The Great Crash posed one question for this country: who would bear the losses? Would it be the banks that caused the problems? The officers, directors and shareholders of those banks? Their careless counterparties? The investors who bought the fraudulent real estate mortgage-backed securities and the complex spin-offs? The owners of capital who threw money into hedge funds and other exotic investments expecting a geyser of money in return?
No. That group doesn’t lose money. They used their control over the government and the Fed to make sure that the losses would be passed on to the rest of us, pushing millions into or near poverty. The savers were trashed by the Fed’s zero interest rate policies. The national debt run up by tax cuts and wars gave the rich an opportunity to end the safety net and focus all of the efforts of government on protecting them and their interests. The rich are safe. The rest of us are in deep trouble.
The government threw money at banks with abandon, leaving incompetent failed executives in place. When it turned out that banks lied about the quality of the notes and mortgages transferred to the RMBS Trusts, the SEC and the Department of Justice refused to investigate, let alone prosecute.
Banks didn’t complete the transfer of those worthless notes and mortgages into the Trusts, so the IRS announced it wouldn’t enforce the requirements for pass-through non-taxable status. The servicing arms of those banks cheated and lied to courts around the nation about ownership, and when they got caught, they talked the government into a sleazy settlement that gives nothing to the people damaged by the frauds and allows the banks to continue to lie and cheat, if at lower levels.
This list could be expanded indefinitely, with the same outcome: the Fed, Congress and the White House have only done those things that protected the money of the rich, whether or not the settlement was consistent with the law or not.
It didn’t have to be this way. From the outset, there were things that could have been done that would have placed the losses where they belonged: on Wall Street and its criminal denizens and its careless clients. The bailouts could have come with constraints and requirements, firings, lawsuits, and indictments. The entire rotten structure could have been pushed into a form that would not threaten the lives and incomes of the middle class, a group whose responsibility for the problems was minimal in contrast to that of crooked lenders and swindlers.
No. Not in this country. Not in a nation ruled by oligarchs and a government in thrall to economic theories years after those theories revealed themselves as nonsense, or to the rich who endow those irrational theories with sanctity of revealed truth, or both. There was never a day when the primary or even subsidiary consideration was the middle class, or the rule of law, or even the pretend values of the free market. The only consideration from the outset was the protection of the rich.
Even two years later, the government showed no interest in raising taxes on the richest Americans. Both parties explained that they couldn’t raise taxes even on the rich in a recession, and that the only solution was cutting out unemployment benefits, lowering the minimum wage, slashing Social Security and Medicare, and removing people from Medicare and the shredded remnants of help for the worst off.
The current lousy economy is a result of deliberately chosen policies. The government could have chosen policies that would have protected the middle class at the expense of rich criminals and their clients and their hedge funds and their off-shore trusts and their tax-avoidance schemes, the people and entities that wrecked the economy. It didn’t.
It’s not that we don’t know what to do to make the economy work for the middle class. We do. The government and the elites and the rich won’t allow it. They go house to house, from Bangor to Bakersfield, saying to the inhabitants, What part of this sentence don’t you understand? You think we’re going to eat our losses? You think we don’t care about our money? Well. Suck. On. This.



47 Comments

“The bailouts could have come with constraints and requirements, firings, lawsuits and indictments.”
Not from this president, they couldn’t have.
And didn’t.
laws?
what are these laws of which you spesk
laws are for the little people like this one
Breast cancer survivor handcuffed and thrown in jail over a mistaken …
http://www.freedominfonetwork.org/…/breast-cancer-survivor-handcuffed-...
5 hours ago – dailymail.co.uk April 21, 2012 A breast cancer survivor who was sent to prison over a mistaken $280 medical bill has highlighted the return of …
massaccio,
Excellent post. And thus, my five star recommendation, should it be deemed necessary.
Furthermore, I would like your permission to quote you and rather extensively, should my rationale require that I do so?
Agains, congrats!
Jaango
Great post, Masaccio.
touché.
who ya gonna vote for, people?
