Our conservative friends constantly say that big government is really bad, but they don’t care how big corporations get. In fact, we can read worshipful coverage of the leaders of giant aggregations of money, and tell us how those leaders deserve all the money they haul home. We hear paeans of praise for the brilliant strategizing of Wall Street moguls, setting up bigger and bigger combinations. Is Glass-Steagall in the way of creating Citigroup? No problem, the laws get changed. Citigroup in trouble? No problem, politicians fall all over themselves to pour money on the problem.
The biggest companies in the country have tendrils that extend throughout the economic structure. Take the Tribune Company, which recently filed bankruptcy. It has 127 subsidiaries, of which 111 filed separately but are being administered together. There are 8 major newspapers, and over 100 niche publications, like the Spanish language newspaper Hoy, and the upscale Chicago Magazine. There are 25 television and cable companies and one radio station. It owns the Chicago Cubs (Maybe Next Year©). There are a bunch of related companies in businesses related to these main companies. For example, it owns a jet or two, a couple of direct mail companies, and something called Internet Foreclosure Service, Inc. It truly is a national business, with at least 14,600 employees from one end of the country to the other. (This information is from the affidavit of Chandler Bigelow, III, an Senior Vice President and CFO of the Tribune Company, in support of the first day motions in the bankruptcy.)
Why? Why should the L.A. Times, the Chicago Tribune, The the Baltimore Sun and Hoy be owned by the same company? Is there some obvious reason why one company should own 25 television stations? Isn’t there someone in Baltimore who can operate the Sun, and might even enjoy it? Maybe they could make a good living, and hire some people and do a good job of providing information to Marylanders?
Think about Starbucks. Is there any reason that one company should own 9,712 coffee stores around the world? Here’s their explanation, from their most recent 10-K:
The Starbucks Experience, or third place beyond home and work, is built upon superior customer service as well as clean and well-maintained Company-operated retail stores that reflect the personalities of the communities in which they operate, thereby building a high degree of customer loyalty.
Why do we need a national company to set up stores in Syracuse or Kansas City that “reflect the personalities” of these cities? Isn’t there anyone in Kansas City who knows how to set up a coffee shop that reflects their community? I think so. That person can make a good living and employ people and contribute to local causes of interest, and generally be a good citizen. Why should those profits go to Seattle?
As a nation, we seem to be hooked on financial gigantism. The Tribune Company bankruptcy offers an opportunity to look at alternative ways of thinking. There are no real reasons to keep this aggregation of companies together. It is assembled more or less like a Lego project. Some rich people, with access to mega-billions from mega-investment banks and mega-law firms, went on a buying spree and picked up a bunch of newspapers and television stations, based on what was available that day, and called it a company, just like we link Lego blocks together and call it a castle.
The good thing about this bankruptcy is that it offers a chance to a lot of people to buy a newspaper or a televisions station. We could start by appointing a trustee for each paper and station and magazine, and one for Hoy, and one for WGN radio, and so on and get on with the task of selling each one to someone local. We look at each sub and see if it can make money by itself, or whether it’s fortunes are so closely tied to another sub or group of subs that it cannot survive by itself. We link those Lego blocks together. The rest go on the block one at a time.
The Trustees look for local purchasers. There are wealthy citizens of each of these towns looking for investments that have a chance to do better than treasury notes paying 0%. Who knows, maybe one of us firedogs could come up with some money and buy the upscale Chicago Magazine.



11 Comments







Hey Massacio
Wow, that would be an interesting project. i’ve always had a yen to work on a magazine. such a collaborative creation, so many aspects. i wanna be in charge of the ‘eye candy’ photos and page layout. i’ll buy a rare lottery ticket tomorrow.
I’m in the little town where you volunteered on election day, almost all of my shopping is at locally owned stores. My grocery is small, doesn’t have the extensive fruits and veggies and deli selection that the larger chain store has, but, it’s locally owned and operated. Only thing I really can’t find at a locally owned store here is clothing. and electronics unless it’s something the tv repair guy carries. there are a few re-use type stores here that quite a few people use. shopping this way i don’t have as wide of a selection as i would if i went to the china chain store, but my money is going directly into the local pockets of my neighbors, although i do go to the chain store here and there for things.
