I had “lied” on my application about taking antidepressants. Actually, I wasn’t taking any but had been written a prescription that I never filled.
After Ron’s intestinal bleed and my first bout with breast cancer we were forced into bankruptcy. After the bankruptcy we both got sick again. This time I was covered by med-cal. Ron still had insurance. We found out after Ron’s bypass surgery that the insurance company intended to pay only 10% of his medical bills.
Suddenly, we owed $170,000 in medical bills and had already filed for bankruptcy. Mercy Hospital in Sacramento cut us a deal and let us pay them only 10% of the bill. We refinanced our house to do this. We refinanced our house three times to pay for either living expenses while sick or medical bills. (You can see how the medical care situation influenced the housing crisis.)
Ron has many of the vascular problems related to his need for by-pass surgery. He has no health insurance now. He will be 65 in 18 months and will be covered under medicare. We hope that he will not need to have surgery or expensive tests. Ron was in the E.R. just last week. We live with our fingers crossed.
The health care system has fallen from grace and become driven by extreme greed. There were always problems but as a young adult I used to think that things would get better. I have watched in horror as my government turned away from its citizens and worked with the financially powerful to put up barriers against effective, reasonably priced health care. I am now a health care reform activist.
Ron and I were supposed to be part of the town hall meeting with Obama this morning. We were supposed to be at the governor’s office in Sacramento to tell our story. The Sacramento meeting was canceled so I am telling my story here.
Thanks for listening. I am off to the hardware store to buy a pitchfork that I will stick in my front yard with an American flag on it. I am not giving up. Single Payer! Single Payer!



82 Comments







single payer. now.
thanks for writing this mary mcc.
Thanks, Suz.
Thanks mary, so glad you posted this. Sure wish you had the chance to speak to Obama directly.
Single Payer! Single Payer!
Hold your fork high and keep pitching, mary.
All the best.
digg is open
Recommended.
Thank you very, very much.
digg is open, but my link in five leads to a fatal exception, sorry, not sure what happened. Mods if can you delete that I’d be grateful.
Mary…When catching up on reading FDL posts, I saw a comment that was made to you about Canada’s health care not working. We have longer waiting times for operations than we used to because we need more doctors. We do not have insurance companies, co-pays, or denial of care…ever. Medical decisions and treatment are decided between a patient and their doctor. No third party gets involved. The monthly premium we pay covers all doctor visits and all operations that are necessary..not cosmetic surgery in other words. The premium is based on a person’s previous year’s net income.
We don’t lose our lives or our homes from medical costs. Doesn’t work? Your politicians are so full of bullshit that all of their eyes must be brown.
What is so complicated that American politicians say single payer can’t be done? The complication is that big pharm. donates lots of cash to the politicians.
Anything you want to ask about how we deliver medical care? If I can, I’d like to give you ammunition for discussions with the nay sayers you encounter.
Yes. Tell me everything. Right now I am trying to convince people who don’t believe in single payer by saying that together Americans should be smart enough to figure out a way to cover everyone. And that we are a creative country that can do better.
Got questions?
Single payer we can’t afford to give the insurance companies any more give aways. Why was the meeting canceled? Is Geithner aware that medical emergencies are or were before the economy went bad one of the biggest reason for people going bankrupt and falling behind in their mortgages?
One plague one epidemic and all Geithner’s plans for the economy disappear as even more people get sick can’t pay their bills and lose their homes forcing more banks under.
National Healthcare for everyone and Paid sick days so people who get sick can afford to take time off from work.
I cannot recall how many times I went to work at fast food joints sick with the flu, fever, coughing, sneezing etc.
I could not afford to take off work, much less see a doctor. For the wages I was paid my boss could not find a replacement or afford to send me home.
Imagine what would happen to America if we get the bird flu but nobody notices because nobody can afford a Doctor or to take off work so they wait days infecting more people hopped up on over the counter flu medicine trying to get through another few days of work.
Until they are so sick they have to go to the hospital which by then they have infected how many people?
Private Health Insurance Penny wise ( they skimp on covering us) pound foolish America spends just how much money to not insure everyone? Our life spans even if your white with health insurance are lower than other countries compared to other folks.