A righteous rant, I agree with it. And yet today there are tens of millions not gainfully employed and the plutocrats have used it to lower pay for the middle class. Poverty is increasing and there is no one even talking about righting the wrongs. It will be many years, even a generation, to recover from what the last twelve and next eight years or more promises to impose on us. Ah he’ll, what’s the use. We all know it.
the whole story
Breast cancer survivor handcuffed and thrown in jail over a mistaken $280 medical bill
dailymail.co.uk
April 21, 2012
A breast cancer survivor who was sent to prison over a mistaken $280 medical bill has highlighted the return of debtor’s prisons in the U.S.
Illinois resident Lisa Lindsay had received the medical bill in error and was told she did not have to pay up.
However, the bill was turned over to a collection agency and state troopers arrived at her home and took her away in handcuffs.
and reccdMass,(who happens to be one of my favorite artists ,that i have 26 print collection of)
With all due respect, isn’t it more to the point to note that the question wasn’t really asked, and that the answer was assumed? I know there were polls, but it’s unlikely that those answering the polls even understood the issues. And how many Americans do now? Very few, which is a huge problem, imo.
Mr. wendydavis and I are the Occupiers here in Mancos, CO, and when folks stop by to ask variations of: “What the hell is it you guys want?“, we have actual conversations, and when it becomes clear that they nothing about the housing bubble created by the legalizing of derivatives, and the hideous amoral practice of banks selling CDSs based on the derivatives they sold, knowing they were worthless, toxic garbage…they are amazed. But they also believe it, which is too their credit. At least Occupy and the disappearance of their pensions, home devaluations, jobless rates, commodity increases have found them intuiting that something’s really wrong in America now.
So alternative media and community outreach by Occupiers, armed with simple pamphlets describing how ‘the Banks really own the place’ as the moon-faced Senator put it…will help answer the questions.
And I guess I should know this, but are you Steve Randy Waldman, masaccio? I blush if it’s so; I read you site as others link to it often.
love your posts masaccio, spot on every time
thanks. america today sure aint the america we want tomorrow.
The question of “who would bear the losses?” was replaced by the question “what do we need to do to save the economy?” And a handful of well-connected 1%ers answered, as they have throughout history, “save the banks.” And all the folks bought and paid for by the 1% chimed in, “save the banks.”
And so we “saved the banks.” And everyone else is fucked.
Like you tell the folks who stop by OWS.
Correction Amerika.
Yes massacio does a great job spreading the underlying facts that are causing pain for the masses and pleasure of the 1% ers.
I’m not, I’m Ed Walker of Nashville, TN.
“The servicing arms of those banks cheated and lied to courts around the nation about ownership, and when they got caught, they talked the government into a sleazy settlement that gives nothing to the people damaged by the frauds and allows the banks to continue to lie and cheat, if at lower levels.”
I assume that you are referring to the recent state attorney general settlement. I hate it … it’s unacceptable and corrupt … but in accuracy’s interest, some of the people that got damaged by the frauds will get something … such as a few thousand dollars for people that got illegally foreclosed … though it is a pittance for the damage that was done to them illegally.
Z
Wealth worship!
Every time I see my state AG, I take it to him on the settlement, MERS, and the devastation to all the homeowners in our country who have lost what was their major investment, their long-term hedge against having nothing in their dotage. He got hot with me today saying, “It may not be all that much money, but who was going to get more, WHO?”
He says the carve out on MERS is still viable as a legal course. I told him that a friend who sold her house last year, in the fall, has found out that her lowered credit score is due to the fact that her mortgage on that house has been listed as foreclosed on. So while she thought it was paid off, someone else is claiming they owned that mortgage. I don’t know how the title was transferred to the current owner. My AG said he hoped that there would be recourse for people like my friend, but probably she has to get her own lawyer. Can you believe it? Of course you can.
In America today, it “has” to be this way.
It seems like the developed world is like the Titanic, but instead of manning the pumps they’re still partying in the ballrooms, and encouraging the steerage passengers below to save themselves by hard work and if they have the gusto and know-how, then they too can join the party. They’re that delusional.
Nor will they change their tune, until the 28-degree water floods the ballroom.
-stewartm
The great lesson being learned from the great recession by the 99% is that they have no recourse. Absolutely none. Certainly not in the voting booth.
Ask yourself this: Can you imagine any Republican in your lifetime abandoning innocent homeowners in stress any more than the current POTUS?
He simply doesn’t give a shit about your friend — or millions of others in the same position.
This is a brilliant summation. Thank you.
