• About us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Send Comments/Tips
  • My FDL
  • Firedoglake
  • News
  • TBogg
  • La Figa
  • Book Salon
  • FDL Action
  • The Dissenter
  • Pam's House Blend
  • Elections
  • FDL TV
  • Just Say Now
  • Activity
  • Profile
  • Diary
  • Friends (0)
  • Groups (0)
User Picture

Tim Shorrock

Last active
1 year, 2 months ago
  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 17:00:03View | Delete

    Thanks folks. Thanks Barb. Thanks Patrick. And thanks to FDL.

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:57:10View | Delete

    Yup, our time is drawing to a close. As the host, I want to thank you, Patrick, for answering our questions and taking part in this discussion. My (Stetson) hat is off to you also for your courage in standing up for the truth and for our vets. Your story is a very moving one and I hope many, many people read your book and learn how you helped bring this issue of Gulf War Syndrome to the American public. On behalf of FDL, thanks for being here today and good luck in the future.

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:56:05View | Delete

    Very good point about the POTUS. I too thought that was a serious mistake. It signalled that past crimes would not even be investigated. And that hurts our democracy and our republic. Other countries have tried past leaders who comitted crimes. South Korea, for example, tried and conficted two former president who, as generals, led a bloody miitary coup in 1980. The country was strengthened by that. The dissident leader who they jailed and later become president pardoned them. Yet here in America people who break the law are glorified, given time on Fox and other networks to say whatever they want.

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:47:05View | Delete

    “Aggressive, probing oversight.” Aye, there’s the rub. If they do that, they’ll never go back to their former agencies, right?

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:46:01View | Delete

    There’s been lots of talk lately about the lack of accountability in high places. At the Academy Awards, the director of a film on the financial crisis noted that no bank executives were ever prosecuted for acts that nearly brought the US economy down. I commented afterwards that a country that doesn’t prosecute war criminals won’t go after financial crooks. It seems we’ve set a very poor example in this country by allowing people like Dick Cheney break laws against torture and other things. How in your estimation can be have a better system of justice in national security? It was criminal (to me) how the CIA and DoD tried to stifle information on Gulf War Syndrome.

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:40:25View | Delete

    Getting back to how Congress works, do you think the intelligence committees have too many staffers who come out of the IC and then go back after their service? Obviously these staffers need security clearances – but wouldn’t it be better to have staffers without an institutional connection to, say, the CIA or the NGA?

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:38:04View | Delete

    So obviously you think these cuts were not justified?

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:37:22View | Delete

    Look how they treated the general, Taguba, who investigated Abu Ghraib.

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:36:18View | Delete

    Some passages in your book are blacked out. Are these sections that you tried to keep in but lost out in your legal fights?

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:33:09View | Delete

    At the top of our session you said this:

    Look at the world from above, whether your using satellite imagery or video from a drone. Google Earth would have been classified TOP SECRET/RUFF SENSITIVE 20 years ago, had it existed. It’s all about being able to distinguish trucks from cars, tanks from armored personnel carriers, etc.

    My question – now this stuff is used by all. Doesn’t that argue against the need to classify so much of our intelligence abilities – the sources & methods that the IC seeks to protect so much? In other words, is too much of our capabilities secret?

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:27:16View | Delete

    That’s interesting because Congress has just given GAO new oversight powers in intelligence – at least I think that passed.

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:23:53View | Delete

    Would you encourage young people to join the intelligence community today despite what you went through? If so, where would you advise them to focus their efforts? NGA? CIA?

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:20:26View | Delete

    Your whistleblower proposal is excellent. What about the IGs? Is there a way they could be strengthened to deal with whistleblowers?

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:16:45View | Delete

    Putting aside the wisdom of the current Afghan war, which many of us disagree with fundamentally, how would you like to see the NGA and IC working to track the possibility (or real use) of chemical and bio weapons by the Taliban or Al Qaeda elements? Is there a better way for information from the battlefield to be used to inform the intel agencies about where to focus?

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:09:00View | Delete

    Are there reforms that could be made to ease the way for whistleblowers like yourself? Also, I wanted to ask – did you ever go to the CIA IG, or did I miss that?

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:07:03View | Delete

    Actually the bulk doesn’t go to the Blackwaters, XEs, etc, but to about 100 companies, including them but encompassing all the major defense contractors and lots of so-called Beltway Bandits that supply certain kinds of technology useful to one or more of the agencies.

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 16:01:50View | Delete

    The last part of your book is a riveting account of how you went back and forth between CIA and Capitol Hill trying to unearth the story of Gulf War Syndrome, and how both CIA and DoD tried to shut you up and keep the story from getting beyond congressional investigators. Can you summarize some of what you learned about fighting the bureaucracy like this? You went through holy hell to find the truth on the chemical weapons used.

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 15:59:08View | Delete

    Getting back to my question on Central America, and Jeff’s on Sudan (#58), how do you think US imagery assets should be used to track human rights abuse, refugee flows, etc, even in countries where we’re not at war or where we don’t have “strategic” interests?

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 15:53:27View | Delete

    Interesting – I’ve been re-reading that too (for the Cuba stuff). Of course Vietnam & IndoChina were heavily contracted, but mostly in the area of logistics – setting up the infrastructure, ferrying troops around, etc. The use of contractors to actually analyze intelligence and function as CIA assets came much later. But the Vietnam era is an important piece in the whole history of outsourcing.