You mentioned bird flu and that reminded me I’d forgot to post this back from over a month ago. It never did get into the US MSM, or internet sites, other than natural health sites. An ‘accident’ like this could happen with all of the safeguards that are in place? A human caused pandemic almost occurred and that wasn’t considered newsworthy?
***********
” The company that released contaminated flu virus material from a plant in Austria confirmed Friday that the experimental product contained live H5N1 avian flu viruses.
And an official of the World Health Organization’s European operation said the body is closely monitoring the investigation into the events that took place at Baxter International’s research facility in Orth-Donau, Austria.
Public health authorities concerned about what has been described as a “serious error” on Baxter’s part have assumed the death of the ferrets meant the H5N1 virus in the product was live. But the company, Baxter International Inc., has been parsimonious about the amount of information it has released about the event.
Baxter hasn’t shed much light — at least not publicly — on how the accident happened. Earlier this week Bona called the mistake the result of a combination of “just the process itself, (and) technical and human error in this procedure.” “
http://www.edmontonsun.com/New…..61061.html
What do people really have to wait for in Canada in terms of treatment?
How much does health care cost per capita?
How is quality of care maintained?
Our doctors negotiate with the provincial government as to what they will be paid for specific services from office visits to operations. All hospitals and doctors get the same fee. No one is allowed to charge more.
Here is the monthly premium cost in British Columbia where I live.
In B.C., premiums are payable for MSP coverage and are based on family size and income. The monthly rates are:
$54 for one person
$96 for a family of two
$108 for a family of three or more
http://www.health.gov.bc.ca/ms…..emium.html
Wait times depend on where a person lives ie longer in small towns than in big cities. It also depends on what it is for. None, or a short wait, if for something serious like a cancer or heart operation. Many operations can have a year long wait list..knee surgery has a long wait list for example.. It is not good, but still, when a person gets their operation it is free.
I am not quite sure what you mean by quality of care. We have boards to oversee all aspects of care in each hospital and we have provincial oversight of doctors and we have federal oversight. Is that what you asked for? If not..I’ll try to answer better next time.
Thanks.
Quality is one of the other dumb arguments that anti health care poops use. I am sure Canada does much that same as the USofA does.
Oh..you meant we are supposed to have substandard doctors and care? Tell them all to STFU. Even better, ask them to give you specific examples of what they think they know and watch them squirm while trying to come up with an answer.
Specifics don’t apply to repugs. Don’t fit into their talking points.
If our doctors and nurses were not highly trained maybe the US would stop luring so many to work in the US with ridiculously high salaries being offered. That is one of the reasons we have a shortage..the frigging US hospitals ‘buy’ them! Did you know that has been going on for many a year? I think it is Windsor, Ontario that has bus loads of nurses crossing the border to work in the US each day. We have lost many specialists to higher salaries in the US.
I am surpised that USofA docs aren’t flocking to Canada. They spend too much time and money trying to get paid by the insurance cabal.
Specifics are mandatory..demand them from all you debate with. Bring them back to it when they try side track you. Pass on some information from http://www.pnhp.org/news/2009/…..ealth_.php
I don’t know why. Maybe some do? I admit to never thinking about US doctors being here working. Not after years of hearing about our nurses and doctors going to the US. We have the same ghastly HB 1 visas as you do and no insurance cabals here to delay or deny treatment or payment. Maybe it is simply that they would be paid less than in America so they wouldn’t want to work here?
Sorry to hear what you and hubby have gone through. We don’t declare bankruptcy or have to re mortgage homes or get divorced in order to get medical care in Canada.
The above at #15 were the maximum costs. If net income is under $28,000, the provincial government subsidizes the premium. Did you note the 3 or more category..yes, that is the maximum fee even if the family had 10 members in it.
************
Regular premium assistance offers subsidies ranging from 20 to 100 per cent, based on an individual’s net income (or a couple’s combined net income) for the preceding tax year, less deductions for age, family size and disability. If the resulting amount referred to as “adjusted net income” is $28,000 or below, a subsidy is available. See the Monthly Premium Rates chart below for full details of premium assistance rates.