Masaccio shortened this comment to spare thoughtful readers.
I don’t like this post. You should have written something else.
Sure. Bend over.
I would like to suggest that we respond to the current economic crisis by nationalizing corporations such as big banks who have received our bailouts, and energy companies who are gouging our citizens and manipulating markets while selling our nation’s resources, back to us, with all profits going to themselves.
Go Argentina!!!
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/apr/22/will-hutton-argentina-oil-grab-justified
Remember the front page article about the retired couple in Maine who could not pay their fuel oil bill in the middle of this past winter?? Do you honestly think that a nationalized energy company, worker owned and socially responsible would let a retired couple rely on the iffy generosity of local citizens, force them to beg for fuel, or even entertain the idea that they might freeze to death?? Do you think a fair and equitable energy company owned by citizens would have people burning their furniture in a wood stove to keep from freezing to death, just to safe the capitalist economic model??
Interesting. You can change my text while keeping my name. That’s called fraud. Tsk.
Yeppers; exactly, econobuzz.
I told you to stay off my threads.
Stay off my threads.
Do not post on my threads.
You are not welcome.
Thanks, Masaccio – excellent post.
Except that the banks haven’t been “saved”, the TBTF banks are bigger and still insolvent.
But these banks are fastened onto the real economy like giant leaches or vampire squids draining us dry.
Excellent post.
Another question posed by the Great Crash of 2008 is what happened to the oil futures speculators when the fraud-based housing bubble finally burst?
Oh right, when the banksters and Wall Street gamblers involved in the housing bubble got bailed-out in TARP I with $700 billion (along with $7.7 trillion in Federal Reserve loans and guarantees) in late 2008, and since many were the same investment gambling firms and individuals, the oil futures speculators also got bailed-out.
Before the Great Crash, oil barrel and gasoline prices were at record highs. When the Great Crash occurred, and before the bail-out funds started reversing things, oil barrel and gasoline prices plummeted, world oil barrel prices plunged by over 80 percent (from about $150/barrel to less than $30/barrel) and gasoline prices here the U.S. dropped over 50 percent (from over $4.00/gallon to less than $2.00/gallon).
Was it supply and demand issues that cause this sharp drop in energy prices over several months in late 2008? No. I don’t remember a huge oil discovery that was instantly processed and on the market, do you? I also don’t remember consumer demand decreasing significantly that would explain this sudden drop in energy prices? Therefore, it must have been decreased trading on the commodities markets, specifically in oil futures trading, essentially inadvertent, yet self-imposed, limits placed on commodities trading by the Great Crash.
As a result of these “limits” on trading, energy prices plummeted in late 2008. That is, until the frantically enacted and signed bail-out occurred (while the Fed secretly pumped almost $8 trillion in federal loans and guarantees into the pockets of those responsible for the Great Crash…and the skyrocketing energy prices). IOW, why are energy prices here in 2012 going up once again to 2008 levels? Need you ask?
The point I’m trying to make is that those behind the Great Crash of 2008 not only didn’t go to jail and didn’t have their fraudulently acquired assets seized (like those in the illicit drug trade do), but they were rewarded for committing widespread fraud. And since most of those behind the Great Crash of 2008 are also involved in oil futures trading, then after being bailed-out in late 2008, they’ve not only recouped their “losses,” but are back to rigging the oil futures market, thus driving up oil barrel and gasoline prices once again.
The Commodities Futures Trading Commission could put a stop to all this unlimited oil futures speculation by strictly enforcing Dodd-Frank provisions that put limits on oil futures trading. Oh wait, this is why Republicans are blocking all attempts to do this. It’s an election year, so they can blame President Obama for what many of the deep-pocket financial backers of the Republicans are really doing, speculating and driving up energy prices. Too bad many of these deep-pocket financial backers of the Republicans aren’t in jail serving lengthy sentences for fraud and criminal malfeasance. Maybe this might put a limit on their speculation and drive down energy prices. Hey, let’s try both approaches, the CFTC puts strict limits on oil futures trading and all those behind the Great Crash of 2008 go to jail which would hopefully put a crimp in their speculative activity, especially if their ill-gotten gains are seized Aw c’mon, I bet energy prices would plummet like they did in 2008. It’s worth a try.