  • Picture

    Tim Shorrock commented on the blog post FDL Book Salon Welcomes Patrick Eddington, Long Strange Journey: An Intelligence Memoir

    2011-03-12 15:50:37View | Delete

    Why was that a source of friction? Wouldn’t they want the signals stuff to augment their intel?

  • Load More  

Tell President Obama:
Reschedule Marijuana and End the War
on Patients and Caregivers

Email: 
Zip: 

Welcome to FDL

Login to Firedoglake and participate in our community.

Not a member? Create an account.

Toolbox

Explore
Find Diaries Find People
Site Activity Find Groups

About MyFDL

MyFDL is the community site of progressive political blog Firedoglake. Anyone can participate by writing a diary, commenting on others’ diaries, or joining groups to find other people in your area. Content posted to MyFDL is the opinion of the author alone, and should not be attributed to Firedoglake.

» More about MyFDL.

» MyFDL Comment Moderation.

» NEW: Report site problems and bugs.

MYFDL RECOMMENDED DIARIES
  • More on Alan Simpson Going Ballistic
    By: mlyon01 2 Comments
  • My New Geiger Counter Arrived
    By: EdwardTeller 2 Comments
  • Why a Growing Movement of Young People Could Ignite a Workers' Revolution
    By: Michelle Chen 0 Comments
  • Beyond Corporate Capitalism: Not So Wild a Dream
    By: Gar Alperovitz 6 Comments
  • Shareholders Challenging the Private Prison Industry
    By: WhyIHateCCA 0 Comments
  • Beyond Capitalism: A Differnet Culture and Priorities.
    By: cmaukonen 0 Comments
  • Saturday Art: Rodin's Balzac
    By: Ruth Calvo 0 Comments
  • Dumb Rich People
    By: Alan Grayson 15 Comments
  • Water Cooler: Happy Birthday Jessie Colter and Rachel Carson
    By: dakine01 4 Comments
  • See and speak to Rocky Anderson, a progressive Presidential Candidate, on May 29th, 4:00 PM ET
    By: Barefoot Accountant 0 Comments
Follow @Firedoglake

Subscribe to Firedoglake RSS

» More FDL feeds

News. Community. Activism.

Firedoglake is a member-supported organization.
Help us continue our work for as little as $45/year.

MYFDL RECENT DIARIES
  • Saturday Art: Rodin's Balzac
    By: Ruth Calvo 0 Comments
  • My New Geiger Counter Arrived
    By: EdwardTeller 2 Comments
  • Why a Growing Movement of Young People Could Ignite a Workers' Revolution
    By: Michelle Chen 0 Comments
  • See and speak to Rocky Anderson, a progressive Presidential Candidate, on May 29th, 4:00 PM ET
    By: Barefoot Accountant 0 Comments
  • Income Inequality and Violence.
    By: TomThumb 0 Comments
  • More on Alan Simpson Going Ballistic
    By: mlyon01 2 Comments
  • Water Cooler: Happy Birthday Jessie Colter and Rachel Carson
    By: dakine01 4 Comments
  • Where are the JOBS Obama? Here, I'll Show You
    By: DSWright 6 Comments
  • Beyond Capitalism: A Differnet Culture and Priorities.
    By: cmaukonen 0 Comments
  • Nevada Supreme Court Put JUSTICE for Sale – Wells Fargo is the highest bidder
    By: dz88 2 Comments
  • The Religious Right’s Assault on Palliative Care
    By: BarbaraCoombsLee 1 Comments
  • What Can Labor Win if It Backs Obama's Re-Election?
    By: Amy B. Dean 9 Comments
  • Shareholders Challenging the Private Prison Industry
    By: WhyIHateCCA 0 Comments
  • Book Sale Benefit for TarheelDem to Replace the Things Jacked by the Chicago InSecurity Apparatus
    By: wendydavis 15 Comments
  • The Special Loophole in Hell for War Lawyers
    By: David Swanson 4 Comments
  • Anti-Sex Ed Curriculum Makes the List: Don't Blame Obama, Blame the System
    By: RHRealityCheck 1 Comments
  • NASA & NOAA: April 2012 Among Top 5 Warmest On Record
    By: WeatherDem 1 Comments
  • Beyond Corporate Capitalism: Not So Wild a Dream
    By: Gar Alperovitz 6 Comments
  • Second recent incident where there is undercurrent of Russian suspicion of USA sabotage of their aviation.
    By: ambassadorzot 0 Comments
  • Emptywheel on Democracy Now Speaking on ‘The Assassination Czar’
    By: wendydavis 31 Comments
  • Obama & Netanyahu Threaten to Dirty-Bomb US Soldiers, Marines & Airmen in Afghanistan
    By: normanb 7 Comments
  • Dumb Rich People
    By: Alan Grayson 15 Comments
  • #Occupy Oakland: Justice May Never Get Here
    By: hotflashcarol 13 Comments
  • Water Cooler: Happy Birthday Tommy Chong, Bob Dylan, and Patti LaBelle
    By: dakine01 10 Comments
  • Obama Taps Allison Macfarlane as New Head of Nuclear Regulatory Commission
    By: Gregg Levine 14 Comments

Read More »

Home  |  Advertise  |  RSS Feed  |  Register  |  Login  |  Subscribe to updates  |  WordPress  |  About  |  Contact  |  Privacy
MyFDL
  • Log In
  • Create a Firedoglake Account
  • ?