The current adjusted net income thresholds are:
* $20,000 – 100 percent subsidy
* $22,000 – 80 percent subsidy
* $24,000 – 60 percent subsidy
* $26,000 – 40 percent subsidy
* $28,000 – 20 percent subsidy
http://www.povnet.org/node/2888
Mary: thanks for sharing this. There is no compassion in a system where the insurance companies make more money by denying care.
Boo: the Digg link at the top of the page worked fine for me.
Thank you Mary. Best to you and Ron.
I forgot to say one thing.
We are still ALIVE!!!!!!! Hurray.
Thank you for sharing your story and illustrating, so personally, exactly why single payer is the only way to go. Our country needs to cut out the obscene profits from the healthcare system. Health insurance is unnecessary and has no place in a developed nation. Any quality processes or oversight (utilization review) that insurers “contribute” to the process can be duplicated better and cheaper by independent entities. I hope you get another chance to deliver your views and experience in person.
All the best to you and Ron.
Bravo and hugs, MaryMc!
We must spread the word.
Thank you Mary, don’t ever stop telling your story.
Sure wish that Sacramento meetup hadn’t been cancelled. Oh, well, maybe next time.
Hi Mary
Did you ever find out who canceled the meeting? Or why?
PS I hope you all get well
John,
I have no idea why is was canceled. I know that the organization that set it up was frustrated because the governor’s office wasn’t calling any of the people they suggested. I think, perhaps, we were too mouthy.
thanks mary — dugg and recommended.
and i’m VERY GLAD you both are ALIVE!!!
Bluebutterfly: do you have to be a citizen to get care? or can you opt in if you live there and aren’t a citizen?
Eligibility
Assistance with the payment of premiums is available to Canadian citizens or holders of permanent resident status (landed immigrants) who have held that status and been resident in Canada for the past 12 consecutive months.
http://www.povnet.org/node/2888
Sorry..my #30 was premium assistance. This is what you wanted to know.
*********
” Eligibility
To qualify for Medical Services Plan (MSP) coverage, you must be a resident of B.C. A resident is a person who:
* is a citizen or permanent resident (landed immigrant) of Canada;
* makes her or his home in British Columbia; and
* is physically present in British Columbia at least six months in a calendar year.
Certain other persons, such as some holders of study and/or work permits issued under the federal Immigration and Refugee Protection Act are deemed to be residents, but tourists or visitors to B.C. do not qualify. More information on eligibility is available on the MSP website.
Dependent – includes a spouse and children who are B.C. residents.
Spouse – a resident who is either married to or is living and cohabiting in a marriage-like relationship with the applicant and may be of the same gender as the applicant. (Note: in the case of divorce, the former spouse is no longer eligible for coverage as a dependent and must apply for separate coverage.)
Child – a resident who is the legal ward or child of the applicant, is supported by the applicant, is neither married nor living and cohabiting in a marriage-like relationship, and is either age 18 or younger or age 19 to 24 and attending school or university full-time. “
http://www.health.gov.bc.ca/in…..ligibility
thank you
You’re welcome..glad you saw it..I was a bit slow getting the information there for you.
Just as an aside-Ron and I are getting divorced for financial reasons. I can claim Bill’s social security. We will be indemnified from each others medical debt. We have to do this since the medical/housing/economy problems have wiped out any possibility of regrouping financially. We will be living in sin. Exciting.
This sounds about right for what the party of ‘family values’ makes happen. So sorry, but do whatever you need to do to get whatever help and services you can get. Single Payer!! Medicare for all. The poor get medicaid and the middle class gets ripped. Shameful.
Under the Republican idea of Creative Destruction (aka the Shock Doctrine) you should consider this an opportunity instead of a disaster. Yep, now is the time for you to reconsider that lifelong dream of marrying a lesbian. Hey, it’s legal now in several states. Talk about exciting. What the Republicans have us go through.
