
AdNags Blogs In Isolated Splendor (photo: bgjohnson/flickr)
I grew up regarding the New York Times as the “paper of record,” so it surprised me both as it slid into the sewer and as I discovered that, if it was covering a story I actually knew anything about, it was frequently, well, shall we say, “less than accurate.”
As one of my friends remarked, “AdNags never gets anything right when he writes about the Mainland. We can hardly expect him to improve when reporting on things 5000 miles away.”
A short summary: Hawaii’s junior senator, Daniel Akaka, is retiring. Linda Lingle, who was the REPUBLICAN [I know, ??????] governor here for two terms, has announced her candidacy.
There are two Democrats vying for the nomination: perennial candidate and faux Democrat Ed Case [cousin of AOL founder Steve Case, thus lots of $$$$] and Mazie Hirono, current Congresswoman and previous Lt. Governor.
Before gazing into his political crystal ball, AdNags should have paid a visit to Wikipedia. There he would have discovered a number of things:
Lingle’s election as a Republican governor - Lingle ran for governor in 1998 and lost to the Democratic incumbent, Benjamin Cayetano. When 2002 rolled around, Cayetano was prevented by term limits from running again, so the Dems nominated the Lt. Governor, the much-less-well-known Mazie Hirono. Lingle, having spent the past 4 years “beefing up” the HI Republican party, ran on a “change” platform [kick out the Dems who've been running the state] and won. [So one must admit that Lingle has beaten Hirono previously.] In 2006, when Lingle ran again, the Dems could barely scare up a candidate, and when they did, he spent only $340,000 to Lingle’s $6 million. The Dem was soundly defeated.
So, while unusual for a “traditionally Democratic” state to twice elect a Republican, the circumstances were unique, and don’t foretell a “switch to the Republican side.”
Look at the numbers - In early 2010, Neil Abercrombie resigned from his Congressional seat to pursue his quest for governor. The election to replace him was a no-primary, winner-take-all affair, and the Democrats, true to their usual bumbling and stupidity, fielded two candidates: Colleen Hanabusa and Ed Case. The DCCC refused to pressure Case to withdraw, probably because he was a Blue Dog near and dear to their heart, and the DCCC financially abandoned the race. The Republican candidate, nut-case Charles Djou, won, with 39.4% of the vote (67,610 votes). [Hanabusa got 30.8 % (52,802 votes) and Case got 27.6% (47,391 votes) ]. When Djou ran for re-election in November, 2010, he was stomped by Hanabusa.
AdNags is now prognosticating on a state-wide Senate race, rather than this House one. Perhaps he thinks lightning’s going to strike twice in the form of a divisive, 2-Dems-in-the-general race, but if you extrapolate from the House race, 100,000 Dem ballots are going to beat 67,610 Republican ones, so I don’t know what he’s smoking.
Lingle’s got a record – Perhaps most laughable about AdNag’s story — other than his quoting a “prediction” from the HI Republican chairman re Lingle’s future success — is the fact that Lingle now has a record of her “leadership” in Hawaii, and that record’s not good.
• as a favor to her business pals, she allowed one of her appointees to grant an exemption from environmental requirements to an $80 million inter-island “Superferry.” [Actually, the Superferry was a much-needed service, but you don't do ANYTHING in Hawaii without appeasing the environmental gods, and you particularly don't thumb your nose at them in this flagrant way.] When protesters tried to block the ferry, she threatened them with prosecution under anti-terrorism statutes. After years of fighting and drama, the Superferry died, a colossal waste of money.
• Lingle enacted draconian budget cuts, furloughing teachers for 17 days in one year, closing libraries and reducing other public services. [Hawaii has the lowest number of classroom days in the nation and is near the absolute bottom in academic achievement, vying with MS, LA and AL.] This is probably what most voters think of when they hear her name.
• Lingle vetoed a civil unions bill that had passed the legislature. [Getting the bill re-passed and signing it was Abercrombie's first deed.]
• Lingle gave what was in effect the nominating address for Sarah Palin at the Republican National Convention. [It was rumored that Lingle herself had been considered for the post.]
