• anotherquestion commented on the blog post No Tech Worker Shortage, No STEM Crisis

    2014-11-25 12:09:47View | Delete

    Thanks for this diary.

    News coverage and political commentary of President Obama’s recent speech on immigration reform mostly ignored the issues of high tech (STEM) guestworkers even though this group was clearly mentioned in the speech and in the press release.


    The issue of hiring spouses of H-1B visa holders is not trivial or obscure, especially at universities where spousal hiring in general is very common.

    Thanks again.

  • anotherquestion wrote a new diary post: Setting Up The Students

    2014-10-24 06:58:53View | Delete

    ThumbnailOur country needs well educated people.The high cost of college tuition and the worsening penalties for student debt raise the question “ Should you go to college? ”.  Various disciplines are experiencing declines in enrollment, even areas like law schools.  Where are the good jobs and is the training worth the expense? Science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) [...]

  • anotherquestion commented on the diary post Over Easy: Monday Science by BoxTurtle.

    2014-10-20 07:57:16View | Delete

    Hello, I’m posting this item here since I no longer have posting privileges. ——- Setting up The Students The high cost of college tuition and the worsening penalties for student debt raise the question “Should you go to college?” (http://www.thenation.com/blog/182153/should-you-go-college). Various disciplines are experiencing declines in enrollment, even areas like law schools. Science, technology, engineering, [...]

  • Alternet reposts from

    Tom Dispatch / By Aviva Chomsky

    The Tragic Truth About the Children Crossing the Border
    The real story isn’t being told. Instead, our politicians, the media, and various organizations have simply been posturing.

    A central comment blames both the Republicans and Democrats for using this latest immigration crisis to ignore unmet, unequal resources for the poor communities where immigrant children end up, and lack of moral high ground on addressing the real foreign policy problems in Central America that cause this immigration.

    These two seemingly clashing narratives — the moral, humanitarian imperative to help children in need and the plight of strapped cities and Americans in need — turn out to neatly complement each other. Both play the game of victimology in the service of party politics. Each asks essentially the same question: Do Republicans or Democrats get more points for defending the neediest victims? Each side claims the humanitarian high ground, while both conveniently avoid looking at the political economy of the problem they lament — and that they have, over many decades, collaborated in creating.

  • Britain is experiencing analogous issues. They find immigrants crowded in dangerous shipping containers try to get to Britain. And figures from both main political parties say that “non-EU students should be left out of official immigration figures to avoid the risk of damaging UK universities.” (Can you say H-1B?)
    The details are not identical, but the details surely rhyme with US immigration issues. At least Britain acknowledges that high skill immigration can cause problems.

  • Thumbnail What’s behind Microsoft’s departure from ALEC? Some people describe watching politics as similar to watching sausage being made. Sometimes the exchange is complex such as the story, true or not, that Frank Sinatra sang eight nights straight at a Mafia-owned club to pay for actions by John and Robert Kennedy after they were in the White [...]

  • anotherquestion commented on the blog post Immigration Surges to Number One Issue With Americans

    2014-07-16 17:41:14View | Delete

    Being interested in immigration as an issue does not mean that respondents support the US Senate Comprehensive Immigration Reform Bill. The immigration issue is covered with as much bias by the mainstream media as the conflict in Israel and Palestine. Years ago, I saw an occasional news item about the effect of H-1B high tech guestworker visas on US workers, but it’s been years. Yet, H-1B visas are a major part of the Senate immigration reform bill. Search engines have a huge bias in favor of corporations acquiring H-1B visa workers and against news about the opposition. I wonder how much Facebook engineers a bias as well.

  • anotherquestion commented on the diary post State Socialization to Build Grit & Perseverance by deft.

    2014-07-05 05:51:37View | Delete

    Here deft argues the limitations of even good teachers when faced with an inappropriate curriculum. I met some talented workers overseas where vocational training was better received. A really well skilled lab technician had only 1-2 years of vocational training, yet was happy and well skilled in a soil chemistry lab. One advocate for enforced [...]

  • anotherquestion wrote a new diary post: Why We Don’t Have Good Jobs!

    2014-05-10 18:47:12View | Delete

    ThumbnailIt would be great to put some restraints on vulture capitalists.Remember the idea “It’s the economy, stupid!”?  Remember the concern about income inequality? Fast food workers are striking for better hourly wages, against wage theft, and for better advancement opportunities.  Other low-wage workers such as Walmart workers are also striking for better wages.  So, we have some discussion [...]

  • ThumbnailMichael S. Teitelbaum has a new book Falling Behind?:  Boom, Bust & the Global Race for Scientific Talent  about the job market in science and engineering. He identifies five cycles of alarm, boom, and bust in the science and engineering job market since World War II. These cycles include the Sputnik campaign and the Y2K programming campaign. A [...]

