• About us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Send Comments/Tips
  • My FDL
  • Firedoglake
  • News
  • TBogg
  • La Figa
  • Book Salon
  • FDL Action
  • The Dissenter
  • Pam's House Blend
  • Elections
  • Just Say Now
  • Bytegeist
  • Activity
  • Profile
  • Diary
  • Friends (0)
  • Groups (0)
User Picture

Spencer Ackerman

Last active
1 year, 10 months ago
  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post Emptywheel Leaving Firedoglake

    2011-07-12 08:55:46View | Delete

    As someone who was really, really sad to leave FDL, I think I may have a sense of what you’re going through. Can’t wait to read your next work, and the future of civ-lib coverage here at FDL, too.

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post The New, Old Mission in Afghanistan

    2011-06-22 18:04:42View | Delete

    Thanks for the link, DDay. One thing you might be interested in that didn’t make my piece: my anonymouse sez that the long-term basing accord is gonna be more like … well, check the transcript:

    we’re not going to have kind of a permanent basing structure like in Korea or something. But I think what we will have is a — it’s fair to say we’ll have a counterterrorism capability. So a strike capability, that we’ll able to ensure that there’s not that reemergence of a safe haven threat to us, or a substantial — well, basically that. I mean, I think we’ll have an architecture that enables us to do that. Now, the exact logistics of that are still being worked out in the context of the strategic partnership.

    FWIW.

    Lord, I miss FDL.

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post Michael Leiter Resigns, Undermining Claimed Rationale for Mueller Extension

    2011-06-12 06:54:35View | Delete

    Or, alternatively, Mueller: Now More Than Evar!!!!1!

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post A Bittersweet Goodbye Post

    2010-12-29 15:22:22View | Delete

    Thanks to all of you for reading, and particularly to my FDL fam. I’ll see you in your comment threads now…

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post I Said This Day Would Never Come

    2010-12-23 05:47:22View | Delete

    Fair point. And as much as I complained about all my New START email spam on Twitter, the arms-control community waged a successful non-stop PR blitz for the treaty for the inside-the-Beltway crowd.

    What I always wonder about is whether nuclear security can be like climate change — something that starts out as the parochial interest of a fairly cloistered political community, but then a movie or something (Inconvenient Truth, in the climate case) comes along and turns it into a widespread social movement.

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post Indefinite Detention Executive Orders We Can Believe In

    2010-12-21 19:12:20View | Delete

    Dafna Linzner, ladies and gentlemen! #honored #ballin

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 16:57:19View | Delete

    And thanks very much to Tony for taking the time for being part of this fascinating chat; and everyone for participating.

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 16:56:42View | Delete

    Coming up on the end here… One of the conclusions of the book is that we need to respect an Afghan reconciliation process with the Taliban. The Taliban leadership say they won’t negotiate until we leave. Do we put that on the table in the hopes of unlocking a peace deal? From the looks of this weekend’s NATO summit, that’s not really on the table. But should it be?

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 16:38:15View | Delete

    Tony, we’re coming up on the final stretch here. What do you want everyone here to know about ABLE DANGER? When it first came to light in 2006 it seemed fantastical — a will to believe we could have stopped 9/11.

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 16:37:13View | Delete

    Ah, I might have read your comment too quickly — if what you mean is targeting Pakistani officials and institutions then yeah, I would imagine not even the Obama administration could argue the AUMF covers that.

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 16:33:59View | Delete

    Except that the AUMF, practically speaking, authorizes anything an administration says it wants authorized. There’s nothing in there about drone strikes in Pakistan or cruise missiles (and soon drones) in Yemen. And yet they occur, justified under the AUMF’s unbounded grant of warmaking authority against al-Qaeda. Boots on the ground could be similarly defended — after all, there are Special Operations Forces in Pakistan now, in an officially “advisory” capacity.

    I’m not making a normative case that we should be on the ground in Pakistan. Just that if we were, the AUMF is hardly an obstacle to doing so as it stands. The real obstacles are political and diplomatic.

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 16:22:49View | Delete

    the Obama WH Afghan policy is nothing more than the super sizing of the Bush WH policy

    Tease this out a bit, would you? Do you mean that it’s not a strategic approach, ie, bringing us to an acceptable endgame? Or that — as you write in your book about the mid-2000s — it neglects the centrality of Pakistan?