So when Lingle talks about running on “my own success as a moderate Republican” and “my own record in Hawaii,” you can hear Democrats around the state saying, “bring it on.”
This is not to say that the Hawaii Democrats cannot snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. Senator Daniel Inouye runs politics in the state, but pretty-boy Case has run afoul of him by challenging Akaka a few years ago. [Why Inouye didn't elbow Case out of the way in 2010, so a Democrat could be assured of taking Abercrombie's seat (and grabbing some seniority) is a mystery, but indicates that Hawaii politics is NOT a well-oiled machine. Maybe it's because Inouye is as much of a Blue Dog as Case. I dunno.]
I’ll close this with what I’d intended to be my intro: ”AdNags, you dumb fuck.”



57 Comments

Bless you.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XlXg7CrrHfw
tweeted and recommended — adnags *is* a dumb funk
(That was for AdNags, by the way.)
BTW, AdNags, either out of ignorance or insolence, refers to Congresswoman Hirono several times in his article as “Miss Mazie.”
Insulting.
That really bothered me too.
Great diary, thanks. The whole premise of Nagourney’s article , that Obama might “lose” Hawaii for the Democrats, required a whole lot of s-t-r-e-t-c-h-i-n-g of truths. Thanks for pointing them out!
To give AdNags the benefit of the doubt, perhaps he was trying to “make a funny” by riffing on “Driving Miss Daisy.”
That’s the only thing I could figure out as a reason for this rudeness.
I had to laugh when the Star-Advertiser had proudly proclaimed: “The Race Is On”… right after Aunty Linda had announced her candidacy….! ;-)
Informative, MM….thanks for posting this.
Btw, MM, I’d love to hook you up with some great free thinkers across the Isles, many are lawyers, and we all chat online…! ;-)
*heh* Congrats, MM, on being front-paged…! *g*
It’s particularly annoying when both papers in the state, the Honolulu Star-Advertiser and the Maui News, are Republican rags.
Jeeze, the editorials, columnists and cartoons in the Maui News daily make me contemplate: “homicide or suicide”?
Great diary, Mauimom!
As for this:
“if it was covering a story I actually knew anything about, it was frequently, well, shall we say, “less than accurate.””
that is sooooo true, and it applies to all of the media. Many times I have glared at the tv because a reporter missed 80 percent of a story and got half of the rest wrong.
Both of the local papers here on the Big Isle are Stephens Media rightwing owned rags…! 8-(
It really is a transformative revelation, isn’t it? You start out — at least in an earlier, less cynical time [and one when the press was better] — thinking that you turn to them to LEARN something.
Then, when you read an article of theirs on a subject that you know something about, and that’s factually completely off, you start to wonder: “they got THIS wrong. How about all that OTHER stuff of theirs I’ve been reading?”
Excellent post, Mauimom. Thanks. Love the parting shot.
Hey Adam?
To quote Dick Cheney: “Big Time.”
CT, the “conventional wisdom” is that the Dem votes are all on Oahu, with a few on Maui, and that the “outer islands” [Kauai, Hawaii, Molokai & Lanai] are where all the Republican votes reside.
Is that what you observe?
To repeat from those above, a great diary. Recommended
Jaango
I read that one, and thought it was really amusing. The question is: how common are Black Swans in Hawai’i?
*snort* The Big Isle is most definitely not a Repug stronghold…! AdNag needs to visit the real ‘Wild West’ of Pahoa town, and get a real taste of the Isles…!
Also, there is no “Hanabuso”, right?
MM do you have my email address…?
*heh* It’s Colleen Hanabusa…! ;-)
Yes, corrected.
Thanks.
I’m pretty sure I do. From LLN.
Thanks for the post on Hawaii politics. Too bad it’s not Inouye who is leaving. He legitimatized presidential corruption by preventing Reagan from being impeached.
Does it really matter if the Democrat or Republican wins in Hawaii?
In 2001, Bush (W) had a 50/50 senate and we were told that he could get his agenda through congress as the vice-president could cast the tie-breaking vote.
In 2009, Obama had 59/41 senate and we were told that 60 votes were needed to get anything through the senate.