I am so sorry to hear about the hardship you have gone through with insurance companies that suck. I can relate in that I have a pre-existing condition and can’t afford insurance. A while ago you told me about insurance through Costco, and I looked into it, but we just couldn’t afford to do it–our house payment and student loans eat up our paycheck rather quickly. We are both self-employed, and non-insured. I can’t help thinking as I pay out of pocket each month for my expensive and necessary prescription drugs that if I lived nearly anywhere else in the world this would be a non-issue. As would our college loan debt. Anyway, I hope that you and Ron continue to have good health and happy days!
Ron and I are both self employed. There is another issue we need to change. Self employed people get to pay double the ss tax.
Mary–I am self-employed, too. But am the one and only employee of a corporation we own. So we pay twice the employee share. But truly self-employed people who file a Schedule C with their 1040 get a discount, paying only 50% of the employer’s half. My wife and I are presently paying over $20K a year for health insurance (due to change once I reach 65 this summer)for so-so coverage. But it is chargeable to the corp, which is a blessing. Means I get a 30% discount on it. Still high.
Reminds me of a 60 Minutes piece a year or so ago about the social net in Denmark. The reporter (Steve Croft?) asked a bunch of youngish folk how much they paid for health care, university fees, etc, etc. The answer was, of course, NADA! The ending of the reportage was that 50% of salaries went toward taxes to pay for those benefits, and of course no American would stand for such high tax rates. I figured that I was paying at least as much (not even counting the $250K to send our two kids to good schools in the 90’s–we were unwilling to apply for financial aid on principle, since my wife was on the town’s scholarship board and they couldn’t fund anybody much over the poverty line. We’re not sorry we did this. But we’re socialists who say ‘SINGLE PAYER, SINGLE PAYER’, also.
A family of 2 would pay a maximum of $96 x 12 = $1,152 per year where I live (BC) irregardless of whether a person was self employed, or not. Our premium rates are based on family size. For that you’d get all doctor visits, all diagnostic tests, all operations, MRIs, CAT scans etc.
Time for a national strike, or state wide strikes,in order to get your government’s attention on the single payer option. Many are trying to change this situation but the impact is proving to be minimal. If you make corporations hurt financially then they will pressure your government. Take a lesson from France’s workers who figured out long ago that widespread strikes bring results. Really, at this point, what do you have to lose?
Thanks so much for the info, bluebutterfly . I am going to print it out.
You are welcome. I hate what I read about all of you who suffer because of lack of medical care. Will always be available to assist with any information that I can give you to help debate why single payer is the answer. I will check here later to see if you have asked any more questions. Have to go out for a little while.
Maybe you could adopt Ron and me.
I’d have to move to another province first.
*******
” The Issue: Current law in British Columbia only allows adult adoption if the adoptee was supported by the adopting parents while still a minor. This is an unfair restriction based on age. Loving family relationships can form at any age!
Ontario, California, Saskatchewan, Illinois, New York, Oregon, Washington State, Alaska, Alberta … citizens in these places have a right that we in British Columbia do not: the right for an adult or couple to adopt another adult as their legal child as long as a judge approves the adoption in court.
Irony: Families in other provinces can adopt adult family members there, and these adoptions will be recognized under B.C. law if they then move to BC, whereas BC residents are forbidden from doing the same type of adoption in BC! “
http://www.geocities.com/adultadoptioninbc/
Mary –
thank you for sharing your story with us. and having the strength to work on behalf of all of us
Sacramento event may have been canceled because your Gov was in L.A. – looks like a big squishy “in the middle” moment for that cretin
here is footage from Single Payer Rally in LA this am – sponsored by Calif Nurses Assoc. and National Nurse Organizing Comm.
http://www.nbclosangeles.com/n…..geles.html
It’s called the Reagan Revolution.
That will be known as neoMarxism.
neoMaryism :)
I’ll vote for that.
I like the idea of neomaryism.
There’s nothing I can do other than to wish you both well. As you’re living in sin you can now come out as a bambisexual. Lots of cuddles and hugs. Including this virtual one from Erdla and me to you both.
du
How many of us have been destroyed by medical debt? Productive professional people earning good money at the zenith of their careers suddenly seeing their world’s collapse about them after being screwed by their benevolent insurers who have been pleased to collect premiums from them for years?