    And going off that question: in the book, you and your colleagues argue repeatedly for raids into Pakistan. I’m not sure what I think about that — it seems hypocritical to bomb Pakistani targets 101 times this year from the air but balk at boots on the ground in the context of a “destabilizing measure.” But on the other hand, what if it is destabilizing? Faisal Shahzad didn’t just talk about the drones as a motivation for trying to blow up Times Square, he talked about the entire Afghanistan-Pakistan war.

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 16:04:42View | Delete

    there IS no problem with identification and tracking of people who meet his profile – it was the “political correct” culture that prevented the laws and regulations from being effectively used…

    Tony, can you explain this a little further? This is a common refrain in the intelligence community and it needs a bit of unpacking. What’s the ‘politically correct’ culture amongst analysts and how does it inhibit good intelligence work?

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 15:55:37View | Delete

    So given that we’re entering a period in which American citizens are emerging as terrorist assets — Anwar al-Aulaqi, Faisal Shahzad, Maj. Hasan — is there a need to harmonize PC standards with EO 12333′s guidelines? I know the Justice Department’s Office of Intelligence labors to be the connection to sync up the intelligence and law enforcement communities, but is there a danger of broad data-mining jeopardizing a terrorism prosecution otherwise?

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 15:48:19View | Delete

    (that should be “from the perspective of finding terrorist connections to U.S. persons…”)

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 15:47:29View | Delete

    From the perspective of finding U.S. persons, are you ever working toward a probable-cause standard? Or (as some intelligence analysts have cautioned me) is that just not a relevant term from an analyst’s perspective, given the category difference between intelligence and law enforcement?

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 15:42:00View | Delete

    As a follow-up: how specific or rigorous are the instructions you receive during a data-mining exercise for what counts as a “connection”? If I try to access the al-Falluja extremist forum, is my IP address going to pop up, or will it be typically filtered out unless I have a variety of other connections to a given target?

    And maybe this is a good segue into how ABLE DANGER actually worked, what it was/wasn’t, etc…

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 15:29:26View | Delete

    So, as someone who’s been inside a big data-mining operation, can you tell us how you balance the privacy/security question? In the book, you tend to give short shrift to the legal questions involved with ABLE DANGER — I think you wrote, “hell, they’re terrorists,” at one point when recounting the SOCOM lawyers wanting to shut the program down.

    But there’s a great fear that mining metadata for possible terrorist involvement is going to ensnare a great deal of constitutionally-protected behavior. Especially now that we’re seeing a stated desire on the part of al-Qaeda’s Yemen offshoot to encourage homegrown terrorism. On the inside, where do the legal restrictions come in?

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 15:17:33View | Delete

    I thought we might bracket ABLE DANGER for a second, given that your book is about very sensitive intelligence operations in Afghanistan. Most of them get messed up by bureaucracy, in your telling, even when they look like they’re going well, or are disconnected from a larger strategy. What do you think the implications of that are for a special-ops-centric strategy going forward in Afghanistan, which frequently gets discussed as an alternative to our huge, heavy footprint there?

  • Picture

    Spencer Ackerman commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Tony Shaffer, Operation Dark Heart: Spycraft and Special Ops on the Frontlines of Afghanistan — and The Path to Victory

    2010-11-20 15:03:30View | Delete

    Hey Tony, which I hope I can call you. Welcome to the Lake & thanks for doing this Book Salon. What kind of restrictions are you under for discussing aspects of the book that have been redacted?

  • Load More  

Tell Your Rep. - Oppose President Obama's
Social Security Cuts

Welcome to FDL

Login to Firedoglake and participate in our community.

Not a member? Create an account.

Toolbox

Explore
Find Diaries Find People
Site Activity Find Groups

About MyFDL

MyFDL is the community site of progressive political blog Firedoglake. Anyone can participate by writing a diary, commenting on others’ diaries, or joining groups to find other people in your area. Content posted to MyFDL is the opinion of the author alone, and should not be attributed to Firedoglake.

» More about MyFDL.

» MyFDL Comment Moderation.

» NEW: Report site problems and bugs.