Inouye is a scumbag. Let’s not forget that his BFF was Stevens of Alaska. They loved to brag how much “earmark” money they funneled back to their [less populated than many others] states.
He’s also somewhere towards the head of the line for the presidency, should Obama & Biden leave this mortal earth.
Be very afraid.
…the HI Republican party, ran on a “change” platform [kick out the Dems who've been running the state] and won.
Because, Cayetano and the Dem Apparatchik had so f*cked it up…! F*ck, even I voted for Lingle over Mazie, merely because Hirono was the ‘Anointed One’…! *gah*
Ad Nags I thought got moved from politics to science writing at the Times years ago mostly denying global warming who moved him back to politics?
Amen, MM…! And Inouye is still f*cking it up for the statewide, and even local races…! 8-(
Drop me a note…! *g*
Who does it serve to have a puff story wove whole cloth from lies about GOP chances in Hawaii? Does the GOP need some random good news that bad to take people’s minds off the GOP Primary race?
Or is Ad Nags to lazy to actually do research and is risking his return to political writing with an imagination piece?
CT, you should not be making these admissions in public!!
*heh* I wear my Heart on my Sleeve…! Like it or not…! ;-)
Having lived in Hawaii, it is worth noting that the parties there are sort of ‘backward’ with respect to their mainland identities. The Dems there are more like Rep’s and vice versa.
Yes and No, ackack…! The Hawai’i Dims, en toto, have decidely swung into the ‘Blue Dog’ ledger, but, there’s still a very viable Progressive push underfoot, Abercrombie and Schatz won in a landslide…! Altho, they then immediately sold us out, but…!
Inouye is a corrupt bully and Hirono is his handpicked choice. At least Case had the guts to challenge the old boys network.
The week after the one Akaka – Case debate in 2006, all you could hear in Ka’u (rural Big Island) IRT Ed Case was “Who he tink he is?”
Linda Lingle will get her a** handed to her, same as her Lt. did in 2010, on basis of 2 words: “Furlough Fridays”.
But, Bra… Case is a Bluedog special, that’s well financed from outa State…! I think Gabbard is the only one to the right of Case…! I did rather enjoy D’jou’s short little stint…! He did make a little stink…! ;-)
Ho Cuz…! Ka’u iz in da house…? I thought I waz da only Ka’u Grad at the Lake…! ;-)
I also recall Ad Nags move to “science” at the NYT (actually moved to doing reprints of oil company handouts).
Meanwhile I just am wishing that Mazie Hirono gets that Senate seat.
Wishful thinking masquerading as learned prognostication isn’t new except there’s a whole lot more of it nowadays than in times past. But in the NYT? It’s everywhere else, so why not?
It’s as if folks’ urgent yearning to control the future leads them to really believe spinning the talk will cause the future to somehow tip over some way.
There must be a subconscious aspect to this as with Pavlov’s dog. Yet eventually the dog realizes the bell doesn’t always result in food, and the drooling ends. I think we’re well past that point, too.
I just tried to upend an empty water glass by looking at it, thinking positively, and saying confidently that it was in fact upside down. I can assure everyone, it didn’t respond or move at all.
The NYT is a despicable rag, touting ideology of the 1%. Northeastern elites think Hawaii is a foreign country, they are so northeast centric. CNN, trying to report on a hurricane, had the anchor pointing to the Galapagos Islands, which they obviously thought was Hawaii. Their ignorance is as vast as their egos. They know nothing but think they know everything.
I had considered that for my opening or headline, but didn’t want to alert readers to my prejudiced POV.
The drooling is clearly continuing at the NYT.
That is hysterical.
I note with wry amusement [and disgust] that Politico is referencing AdNag’s “wisdom”.
http://www.politico.com/blogs/david-catanese/2011/12/national-scrutiny-of-hawaii-senate-race-begins-108460.html
These fools just reinforce each others’ stupidity.
Linda Lingle also is a very vindictive woman. She got mad at Maui County because after having her as mayor a majority in our county voted for her opponent. She took it out on us.