a new local coffee shop just opened on the edge of town, right next to the location of the other obama headquarters here where i volunteered-sorry i missed you. i didn’t think it would make it, but it’s attracting locals who don’t want to fool with parking uptown and students-i like the bustle of uptown. they serve quiche and donuts and really good coffee and are going to expand. when the students are out it is a challenge to find an open restaurant uptown sometimes. and our one street that is being developed- because there is now a walmart there-is now lined with fast food and chain restaurants. that has all grown in the last two years or so.
but one little local italian place just opened up and seems to be doing well.
we also have a thriving farmer’s market and stores and restaurants that use and sell local produce and meats and other products.
a guy i know sells the most delicious goat cheese. homemade. firm or soft. when drizzled with honey? oh my. he also makes products from paw paws. and other things unique to our area. his latest venture is making mulch out of walnut shells from a nut-processing company in missouri. still in the experimental stage but promising.
there is a large sustainability contingent here. all kinds of interesting homemade and homegrown and locally-raised products are made here. if you like to eat whole foods, this is the place. the most delicious eggs i’ve ever eaten. i feel spoiled every time i ‘crack’ one. but as i said to james earlier, not a good pastry to be found within two hours. unless i make it myself. i moved from an area of a city that had 5 german bakeries within blocks of each other.
it is a good thing to have locally owned places, but it is more work to go get what you need from each one, so, i do understand why some go to one or two superstores to get what they need. but to me it’s overwhelming, i prefer the smaller locally owned and operated places. it’s fun to say ‘hey’ while i’m gathering what i need. and knowing that i may be helping them pay for that new deck overlooking the woods they’ve been planning to build or for their pet’s vet bill, it makes me feel cozy.
p.s. one of my dad’s hobbies (retired accountant) is tracking which company owns which. you can name a product or a restaurant etc. and he can tell you who owns it. i used to look at the books that list some of them, i forget the name of it….so, even when we shop locally, keep in mind who’s getting your money on the inventory end. he buys stocks for products he uses and products people use. he loves telling people that one of the only american-made casket companies is in indiana. wise guy. his latest one is–do you know who owns trader joes? aldi corporation. dutch. you can buy the same german rye at aldi’s that trader joe’s sells. for two bucks. no joke. just remember to take your own shopping bag. they charge for them.
I’m sorry we didn’t touch base, it seemed like a nice place. Let me know how that lottery thing turns out!
yep, me too. i couldn’t believe i missed you. i was too exhausted to go to the party, i was around when it was being planned/figured out. and knew people at the other one up the street. watched the returns on tv at home.
next time.
(sorry about the ‘no water’ inconvenience, see, if i would have known, you coulda used my water!)
Hey! Great post!
I’m still wondering what happened to enforcement of the Sherman Anti-trust Act? The only company I know of in recent memory that had that used against them was Microsoft and the whole thing – as a legal case – was kind of ridiculous. The company with the 90% market share suing the one with 10% and accusing them of violating anti-trust laws. WTF?
Anyway – in your example, I think the people need to take back the ‘public’ airwaves and limit ownership much more than we currently do – and enforce these rules!
I also think that if some company that is ‘too big to fail’ actually gets itself into trouble – it should be split up as a condition of any assistance. No matter who or what it is.
Well, I can dream can’t I?
I believe in the “unseen hand,” and I believe that the unseen hand has just now whupped the United States of American up side the head for being so stupid as to believe that the unseen hand is the most effecient way to organize its economy.
I believe in self-regulating systems, e.g., lung cancer is mother nature’s way of letting you know that cigarettes are bad for you — but is it the most efficient?
BTW, a great read: http://www.portfolio.com/news-…..om/?page=0
Wow.
Wigwam – thank you.
As far as I’m concerned, there is a lot to be said for a company that put customer service first the way Starbucks does. Yes, I have a local coffee shop within walking distance of my apartment here in NYC and my wife and I often frequent it. However, there are times when I’d like a cute girl with a ponytail to call me “Sir” when I buy a coffee rather than a surly waiter giving the place “atmosphere” and annoying the piss out of my on a Sunday morning.
If people want to provide a local experience then f*cking learn how to act towards the people buying your service or product. Bitch all you want about Starbucks but the people who work there know how to be sufficiently subservient.
Can we please have a button that allows us to edit? I have trouble proofreading when I get a head of steam.
OT — Uhm, you’re saying subservient is good? Or was that the part that you wish @8 that you’d self-censored?
Hmmm, you nailed it! That word SUBSERVIENT told me all I need to know about Splicer. I will scroll past any future comments by him.