I know I have a story like Mary’s. Another item which she didn’t mention was the co-pays. Unnoticed until they bill you is the co-pays for all the items which they have 25%, 30%, even 50% co-pays on, look at the your policy carefully and you will undoubtedly see some items they will charge you these co-pays for. Items like Surgery Packs, Operating Rooms, Implantable Devices, all sorts of things. They even attempted to charge me for my Hospital Room,, claiming the policy only covered a semi-private room and I was in a private room. When I called the Hospital, they told me all the they had was private rooms and not to worry about it, as there was a representative for the insurance company that worked on site! Why was I bothered by them billing me in the first place? How many people just paid that without contesting it? They deluge you with bills and paperwork, by the time you can (if you ever do), figure out what is going on, Bill Frist’s hospitals are threatening to turn your accounts over for collection.
I had to sue my Long Term Disability Insurer to make them pay, I was fortunate my Sister was a lawyer. One of her partners, a litigation specialist, took care of it for me-this was when they thought I had ALS. The LTDI folks were obviously trying to delay things until I expired and they successfully managed to drag things out almost two years. I always wonder how many people who didn’t have the type of support I was blessed with simply gave up. This particular Company was featured on 60 Minutes for its ruthlessness in denying valid claims. I, of course, was very depressed, and without my Sister’s support, both financially and morally, would have probably done myself in.
I now live on Disability and receive less a month than I used to earn in a week. But on the plus side of things, I do have a new, improved outlook on life and I didn’t lose a nickle on my 401K’s & CD’s when the market went to hell this time. Of course, I no longer have any of those investments, so as to that fabulous retirement I once planned…
mary, i’m so sorry for what you’ve had to go through (and nonplussed and everyone who has their own story to tell). it is just so unfair that we don’t have single payer already.
Single Payer! Single Payer!
please don’t let anyone tell you that the MA reform model is the way to go.
p.s. this is probably the best diary i’ve ever read. thank you mary.
Seconded! A powerful story, (((MaryMcC))).
I urge you to send your diary straight to the White House, and to “your” so-called reps in Congress.
I just sent it to Obama. Thanks for the idea.
Thank you for sharing your story, as horrific as it is. Besides shouting for ’single payer’, voices need to be also shouting ‘no public option’ as it precludes single payer and does nothing to address the underlying issue that healthcare should NOT be an issue of ‘profit’.
Thanks Mary for you incite full Diary!!
The only answer for the people of this country is cut the Insurance Companies out of the Medical world completely, they had their shot and they have abused it. I wonder just how many citizens have lost their lives because of the Callous Insurance Companies who ONLY are interested in making as much money as they can at our expense??
Single Paye is the only answer!!! Any solution that includes the insurance Companies is sure to fail the people! They must be set free from the Medical world including all the malpratice insurance, which they are making a killing at!!
SINGLE PAYER SINGLE PAYER SINGLE PAYER
DUGG and Recommended! Be sure to also SHOUT this out to all your http://digg.com/politics/Ron_a…..are_town_h friends Pups when you are Digging this great Diary!!
I believe that there are many thousands of deaths due to lack of health care. It is easy not to count the deaths caused by neglect.
there’s a 24-year-old woman i know of who died in boston last week. she had cystic fibrosis and needed a lung. a lung was located and the transplant people were standing by. the insurance company wouldn’t approve payment for the transportation. while the family was trying to talk to the insurance company/starting to inform the media/trying to decide if they should drive the young woman went into a coma and died.
single payer insurance is the only health care that makes sense to me.
Sorry for your friend GW(:>((
That story points out just how fucked the Insurance Companies are. As I said earlier “They had their chance and fucked it up” They are not needed in the Medical field they just suck off the Medical tit for their profits at the expense of the patients in dollars and lives. They are driven by GREED as are all big Corporations. It is time things change and change in a big way. The whole Medical situation is just the current glaring example of the Regan brand of business that GREED is good. Greed has cost many their lives, I mean for the cost of an ambulance ride they haggled a young to death.
This is long but it is ON Topic and sorry for all the links Lurk.