  • I agree. So, why have 160,000-300,000+ new H-1B guestworker visas each year to compete with US citizens at a time of already low demand for these skills? And why are universities already exempt from the national cap on H-1B visas even before passage of the Comprehensive Immigration Bills in the US Senate and US House? There is another visa program (not H-1B) for non-citizens with exceptional skills.

    Thanks for your posting.

  • Thanks DSWright for the post on this topic.

    I also recommend the following article:
    “The Myth of the Science and Engineering Shortage”

    That article is a preview to a new book also by Michael S. Teitelbaum:
    Falling Behind? Boom, Bust, and the Global Race for Scientific Talent

    The author is a demographer, a former Rhodes scholar, a fellow at Harvard University, and was on the faculty of Princeton and Oxford. The article and the book discuss the booms and busts in the science and engineering labor market since World War II.

  • anotherquestion commented on the diary post Ahhh, the GOP’s Immigration Principles* by jaango.

    2014-02-02 06:50:43View | Delete

    Most news reports and public discussions about immigration reform consider only the non-documented (a.k.a. illegal) immigrants. The Comprehensive Immigration Reform bill that’s supposed to solve all the problems rolls together the non-documented immigrants (workers, DREAMers) along with the legal immigration system greatly increasing the number of guestworkers, especially the H-1B high skilled guestworkers. I do [...]

  • anotherquestion commented on the diary post Ahhh, the GOP’s Immigration Principles* by jaango.

    2014-02-01 14:27:11View | Delete

    Thank you for the observation. I do not want a wall in Texas for the Republicans, nor do I want the Wall Street Democrats to take good middle class jobs in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics using H-1B high skill guestworker visas as a form of eminent domain.


  • Thank you for the previous comments including the original post by Jon Walker. I, too, wonder what are the real goals for Emily’s List.

    Emily’s List supports US Senators Amy Klobuchar, Patty Murray, and Tammy Baldwin. I deeply question whether the current budget agreement is either progressive or liberal. Senator Klobuchar was the senator who formally introduced the bill to expand the number of H-1B visas, based on a claim that employers cannot find enough US citizens with the necessary skills even during a time of very high unemployment. Senator Baldwin was on the committee negotiating with US Rep Paul Ryan and she frequently writes letters about the glories of the budget sequester.

    Senators Murray, Baldwin, and Klobuchar all did good things for working people in the past, but times have changed. Are they any different now from the Log Cabin Republicans who support gay marriage (and maybe abortion), but share economic goals with Republicans (and President Obama)?

  • anotherquestion commented on the diary post Ending Academic Apartheid: Equity and Dignity for Adjunct Professors by robertwfuller.

    2013-12-08 04:46:51View | Delete

    PS. That advertised pay of $31,000-35,000 per year is the full-time rate. Since the job is actually 50% time, the pay is $15,500-17,500 per year.

  • anotherquestion commented on the diary post Ending Academic Apartheid: Equity and Dignity for Adjunct Professors by robertwfuller.

    2013-12-08 04:43:14View | Delete

    The issues you describe for teaching staff are becoming more common for research staff, too. It used to be that a Master’s in statistics and connections at a large university wouldn’t make you rich, but you would always be able to eat. Now, such jobs are very scarce. They advertise $31,000-35,000 per year, often requiring [...]

  • Thanks much DSWright. Yes, President Obama led this mess, but he had sincere help from the US Congress. I don’t like the fundraising advertising now for “Progressives” in Congress that were instrumental in promoting the sequester and other austerity programs, and the guestworker/H-1B stuff precisely at a time of a bad economy and already high unemployment.

    President Obama and certain members of congress were marketed based on a history of progressive voting records. Some of these members of congress did have legitimately progressive records. Yet, they as a group collaborated on all those projects you list to depress the 99%. The news media helped in these bad actions. Thanks to FireDogLake and other independents for news and a forum to circumvent the newsmasters.

  • anotherquestion wrote a new diary post: Immigration Reform under President Obama

    2013-11-26 08:42:39View | Delete

    Immigration Reform is back in the headlines.  Kevin Gosztola wrote a thoughtful piece that considered various aspects of the situation and attracted several comments. President Obama himself put this issue in the news .

    If they want to chop that thing up into five pieces, as long as all five pieces get done , I don’t care what it looks like,” [...]

  • Yes, it is interesting. Do you remember how the news could easily find a tiny handful of Tea Partiers near any protest, but rarely had any worthwhile coverage of the 50,000+ peaceful protestors at the same event? It is interesting how ABC interviews Mark Zuckerberg for his “new” push on Immigration Reform with FWD.us, a push that is already many months old.

    In the same way now, the news highlights any protest of sympathetic young people and undocumented cheap workers blessed by corporations. I sympathize with these vulnerable people. Yet, the news conveniently censors the guestworker issue of H-1B visas and migrant farmworkers. Universities promote “deserving young scientists,” while configuring jobs for researchers and adjunct faculty to avoid providing health insurance.

  • Load More