-
Shahid Buttar wrote a new diary post: President Obama vs. his administration’s legacy
President Obama’s speech yesterday, presenting his vision of a comprehensive counter-terrorism strategy, included welcome rhetoric about the importance of constitutional principles, including Due Process and rights to dissent. It may represent the high watermark for civil liberties since his inauguration five years ago. It is disappointing, given his thoughtful words, that he ignored so many inconvenient truths. [...] -
Shahid Buttar wrote a new diary post: Killing us softly
Why Holder’s letter carries little water Last week, Senator Rand Paul (R-TX) forced a long overdue conversation in Washington about checks and balances on executive power. Yet few observers recognize the ultimate importance of his actions, or why the Senate’s confirmation of the new CIA director remained premature. Prompted by Sen. Paul’s filibuster last Wednesday, Attorney General Holder [...] -
Shahid Buttar wrote a new diary post: Bipartisan Senate filibuster challenges Brennan CIA nomination
A bipartisan filibuster of John Brennan’s nomination to lead the CIA riveted Washington on Wednesday. Senators from both sides of the partisan aisle, led by Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY), took to the Senate floor to force further debate on a nomination that should not proceed. Sen. Paul’s 12 hours of comments included a succinct and clear [...] -
Shahid Buttar wrote a new diary post: Immigration enforcement: a trojan horse?
Comprehensive immigration reform, along with the fiscal cliff and sequester, has recently dominated Washington. But observers have overlooked how calls for stronger immigration enforcement could undermine the rights of not only immigrants, but also US citizens. Conservative members of Congress have demanded tighter enforcement as a condition of considering meaningful reform of federal immigration policy. But [...] -
Shahid Buttar wrote a new diary post: Clapper v Amnesty: Courts and Congress v Our Constitution
This article was originally published on the People’s Blog for the Constitution . Tuesday’s decision by the Supreme Court in Clapper vs Amnesty Int’l reflects judicial formalism at its worst. The decision abandons fundamental rights and the courts’ constitutional mandate, while placing government agencies above the law, so long as they commit their abuses in secret. Clapper is a constitutional travesty [...] -
Shahid Buttar commented on the diary post Will Obama’s second term finally fulfill his 2008 promises? (Part I) by Shahid Buttar.
Thanks for everyone’s feedback. If these issues concern you, subscribe to the Bill of Rights Defense Committee’s monthly updates for more analysis beyond the headlines, as well as opportunities to take action and build the grassroots movement to restore civil liberties.
-
Shahid Buttar wrote a new diary post: Will Obama’s second term finally fulfill his 2008 promises? (Part I)
This article was originally published on the People’s Blog for the Constitution and is the first in a forthcoming series articulating specific civil liberties recommendations for the second Obama administration. President Obama’s reelection has sparked an onslaught of analysis attempting to define the agenda for his second term. Will it reflect the vision of restoring liberty and security on which [...] -
Shahid Buttar wrote a new diary post: Uncle Sam is watching you
This week, Congress prepares to abuse the Constitution again, by extending its 2008 amendments to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA). With the House of Representatives poised to vote today on a premature five year extension, will members remember what they heard when theatrically reading the Constitution on the House floor, or instead entrench the [...] -
Shahid Buttar commented on the diary post Fazaga v. FBI: Eroding democracy, in two dimensions at once by Shahid Buttar.
That’s a great point, Tom. Even the Church Committee envisioned an ongoing need for vigilance to prevent the COINTELPRO era’s abuses from recurring. Yet ever since Attorney General Levi promulgated the FBI Guidelines in 1976, their protections have been steadily eroding.
-
Shahid Buttar wrote a new diary post: Fazaga v. FBI: Eroding democracy, in two dimensions at once
On Tuesday, August 14, a federal judge issued a disturbing ruling allowing the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) to evade public accountability for infiltrating faith institutions, monitoring law-abiding people, recording sexual encounters, and then lying about all of it. Carney’s decision erodes democracy in two dimensions at once, enabling ongoing constitutional violations by the executive branch [...] -
Shahid Buttar wrote a new diary post: America’s one-party state
Both 2012 presidential campaigns advance the legacy of Dick Cheney Among the most tragic casualties of the war on terror is the separation of powers that our Founders envisioned to help keep America free. Not only has executive power expanded to disturbing – and profoundly dangerous – proportions in the decade since the 9-11 attacks, but [...] -
Shahid Buttar wrote a new diary post: What Do We Celebrate this July Fourth?
When the United States championed democracy, freedom, and opportunity, it made sense to celebrate the Fourth of July. But are we still promoting those values? If we are paragons of neither opportunity nor freedom, what exactly do we celebrate today? Our Statue of Liberty bears an inscription welcoming the world’s “tired and poor…huddled masses yearning to [...] -
Shahid Buttar commented on the blog post Levin: Let’s Not Let the Constitution Get in the Way of Indefinite Detention
It’s not even particularly crazy, given the MEK story. See http://www.constitutioncampaign.org/blog/?p=7680.
Also, FWIW, we’re on the same train: http://www.constitutioncampaign.org/blog/?p=7602.
-
Shahid Buttar commented on the blog post Levin: Let’s Not Let the Constitution Get in the Way of Indefinite Detention
Indeed! He may not intend it, but last week’s events in Chicago are a perfect demonstration of what life under the NDAA might look like. http://www.constitutioncampaign.org/blog/?p=7602
-
Shahid Buttar commented on the blog post Abdulmutallab Sentencing Shows That Civilian Courts Sufficient to Prosecute Terrorism
While the sentencing does indeed show the continuing viability of relying on Article III civilian (i.e., constitutional) courts, our government has already expanded the alternative military (i.e., unconstitutional) detention regime in the NDAA. But we need not stand for it. Cite this article when raising your voice where you can make a difference — where you live. Communities around the country, in states both blue and red, are already raising their voices: http://www.constitutioncampaign.org/blog/?p=6098. Will your’s be next?
-
Shahid Buttar wrote a new diary post: What Comes Next? The Future of the NDAA
This is the final part of a 3-part FAQ about the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) that began with Another Assault in the Dead of Night and continued with Torture Enabling Expanded Detention . The first installment explained how the NDAA could be used as a tool for political repression , especially in concert with parallel powers expanded by the [...] -
Shahid Buttar wrote a new diary post: Torture Enabling Expanded Detention: the NDAA in context
This is the second part of a 3-part series about the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) that began with ” Another Assault in the Dead of Night “. As I concluded there:
elieve the hype: the NDAA’s detention provisions represent a frontal assault on the Bill of Rights. They are noxious now. They will be worse in the [...]
-
Shahid Buttar commented on the diary post The NDAA: Another Assault in the Dead of Night by Shahid Buttar.
I fully agree, and do think that, as lawyers, we owe a particular obligation to identify — and challenge — the radicalism that has seized both major political parties. “It’s an obligation I think is incumbent on all lawyers and law students — to defend the rights of dissent in an age of state repression.” [...]
-
Shahid Buttar commented on the diary post The NDAA: Another Assault in the Dead of Night by Shahid Buttar.
I think one reason the NDAA hasn’t attracted much media attention is because its legislative process was relatively secret. Hearings are typically how issues get raised, rather than through the back room deals orchestrated by Dick Cheney & his minions that ushered the NDAA through Congress. I suspect most members of Congress don’t even realize [...]
-
Shahid Buttar commented on the diary post The NDAA: Another Assault in the Dead of Night by Shahid Buttar.
Signing statements can certainly be rescinded or ignored by future presidents. They have no binding authority, so any potential caveats articulated by the Obama administration via signing statement are good for only as long as he remains in the White House.
- Load More