From Moveon.org:
Dear MoveOn member,
Exciting news on health care: Today, the New York Times editorial board has joined Dr. Howard Dean, Paul Krugman, and progressive champions in Congress in support of President Obama’s public health insurance option.1
Why is this such a big deal? The public health insurance option is the key to finally covering everyone and lowering insurance premiums by as much as 30 percent.2 It will take the power away from the private insurance companies that have driven up costs and denied coverage for years.
This is the biggest fight in the health care debate, but too many people don’t even know about Obama’s public health insurance option. We need to make sure our neighbors, friends, and elected officials know we support this plan to guarantee affordable health care for everyone. Can you write a letter to the editor of your local newspaper today?
The debate is heating up right now, so we’re aiming to get letters published this week. This is the best time to write since our members of Congress are home from Washington and watching the local papers closely. Writing only takes a few minutes, and our online tool makes it easy. Just click here to get started:
http://pol.moveon.org/lte?camp…..x&t=3
Here are some important points for your letter:
• During the election, President Obama promised to give everyone the choice of private insurance or a public health insurance plan like Medicare—with lower premiums and better benefits.3
• Obama’s public health insurance option would save us up to 30% on our insurance premiums by being more efficient and driving down prices across the board, according to the Commonwealth Fund report.4
• The insurance lobbyists are fighting against Obama’s public health insurance option. Insurance companies know that lower costs for us mean lower profits for them.5
A public health insurance plan achieves universal health care and lowers costs by giving people the choice of their existing insurance or a new, more affordable health insurance plan sponsored by the government. Either way, you get to pick your doctor.
The choice of a public health insurance plan is considered a crucial part of health care reform by Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman, Dr. Howard Dean, and groups like Planned Parenthood and SEIU (the largest health care union in the country).6
Last week, the Congressional Progressive Caucus sent a letter promoting a government role in health care. The letter says:
“Regarding the upcoming health care reform debate, we believe it is important for you to know that virtually the entire 77-Member Congressional Progressive Caucus (CPC) prefers a single-payer approach to health care reform. Therefore, it will come as no surprise as you work to craft comprehensive health care reform legislation, that we urge the inclusion of a public plan option, at a minimum, in the final legislation. We have polled CPC Members and a strong majority will not support legislation that does not include a public plan option that is supported on a level playing field with private health insurance plans.”7
If we want real health care reform, we need to tell our neighbors about how President Obama’s public health insurance option will guarantee health care and save us money. The letters section is often the most read part of a newspaper.
Click here to write a letter to the editor using our easy online tool:
http://pol.moveon.org/lte?camp…..x&t=4
Thanks for all you do.
–Noah, Wes, Marika, Carrie and the rest of the team
Sources:
1. “A Public Plan for Health Insurance?” The New York Times, April 6, 2009
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04…..7tue1.html
“House liberals insist on public health plan option,” The Hill, April 2, 2009
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=5129…..x&t=5
“Why not single-payer?” Paul Krugman, October 7, 2007
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=5126…..x&t=6
2. “The Path to a High Performance U.S. Health System,” The Commonwealth Fund, February 19, 2009
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=5122…..x&t=7
3. “Plan for a Healthy America,” BarackObama.com
http://www.barackobama.com/issues/healthcare/
4. “The Path to a High Performance U.S. Health System,” The Commonwealth Fund, February 19, 2009
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=5122…..x&t=8
5. “Insurance groups pen letter against Obama health plan,” The Hill, March 24, 2009
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=5125…..x&t=9
“McConnell: No gov’t health insurance,” Politico, March 4, 2009
http://www.politico.com/news/s…..19633.html
6. Health Care for America Now coalition members, March 27, 2009
http://healthcareforamericanow…..ho_we_are/
7. “Progressive Caucus to Insist on Public Plan Option as Part of Comprehensive Health Care Reform Bill,” Congressional Progressive Caucus, April 2, 2009
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=5129…..&t=10
Good. Now to the phones, keyboard, fax machine, etc.