MYFDL RECOMMENDED DIARIES
  • Over Easy: The Honeybee Crisis
    By: Crane-Station 140 Comments
  • New documents show Exxon knew of contamination, claimed Lake Conway was "oil-free"
    By: Jcoleman 9 Comments
  • Institutional Investors Love Sleazy Bankers
    By: masaccio 0 Comments
  • Those they despise .....
    By: cmaukonen 3 Comments
  • Which DC Lobbying Firms are the Unemployed Hiring To Represent Them?
    By: spocko 1 Comments
  • The Boston Case Reviewed: What We Know and What We Don't
    By: E. F. Beall 81 Comments
  • Farmworkers Fight Wendy’s, the ‘Last Holdout’ on Fair Food
    By: Michelle Chen 6 Comments
  • Frackalypse Now: Mark Fiore Spoofs Oil Industry's PSYOPS Campaign To Derail Fracking "Insurgency"
    By: bdemelle 0 Comments
  • Tuesday Watercooler
    By: Kit OConnell 0 Comments
  • And Here We Are
    By: Daveparts 0 Comments
Follow @Firedoglake

Subscribe to Firedoglake RSS

» More FDL feeds

News. Community. Activism.

Firedoglake is a member-supported organization.
Help us continue our work for as little as $45/year.

MYFDL RECENT DIARIES
  • Institutional Investors Love Sleazy Bankers
    By: masaccio 0 Comments
  • A Troubling Trend Continues: A Growing Share of Wisconsin Schoolchildren are Low-Income
    By: WI Budget Project 0 Comments
  • From Field to Table: Rights for Workers in the Food Supply Chain
    By: Other Worlds 0 Comments
  • Five Ways the Proposed Income Tax Cut Could Hurt Wisconsin
    By: WI Budget Project 0 Comments
  • Vitamin C does not help with TB
    By: ThingsComeUndone 1 Comments
  • And Here We Are
    By: Daveparts 0 Comments
  • Connecticut Advances Conversion from War to Peace Economy
    By: David Swanson 0 Comments
  • Over Easy: The Honeybee Crisis
    By: Crane-Station 140 Comments
  • Which DC Lobbying Firms are the Unemployed Hiring To Represent Them?
    By: spocko 1 Comments
  • Tuesday Watercooler
    By: Kit OConnell 0 Comments
  • Some unions protest Obamacare’s impact on Multiemployer Health Plans
    By: Kay Tillow 0 Comments
  • Those they despise .....
    By: cmaukonen 3 Comments
  • Farmworkers Fight Wendy’s, the ‘Last Holdout’ on Fair Food
    By: Michelle Chen 6 Comments
  • To Offset Disaster Relief, Curb the Drug War (VIDEO)
    By: Jesse Lava 7 Comments
  • Frackalypse Now: Mark Fiore Spoofs Oil Industry's PSYOPS Campaign To Derail Fracking "Insurgency"
    By: bdemelle 0 Comments
  • My European Union Rant
    By: David Seaton 3 Comments
  • New documents show Exxon knew of contamination, claimed Lake Conway was "oil-free"
    By: Jcoleman 9 Comments
  • Obama Admin. Approves ALEC Model Bill for Fracking Chemical Fluid Disclosure on Public Lands
    By: Steve Horn 0 Comments
  • "Gasland 2" Grassroots Premiere in Illinois Highlights Industry PSYOPS and Ongoing Fracking Fights
    By: Steve Horn 2 Comments
  • Oklahoma Tornadoes and building codes
    By: ThingsComeUndone 2 Comments
  • Mattea Kramer and Jo Comerford: Congress Tweeted While America Burned
    By: Tom Engelhardt 8 Comments
  • Increased Word Usage in Society predicts coming social change and points out the Left's mistakes.
    By: ThingsComeUndone 7 Comments
  • New Marriage Equality States Do Nothing to Solve the Problem of Same-Sex Divorce
    By: Gideon Alper 5 Comments
  • The Boston Case Reviewed: What We Know and What We Don't
    By: E. F. Beall 81 Comments
  • Over Easy - Moore, OK
    By: KrisAinTX 166 Comments

Read More »

Home  |  Advertise  |  RSS Feed  |  Register  |  Login  |  Subscribe to updates  |  WordPress  |  About  |  Contact  |  Privacy  |  Copyright Claims Notice
MyFDL
  • Log In
  • Create a Firedoglake Account
  • ?