Great piece Masaccio. There’s a new piece on MERS, RICO and what’s going in in Louisiana here: http://www.economonitor.com/lrwray/2012/04/21/louisiana-sues-banksters-under-rico-laws-will-the-biggest-banks-finally-go-the-way-of-the-gambinos/
“…The government could have chosen policies that would have protected the middle class…”
There are no big-money lobbyists representing the middle class since the labor unions have been crushed or marginalized. Congress and the White House only respond to offers of money or the threat of that money being withheld or delivered to their political opponents. Corporate lobbyists call the shots on behalf of their fat-cat employers, and nearly every American politician does what those lobbyists demand. The question of what policies would actually fix the problem and provide the most help for the majority of Americans was never even considered.
Masaccio, you frequently describe our situation as an “oligarchy”, which is rule by a very few individuals, and that is certainly accurate. But I still prefer the term “plutocracy”, which is rule by the wealthy, because it is wealth specifically which determines who those very few happen to be.
O please spare me that stupid whiny interfluidity bastard.
I agree
And that whiny bastard too.
And all the comprador accomplices too? Heavens, that would be as great a relief as the rapture.
No, I think even Naomi Klein didn’t go far enough. This is about demolition, and certainly not incompetence.
This litany of complaint is so futile.
The tax payers, of course. But, that has to be understood in a global sense.
When an excessive amount of money gets pumped into the economy, ultimately, the way we must deal with it is to retrieve it through taxation. Let me explain.
Every subprime mortgage created an equal amount of money in the account of the borrower, which immediately got spent on paying off the owners, their agents, etc. That bank-created money was spent on very real expenses and was then into the economy. Some day, when we are back to full employment, those dollars will have to be taxed out of existence, but those taxes will not necessarily fall to those who profited from that underhanded transaction.
Double that. Right on point ans irrefutable.
Well said, sadly.
While focusing on Europe’s austerity minded oligarchic kleptocrats in power, this piece by Dave Johnson at CAP brings out that these PTB leaders are smart enough to realize the outcome of their policies — and they must have wanted those outcomes.
Same here. They got themselves rescued and are not looking at how they can profit from the misery of losses of the lower quintile caused by their actions.
Yeah, lookin’ at you, Obama. Oh, and you could have enforced some actions against speculators early on, President Peace Prize….
“May the fleas of a thousand camels rest in your armpits.”
–Johnny Carson
You should thank me. I’m being nice.
Righteous rant, Massacio, and very highly recc’d. Thanks.
I prefer the word kleptocracy to plutocracy or oligarchy.
Love your article, Ed.
We’re almost neighbors. Crane-Station and I live in Paducah, KY.
Recommended.
Fred Leatherman
I left a comment in yesterday’s Roundup about NY AG Schneiderman’s rather amazing tweet:
http://news.firedoglake.com/2012/04/21/the-roundup-for-april-21-2012/#comment-185783
I wish Masaccio/Cynthia Kouril/Abigail Field could untangle the story for me: A man loses his house in foreclosure, gets dinged $300 a year later by the city for tall weeds at the house he no longer owns and hasn’t lived in for a year, the city attorney tells him it’s par for the course for Citi (bank) to leave the title in the foreclosed owner’s name so Citi isn’t held responsible for damages and the man is still on the hook, and the “happy” ending is that the city deflects the fine into a lien on the house so whoever buys it has to pay it. There’s no mention of straightening out the screwed-up title system, and no mention of a city attorney or state attorney general making Citi accountable for its property. And this is the story that Eric Schneiderman links to as an example of how to restore confidence in America’s institutions. It is incredible on so many levels.
To be completely honest, I wouldn’t want to be a shareholder going into the great crash.
I’ve said it once and I’ll say it again: we’re all house wiggers now. And the DNC (along with the 101st Failsauce Keyboardists that comprise much of the left blogosphere) is dead fuckin’ set to make sure we remain house wiggers who had better start knowing our place and station in life, take whatever meager concessions they wring out the rich bipartisan plantation masters, knuckle under, keep casting fucking retarded votes, and keep our lippy uppity activist truth-mongering mouths shut.
Otherwise, President Aceveda and his DLC/Third Way cretins will deliberately lose another election just to narc us out to Romney, and he and the GOP White masters goan git mad an’ hosswhup real good. Get our mind right Cool Hand Luke style …