Dear MoveOn member,
Exciting news on health care: Today, the New York Times editorial board has joined Dr. Howard Dean, Paul Krugman, and progressive champions in Congress in support of President Obama’s public health insurance option.1
Why is this such a big deal? The public health insurance option is the key to finally covering everyone and lowering insurance premiums by as much as 30 percent.2 It will take the power away from the private insurance companies that have driven up costs and denied coverage for years.
This is the biggest fight in the health care debate, but too many people don’t even know about Obama’s public health insurance option. We need to make sure our neighbors, friends, and elected officials know we support this plan to guarantee affordable health care for everyone. Can you write a letter to the editor of your local newspaper today?
The debate is heating up right now, so we’re aiming to get letters published this week. This is the best time to write since our members of Congress are home from Washington and watching the local papers closely. Writing only takes a few minutes, and our online tool makes it easy. Just click here to get started:
http://pol.moveon.org/lte?camp…..x&t=3
Here are some important points for your letter:
• During the election, President Obama promised to give everyone the choice of private insurance or a public health insurance plan like Medicare—with lower premiums and better benefits.3
• Obama’s public health insurance option would save us up to 30% on our insurance premiums by being more efficient and driving down prices across the board, according to the Commonwealth Fund report.4
• The insurance lobbyists are fighting against Obama’s public health insurance option. Insurance companies know that lower costs for us mean lower profits for them.5
A public health insurance plan achieves universal health care and lowers costs by giving people the choice of their existing insurance or a new, more affordable health insurance plan sponsored by the government. Either way, you get to pick your doctor.
The choice of a public health insurance plan is considered a crucial part of health care reform by Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman, Dr. Howard Dean, and groups like Planned Parenthood and SEIU (the largest health care union in the country).6
Last week, the Congressional Progressive Caucus sent a letter promoting a government role in health care. The letter says:
“Regarding the upcoming health care reform debate, we believe it is important for you to know that virtually the entire 77-Member Congressional Progressive Caucus (CPC) prefers a single-payer approach to health care reform. Therefore, it will come as no surprise as you work to craft comprehensive health care reform legislation, that we urge the inclusion of a public plan option, at a minimum, in the final legislation. We have polled CPC Members and a strong majority will not support legislation that does not include a public plan option that is supported on a level playing field with private health insurance plans.”7
If we want real health care reform, we need to tell our neighbors about how President Obama’s public health insurance option will guarantee health care and save us money. The letters section is often the most read part of a newspaper.
Click here to write a letter to the editor using our easy online tool:
http://pol.moveon.org/lte?camp…..x&t=4
Thanks for all you do.
–Noah, Wes, Marika, Carrie and the rest of the team
>SNIP>
Sources:
1. “A Public Plan for Health Insurance?” The New York Times, April 6, 2009
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04…..7tue1.html
“House liberals insist on public health plan option,” The Hill, April 2, 2009
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=5129…..x&t=5
“Why not single-payer?” Paul Krugman, October 7, 2007
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=5126…..x&t=6
2. “The Path to a High Performance U.S. Health System,” The Commonwealth Fund, February 19, 2009
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=5122…..x&t=7
3. “Plan for a Healthy America,” BarackObama.com
http://www.barackobama.com/issues/healthcare/
4. “The Path to a High Performance U.S. Health System,” The Commonwealth Fund, February 19, 2009
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=5122…..x&t=8
5. “Insurance groups pen letter against Obama health plan,” The Hill, March 24, 2009
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=5125…..x&t=9
“McConnell: No gov’t health insurance,” Politico, March 4, 2009
http://www.politico.com/news/s…..19633.html
6. Health Care for America Now coalition members, March 27, 2009
http://healthcareforamericanow…..ho_we_are/
7. “Progressive Caucus to Insist on Public Plan Option as Part of Comprehensive Health Care Reform Bill,” Congressional Progressive Caucus, April 2, 2009
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=5129…..&t=10
what happened to single payer while i was gone?
you all signing up for an insurance centered plan from the dems???
We can still fight for single payer.
A 30% savings on insurance is not good enough. If I cannot afford $800 a month then I can probably not afford $534.