She also invested $3billion in some junk bonds, leaving our subsequent Gov Abercrombie unable to access the money during this economic downturn. She left the accounts in shambles as though no one was DOING the finances for the state.
On the Superferry, she spent $40million on Chinese-made barges in an attempt to circumvent environmental law. The effect of her ignoring environmental law was that the Superferry took over our interisland freight dock and they tore down the shed that kept our partial loads out of the rain. Virtually EVERYTHING comes into Maui via interisland barge. (food goods, building materials, etc) Those tax-payer funded barges are still taking up space at our docks – where berths are at a premium since we are constrained on expanding our docs.
She doesn’t keep her word in negotiations. We’ve gone in, negotiated, come to an agreement, given up substantial concessions, and 2 hours later Lingle completely abrogates the agreement.
Unfortunately, she is a pretty smart cookie and good at presenting herself publicly, which makes her extremely dangerous because behind that public face is a voraciously ambitious woman who will do anything to advance her career and has absolutely no ethics.
Tulsi or Mike? Tulsi’s making a run for Mazie’s old House Seat. Also Mufi (“I’m brown and you’re not”) Hannemann is running for that seat. So far no progressives except maybe Bob Marx. The other candidate, Esther Kiaʻaina, who worked for Ed Case, which is NOT a recommendation in my book.
I remember going to Case’s “talk story” long after even the most hawkish Dems figured out we’d been lied into the Iraq War and he was still hardcore hawk. He’s just like the GOP – all “we gotta cut programes EXCEPT let’s throw EVEN MORE money into the military”
They can pretend that’s fiscal conservatism but it is the worst kind of spendthrift attitude.
Hey – I’ll agree that Inouye is a bully and he also voted for “indefinite detention” which is repugnant. And he was buddies with former Alaska Sen Stevens so probably corrupt too.
But Mazie Hirono is a really progressive candidate. She’s Buddhist, anti-war, consistently votes progressively. Mazie is da bomb!
Inouye wields a lot of behind the scenes power as far as determining who gets National DCCC money and so on. But at the state level, he can’t do much because our State democratic party has no money and is filled with progressives who aren’t going to go for someone just because Inouye picks them.
Mazie’s just one of those people, who everyone likes – progressives, unions, even Inouye. (Here in Hawaii, the ILWU HATES progressives, so this is 2 very different constituencies)
But true dat, that Inouye will support ABC (anyone but case) Case was so arrogant as to run against a well-loved incumbent, Akaka. In fact, I’ve seen Case support a REPUBLICAN county councilmember because he still held a grudge against the guy running against the Republican. And Inouye managed not to get kicked out of the Democratic pary even though we have a rule against endorsing people from other parties.
I mean INOUYE supported a republican county councilmember. Sorry bout that
I never thought Schatz was progressive…ambitious-yes…
You are high!!!! The Hawai’i Democratic party is filled with Republicans too scared to run as Republicans (e.g. Ed Case) but the Republican party in Hawai’i is to the right of the John Birch society and filled with horrible, dirty-fighting mean people.
But both parties have a majority who have sold out to the corporations.
Bite your tongue! Inouye as president? Ahhhhhhh….talk about pro-military and corrupt corporate guy.
It matters a LOT. Although if Case wins, like or not he’ll vote with the other Blue Dogs to kill all progressive legislation and filibuster all the progressive bills.
That’s why we need Mazie Hirono to win – she’s in the Progressive Caucus.
Agreed. Obama is still well-loved here, even though we are not happy about some of his actions. But we’re a whole lot LESS happy with the GOP.
I think that we have to realize that over half the Hawai’i Dems are really chicken Republicans. So we have to (as you did) vote for the person.
Although, after experiencing Lingle’s vindictiveness as Mayor of Maui, most of us in Maui County saw through her polished image into the reality of her over-weaning and ruthless ambition.
But I don’t blame anyone who didn’t live in Maui county for voting for Lingle. She create a slick image of reasonableness (at total odds with her vindictive and irresponsible governing).
And at that time I knew nothing about Mazie Hirono. Now that I’ve known her and know her voting record, I’ve been completely won over.