Hell, I cannot afford the $15 co pay for drugs.
and that is exactly why i don’t think something like the MA reform model works. we’ve already done the experiment.
did you see BargainCountertenor’s analysis of the single payer bills now in congress?
more here: Democrats seek compromise on health care plan
ooooops. You are right Selise.
This is what happened a couple of years ago in California. There were two competing bills for reform. One has less teeth than the other. Sheila Kuehl has the single payer plan. At the time I thought that the more moderate plan had a better chance of passing. I was wrong. Neither passed. I should have put my efforts behind the Kuehl plan.
i had no idea about that story. thanks for telling me.
sorry to be a wet blanket. i really want to be wrong about this, but i think we’re getting played. the MA model of reform sucks. and no one will tell me how we should have done it differently to make it work. :(
also, thank you so much for having an open mind mary.
Mark Leno has basically the same plan (I think?) as Sheila Kuehl’s
SB 810
First Hearing for SB 810: Senate Health Committee, April 15, 1:30 pm
this so reminds me of when moveon was whipping for pelosi’s blank check for bush’s war – after we had worked to elect dems to congress in 2006 so that they would end the war (scan down the comments if you’ve forgotten).
when are we going to stop being charlie brown to the dems lucy?
I have to learn not to react immediately.
no. i think you are doing just fine (seriously a wonderful diary). it’s our politicians who are screwing up.
You are completly corrwect selise what we should have is the same thing as the VA provides only better. The VA does provide great health care but it HAS suffered under the Republican cut backs and the “Means Test” they forced upon the VA which cut out many Vets who earned the coverage that was promised when they served their country.
But We do need a Single Payer system and cut out ALL of the Insurance companies from the Medical System completely. Unfortunately the Repukes can still stop such a plan from becoming Law. SO it behooves us all to work to get rid of them and the BlueDogs via the ballot box and replace them with progressives who WILL work for a Medical System for every citizen. Health Care is not a privilege but a right for everyone in our country.
i just wrote this on ralphbon’s diary:
by organizing for single payer now, we’re also making the case for progressives. also by organizing for single payer now, we’re making the case for blue dogs to vote for it.
i don’t think there has ever been a better time to make the case – economically, socially, etc – for single payer.
ymmv, but that’s my 2 cents.
Perhaps we should take the fight directly to the repugs who always stand in the way of progress. It is time to start protesting their greedy narcissistic stance. Dan Lungren’s office is a few blocks from me. It has been awhile since my friends and I went over there with our signs. The repugs make fun of the French. Maybe we could use some of their recent tactics and create a loud nonviolent presence.
Hi, Mary. Your personal tale is perfectly dreadful, and it’s sick that anyone would be fighting to sustain any portion of the system giving rise to it.
I’ve been waging the purist fight on single payer knowing full well that we’re not going to get it anytime soon, because I believe that pre-conceding that point merely helps ensure a more compromised compromise.
In fact, if I’ve learned anything from getting yelled at by my lawyer, it’s that in negotiations you demand more than what you want and deserve, so that when the dust clears, you’re more likely to actually have gotten what you want and deserve.
By that measure, even my purist stance is wimpy. Progressives should be demanding single-payer PLUS PUNITIVE DAMAGES!! Then when the damages come off the table, we’ll be left with merely what we deserve.
Best regards, and congrats on what may be the longest Oxdown comment thread so far.
i like the way you think. single payer with punitive damages. a program i can live with. don’t give up the punitive damages either.
Dugg and recommended, Mary.
Nobody should have to endure what you and Ron have been through.
Too bad we cannot figure out how to get people to stop paying their health insurance. That would be too scary for folks.
marymccurnin,
Thank you for this diary. We have been trough a number of insurance meltdowns.
mary..when the other side mentions waiting lists in Canada for some operations, just tell them that America’s lists are shorter only because 47 million or so citizens haven’t any health insurance/money/credit so they can’t get on a list…ever. Sometimes the obvious escapes the anti-single payer crowd.
To see a person’s family doctor is usually 3-4 days. Same day if a serious issue developes. We have walk-in clinics..walk in and wait your turn..that is same day service. Whether we go to our family doctor, a clinic doctor, or the Emergency Room at the hospital, it is free.